Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Promoted.. already have issue with one colleague

62 replies

1982mommaof4 · 15/12/2023 23:46

I have worked for the company the same amount of time as my colleague. We have worked on the same projects in the past, there have been a few communication issues. Fast forward we have both applied for a promotion and I got the position.

It is clear my colleague is unhappy, I have been in the role for a week and they are already being challenging.

I'm looking for tips on how to manage this as sensitively as possible!

OP posts:
GaryLurcher19 · 16/12/2023 07:16

I'm sorry @GreatGateauxsby but I don't think that's good advice...yet.

I think OP's colleague just needs a short bit of time to get over the rejection. They are friends too. If OP follows your advice she's marking her friend's cards with the higher management for what is likely to be a brief thing. The woman isn't even being disruptive, merely refusing to make a decision. It's a bit babyish, but probably something she'll regret in a few days time.

If it persists for a couple of months, then I'd agree. But on the evidence, it's likely very temporary and not a big deal.

Azandme · 16/12/2023 07:12

Stop asking - it allows difficult people to be, well, difficult. It also creates work - following up people like your colleague, and it makes you look wishy washy, and a bit scared.

If a meeting is needed, set the meeting. If you need something doing set the task. If there needs to be a deadline, set one. If someone has a genuine need for something to be changed let THEM ask you.

You are the manager - it's your role to manage these things.

And get your team to share their calendars with you. The software will then do all the "when are we all available" for you.

filka · 16/12/2023 07:07

You seem to be trying to manage by consensus, asking when your team could kindly agree to attend your meeting. You're the manager, you need to be in tell mode, just give them a date.

If you are setting up the meeting in Outlook you can look up everyone's calendar to see when they are available, no need to ask.

If she doesn't attend then discuss the plans with the team anyway, set everyone's objectives and deadlines (as required to achieve your team deadlines) including hers, and communicate to all.

NuNameNuMe · 16/12/2023 07:00

A resource I found useful as a new manager is Ask a Manager website (and podcast?) by Alison Green. She offers advice on handling common problems like this in very straightforward, practical way.

GreatGateauxsby · 16/12/2023 05:45

Deal with it empatheticaply but directly asap.
State don't ask your business need.

Also...
advise your big boss you are getting pushback but dealing with it. It's a FYI not a "mummy /daddy please help me" message.

They should be aware so they don't inadvertently do something that helps jealous colleague undermine you or make life harder.

GaryLurcher19 · 16/12/2023 05:24

1982mommaof4 · 15/12/2023 23:56

I sent her an email suggesting we meet to discuss her work schedule and the best time for us to discuss what days suit her best to hand in the monthly reports. Her response was that she didn't have time to respond to this answer today.

I sent an email out to the team to arrange a team meeting in January and suggested a few dates, I had checked the teams diary to make sure the dates fit in with the service we are under, all the team agreed on a date but no response from her. I left it a few dates and sent out an invite for that agreed date, she responded to say that she had not agreed the date. I asked which date would suit her and we can look at changing, her response was I will let you know in due course ( two days ago) 😵‍💫

OP, you're trying to be kind by asking for things when you should simply state them. I understand why, but it has the opposite of the desired effect. She won't feel less rejected by you asking her for details that you should decide on. She'll feel like she's being asked to make your decisions despite having been rejected for the decision maker's role. You can't share being the boss with her. Just politely tell her when to turn up for the meeting.

She's bound to feel a bit sore just now. Don't heap additional pressure on her. Just let her get over it in her own time.

jemenfous37 · 16/12/2023 05:18

One great piece of advice I was given is that as manager, you can be friendly to you subordinates but you are not their friend.
Yours is a perfect example why. You are in your 1st senior role and you want to be liked; however, bending over backwards to accommodate 1 person will have the whole team resnting you, or they and 'ms annoying' will take the piss.
It is hard, but look at other sucessful managers and how they work. Interestingly, many sports team managers work (Postacoglu being good example) in such a way, as do many hierachical professions

It is the lot of a manager to be moaned about, and you will never please all of the team all ofvthe tome.
so don't tie yourself in knots; draw your lines, stick to the, deal with transgressors.
Good luck!

Kwasi · 16/12/2023 05:11

She also worked hard for the position.

Think how she must be feeling. Think what you would do if the shoe were on the other foot and your wounds were still raw.

PsychoHotSauce · 16/12/2023 04:23

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:23

@PaulaPocket No unfortunately not, like I said this is my first senior position. I am just conscious of how come across to the team, who are all my previous colleagues.

You need to find your assertiveness. Its a key skill and not "bossy", "confrontational" or "aggressive".

Shes being passive aggressive and is in fact showing you up as being weak and ineffective for the role. Find your balls and your voice or you may find her intention is to get you fired/demoted, and her moved into the position.

Don't take this shit. Take the stance in your mind that it's better to be thought of by her as a bit bossy, than for your bosses to think of you as weak and not right for the promotion.

2021x · 16/12/2023 04:16

Yup... big girl pants on. No more emails allows her to avoid. Ask her directly, and just wait for the response you need. Silence is more effective than words. It will be uncomfortable but when you have done it once it gets easier.

This is probably galling for her so she needs to chose how she handle it. Its not personal towards you, she has just been told she is not good enough.

Beinghonestforonce · 16/12/2023 03:59

I think its really hard to be promoted over your old colleagues and have to be their boss. Simple fix to this is precision as said above, refuse to accept wishy washy language like 'in due course', you need to set the deadline when you ask things, you've got a ship to run here, cant be waiting indefinitely to have meetings. At my place if you miss a meeting itd be very frowned upon unless ypu had a brilliant excuse and you'd be left out, left behind, tough titties!

Emeraldsanddiamonds · 16/12/2023 03:30

I tend to ask but I'm not dealing with people trying to undermine me. I have had a few occasions where I have got rid of people (eg told person recruiting that I refused to ever work with this sulky rude woman who had previously been a temp ever again and have been responsible in a very unfortunate situation for somebody being fired). I have had a very blunt talk to somebody who tried to undermine me in front of a team member - told her that she could say what she liked to me but never in front of a team member ever again. The key thing is to be pleasant but not eager to be liked. I treat people who work hard and are team players very well in terms of salary, preferred work types, training, flexible hours and so on so I'm not some kind of ogre.

EBearhug · 16/12/2023 02:51

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:26

Yes but it's ongoing, I haven't had any other issues so far. I have lead various projects.

Didn't you have to organise meetings when leading projects? Meetings should be the easy bit - you look in everyone's calendars and find a mutually suitable time (admittedly this isn't always so easy, if you have a lot of people) and tell them that's when it will be. If they don't keep their calendars up to date, it's their problem to fix.

Would it be easier to put in a recurring monthly or fortnightly meeting, and reschedule only if it becomes necessary?

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 16/12/2023 00:32

As previous people have said, you should be telling not asking. My boss sets a meeting for the team, I move things around to accommodate it! She needs to do the same for you.

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:26

ludicrouslycapaciousbags · 16/12/2023 00:24

Have you have relevant training to become a manager?

Yes but it's ongoing, I haven't had any other issues so far. I have lead various projects.

OP posts:
ludicrouslycapaciousbags · 16/12/2023 00:24

Have you have relevant training to become a manager?

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:23

Blobblobblob · 16/12/2023 00:17

It's difficult to change gears when you're promoted from within, but you just need to be calm and assertive.

It's your job to do this. Being wishy washy isn't good, it's confusing and annoying for the team. It also reinforces her belief that she should have got the job because you aren't acting like you deserve it.

We are meeting on X day at Y time. The end. Be polite, be friendly, but be decisive. She'll either get over it or not, and that's her issue not yours.

Thank you, this is helpful

OP posts:
1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:23

@PaulaPocket No unfortunately not, like I said this is my first senior position. I am just conscious of how come across to the team, who are all my previous colleagues.

OP posts:
Blobblobblob · 16/12/2023 00:17

It's difficult to change gears when you're promoted from within, but you just need to be calm and assertive.

It's your job to do this. Being wishy washy isn't good, it's confusing and annoying for the team. It also reinforces her belief that she should have got the job because you aren't acting like you deserve it.

We are meeting on X day at Y time. The end. Be polite, be friendly, but be decisive. She'll either get over it or not, and that's her issue not yours.

PaulaPocket · 16/12/2023 00:11

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:00

I don't want to seem bossy, maybe I'm not suitable for a senior position!!

Is this a joke?

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:07

Thanks for the responses, you are all telling me exactly what I know I should be doing. Fresh start Monday!

OP posts:
dahliaaa · 16/12/2023 00:06

She will continue to try to be evasive. To counteract this you need to be very precise with your questions. 'Please respond by 12 noon on Thursday.'
You can then say - I asked for responses by that time. You did not reply and so I chose a date based on the replies from the rest of the team.
Repeat every time.

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:05

Lochness1975 · 16/12/2023 00:02

Use supervision to get to the bottom of the issues. Plus you need to be telling her when the meetings are, not offering to move diary dates around to accommodate her.

We have supervision in January so hopefully we can smooth things over.
I am absolutely dreading it!

OP posts:
KaiserChefs · 16/12/2023 00:05

1982mommaof4 · 16/12/2023 00:00

I don't want to seem bossy, maybe I'm not suitable for a senior position!!

It's not bossy.
It's endlessly frustrating to work under someone who does everything by committee, it means things either take forever or never get done. Just make some decisions and tell her "we are doing X on date Y." If she comes back with a complaint that she's not available, "I'm sorry I caught you on the back foot, in future please respond to requests for availability in reasonable timeframes and I will be able to take your availability into account."
Don't let one person's opinion or complaints change what you are doing if it works for you and everyone else!

user1471447924 · 16/12/2023 00:05

Stop pandering to her straight away, because it will only get worse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread