Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still feel slightly bitter about this? (Inheriting social housing)

305 replies

Buddybud · 15/12/2023 22:34

I grew up in a two bed council house with my mother (single parent) and my sister in what could now be considered a highly gentrified area within walking distance of the city centre. My mother benefited from a life time tenancy. I left at eighteen to go to university, and my mother didn’t keep a place or bed for me. If I went back during the holidays i would have to sleep on the sofa which I found quite annoying especially when so many of my friends at Uni still had rooms in their parent’s houses. Fast forward a couple of years and I graduated, moved away, met my DH and we now have our own home but have been struggling with our mortgage due to cost of living, etc. My mother on the other hand remarried and moved in with her DH whilst putting my sister on the council house tenancy so my sister now has a life time tenancy with subsidised rent in an area I could never afford. Aibu to feel like that’s abit shitty?

OP posts:
NotARealWookiie · 16/12/2023 03:04

I totally understand the feelings of rejection after uni and the inequality now.

Ultimately though, at this point it can’t be made fair. You are older and have your own life. You can’t live in this property with your DH and your sister.

Sorry to hear you are struggling with the mortgage. Life is tough and not always fair.

Gowlett · 16/12/2023 03:03

It’s really a no-brainer to hold onto the place.
Unfair to you, I suppose. But it’s the same with my sister. She’s had Uni, gap year, two house deposits, a car, a wedding & a new extension. I’ve had none of those. I don’t say anything…

Zoreos · 16/12/2023 03:03

To a degree I do understand on the face of it your frustrations but I think there’s a few things you need to take into consideration.

You know already that for a property to exchange sole tenants that you would have to have lived in the property for two years.

I think your mum was very reasonable to originally convert her living room into a bedroom for you. Many people not unreasonably wouldn’t or couldn’t do that and you’d have been left as an adult to share your bedroom with your sister anyway. I think it would be usual in that arrangement if a young adult went off to university that they would turn their living room back. I’m going to assume your sister chose not to go to university because this would be a huge drip feed from you if she were allowed to move out then back in again. If THAT was the case I’d say YANBU. But we are to assume she has never moved out so has spent years consecutively living there.

On to my second point and most important. I’m going to assume you’ve lived with your husband for at least a few years considering the fact you have a mortgage and a husband. Can you honestly, hand on heart say that if you hadn’t gone to uni and your mum hadn’t married, that right now your circumstances would be that you and your husband would currently still likely be living in your mums dining room? Is it a stretch to wonder if your mother’s DH also lived at the property for at least a time as well? If yes, did you expect your mum not to move on and meet anyone? I think she’s been very lucky in meeting someone who could supply her with a new housing opportunity. Your mum is now vulnerable because if anything happens to this marriage she would likely be made homeless unless her new DH is minted and their house has enough equity for two houses after a divorce. She won’t be able to obtain a council property again easily if at all ever. It’s worth taking into account that tenancy agreements for council houses always have an occupancy limit written into them as well. (I am aware of the current housing crisis before anyone jumps on me and that many people are in this situation; but the housing association would take this on board before passing it down as a matter of contractual legality). If the answer to this question is Yes you could readily envisage you all living there together under the same room if you’d never moved out then YANBU. If the answer is no and that you’d have probably moved out anyway YABU because councils won’t give the option of a lifetime tenancy to someone who already owns their own home. At the end of the day, comparison is the thief of joy and whilst it’s hard now, you own your house and have little restriction with what you can do with it and when/if you have your own children you can leave your property to them forever so they’ll never face potential homelessness. Your sister may very well do at some stage in her life if she needs to move out.

Justfinking · 16/12/2023 02:59

steff13 · 16/12/2023 01:05

In the past month I have had to replace my water heater, my furnace, and my dishwasher. In the next year I'm going to have to replace my roof and my deck. I can think of some pros to renting.

Yes but you have an asset which consistently increases in value that is yours. If you were renting, your rent would probably be going up to cover those costs and after years you'd be no better off and left with nothing

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 02:57

TeaAndTattoos · 16/12/2023 02:44

I think you’ll find that it’s you who is being wilfully ignorant not @XenoBitch. You might want to go back and read your own post again where I think you will find that you wrote I graduated, moved away and met my dh. Now Incase you don’t feel like going back and rereading what you wrote I have helpfully screenshot the part for you. Learn how to remember what you wrote and stop being rude to people.

Read my other posts. I went on to elaborate in further detail.

OP posts:
Passingthethyme · 16/12/2023 02:56

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:30

In all honesty a-bit of money to make up for it would have been nice, but I would have settled with the acknowledgment that it was abit shitty.

Stop wanting handouts. YABU.

TeaAndTattoos · 16/12/2023 02:44

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 00:35

You either haven’t read the thread properly or you are just being wilfully ignorant now.

I think you’ll find that it’s you who is being wilfully ignorant not @XenoBitch. You might want to go back and read your own post again where I think you will find that you wrote I graduated, moved away and met my dh. Now Incase you don’t feel like going back and rereading what you wrote I have helpfully screenshot the part for you. Learn how to remember what you wrote and stop being rude to people.

To still feel slightly bitter about this? (Inheriting social housing)
dorriss · 16/12/2023 02:26

because no one can be. humans are just greedy, grasping b...ds worse since covid and full of judgement and envy

JanglingJack · 16/12/2023 02:19

It's not right at all.

Maybe Mum thought you were on your feet and living the life with DH - married with kids and a mortgage blah blah

Life time tenancies don't exist as they used to , so I wouldn't get too wound up thinking this is the situation.

DianaTiana · 16/12/2023 02:11

I too would feel very hurt, OP.

But, as they say, it's not what happens to you in life it's how you deal with it.

So live your life well and don't look back. You will ultimately be the winner.

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 02:11

Diggerdriverless · 16/12/2023 01:49

Jealousy and bitterness are only hurting you. I understand that you feel let down by your mother, not making space for you in her home in uni holidays and after graduation, but this isn't your sister's fault. Yet you seem to blame her too. Would you and your DH have actually wanted to share a 2 bed property with your mum and sister, sleeping in the dining room? Maybe you would have, to succeed to the tenancy, but possibly your mother moving out didn't look likely when you were renting?

i know it’s not her fault but she could at least acknowledge the unfairness of it all. But she doesn’t because she will never understand.

OP posts:
Amibeingadick · 16/12/2023 01:57

No of course she didn’t want it. But it doesn’t mean she can’t think it’s unfair

Diggerdriverless · 16/12/2023 01:49

Jealousy and bitterness are only hurting you. I understand that you feel let down by your mother, not making space for you in her home in uni holidays and after graduation, but this isn't your sister's fault. Yet you seem to blame her too. Would you and your DH have actually wanted to share a 2 bed property with your mum and sister, sleeping in the dining room? Maybe you would have, to succeed to the tenancy, but possibly your mother moving out didn't look likely when you were renting?

Amibeingadick · 16/12/2023 01:45

no you’re not being unreasonable at all. I can’t believe the responses fro people on here. 🥲 no wonder you’re bitter. You’re doing the right thing for yiou. It’s ok to be bitter just don’t let it ruin what you have x

allitdoesisrain · 16/12/2023 01:39

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:30

In all honesty a-bit of money to make up for it would have been nice, but I would have settled with the acknowledgment that it was abit shitty.

This is unreasonable. She might not have had it to spare, but even if she did, she didn't owe you anything. Yes, you were paying rent. That's what grown ups do and that's theirs to manage. It's quite possible that your sister has done more caring for your mother (or will) and it's balancing out some other way.

When I was a young newly wed, renting a small apartment, my mother took my sibling on a round the world trip that she paid for. I didn't resent it or expect compensation. I'd started my own adult life, so it was different.

Your last few posts make it sound like this issue is just a tiny slither of what has gone on though. It's almost like this issue is the scapegoat for a bigger picture. Don't mix up genuine gripes with unrealistic or unfair expectations though.

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:37

Panaa · 16/12/2023 01:36

Does she have money to give to you?

I hear you on wanting acknowledgement and if your mother is resistant to that then you're probably never likely to get it. I'm no contact with my parents now for various reasons but I probably wouldn't have taken that no contact step if they had acknowledged stuff from the past, but that was never going to happen so I did what was right for me!

Ditto.

OP posts:
Panaa · 16/12/2023 01:36

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:30

In all honesty a-bit of money to make up for it would have been nice, but I would have settled with the acknowledgment that it was abit shitty.

Does she have money to give to you?

I hear you on wanting acknowledgement and if your mother is resistant to that then you're probably never likely to get it. I'm no contact with my parents now for various reasons but I probably wouldn't have taken that no contact step if they had acknowledged stuff from the past, but that was never going to happen so I did what was right for me!

LusaBatoosa · 16/12/2023 01:35

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:16

I will give only as much detail as I am comfortable with, and I certainly won’t give ages or dates. 😊

Ballpark? Twenties, thirties, forties, etc?

LBFseBrom · 16/12/2023 01:34

Eekmystro · 15/12/2023 22:40

It’s a shitty situation, but the issue is the horrific housing market/social housing shortage not the actions of your mum or sister. However not having a bed when you were home from uni was harsh!

Yes, I don't get that at all. Presumably, you shared a bedroom with your sister before uni, why could you not share with her when you came home for the holidays? Most people would do that. Did your mother and sister not like you?

Regarding your sister 'inheriting' the tenancy, I see nothing wrong with that and don't understand why you are jealous. She has to live somewhere and that has always been her home; you have your own house and don't need it. It's likely that sister will eventually go in for her own place and leave her current home (unless she is allowed to buy it at some stage). It doesn't really affect you and I am sure you prefer being a home owner to a tenant.

Jealousy is a pointless, immature emotion that damages you. Move on!

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:33

Robinni · 16/12/2023 01:29

Yes I know @Longtimelurkerfinallyposts its late and my brain wasn’t fully engaged. I apologised to OP and corrected immediately - can’t edit as on phone.

I do think she might need counselling though to work through her feelings and move to a healthier position for herself.

All the resentment, it isn’t doing anything but cause harm to herself; the Mum and sister are fine by all accounts.

It’s ok. She’s basically dead to me anyway.

OP posts:
Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:32

allitdoesisrain · 16/12/2023 01:27

Yes, mother moved out. Doesn't it make sense to pass the tenancy on to the one already living there, especially when the other is married and has their own home already?

We were still renting and paying an exorbitant amount when this happened.

OP posts:
Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:30

Panaa · 16/12/2023 01:25

But your mum didn't have the means to give something to both of you by the sounds of it so what was she to do?

In all honesty a-bit of money to make up for it would have been nice, but I would have settled with the acknowledgment that it was abit shitty.

OP posts:
Robinni · 16/12/2023 01:29

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 16/12/2023 01:25

The OP hasn't said that her mother died! She got married and moved in with her new DH! Leaving the sister in what had been the family home.
So I'm not sure that 'bereavement' counselling is what's needed here.
Maybe some PPs have assumed that the OP's mum had died due to the word "inheriting" in the thread title? The legal term for what's happened is that the sister's succeeded the mum as the tenant, so a "tenancy succession" rather than what most people think of as an "inheritance".

Yes I know @Longtimelurkerfinallyposts its late and my brain wasn’t fully engaged. I apologised to OP and corrected immediately - can’t edit as on phone.

I do think she might need counselling though to work through her feelings and move to a healthier position for herself.

All the resentment, it isn’t doing anything but cause harm to herself; the Mum and sister are fine by all accounts.

Buddybud · 16/12/2023 01:28

I don’t speak to either of them anymore. I feel justified in not speaking to my mum as my childhood was horrific, but I sometimes feel guilty about my sister. But if she can’t understand why I’d be upset then it’s not worth trying to have a relationship with her.

OP posts:
silemen · 16/12/2023 01:28

Delightfuldays · 16/12/2023 00:53

I thought you could only succeed a tenancy if the main applicant dies.
Not just because they want to move out and don't need the property.

Are you sure your sister has succeeded a 2 bed property especially as she is only a 1 bed need?

Succeeding is the term for inheriting a council tenancy when the original tenant dies.

https://england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/council_housing_association/can_you_inherit_a_council_tenancy

Assigning a council tenancy is the term for putting the tenancy into someone else's name (which is done by the original tenant while they are alive).

https://england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/council_housing_association/assigning_a_tenancy

OP has used the term inherit to mean "putting the tenancy into her sister's name" but as the mum is still alive it's clear the legal term is assignment not succession.

Shelter icon

Can you inherit a council tenancy? - Shelter England

You can sometimes inherit a tenancy from another joint tenant, a partner or close relative who you live with. Find out about the council tenancy succession rules.

https://england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/council_housing_association/can_you_inherit_a_council_tenancy

Swipe left for the next trending thread