Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

american bragging christmas cards

132 replies

thatsnotmywean · 16/12/2023 13:07

We got the annual christmas card from an american acquaintance. I say acquaintance as they are a friend of a friend and we couldn't care less.

What is it though with this American trend of bragging every christmas? Its like competitive parenting. This card is full of "my beauty business is doing SO well this year, little johnny really loves his music and has a future as an aspiring musician, little janey does cheerleading practice 3 times a week, she's so dedicated" and so on.

AIBU to think, this is a stupid tradition?

Also, I think if we have time, we should send one back full of stupid shit. Can I have suggestions of what to say?

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 16/12/2023 22:06

MaidOfSteel · 16/12/2023 17:22

It's not a way of letting everyone know how their lives are going. It's bragging. Half of it is probably made up. If it was on Facebook, MN would be decrying it.

Again the word 'bragging', accompanied by refusal to believe some people live happier and more successful lives than you do.

Why do you think it's bragging? Why do you think it's not true? How can both thoughts coexist?

mathanxiety · 16/12/2023 22:03

thatsnotmywean · 16/12/2023 16:14

I have american relatives (and friends) so not anti american, but every single American family I know does this and not one from any of the other many countries I have family, friends and colleagues from. Its really cringey.

It's funny how someone imparting good news is considered bragging. Why is that, would you say?

mathanxiety · 16/12/2023 21:56

@thatsnotmywean

I suggest you look up the longstanding Janet and Roy seasonal joke here on MN.

It's a hilarious take on a very British tradition.

I'm in the US and never send or receive any letters of the sort that has got on your tits.

Zwellers · 16/12/2023 21:34

I just don't understand why anyone regardless of nationality thinks people outside of thier immediate close family care about what them and thier kids get up to. It's just self obsessiveness

whiteorchids44 · 16/12/2023 21:30

Not every American sends Christmas newsletters and in fact I've seen Brits send them out as well. I suppose these newsletters are like Marmite. You either love or hate them.

There is a movie on Netflix about Christmas newsletters. It's called Best. Christmas. Ever! with Heather Graham, Brandy and Jason Biggs. Heather Graham finds the Christmas newsletters that Brandy sends about her family cringey. I have a soft spot for Christmas movies so I definitely watched it.

Evenstar · 16/12/2023 21:29

I look forward to receiving letters with my Christmas cards and hearing people’s news, I always include one with photos with mine particularly for elderly relatives and friends without social media.

It has actually been mentioned at some elderly relatives funerals how much they looked forward to a letter at Christmas. I had a letter back from the daughter of my former neighbour last year saying how much pleasure the letter had given her mother who is nearly 105 now.

There is no need for boasting, I think social media is far worse for that anyway.

Zanatdy · 16/12/2023 21:14

Why does updating someone on your life equate to bragging. Would you rather - best wishes, john? If so what’s the point? I know many Brits who attach a letter in Christmas cards, I personally like to hear how someone’s year has been

dudsville · 16/12/2023 21:10

Every single American family you know does this... and you know.. what... 500 American families? No? Would even 500 be representative of a country that size? Cool your jets. You didn't like the card. Bin it. No harm done.

rumred · 16/12/2023 21:07

Boastful letters =smug marrieds
No thanks

FriedasCarLoad · 16/12/2023 21:04

It wouldn't be my style, but boastful round robins are hardly uniquely American - I remember one British acquaintance listing her children's examination results in a table each year!

I've grown to love the American tradition of photo Christmas cards. I genuinely enjoy seeing their cards each year.

I get a bit fed up people turning up their noses at Americans.

Previousreligion · 16/12/2023 20:55

My Mum and her friends do Round Robins. Some of them are so witty and entertaining I look forward to reading them myself each year even though I've never met the authors!

None are boastful, it's really nice to hear about their year. They include the good and the bad. I wish my friends would do it!

Rocksonabeach · 16/12/2023 20:47

Omg I’d forgotten the bragging letters I used to get as Robins from some friends of my parents. They were friends with my parents and back in the 1980s parents were very no sugar, no tv - all academic each letter was …. Here’s a picture of Alan look how tall and handsome he is. He decided against going to Oxford and is having a year out to travel to Columbia to eradicate the drug problem etc etc etc they went on for years. They spotted when Eldest son went to prisoner for dealing drugs and then youngest became awful - local councillor type argumentative, sexist, heavily obese and just dire. He was well known both the parents father and the younger son had affair after affair after affair. Just grim

AppleDumplingWithCustard · 16/12/2023 20:40

I think you just have to accept the degree of exaggeration they contain and take it with a pinch of salt. I had an acquaintance that used to send a very self-congratulatory missive each year. They lived in a large house in a lovely area and on one occasion mentioned the summer house in their garden. I was very disappointed when I visited to see the summer house was in fact a run of the mill garden shed, albeit quite large and containing a sofa bed for overnight guests. Despite this though they were nice people.

EtiennePalmiere · 16/12/2023 20:36

The only person I know who did this in the US was a German family living there. The son who I knew was mortified lol, a lot of it was describing his brother's modelling career.

Anyways, surely it's actually a British thing, it was done in Adrian Mole Wink

Kitkatfiend31 · 16/12/2023 20:31

I love Xmas 'round robin' letters. Read the book 'The Cat that could open the fridge'. It's really funny and will give you lots of ideas for your own.

phoenixrosehere · 16/12/2023 20:25

daisychain01 · 16/12/2023 20:06

I was just coming on here to say that I can't stand anti- nation hate threads and as you've pointed out it's vile to have nasty things said about your entire homeland as a lazy generalisation.

Says more about the OP than the US that's for sure.

Right.

Even in my lowest days, I would never begrudge someone from seemingly doing well, and writing of the positives of what is going on in their family. I also wouldn’t see it as braggy but some seem to rather assume someone’s bragging instead of just relaying positive information especially in written form when there is little clue of tone.

I have only seen such things in the occasional American Christmas movie yet never received one growing up in the States. It seems some forget or struggle to acknowledge that the US has different regions with different traditions just like the UK.

QueenOfHiraeth · 16/12/2023 20:14

Spinet · 16/12/2023 13:51

I work with Americans. While there are lots of things that are annoying about the cultural differences between us, I love the fact that they are generally nicer to and about other people than we are. As a nation we are a load of crochety bitchers aren't we

I had never been aware of anti-American sentiment until I became friends with a woman who was here for a few years with her husband's job. The open prejudice truly shocked me and, I agree, the Americans I have met are often nicer

I am much older than most current MN users, been here "since it were all fields", and I have to say our age group (60s) are probably the most guilty of sending round robins as older than us didn't have computers/printers, etc when their children were young and they had news to share while younger than us have used social media more. We still get a fair few and still send ours out although we try to be as minimally nauseating as possible.
Having said that I'd sooner risk being thought of as cringey than be as bitchy, negative and snarkey as many posters seem to be now

Mumof118 · 16/12/2023 20:13

I love hearing about my friend’s and family’s happiness at Christmas time, and I’m glad it’s the season to focus on the positives.
They are letting you know how they are doing.

American’s tend not to waste as much time on polite modesty and I’ve always found the ones I’ve met to be straightforward and kind. So that’s how I’d take that card. They probably hope you guys are doing equally as well.

And at least they aren’t sending a card full of their recent pain and failiures, as that would be awkward wouldn’t it 😬

Copkake · 16/12/2023 20:12

Just tell them you don't like them much? It's more cringey to bitch about your supposed friends.

Dear X and Y,

Please stop sending me any updates on your family. I dislike you to the point of making a post on the internet complaining about your cultural traditions.

Happy Christmas,

Scrooge

MrsCarson · 16/12/2023 20:07

I just ignore the bragging on the one I get. I send a card with just greeting from the Carson's on it. We usually meet up once a year anyway so I hear all the gossip of how great they are then.

daisychain01 · 16/12/2023 20:06

TheBraves · 16/12/2023 13:16

I’m American and lots of ‘us’ don’t do cards anymore and didn’t do this when we did, so not sure it’s an American trend. Mumsnet sure do like to talk shit about us. 🙄

I was just coming on here to say that I can't stand anti- nation hate threads and as you've pointed out it's vile to have nasty things said about your entire homeland as a lazy generalisation.

Says more about the OP than the US that's for sure.

Hermione101 · 16/12/2023 20:04

Love the tradition and love the family updates. People have to be really miserable in their own lives to hate on things like this.

Illbebythesea · 16/12/2023 20:02

SeaToSki · Today 14:04

Interesting..I just finished reading a Christmas letter…from a British relative and I haven’t received any from any of my American friends for as far back as I can remember (and since I live in the US there would be a high chance of me getting one if it was a country-wide phenomenon)

I do get lots of lovely photo cards from my American friends which I enjoy receiving as I can see how their dc are growing up etc.

As ever, if you are going to be rude about someone or something that someone does or says, may I suggest you dont assume that the rest of their country does or says exactly the same things. I have British friends that like to eat deep fried Mars bars (which I think is disgusting and a quick route to diabetes 2) but I would never moan that all Brits have a bad diet with too many fried foods as that would not be kind or fair (or true)

🤣🤣🤣 cor yeah… an American chastising the British diet. That one doesn't live any room for retaliation 🤣🤣… you should have gone with our bad teeth or horrible accents. We would have had to own that…

Illbebythesea · 16/12/2023 19:58

It’s awful, awful. No one gives a shit they’re taking the piss out of you whilst reading it. If you’re British… I can’t speak for other nationalities but this is very un-British. If anything you should send a card moaning but with some wit 😂

OneTC · 16/12/2023 19:55

I don't associate this with America particularly, the people in my family that do this are Australian and Scottish. Think it's just a bit old fashioned rather than regional