Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 08:07

WickDittington · 17/12/2023 08:04

The poster who claimed that wanting to work remotely and stating that their DC suffered during lockdown want it both ways

That’s actually not what I wrote. I wrote that I’d like to see a Venn diagram of posters holding those views.

It's part of what you wrote. You also put 'you can't have it both ways'.

WickDittington · 17/12/2023 08:04

The poster who claimed that wanting to work remotely and stating that their DC suffered during lockdown want it both ways

That’s actually not what I wrote. I wrote that I’d like to see a Venn diagram of posters holding those views.

WickDittington · 17/12/2023 08:01

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 06:59

I'm not sure people are thinking that WFH is the same as lockdown. It's people acknowledging that hybrid isn't WFH and that there's skills involved in developing positive soft skills in the workplace.

There's a group of people that seem to think that because they've got a fully WFH job, that people are reasonable for accepting a hybrid job and turning it into WFH by stealth or awkwardness because you don't need to be in the office, you don't have to be in person to learn, you don't need to have positive workplace relationships, you don't have to be together to collaborate, repeat ad nauseum about everything.

Yes indeed @LolaSmiles

We discovered during lockdown just how much we can do working remotely. But in many fields - and often the more creative and complex requiring high levels of a range of skills - working remotely is not a substitute for in person co-location. Hybrid working seems reasonable in such cases.

As an academic (thus creative work requiring extremely high levels of complex skills) I’ve always worked in what we now call “hybrid” mode. But my job isn’t humdrum admin or spreadsheets ….

It’s not unreasonable of @Benibidibici to insist on employees satisfying the terms of their contracts.

socialworker222 · 17/12/2023 07:48

Couldn't agree more OP. I managed a couple of staff who variously opted to move further away and got dogs, and now constantly ask for flexibility around this and say the commute impacts their wellbeing. The majority just come in as asked. We have a very clear onsite requirement as we are customer-facing. I'm very flexible but it is being abused by a few so sadly I am going to have to narrow the reasons for flexibility, monitor, than use HR process to enforce business need. It's really frustrating, the entitlement and lack of personal responsibility.

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 07:34

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 06:59

I'm not sure people are thinking that WFH is the same as lockdown. It's people acknowledging that hybrid isn't WFH and that there's skills involved in developing positive soft skills in the workplace.

There's a group of people that seem to think that because they've got a fully WFH job, that people are reasonable for accepting a hybrid job and turning it into WFH by stealth or awkwardness because you don't need to be in the office, you don't have to be in person to learn, you don't need to have positive workplace relationships, you don't have to be together to collaborate, repeat ad nauseum about everything.

The poster who claimed that wanting to work remotely and stating that their DC suffered during lockdown want it both ways was doing just that, though. If they didn't mean to make a lockdown comparison, they wouldn't have mentioned it. What you have written here is something quite different.

As for ad nauseum, you've come out with one of the commonest tropes here yourself. Conflating positive working relationships and collaboration with being physically present in the workplace. I don't doubt that there are some of you who need to do this for your roles, and if you say that has to happen in the office I believe you. But some of us have jobs where we need to achieve that with people who don't happen to live within commuting distance of our employers.

NonPlayerCharacter · 17/12/2023 07:25

doodlepants · 17/12/2023 06:13

@NonPlayerCharacter they have given me a laptop... but it's a laptop. Can't look at 3 spreadsheets at once on a laptop. I have a £2.5k gaming pc with 3 screens at home and would much rather use that. Also ultra high speed internet that we pay extra for (husband is a serious gamer). I don't know many work places that shell out £2.5k on each pc...

A six figure industry and they don't also give you a large screen, dongle, cables, mouse, keyboard and headset?

What industry is this?

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 07:24

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 07:09

It’s not a personal attack, I’m genuinely wondering and asking what your motivation and thinking process is.

TBF, Blossomtoes isn't the only poster who's come out with that one. There was another barely disguised just you wait from someone upthread, AI themed in this case, and I don't think that poster is retired. It's not an age thing.

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 17/12/2023 07:17

I run Christmas stalls with temp staff and many have long commutes.
They get £10 hr and some have long commutes, one girl travels one hour each way and works 9-6 for 4 days, works another job inBurger King for 2 days and is doing a degree in accounting as well while sending her money to India to support her mother and two children (father died).
Another staff member has a 2hour commute and works for 3 days a week, another commutes for 7 days a week (for a month) for 2 hours each way.
Your staff just seem incredibly privileged to me to be on such high wages and I bet the staff who serve them coffee earning £10 hr commute for just as long and more frequently.
I think you need to put your foot down and insist that it’s a necessity to come in a few days a week for team cohesion.

BIossomtoes · 17/12/2023 07:12

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 07:09

It’s not a personal attack, I’m genuinely wondering and asking what your motivation and thinking process is.

And it’s of no relevance. It was a personal attack.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 07:09

It’s not a personal attack, I’m genuinely wondering and asking what your motivation and thinking process is.

BIossomtoes · 17/12/2023 07:06

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 06:13

Why is it so important for you to believe this and keep stating it? It seems like you really resent the fact that workers have more power to negotiate favourable working conditions these days.

Why is that? Is it because it’s now too late for you to benefit and you are jealous of the flexibility and new opportunities available to the younger generation?

Can we not have a reasonable discussion without personal attacks?

I’m not remotely jealous, I’m one of those people who don’t want their home to be their workplace and like the separation. I’m just appalled at the level of entitlement this thread’s revealed.

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 06:59

I'm not sure people are thinking that WFH is the same as lockdown. It's people acknowledging that hybrid isn't WFH and that there's skills involved in developing positive soft skills in the workplace.

There's a group of people that seem to think that because they've got a fully WFH job, that people are reasonable for accepting a hybrid job and turning it into WFH by stealth or awkwardness because you don't need to be in the office, you don't have to be in person to learn, you don't need to have positive workplace relationships, you don't have to be together to collaborate, repeat ad nauseum about everything.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 06:21

WickDittington · 16/12/2023 14:32

YANBU @Benibidibici and I suspect that a number of PPs who tell you that you are have very humdrum admin jobs which could be done anywhere. Rather than what sounds like your quite creative dynamic workplace

There are many professions where real collaboration around a table is essential. And there are a whole slew of jobs such as teaching or medical care where in person is essential for health and life!

I’d be really interested to see a Venn diagram of PPs who say that in person work is old-fashioned, bad etc and posters who moan all the time at how terrible lockdown was for their DC. You can’t have it both ways.

I think conflating WFH with being in lockdown is the problem for some people.

WFH is not being in lockdown. WFH does not mean no socialising. and personally, when I am at work, wherever that is, I do not see it as a social occasion. That is when I do my job, whatever that might be.

When you WFH, You’re free to socialise with friends, go out, visit family, have holidays etc. in fact you have more time to do this, as you’re not wasting time commuting. It’s nothing like being in lockdown. If you don’t like WFH and feel it is bad for you personally, then fine! Don’t do it!

But you should accept it when other people say that they do like it and it improves their wellbeing.

doodlepants · 17/12/2023 06:13

@NonPlayerCharacter they have given me a laptop... but it's a laptop. Can't look at 3 spreadsheets at once on a laptop. I have a £2.5k gaming pc with 3 screens at home and would much rather use that. Also ultra high speed internet that we pay extra for (husband is a serious gamer). I don't know many work places that shell out £2.5k on each pc...

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 06:13

BIossomtoes · 16/12/2023 13:29

It's an employees market overall.

For now. The economy has a habit of changing and the labour market is one of the first to be affected when it does. The economy isn’t looking very healthy right now.

Why is it so important for you to believe this and keep stating it? It seems like you really resent the fact that workers have more power to negotiate favourable working conditions these days.

Why is that? Is it because it’s now too late for you to benefit and you are jealous of the flexibility and new opportunities available to the younger generation?

SharSharBinks · 17/12/2023 06:03

I'd be tempted to tell them the business needs them in four days a week now!

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 05:58

OP, are the people concerned actually getting their allocated work complete? Ie, are they coming in when they have physical testing to do, but then just staying at home to do the rest of it?

And if so, could you consider whether the 2 days stipulation is actually a bit arbitrary and that you could leave it to them that they come in when necessary for the testing rather than a blanket 2 day per week policy?

Or is there physical testing that they are not getting done because they are at home? Because if that’s the case then that’s what I would focus on.

If it was just one person but you say it’s all 3 recently recruited. So it seems you are going to struggle to recruit someone with the required skills that will be willing to come in for 2 days every week. So you might have to reassess your conditions.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 05:49

Hecate01 · 16/12/2023 09:53

@Deliria I agree no one has to do anything but applying for a weekend job then expecting to work everything else apart from said weekends is entitled. A company can't change the needs of the business to suit the needs of the employees. I've worked in retail and hospitality all my life and I can imagine how annoyed people would be if they couldn't go shopping or out for a meal and stay in a hotel over the weekend because all the staff wanted to work Monday to Friday.

If you want Monday to Friday 9-5 then maybe people need to stop applying for sectors that operate 24/7.

Does your workplace pay double time on the weekends? If you’re struggling to find workers willing to work unsociable shifts then it’s a sign you need to pay more to make those shifts more attractive.

I think it’s fine for employees to try to negotiate working shifts that are more attractive to them. If you pay enough then there will be people keen to pick up weekend shifts. I worked weekend retail as a school kid - it should be attractive to pupils and students particularly.

mollyfolk · 17/12/2023 00:13

Two days in the office are more doable than 3. I’d push for 2 set days where you come in and have an all team meeting if possible. I’ve worked both fully remotely and hybrid and I think hybrid offers the best of both worlds. I love working from home because I have kids and it means I can drop them to school and have a short commute to their afterschool so they are picked up early. But I value in office days as my job involves working across departments and building trust by having a personal connection with these people is important to actually achieving my goals. I would have an honest conversation about why the in office days are important and non negotiable and take it from there.

stichguru · 16/12/2023 23:51

Just remind people of the rules and tell them they HAVE to stick to them, unless there is a really specific, new, reason not to. (Temporary childcare disaster, not through their lack of planning, or injury making travelling hard, for example.) BEFORE you do this though I would go back and look at what you are actually saying: it's frankly weird that THREE people really want a lot of WFH and have failed to notice that you have said the job can't accommodate much WFH. Maybe you aren't being as clear as you thought, in which case you need to accommodate what you actually SAID you would, not what you WISH you had said you would!

Ee1498 · 16/12/2023 23:16

I don't think you're being unreasonable here. It was clear in advert and interview what the expectations are, so that's on the employee. Have you had a one to one with the people grumbling/not abiding by the rules? If it were me, I'd have a meeting and make it clear what I was aware of what they were saying and ask them to be open with how they're feeling. It could be there is a personal or professional reason why they are struggling with in office days. If its because they just rather be at home, then you can make it clear that its mandatory for all team members and that's not going to change, so from that point forward they need to come in on those days unless there are exceptional circumstances why they can't. If they don't like it they can leave.
I recently was looking for a new job that was permanently WFH. I refused roles that stated hybrid because I knew that's not what I wanted to do. I managed to find a role that was WFH but I'd occasionally have to go to the office in Europe for meetings (once a month/6 weeks.) That seemed fair, so I accepted the position. I have never not gone in for those meetings, as that was the agreement we made when I was offered the role. If I didn't like it, I would leave. As should your employees if they are no longer happy with the terms.

Crikeyalmighty · 16/12/2023 22:44

@bakebeans unfortunately I know of someone I worked with a good while ago and that was exactly her reason- a full on side mail order project that needed her to be around stuffing envelopes and posting out- as well as getting a full time salary- there are some cheeky devils out there

Crikeyalmighty · 16/12/2023 22:41

@thevegetablesoup yep- I suspect an awful lot of women working from home are indeed picking up even more of the domestic stuff - because you know 'you are at home' -- thing is it will suit many women with young children more if they have to do drop offs and pick ups- I do get that -so I think many will be reluctant to admit that domestically their partners are now expecting dinner on the table etc -

thevegetablesoup · 16/12/2023 21:56

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

Load of rubbish.

In my experience it's more important to young people to be in the office learning from those around them and socialising. Older people are the ones who benefit from wfh.

As for women, it's hardly the progressive option to support a way of working which involves a retreat back away from the public realm and into the domestic sphere for women who are then expected to do even more domestic drudgery and childcare as they are at home anywhere.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 16/12/2023 21:45

But in this case the employee has more power as evidenced by his refusal to do as he's told and OP's tolerating this. So no, in this case he did the right thing - he got the pay he wanted and the terms and condition (WFH) he wanted, and it's now down to OP to see if she has the guts to sack him or whether she knows she can't because she knows that it is impossible to find someone as good for the same money who will come in.

//

I've taken this as more OP understandably is uncomfortable micro managing this individual as it's not gonna to be a nice conversation to have but OP seems to have got to a breaking point and may do it.

I'm sure they will find a replacement. Not everyone is a chancer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread