Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teaching Assistants excluded from class Christmas present

341 replies

LyricalBoudicca · 15/12/2023 16:35

Class representative organised the traditional Christmas whip-round to buy vouchers for the teacher with a % given to the rest of the school staff community to save teachers/staff being inundated with lots of gifts. This year they have announced that the 2 TAs in the class will not be included in the voucher gifting because they only work with 2 SEN children and not the rest of the class. AIBU in thinking this is a bit mean? Nobody has to take part of course but I feel rather uncomfortable about the whole situation.

OP posts:
TheHeadOfTheHouse · 15/12/2023 20:27

greengreengrass25 · 15/12/2023 20:24

To be fair though you are not paying for the TA out your own pocket

Yes I bloody well am!

ive had to pay the school for her due to ‘no funding’ and being refused the EHCP.

i had no bloody choice but to cough up the many thousands of pounds for her.

PicaK · 15/12/2023 20:26

Hsng on. The main block funding contains a certain amount to support SEN children. So the SEN kids don't take away resource. Then there are Higher Level Need payments depending whether child is E1 E2 E3 or E4.
Lots of TAs with 1:1s have an additional SEN payment but my god its minimal.

greengreengrass25 · 15/12/2023 20:24

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 15/12/2023 20:13

My son has a 1-1 for half of the day (the TA doesn’t work afternoons) and there is another child with a full time 1-1.

in the class collection, we both said no to the 1-1s being included in the standard pot.

we buy our 1-1 a present separate from the pot (but we both still contribute to the pot) as we don’t expect them to be included in the main pot when they only deal with our child.

its concerned me that so many 1-1 teachers are being used for other children when they aren’t funded for them.

To be fair though you are not paying for the TA out your own pocket

UrsulaBelle · 15/12/2023 20:21

In my case as a 1:1, the child needed to be integrated with the class for his developmental needs. He was supported by me and he was my first priority but if I’d stuck by him like glue he wouldn’t have been able to join in with the rest of the class, socially and in group work. So I could have sat separately and refused to work with any other children 🤷🏼‍♀️when he didn’t need me, but that would have been weird.

Changeinschoolperhaps · 15/12/2023 20:20

@Ihatemondaymorning
EHCP states that 15 hours 121 are funded but child actually needs 30 hours 121.
Funding therefore has to be found from elsewhere….. so usually means fewer ‘class TAs’ or other resources that benefit all children are cut.

I'm not blaming the child or the school… the system is fucked.

I’d say majority of EHCPs do not fund sufficient hours for the needs of children.
Sadly, the SEN children are taking resource away from others. But if the hours are not provided, the consequences or disruption is worse.
And people wonder why schools are crumbling and there is no money. But this is why schools are not jumping at the chance to accept more SEN children.
And this is also why schools with low levels of SEN often get higher ofsted ratings as they have more money and more resource.

TheHeadOfTheHouse · 15/12/2023 20:13

My son has a 1-1 for half of the day (the TA doesn’t work afternoons) and there is another child with a full time 1-1.

in the class collection, we both said no to the 1-1s being included in the standard pot.

we buy our 1-1 a present separate from the pot (but we both still contribute to the pot) as we don’t expect them to be included in the main pot when they only deal with our child.

its concerned me that so many 1-1 teachers are being used for other children when they aren’t funded for them.

GRex · 15/12/2023 20:09

TurquoiseDress · 15/12/2023 19:58

Er no I don't think that one set of parents/single parent should pay £72.50 or whatever, how ridiculous...can't tag the poster who wrote that

I'm talking about a gift eg big box of chocolates or something from the parents whose child has a 1 to 1 TA

Look I contributed to our class whip round, presents were bought for the teacher and TA

The other class I have no idea what was contributed/exact amount...and equally no idea what gifts were bought.

All I know is parent(s) of child with 1 to 1 TA bought an individual gift which they apparently really wanted to do and were happy with this. They didn't contribute to the main class collection...which is fair enough (although I'm sure I'll be told otherwise!)

This

Ah, you couldn't follow logic. What a shame.

TurquoiseDress · 15/12/2023 19:58

Er no I don't think that one set of parents/single parent should pay £72.50 or whatever, how ridiculous...can't tag the poster who wrote that

I'm talking about a gift eg big box of chocolates or something from the parents whose child has a 1 to 1 TA

Look I contributed to our class whip round, presents were bought for the teacher and TA

The other class I have no idea what was contributed/exact amount...and equally no idea what gifts were bought.

All I know is parent(s) of child with 1 to 1 TA bought an individual gift which they apparently really wanted to do and were happy with this. They didn't contribute to the main class collection...which is fair enough (although I'm sure I'll be told otherwise!)

This

stayathomer · 15/12/2023 19:56

Yanbu but unfortunately I’ve never seen people give presents to the tas that didn’t have direct and constant contact with them. Tbh my first and best gift generally goes to the school secretary as she deals with more crap than anyone!!

Notmetoo · 15/12/2023 19:54

That's horrible. TAs get paid a pittance and they are the ones that provide the care and support to the children

rosyglowcondition · 15/12/2023 19:54

If a child has a one to one, of course the parent should gift the TA.

Ihatemondaymorning · 15/12/2023 19:53

@Changeinschoolperhaps could you explain a bit more about that
how is said child having a 1-1 taking recourses away from other children ?

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 15/12/2023 19:53

That's awful.

I would remove myself from that.

Changeinschoolperhaps · 15/12/2023 19:49

As above…. The 121s I know are often only funded for say 15 hours but the school have to top up and use them full time as the needs of the child are so severe they are needed for 30 hours.
They might occasionally help another child but they are in no way ‘class TAs’.

The assumption that they are all helping other children and benefiting them is untrue…. In fact having them there full
time dedicated to one child is taking resource away from the other children (but that’s a whole other thread and not the fault of the 121, school or the SEN child).

They are sometimes included in class collections, sometimes not. I can see how they would feel if not included so I think I’ll push for them to always be included in future. I hadn’t really given it much thought and haven’t organised myself! But equally, if I was buying individual gifts I wouldn’t buy them one myself if they are not ever supporting my child.

Blinkin · 15/12/2023 19:40

Ihatemondaymorning · 15/12/2023 19:31

The assumption that every school use a child’s dedicated 1-1 as classroom help etc is so wrong.
not every school goes against what a child EHCP says. If a child here needs a 1-1 for 32.5 hours a week that is exactly what they get.

Exactly. As before, absolutely include them in a present for all the reasons mentioned above but I completely disagree that all TAs are essentially general TAs for some of their hours. There are children in mainstream who could be in special schools if their parents chose. Sometimes their needs are such that they don't do group work or other activities with the rest of the class.

Shopper727 · 15/12/2023 19:35

That’s so petty. The sla in my sons class last year was shocking however I still gave to the gifts at Christmas and end of term for both teacher and sla

UrsulaBelle · 15/12/2023 19:34

I was a 1:1 TA with a boy for 4 years. His parents didn’t want the rest of the class to know I was ‘his’ TA so it was never mentioned. I always worked with whatever group he was in or with other children if the teacher was working with his group. I was the only TA with the class in the afternoons. I helped with trips, performances etc. After 4 years I knew his class really well. I got a handful of gifts compared to the teacher and morning class TA. It was a bit galling, when I had spent more time with those children than any other member of staff, but I guess they thought I was ‘just the 1:1.’

GRex · 15/12/2023 19:32

TurquoiseDress · 15/12/2023 19:15

In our year 1 class we did a whip round and bought gifts for the teacher and the TA

In one of the other year 1 classes there is a 1 to 1 TA for one of the pupils, as far as I know they bought gifts for the teacher and main class TA but not the 1 to 1 TA- their logic is that the parents would buy them something directly

So the parents are to contribute for the 1-1 while 29 other parents contribute say £5 for the teacher and shared TA. That's £72.50 for the teacher, £72.50 for shared TA, and how much for the 1-1? You think the parents of the child with additional needs should pay £72.50, only because their child has additional needs, just to ensure that a low wage worker gets a fair Xmas gift?

The charitable version of why you think this is that you didn't get the help you clearly needed at school with maths from a decent TA.

Ihatemondaymorning · 15/12/2023 19:31

The assumption that every school use a child’s dedicated 1-1 as classroom help etc is so wrong.
not every school goes against what a child EHCP says. If a child here needs a 1-1 for 32.5 hours a week that is exactly what they get.

NameChange30 · 15/12/2023 19:28

I voted YANBU and I'm glad to read that the majority agree.

My DC is in Y2 and there has been one TA in each class so far, we have met the TAs because they're always at the classroom door with the teacher when we collect, and DC talks about them a lot. So I have always done cards and presents for the TA as well as the teacher. I organised collective gifts at the end of last year - gift vouchers of equal amounts for the teacher and TA.

There have been no 1-2-1 TA's in my child's class, but if there were, I would definitely have included them when organising a collective gift. With a contribution of £10 per child, if there are 30 in the class that's £300, which is plenty to share between a teacher and 2 TAs, that's £100 each or £150 for teacher and £75 for TAs if you must differentiate.

CarolinaInTheMorning · 15/12/2023 19:16

Getoverit1965 · 15/12/2023 18:49

If the teaching assistants work 1 to 1 only with the SEN children or is for a reason. They need that level of support to be in the classroom and having them there let's the other children get along with less interruptions etc. They benefit the whole class regardless of who they are physically helping. I've never heard anything so miserable in my life as leaving them out of a gift.

Exactly. It's immaterial whether the TAs help other children. They are there to make learning more accessible for the pupils they support and which also benefits the entire group. It's an important aspect of the social model of disability: to remove barriers so that all can participate.

TurquoiseDress · 15/12/2023 19:15

In our year 1 class we did a whip round and bought gifts for the teacher and the TA

In one of the other year 1 classes there is a 1 to 1 TA for one of the pupils, as far as I know they bought gifts for the teacher and main class TA but not the 1 to 1 TA- their logic is that the parents would buy them something directly

MissingMoominMamma · 15/12/2023 19:12

I’m employed as a 1-1 with a child. Ask any of the children in our class and they would list me as one of the staff who help them.

Hipponimous · 15/12/2023 19:12

My daughter (primary) has a 1:1. She gets full time 1:1 support - but ofcourse 'her' ta still supports the rest of the class. And this has been the case with all her TAs through her schooling - I can't imagine how it would work otherwise?? My child doesn't just sit in a corner with her ta on her own 😅 she is a full member of the class and she and her ta are involved in everything. I always contribute to the class gift and for the first couple of years I used to say to the other parents that I didn't mind being responsible for that TA's gift if they preferred but they never took me up on it and now I have stopped offering - the ta deserves to be treated like other classroom staff. I do usually buy a token extra myself but it's only a token as that's all I can afford.

GRex · 15/12/2023 19:10

The whole "1-1 parents should get" is ludicrous, those parents give to the teacher as well. Besides which, it's just not in the spirit of Christmas giving is it? The whole point of giving as a class is so one person can give £50 and another 50p, but the adults around them are all thanked equally by all the children.