Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What are reasonable overnight arrangements with 175 miles of distance?

120 replies

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 08:58

Both parents work full time Mon- Fri. Child is 5. Third party needed for handovers due to history of abuse so father would have to drive to collect and mother would have a friend facilitate. Child lives with mother (me) and courts want to work towards overnights at father's house 175 miles away. Any advice on what would seem reasonable? I don't want this to happen due to what I feel are risks to the child however I'm being forced to come up with a plan. And I need to make suggestions or the judge will just decide. No money for legal advice and have no idea what is reasonable. Any suggestions?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 18:56

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 16:12

I took it to the police who said I wouldn't get a positive outcome and talked me out of it. It's a big regret of mine but they said CPS wouldn't even look at it as coercive control hard to prosecute, as is rape, as is historic physical abuse. It was all found to have happened in a fact finding though so at least the family courts accept it to have happened. But accept it is a lower burden of proof than in criminal courts.

the family courts are basing their judgements on fact that he is a rapist and assaulted his newborn child?

Yes sadly happens all the time in family courts. They do a perpetrator programme, an hour a week for 6 months. And they're suddenly healed of their abusive behaviours. Bizarre.

OP posts:
hellsBells246 · 16/12/2023 16:35

silverheartstogether · 16/12/2023 10:12

Rape, racial abuse, and putting his baby in danger and he's still judged by the courts as deserving of a chance to be a father. The bar really is frighteningly low for men isn't it.

So sorry, OP Flowers

This 🥲

Hugs, op 💐

MeMySonAnd1 · 16/12/2023 16:22

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 16:12

I took it to the police who said I wouldn't get a positive outcome and talked me out of it. It's a big regret of mine but they said CPS wouldn't even look at it as coercive control hard to prosecute, as is rape, as is historic physical abuse. It was all found to have happened in a fact finding though so at least the family courts accept it to have happened. But accept it is a lower burden of proof than in criminal courts.

the family courts are basing their judgements on fact that he is a rapist and assaulted his newborn child?

It is not that rare you know? Apparently a father can be a rapist, an addict or be involved in criminal behaviour but still be believed by courts that contact is of benefit to his children.

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 16:17

sounds awful. very stressful op. i feel for you.

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 16:12

I took it to the police who said I wouldn't get a positive outcome and talked me out of it. It's a big regret of mine but they said CPS wouldn't even look at it as coercive control hard to prosecute, as is rape, as is historic physical abuse. It was all found to have happened in a fact finding though so at least the family courts accept it to have happened. But accept it is a lower burden of proof than in criminal courts.

the family courts are basing their judgements on fact that he is a rapist and assaulted his newborn child?

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 16:10

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 16:01

Yes I have explained it in one of my previous posts.

apologies i’ll read back

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 16:10

and also fact that he’s both employed, which means annual leave and CMS etc

and also under declares his earnings?

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 16:01

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:45

ut the courts are clear that this was my only reasonable option due to the severity of the abuse

but what i’m confused about is that he has never been convicted and yet the abuse is still accepted as a point of fact the courts?

Yes I have explained it in one of my previous posts.

OP posts:
escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:45

ut the courts are clear that this was my only reasonable option due to the severity of the abuse

but what i’m confused about is that he has never been convicted and yet the abuse is still accepted as a point of fact the courts?

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:43

you say it was proven he assaulted his 3 month old, did it go to court?

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:43

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 15:24

He wasn't convicted no

sorry if delicate for you to answer

but if he’s an innocent man in the eyes of the law, why is this arrangement in place?

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:41

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 15:24

No he's not self employed. He works for his mate cash in hand.

and his mate has said he can only get 4 weeks annual leave? presumably he can take whatever holiday he wants unless this mate paying cash in hand will pay him for those 4 weeks!

and he must be self employed if he’s “under “declaring” otherwise he would be paid through PAYE and pay tax etc via HMRC

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 15:24

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:19

just to be clear - he was convicted of rape and abuse of you, and an assault on his 3 month old child?

was he imprisoned?

He wasn't convicted no

OP posts:
CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 15:24

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:23

an ok he’s self employed then

in which case, he’s not tied to the 4 week summer holiday annual leave you were worried about

No he's not self employed. He works for his mate cash in hand.

OP posts:
escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:23

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:40

No he just under declares his earnings. The judge knows nothing of our finances.

an ok he’s self employed then

in which case, he’s not tied to the 4 week summer holiday annual leave you were worried about

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:21

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:34

Yes. He works cash in hand so its £20 odd a week. I've reported him for tax evasion but they don't do anything. I've stopped worrying about it now.

so he’s registered unemployed?

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:20

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:28

I mention it because the judge was suggesting we stopped using a contact centre due to the cost to father, which is far less than a hotel. She seems to be very concerned about his finances for some reason!

he pays you CMS?

escapethemaze · 16/12/2023 15:19

just to be clear - he was convicted of rape and abuse of you, and an assault on his 3 month old child?

was he imprisoned?

PurpleBugz · 16/12/2023 12:30

Rights of women helpline.

020 7251 6577

They can give free advice on child arrangements and family court

PurpleBugz · 16/12/2023 12:24

Coram used to have a free family law advice line you could phone. Actual barristers and solicitors to speak to. It was always engaged and I'd be trying for an hour on average to get through but when you can't afford legal advice it's invaluable

PurpleBugz · 16/12/2023 12:16

Court ordered overnights with my abusive ex a similar distance away when my youngest was 6 months and breast fed. He had one overnight then upped to two when baby was 7 months. This was because judge decided I was too resistant to overnights as I said kids too young. The system is so fucking disgusting it serves fathers not the children.

If it's already planned to go up to 8 hours a visit I'd suggest 2-3 months of that then one overnight with the agreement to re look at it once child settles. I doubt you will get away with that but I'd try because as you say you can't tell when child is ready.

Look up child maintenance amounts as it depends on overnights. If you give two overnights every other week/equivalent to one overnight a week the maintenance reduces this May b part of his motivation. Offer just enough to reduce his maintenance that may satisfy ex.

I did stand my ground on handover location. We had somewhere public close to me and I had someone else do it. Ex fought most over this as he wanted me doing the travel. Stand your ground in this. I'd fight it more than the amount of contact because in my case ex doesn't want to see kids he wants to control me. I'm glad I did because driving that far every other week costs a fortune and it impacts your life- you can't enjoy your child free time as you spend it driving. You can't see friends or have a life or spend time with a nee partner as your ex contact sabotages it. Obviously don't use the need for your own life as your reasoning for not doing the drive but honestly stand your ground. If you have the history of abuse accepted by court and the need for third party handovers then you can say if it's not local to you finding appropriate third party kid knows well enough will be too difficult and will have a negative impact on contact. Keep child focused in everything you say.

Another thing to consider is Christmas and holiday contact. Usually a court order says to split them but doesn't tell you how it expects you to agree between yourselves- this just gives ex more control over you. I insisted all holiday contact would be set out in court order, as Christmas was over the weekend and fell on his weekend for 3 years running I argued we don't do extra holiday contact the kids spend Christmas with the parent who's regular weekend it is. As I was giving away 3 Christmas in a row the judge ordered this. (Ex then cancelled 2 out of those 3 Christmas last minute). Have a think about it. Maybe something like alternative years Christmas Eve 1pm to Boxing Day 1pm. You want the times in the order. If Christmas falls immediately before or after ex regular weekend then you have to decide if you argue he misses that weekend or accept 4 nights with your child away. Look at the calendar and work out where Christmas falls in the next few years in relation to who has the closest weekend.

For holiday contact again I argued we couldn't agree amoung ourselves. I gave ex one half term of his choice but that it would be the same each year and he chose which and that went into the order. and 2 weeks I'm summer- with the condition he give me 2 or 3 months notice which weeks (can't remember now how long exactly) it wasn't to be an agreement it was his choice but he had to give me reasonable notice. I think the first year it had to be two separate weeks as kids hadn't been away. Again ex not bothered with his holiday contract despite fighting for it. I think the first extended stay was agreed to be 4 days rather than the full week (it was the half term) so you could suggest the first couple of extended holiday contacts are 4 nights before it's increased to a week.

I am certain that by giving so much of my Christmas time with the kids and by insisting the order set everything out so he could not use the kids contact to control and abuse me the judge saw my genuine fear and gave the order we needed if I had been picky and argued I need to see the kids over Christmas I would have ended up arguing with ex over Christmas contact every year which he would have loved. I'm also certain that because I reply "we will follow the court order kids will be available for collection x time x date as per court order" then I don't respond to repeated attempts to draw me in I've escaped years of his continuing control and abuse and the kids have benefited as they cannot be used as pawns to the same extent I see others suffer with these holiday contact "as agreed between parties" orders. Do everything you can not to have that wording it's cart balance to mess with your life.

At the end of the day it will be a judge who makes a decision on if your proposal is reasonable. The judge is a human being and they vary as all people do. I've known people get much better orders than mine and much worse (all of us are DV sufferers we met on the freedom program). Judges have too much power in my opinion. But keep child focused on all your arguments and don't be picky about arguing over small details it just pisses them off and your order will be worse.

Good luck. It's horrible and traumatic going through court but hold onto the fact once it's over and done you will have that court order to protect you from future abuse and control. When I went through it I thought it was horrible and I was bereft at loosing my kids at the weekends but as time has passed I'm immensely glad we have the order initially it did do harm to the kids they were too young to go but in the end it's protected me from his continuing abuse and protected them from being used for that abuse. I actually enjoy my weekends off now as it turned out the baby has significant needs and is disabled so I need the break, ex gives kids to his gf or mother to care for generally and while they are not great they are good enough so I don't worry about them like I use to when he was doing it. Once you get free from court that could be the case for you too. See it as him loosing his control not you loosing your child. The best thing for your child is him not using contact to abuse you

Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 11:27

Cafcass are notoriously shit. I would contact your local social services and ask for advice about the potential risk and for a social worker to be assigned maybe.

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 11:23

Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 11:22

Fully aware of that. That is why I asked if your son has a social worker. One should have been appointed by the court.

Yes Cafcass

OP posts:
Onceuponaheartache · 16/12/2023 11:22

CandyFluff99 · 16/12/2023 10:44

Unfortunately it's not that simple.

Fully aware of that. That is why I asked if your son has a social worker. One should have been appointed by the court.

Swipe left for the next trending thread