Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are reasonable overnight arrangements with 175 miles of distance?

120 replies

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 08:58

Both parents work full time Mon- Fri. Child is 5. Third party needed for handovers due to history of abuse so father would have to drive to collect and mother would have a friend facilitate. Child lives with mother (me) and courts want to work towards overnights at father's house 175 miles away. Any advice on what would seem reasonable? I don't want this to happen due to what I feel are risks to the child however I'm being forced to come up with a plan. And I need to make suggestions or the judge will just decide. No money for legal advice and have no idea what is reasonable. Any suggestions?

OP posts:
CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:13

silverheartstogether · 16/12/2023 10:12

Rape, racial abuse, and putting his baby in danger and he's still judged by the courts as deserving of a chance to be a father. The bar really is frighteningly low for men isn't it.

So sorry, OP Flowers

Yep. Contact at all costs. It will go wrong eventually I am quite sure of it.

OP posts:
silverheartstogether · 16/12/2023 10:12

Rape, racial abuse, and putting his baby in danger and he's still judged by the courts as deserving of a chance to be a father. The bar really is frighteningly low for men isn't it.

So sorry, OP Flowers

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:08

Flensburg · 16/12/2023 10:06

I'm so sorry this happened to you and that you are now having to do all this mental work for your child to see someone who in no way deserves a relationship with him.

He was also found to have assaulted our child at 3 months old and put his medical health in danger to spite me. Also racial abuse and harassment (he's white and I'm black). It's unbelievable.

OP posts:
Flensburg · 16/12/2023 10:06

I'm so sorry this happened to you and that you are now having to do all this mental work for your child to see someone who in no way deserves a relationship with him.

Tina221 · 16/12/2023 10:04

Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 09:25

Working towards doesn't mean they expect you to hand your sin over next time for an overnight!

They want you to show you are willing to work uo to more contact.

Proposals generally involve a paced approach of small increases of time spent together. So if as you say the current order is 2 hours every other week I would begin by proposing that this increases to 4 hours every other week and increase by 1 hour over a period of say 6 months until it builds to a full day on a Saturday.

Your next step is that son comes home over night and his dad has him again on the second day until day lunchtime again building it up slowly to him staying overnight someehwre local to your sons primary residence within a year.

Once overnight is established it can then be built on so that it then becomes 2 nights during a school holiday l, locally to primary residence until such a time as your son is confident at being away from you.

Your reasoning always needs to be that his man is still a virtual stranger and you are concerned that there is a risk to you via contact.

This 💐

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:03

Marmiteidea · 16/12/2023 10:02

💯 this and I’m really sorry for you. It is horrendous. These toerags get contact orders almost no matter what.

Thank you both. You are absolutely right.

OP posts:
Marmiteidea · 16/12/2023 10:02

Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 09:54

I get that. Unfortunately the court will expect you to separate the abuse to you from his behaviour with your son.

Assuming he isnt abusive to your son then the court will push for contact as they staunchly uphold that it is best for the child to have a relationship with both parents.

The key is proposing something that delays the inevitable as long as possible. Most abusive rapists can't maintain the facade indefinitely, you need to appear as reaaonable as possible, always using the argument that father is a stranger, son needs to build a relationship in somewhere he feels safe and familiar until he reverts to his standard behaviour and slips up. I know that means putting your son at risk but unfortunately til that happens the courts will push on.

As court are allowing contact I assume you didn't press charges?

💯 this and I’m really sorry for you. It is horrendous. These toerags get contact orders almost no matter what.

CunkEverywhereOnEverything · 16/12/2023 10:00

I’m so sorry OP. I’ve been through family court myself due to DV and while I was lucky to get a place in a refuge with my children that had great staff who had connections with some incredibly helpful people. Not everyone is that lucky. And fwiw, my ex was no less of a danger and a terrible father to our children. I would try and drag out the building up to overnight contact as long as possible in the hope he loses interest in your child. The best thing my ex has ever done for my children is stopping contacting them eventually, presumably as he lost interest in them.

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:57

Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 09:54

I get that. Unfortunately the court will expect you to separate the abuse to you from his behaviour with your son.

Assuming he isnt abusive to your son then the court will push for contact as they staunchly uphold that it is best for the child to have a relationship with both parents.

The key is proposing something that delays the inevitable as long as possible. Most abusive rapists can't maintain the facade indefinitely, you need to appear as reaaonable as possible, always using the argument that father is a stranger, son needs to build a relationship in somewhere he feels safe and familiar until he reverts to his standard behaviour and slips up. I know that means putting your son at risk but unfortunately til that happens the courts will push on.

As court are allowing contact I assume you didn't press charges?

I took it to the police who said I wouldn't get a positive outcome and talked me out of it. It's a big regret of mine but they said CPS wouldn't even look at it as coercive control hard to prosecute, as is rape, as is historic physical abuse. It was all found to have happened in a fact finding though so at least the family courts accept it to have happened. But accept it is a lower burden of proof than in criminal courts.

OP posts:
CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:55

So I'm thinking:

  • working up to a full day near child's residence as laid out in court order
  • then work towards father staying overnight (not sure how often yet) returning child home to mother for the evening, then spending a second day together, building that second day up in increments (possibly with half a day as a starting point)
  • then build up to child staying overnight with dad near child's home (would he need a separate bed or would one bed be OK?)

That's as far as I've got. I have no idea how to frame the overnights at father's house as I can't predict when he will be ready for that. I will need to work on him staying overnight at grandparents and play dates etc as currently he doesn't stay away from me and the handful of times I've tried it has been quite stressful for him.

OP posts:
Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 09:54

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:45

My brain hurts 😣 can I just say how hard it is even considering writing this plan for a man who raped me to spend time with our child. It's taking every fibre of my being to comply and appear reasonable.

I get that. Unfortunately the court will expect you to separate the abuse to you from his behaviour with your son.

Assuming he isnt abusive to your son then the court will push for contact as they staunchly uphold that it is best for the child to have a relationship with both parents.

The key is proposing something that delays the inevitable as long as possible. Most abusive rapists can't maintain the facade indefinitely, you need to appear as reaaonable as possible, always using the argument that father is a stranger, son needs to build a relationship in somewhere he feels safe and familiar until he reverts to his standard behaviour and slips up. I know that means putting your son at risk but unfortunately til that happens the courts will push on.

As court are allowing contact I assume you didn't press charges?

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:49

CunkEverywhereOnEverything · 16/12/2023 09:45

I don’t see why that matters when there’s domestic abuse involved. Sometimes you have to leave the area you once lived in because of
it.

OP, are you sure you are not
entitled to free legal aid? You say you can’t afford legal assistance but if there’s been abuse you shouldn’t be having to pay. What has your ex been expected to do by the judge to show he is a responsible, trustworthy parent? Has he been
keeping up his end of that? I do understand your concerns.

It doesn't matter and the courts have already acknowledged that I had no other choice and that travel is responsibility of the father (currently anyway).

I can get legal aid but I'm not eligible due to how far into court proceedings I am and the details of the case. Rights of women have confirmed I'm unlikely to get it. Its hard to come by these days.

He completed a domestic abuse perpetrator programme, but the report was littered with lies he'd told and he was still denying the abuse. They aren't worth the paper they're written on (and have now been stopped for review as found not fit for purpose!!!)

OP posts:
CunkEverywhereOnEverything · 16/12/2023 09:45

SgtJuneAckland · 16/12/2023 09:05

Who moved 175 miles?

I don’t see why that matters when there’s domestic abuse involved. Sometimes you have to leave the area you once lived in because of
it.

OP, are you sure you are not
entitled to free legal aid? You say you can’t afford legal assistance but if there’s been abuse you shouldn’t be having to pay. What has your ex been expected to do by the judge to show he is a responsible, trustworthy parent? Has he been
keeping up his end of that? I do understand your concerns.

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:45

My brain hurts 😣 can I just say how hard it is even considering writing this plan for a man who raped me to spend time with our child. It's taking every fibre of my being to comply and appear reasonable.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 16/12/2023 09:43

Dont overcomplicate it. When your son is ready, you'll facilitate a handover that includes dad staying near you on a Saturday night in a hotel/air bnb, for one night. This will continue for a while and then dad can stay Friday and SAturday night and move up to 2 overnights in a row

This could happen monthly or fortnightly according to need

As the child gets older, if this is still meeting the child's needs and if handovers are safe and positive, then perhaps the overnights could occur at father's house with father doing the drive to collect and drop off (although that is a hard one as you were the one to move away) but travel training once he starts secondary school would ensure he can do the journey on his own

Over time, and as the child develops, might need to work around saturday morning clubs or friday even play dates etc, so could incorporate some school holiday staying time.

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:42

Marmiteidea · 16/12/2023 09:41

No courts don’t consider those kinds of things. The focus is the children having a relationship with the parent.

Fair enough, I'm not trying to be obstructive, I just don't want to include details the courts aren't interested in. It's so hard self representing.

OP posts:
Marmiteidea · 16/12/2023 09:41

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:39

Are they likely to take into account hobbies/friends/birthday parties etc or should I just accept that he's going to miss things? I see this being difficult as he gets older but courts might mo see it as an issue.

No courts don’t consider those kinds of things. The focus is the children having a relationship with the parent.

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:39

Are they likely to take into account hobbies/friends/birthday parties etc or should I just accept that he's going to miss things? I see this being difficult as he gets older but courts might mo see it as an issue.

OP posts:
Namechangenamechange321 · 16/12/2023 09:39

Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 09:25

Working towards doesn't mean they expect you to hand your sin over next time for an overnight!

They want you to show you are willing to work uo to more contact.

Proposals generally involve a paced approach of small increases of time spent together. So if as you say the current order is 2 hours every other week I would begin by proposing that this increases to 4 hours every other week and increase by 1 hour over a period of say 6 months until it builds to a full day on a Saturday.

Your next step is that son comes home over night and his dad has him again on the second day until day lunchtime again building it up slowly to him staying overnight someehwre local to your sons primary residence within a year.

Once overnight is established it can then be built on so that it then becomes 2 nights during a school holiday l, locally to primary residence until such a time as your son is confident at being away from you.

Your reasoning always needs to be that his man is still a virtual stranger and you are concerned that there is a risk to you via contact.

This. And stretch it out as much as possible. So first overnight will be in a year. Then two night overnights a year after that, working up to a week twice a year when child is, say, 9. You can stipulate that ex needs to be on leave (ie not working) during contact. Hopefully ex will get sick of the faff and palaver and give up, or a miracle will happen and he’ll turn into a fine upstanding citizen and impeccable role model…

Marmiteidea · 16/12/2023 09:38

This happens in our family. The abusive ex is living abroad, the agreement is a week annually. He flies over to collect them. It is the abusive twunt who is my family member, ex wife unfortunately for her, married into the family. He Andrew Tate’s that is all the Mum’s fault, but he is an absolutely vile specimen of humanity and his own family including his kids know that.

It is such a tough one and the courts do not protect children from an abusive low life parent. I think see can you get the visits starting on your local contact centre and you put in an age suggestion.

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 09:36

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:30

According to cafcass it isn't and he will need to ensure he's not left with anyone he doesn't know well for significant portions of the contact.

Easily done

added to which that holiday allowance is what most single parents have.

Trust me - that won’t loom large on courts radar

geckofrog · 16/12/2023 09:36

You can specify that if dad is unable to look after your child you are given first refusal for them to be with you

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 09:35

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:29

I can't just walk into court and say that though, they're giving us the time for discussion now and want a plan. The judge was explicit that she wants a plan that will take us to overnights and she wants to know when that will happen. It's so hard because I can't predict that. Even cafcass have said they don't know what to suggest and need advice.

in that case - make your plan on the basis of him continuing to do what he’s done multiple times for a few hours…. he travels to your hometown where a third party will be present to do the handover. Your child then stays the weekend with him every other weekend. And he returns him to your to the third party.

You will have to compromise but use that as your starting line.

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:35

Doggymummar · 16/12/2023 09:33

Surely the contact centre continues, but the time get longer, by say 15 mins a week until it's built up to a full day where he is trusted to take him out the contract centre and return him back, for say six months. Then he could collect him and take him to his house for an overnight and drop back at the centre say 5pm the next day, it drop him at school for the correct time if it's a school day. No need for you to be involved at all. You say you moved back to you home area so a family member can facilitate.

If your child doesn't want or like this arrangement make sure he knows he can tell you

It seems like madness to drive a child 4 hours in one direction, for one overnight, then 4 hours back the next day. But if that's what people do then I can't really argue it.

OP posts:
CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 09:34

TiptoeTess · 16/12/2023 09:31

God, this feels appalling. Who on earth thinks an abusive man is a good role model for a child?? I despair.

OP, I think I would suggest that contact continues via your local contact centre as it currently is for another year, ie a few hours, then progresses to a full day via the contact centre (still local to you) next year, then an overnight facilitated by the contact centre (still local to you) the following year and then to two nights during school holidays the following year BUT still facilitated by the local contact centre (ie he still has to do the 175 miles each way.)

I would argue this on the basis that due to the abusive history it will be important for your son’s contact to continue to be facilitated by somewhere familiar to him. Say how strongly you feel that this adds risk and so your compromise is by going along with it at all. Don’t offer midway; make them force you out f it comes to it. I have no idea what’s reasonable or what they’re likely to agree but do not make it any easier for him than you have to!

I’m hoping at some point during that time your ex basically gets sick of doing the miles and drops out tbh.

It's been very difficult. I have done everything the courts have asked me to so far. They are increasing contact from 2 hours to 8 hours over two months so that bit is already decided. It's just the overnights (or lack of) that the judge wasn't happy with.

OP posts: