Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teaching Assistants excluded from class Christmas present

341 replies

LyricalBoudicca · 15/12/2023 16:35

Class representative organised the traditional Christmas whip-round to buy vouchers for the teacher with a % given to the rest of the school staff community to save teachers/staff being inundated with lots of gifts. This year they have announced that the 2 TAs in the class will not be included in the voucher gifting because they only work with 2 SEN children and not the rest of the class. AIBU in thinking this is a bit mean? Nobody has to take part of course but I feel rather uncomfortable about the whole situation.

OP posts:
GRex · 17/12/2023 11:28

Tandora · 17/12/2023 10:43

Parents aren’t hear to subsidise TA salaries!!

This whole gift giving for teachers has got completely out of hand. It used to be just a small token to acknowledge / say thank you to your kids teacher at the end of the year. Now there’s all this fundraising to buy a million different people gifts every term. My kid’s class of 30 has 2 teachers and 5 TAs!

Surely the SEN TAs can expect a thank you (in whatever form) from the parents of the kids they are there to support?

Are you really so stingy that you can't bear for 50p of your money to go to thanking someone at Christmas who looks after your child's friend? Couldn't you be grateful that your child doesn't have additional needs and be kind to those supporting children who do?

I'm getting ever more baffled here, I struggle to believe real humans are this selfish. I'm so glad parents in our class aren't like this.

jmh740 · 17/12/2023 11:14

WhichIsItWendy · 17/12/2023 09:56

That's bad practice of the school then. They're saving the money of a TA but using you - when you're supposed to be there for the SEN child only.

So your SEN child doesn't get you 1 to 1 even though their EHCP says they should? :(

Our school is outstanding for sen, isn't a general ta in the whole school with 1300 children just sen tas and no we don't get extra pay for sen.we have at least 50 ehcp children and 23 tas, I've worked as a ta for 10 years in various schools and never just worked with 1 child.

AnneValentine · 17/12/2023 11:08

Tandora · 17/12/2023 10:43

Parents aren’t hear to subsidise TA salaries!!

This whole gift giving for teachers has got completely out of hand. It used to be just a small token to acknowledge / say thank you to your kids teacher at the end of the year. Now there’s all this fundraising to buy a million different people gifts every term. My kid’s class of 30 has 2 teachers and 5 TAs!

Surely the SEN TAs can expect a thank you (in whatever form) from the parents of the kids they are there to support?

Which is the entire class.

Tandora · 17/12/2023 10:43

Hipnotised · 15/12/2023 16:37

That's really shitty, especially bearing in mind how little TAs get paid.

Parents aren’t hear to subsidise TA salaries!!

This whole gift giving for teachers has got completely out of hand. It used to be just a small token to acknowledge / say thank you to your kids teacher at the end of the year. Now there’s all this fundraising to buy a million different people gifts every term. My kid’s class of 30 has 2 teachers and 5 TAs!

Surely the SEN TAs can expect a thank you (in whatever form) from the parents of the kids they are there to support?

AnneValentine · 17/12/2023 10:39

Soontobe60 · 17/12/2023 10:06

Sadly thats increasingly becoming not the case. My mainstream school has 7 children who’s EHCPs state 1:1 adult support for 32.5 hours a week - those children are all on a waiting list for special school because no mainstream school can meet their profound needs. The schools in our cluster are all in the same position. 5 years ago, this was not the case because there was more availability of special school places. The system is totally broken.

1:1 adult support doesn’t mean they cannot step away but that’s a badly worded ehcp regardless.

Blinkin · 17/12/2023 10:38

It's not really true that these 1:1 TAs free up the teacher. Without them, many of these children just wouldn't be in mainstream full stop.

This thread is going round in circles anyway with it being repeated over and over that 1:1 TAs always work with the rest of the class when it's been stated by various posters working in schools that's not always the case. Some posters are underestimating the level of need some pupils in mainstream demonstrate (children who undoubtedly would have been in special schools a decade ago). And no, it's not inclusion by any means, but it is what the government has made it.

User2346 · 17/12/2023 10:19

My DS had a 1 to 1 in primary school and part of the remit was that she did small group work including my DS plus run clubs such as Lego and sewing. On top of that she was the school’s ELSA practitioner so very much part of the class.

Underhisi · 17/12/2023 10:12

The 1:1 TAs will be contributing to the class running smoothly even if they only ever work directly with one child. You would notice a difference if they weren't there.

rrf · 17/12/2023 10:10

@Flamingbow spot on, and completely accurate about the amount of support required for individual children.
I think it's important to remember, inside the classroom, we act as a team. We do not see the 121 as different, they are an important part of our TEAM. A valuable lesson for children to learn. EVERYONE counts, and everyone helps make the classroom a great environment.

Soontobe60 · 17/12/2023 10:06

AnneValentine · 17/12/2023 09:58

It’s exceptionally rare for an EHCP to require that a TA is 1:1 at all times to the extent of excluding others.

Sadly thats increasingly becoming not the case. My mainstream school has 7 children who’s EHCPs state 1:1 adult support for 32.5 hours a week - those children are all on a waiting list for special school because no mainstream school can meet their profound needs. The schools in our cluster are all in the same position. 5 years ago, this was not the case because there was more availability of special school places. The system is totally broken.

Flamingbow · 17/12/2023 10:03

WhichIsItWendy · 17/12/2023 09:56

That's bad practice of the school then. They're saving the money of a TA but using you - when you're supposed to be there for the SEN child only.

So your SEN child doesn't get you 1 to 1 even though their EHCP says they should? :(

But 1:1 support doesn't mean stuck side by side in a locked part of the classroom segregated from all of the other children for the entirety of their school careers. 1:1 support is different for every child who needs it, but invariably a part of it for the majority is the TA supporting inclusion into small groups or class activities, for example. That's still supporting the child 1:1, but not necessarily by themselves. Some classes don't have any classroom TAs at all anymore, this doesn't mean that the 1:1s don't do what they should, but that it doesn't mean the poster is doing anything wrong that warrants a sad face by stating a fact. Even if the TA is sat away from all of the other children they're still a part of the classroom, it's sad some parents wouldn't be teaching their children that.

AnneValentine · 17/12/2023 09:58

WhichIsItWendy · 17/12/2023 09:56

That's bad practice of the school then. They're saving the money of a TA but using you - when you're supposed to be there for the SEN child only.

So your SEN child doesn't get you 1 to 1 even though their EHCP says they should? :(

It’s exceptionally rare for an EHCP to require that a TA is 1:1 at all times to the extent of excluding others.

WhichIsItWendy · 17/12/2023 09:56

jmh740 · 17/12/2023 08:57

No general ta just me

That's bad practice of the school then. They're saving the money of a TA but using you - when you're supposed to be there for the SEN child only.

So your SEN child doesn't get you 1 to 1 even though their EHCP says they should? :(

threatmatrix · 17/12/2023 09:47

You can always get them a small present just from you, wine is always appreciated.

rrf · 17/12/2023 09:42

The 1-2-1 TAs job is to make sure the work is appropriately set and/ or accessable for their child, but ALSO to make sure they are included socially and emotionally in everyday classroom life. So they WILL take small groups and work with other children, and they will most certainly speak with, and deal with other children in the class, every day. They don't just sit in the corner and work exclusively with one child, because that's not inclusive is it? I think the SEN TA should get a pressie. I don't understand why they wouldn't. As an aside, the other kids probably really like him/her and have had positive interactions/ helped by/ Surely this is what it's all about?

Ilovecleaning · 17/12/2023 09:38

Very bad example to set for children- it’s ok to leave people out.

Beautiful3 · 17/12/2023 09:35

@User2346 · Yesterday 22:48

"So SEND parents are far more likely to be living in poverty? Jesus Christ what a thing to say and inaccurate to say the least and very offensive."

It's actually true. I've worked with disabled children/young adults in education for 10 years. Most of them, come from low income backgrounds.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 17/12/2023 09:25

Sparklyormatte · 15/12/2023 16:40

The other children the TAs don’t actually help are still benefitting from the TA though, if they weren’t there the teacher would be spread much thinner and the children the TA don’t interact with would have much less of the teachers time and attention.

I think this is a really good point!

Flamingbow · 17/12/2023 09:24

Africa2004 · 17/12/2023 08:57

I think you’ve misunderstood me. I totally value our class TA’s and they are included fairly in gifts. It’s the one’s employed as a 1:1 who I hope are focusing on one child that I’m referring to. If my child had a 1:1 I know I would but them a huge gift but not expect other parents to also.

I think there's a lot of ignorance around this to be honest. A child requiring 1:1 TA support doesn't just sit segregated from the rest of the class all day, locked away with zero integration at all. For some children interactions with the rest of the class is limited, but for others even on 1:1 part of the support they recieve is support in joining in with small groups or with whole class activities. The 1:1 TA will also no doubt be helping around the classroom after school hours as other school staff do to help put up displays, assist with admin stuff and tonnes of other invisible duties- even if they don't (which they shouldn't tbh as its not fair on them), if the child is off school they'll help where needed across the classroom or wider school. Their presence also benefits the other children in the class indirectly by meaning the teacher and other support staff aren't having to give a disproportionate amount of support to children who need it at expense of the others. Most importantly imo is that it's good for children to see them as an equal part of the classroom, they bring value to all of the children and I hate the othering and exclusion it promotes, not just for the TA but to the children and their family.

WilderRose · 17/12/2023 09:23

As a previous poster said, some children genuinely need a shadowing one to one. In our school there is a child who has such support and there is no class TA either. Without a one to one TA this class could not function. Teacher and TA are on their toes all day every day. A juggling act all day. Lunch times hard as simply not budget for child to have one to one then. TA incredibly committed.

GRex · 17/12/2023 09:23

Africa2004 · 17/12/2023 08:54

I recognise that the class TA is there for the whole class but the ones who are employed as a 1:1 are surely there to meet the needs of that one child? Without that need there’d just be the class TA.

The child is part of the class. If the gifts are from the whole class, then they should recognise the contribution for that child. The same way a whole class party should include that child. As others have said, there will also be benefits to other children such as small group work, but even if there was no benefit to any other child the TA is part of one team looking after that class and deserves a bloody card and gift just the same as the others. This othering is really very disturbing to me. Do you really not see after all these comments that TAs are just humans, with feelings, so it is nice to say happy Christmas alongside their colleagues?

AnneValentine · 17/12/2023 09:13

Beautiful3 · 17/12/2023 09:07

For 2 years I was a TA for a disabled child. I never got any christmas presents or cards. The teachers got them all. I did think it was a bit unfair. But I suppose the parents viewed me as x's support and nothing to do with their child. The child I supported came from a low income family, so I didn't expect anything anyway. When my children went to school, I made sure to get equal presents for the TA and teachers. Not only are they underpaid, they work really hard.

Honestly it’s so gross. And so exclusionary.

Beautiful3 · 17/12/2023 09:07

For 2 years I was a TA for a disabled child. I never got any christmas presents or cards. The teachers got them all. I did think it was a bit unfair. But I suppose the parents viewed me as x's support and nothing to do with their child. The child I supported came from a low income family, so I didn't expect anything anyway. When my children went to school, I made sure to get equal presents for the TA and teachers. Not only are they underpaid, they work really hard.

AnneValentine · 17/12/2023 09:06

Africa2004 · 17/12/2023 08:54

I recognise that the class TA is there for the whole class but the ones who are employed as a 1:1 are surely there to meet the needs of that one child? Without that need there’d just be the class TA.

They don’t though. That’s the point. Very very few children actually have a specified 1:1 and even those who do don’t actually need the 1:1 at all times.

We have a student who needs 1:1 for medical needs - her lesson based needs are none so the TA supports the rest of the class.

Another has one for behavioural needs but again that’s sporadic throughout lessons so TA will support whole class.

student with learning needs, vast majority of support is small group based.

What actually happens with the vast majority of 1:1’s is they are used to support all children who need extra help. The average school, 1/5 have SEN. If there is a TA in your class it means those with needs are supported - all of them - and the class teacher is supported to support all children. I guarantee you your child benefits whether it’s directly or indirectly. Our classes that thrive are those fortunate enough to have a child with a TA.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 17/12/2023 09:00

really bad form. And surely without the TAs the teachers would have far less time for the kids with no SENs? So they all benefit.