Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 09:02

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 08:57

I always think it's quite interesting that people being able to exercise choice over where they work is often treated in a different way to other positives of a job such as pensions, better salaries, more holiday etc
I'm not sure it is by many sensible people.

I'd not take a job with Company Pension A and then 4 weeks in decide that the company need to offer me Lola's Personal Pension Scheme that does exactly what I think is best for me.

I didn't work term time only, and then demand that my schools allowed me to take 2 weeks term time holiday because it would have been better or cheaper for me.

Same if I took a hybrid role. I'm signing up to a hybrid work pattern, so wouldn't accept a hybrid job and then refuse to come in, make excuses or be awkward because Big Important Lola would rather not use breakfast club for DC, and it's a bit annoying to do the commute a couple of days a week, and I don't think it's that important to go in.

We accept or decline the employment packages offered, or negotiate before accepting. If some wants to WFH they need to find a job that is WFH.

TBF I wrote that before clocking that the poster concerned was blatantly on a wind up.

It does come up though, people in good faith talking about remote working being a double standard, totally failing to apply the same logic to things like wages, holiday and pensions. I pointed it out to someone on another remote working thread maybe a week or two ago. Would agree with you it's not a sensible take, though!

The other stuff you've written about people trying to change the terms once they're in isn't what the sub-discussion was about, though obviously it is the wider topic of this thread. That being said, it's another example of people saying others 'need to' do things that they do not in fact need to do, when what they actually mean is they think people should. The reality is that people do what they think they can get away with, and sometimes it works.

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:01

Crikeyalmighty · 16/12/2023 20:45

@Usernameundiscovered

I never mentioned work once in my post- I said 'attend' - they don't work- they rock up to the event for free, usually get free drinks (and if they don't they can claim expenses- also can claim any travel ) and go to the after show party if there is one. Maybe chat to the promoter or artist etc

It's the nature of most jobs in PR - certainly within entertainment and is maybe a 4 or 5 times a year thing- not twice a week. Most normal people in our business see it as a very nice perk of the job -

It's not exactly an industry with candidate shortages either-

Can you confirm that they are at liberty to get as drunk as any other audience member and blanking any other audience member or promoter or artist if they want is fine? If so then they are not working. If you have ANY EXPECTATIONS of them then it's work in my view.

BIossomtoes · 17/12/2023 08:59

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 08:58

If it is 100% social then there is zero reason for the employer to demand attendance.

Nobody said it was social at all. It’s a perk.

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:59

Recruitment and retention issues
These include: High vacancy rates: Skills for Care, the workforce development and planning body for adult social care in England, estimates an average of 9.9% of roles in adult social care were vacant in 2022/23, equivalent to approximately 152,000 vacancies.14 Nov 2023

commonslibrary.parliament.uk › ...

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 08:58

BIossomtoes · 16/12/2023 20:06

Work wasn’t mentioned, the post referred to attending gigs.

If it is 100% social then there is zero reason for the employer to demand attendance.

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:57

At the moment the NHS relies hugely on overseas recruitment. If this is cut back it will result in greater shortages in health care. There is talk about people on job seekers allowance being forced to accept work as carers.

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 08:57

I always think it's quite interesting that people being able to exercise choice over where they work is often treated in a different way to other positives of a job such as pensions, better salaries, more holiday etc
I'm not sure it is by many sensible people.

I'd not take a job with Company Pension A and then 4 weeks in decide that the company need to offer me Lola's Personal Pension Scheme that does exactly what I think is best for me.

I didn't work term time only, and then demand that my schools allowed me to take 2 weeks term time holiday because it would have been better or cheaper for me.

Same if I took a hybrid role. I'm signing up to a hybrid work pattern, so wouldn't accept a hybrid job and then refuse to come in, make excuses or be awkward because Big Important Lola would rather not use breakfast club for DC, and it's a bit annoying to do the commute a couple of days a week, and I don't think it's that important to go in.

We accept or decline the employment packages offered, or negotiate before accepting. If some wants to WFH they need to find a job that is WFH.

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 08:56

Women on here are so quick to moan about the lack of carers. They don't see that insisting on the rights of some limited number of female workers to wfh has such a detrimental effect on the huge armies of women who cannot work from home. Look where the majority of women work, teaching, caring health care professionals, try campaigning for them otherwise society is going to crumble

Now take a deep breath for this, it's a shocker, but maybe - just maybe - The Menz could take on some caring roles both at home in the classroom? That can only be a good thing, surely.

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 08:54

IndecentFeminist · 16/12/2023 18:26

My point, was that instead of taking a job that has very clear stipulations and then trying to argue that those stipulations are ridiculous and don't apply to them is not on. They should either not take the job, or hand in their notice and go for a job that meets their requirements. The OP is not being unreasonable to be hacked off.

My point is that under capitalism everyone's "job" is to look out for themselves the best way they can. I believe that the employee is doing that. OP now needs to do what is best for her (which involves sacking the employee... unless they messed up his contract and he's not in breach).

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 08:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 08:53

If anything I think WFH possibly makes things better for teachers. My DH and I are able to be so much more present, available and engaged in our DCs school life due to our flexibility. Ten years ago we'd have dropped them at breakfast club, picked them up from after school club and that was that. We'd not have been involved in anything extracurricular, not seen or spoken to the teacher etc. We'd have needed a day off to pop into the school for a 20 minute assembly etc. Now we can fold it into a flexible work life. It's revolutionary.

My DSIS is a teacher and misses the assemblies and nativities and party drop offs etc. It is shit but she loves the rest of her job.

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:52

Overall, the total target for recruitment to teacher training for both primary and secondary was missed by 38 per cent. In total there were 26,955 new entrants to ITT in 2023-24 compared to 28,463 in 2022-23, 36,159 in 2021-22 and 40,377 in 2020-21.7 Dec 2023

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 08:52

I always think it's quite interesting that people being able to exercise choice over where they work is often treated in a different way to other positives of a job such as pensions, better salaries, more holiday etc.

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:49

Women on here are so quick to moan about the lack of carers. They don't see that insisting on the rights of some limited number of female workers to wfh has such a detrimental effect on the huge armies of women who cannot work from home. Look where the majority of women work, teaching, caring health care professionals, try campaigning for them otherwise society is going to crumble.

shearwater2 · 17/12/2023 08:48

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 08:46

This is just jealousy. It’s not a race to the bottom.

Women are allowed to leave teaching and seek a better life for themselves. The answer is not to artificially make conditions worse in other jobs so that there aren’t any more attractive routes for them to pursue.

The answer is to improve the pay and conditions in teaching!

I am a teacher and I want everyone whose job can be done (fully or partly) from home to have the option to do that if they choose.

Making other people unhappy in their jobs or unable to work doesn’t make my job any better or me any happier.

Hear hear!

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 08:46

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:39

@NotExactlySuits . I notice you say 'Once you have dropped the kids off'. What are you and all the other women who insist on WFH going to do when schools are sending home classes because they cannot recruit teachers. My granddaughter's nursery has had to send children home because of huge problems with staff recruitment.
It seems that people like you are full of 'don't do as I do, do as I say'
Why should some women get to cosily wfh and yet the great armies of women who do the majority of health care and childcare, don't have the same flexibility.

This is just jealousy. It’s not a race to the bottom.

Women are allowed to leave teaching and seek a better life for themselves. The answer is not to artificially make conditions worse in other jobs so that there aren’t any more attractive routes for them to pursue.

The answer is to improve the pay and conditions in teaching!

I am a teacher and I want everyone whose job can be done (fully or partly) from home to have the option to do that if they choose.

Making other people unhappy in their jobs or unable to work doesn’t make my job any better or me any happier.

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 08:46

I notice you say 'Once you have dropped the kids off'. What are you and all the other women who insist on WFH going to do when schools are sending home classes because they cannot recruit teachers. My granddaughter's nursery has had to send children home because of huge problems with staff recruitment.
It seems that people like you are full of 'don't do as I do, do as I say'
Why should some women get to cosily wfh and yet the great armies of women who do the majority of health care and childcare, don't have the same flexibility

Why are you so angry that other people have different career choices that allow them flexibility?

It's not actually any of your business but I work in the NHS, just not in a patient-facing role. I think I provide monumentally better value for money WFH thus saving precious healthcare resources.

I've not heard of any issues in recruitment of nursery or teaching staff - the opposite here where teachers qualify without being able to find a placement.

Also 'insist on WFH' please read my actual post without the chippy attitude and you'll see why I feel miffed about presenteeism for presenteeism's sake. I'm not insisting on anything.

shearwater2 · 17/12/2023 08:46

If the contract says they must be in the office two days, and they must be physically present to manage and support junior staff, then it's a simple breach of contract and surely disciplinary action can be taken?

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 08:40

I always find it amazing that people who work from home fail to see the impact on other workers. My daughter is a local primary head and she lost 50% of her staff at the end of the summer term. These ( mainly women) were not going to other teaching jobs but choosing instead to change to jobs that allowed working from home. The recruitment numbers this year are the lowest ever in teaching. Like the NHS they will never be able to sustain workers when their working conditions lack the flexibility of other career choices.

Roles that need to be done face to face at set times are going to have to pay more in order to compensate for their lack of flexibility. Unfortunately, we as a society haven't yet managed to accept this. Too many people prefer complaining about market forces and trying to argue their way out of supply and demand instead.

With respect to teaching and the NHS specifically, even that might not be enough bearing in mind the general shittification of the health and education systems, but that's another point again.

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:39

@NotExactlySuits . I notice you say 'Once you have dropped the kids off'. What are you and all the other women who insist on WFH going to do when schools are sending home classes because they cannot recruit teachers. My granddaughter's nursery has had to send children home because of huge problems with staff recruitment.
It seems that people like you are full of 'don't do as I do, do as I say'
Why should some women get to cosily wfh and yet the great armies of women who do the majority of health care and childcare, don't have the same flexibility.

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:31

@BlueberryVelvet
I always find it amazing that people who work from home fail to see the impact on other workers. My daughter is a local primary head and she lost 50% of her staff at the end of the summer term. These ( mainly women) were not going to other teaching jobs but choosing instead to change to jobs that allowed working from home. The recruitment numbers this year are the lowest ever in teaching. Like the NHS they will never be able to sustain workers when their working conditions lack the flexibility of other career choices. My GP surgery is now allowing doctors to work from home a couple of days a week. It is very hard to obtain a face to face point appointment.
If you are going to insist that all women can work from home, will you accept taking responsibility for primary age children to educated from home via zoom. It is such an unbelievably short sighted proposal. Do you not care at all about women who work as teachers or nurses or hospital doctors or physiotherapists etc etc. it seems to me that it is a very select number of women that you are trying to protect and all other women have to put up with impossible conditions because you don't give a stuff about the armies of women required to work face to face.

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 08:26

WickDittington
I agree with you. I'm in favour of WFH and hybrid working and better flexible working arrangements in general. I know lots of people who had hybrid working arrangements before the pandemic.

It annoys me that the response to people pointing out that hybrid and WFH aren't the same is often people claiming it's hating on WFH, there's no need to be in person, but what about all these people who can't do or would prefer not to do hybrid because it's better for them.

If someone wants or requires a WFH job, they need to apply for a remote job, not a hybrid job.

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 08:26

Not sure what the answer is OP. From my perspective, I have a commute, I did pre COVID as well as despite a very high income the housing choice and quality of life in the city was poor for a young family.

Anyway I think for me when I moan about the commute it's because it feels like a monstrous monumental waste of my time. Since WFH/flexible working I've realised how much better my time is utilised by doing so. My life has been revolutionised by being able to drop the kids off and be started at work 5 minutes later, work solidly at my own pace without interruptions and then stop 5 minutes before getting the kids. It's SO much better. A day in the office involves hours of travel, chatting, coffees, constant interruptions. It involves setting up my workstation at a hot desk (uuuugh) without my own stuff around me. It is a monumental fucking waste of time unless there is a good reason for me to be there - someone specific to see or an in person meeting. It's presenteeism for presenteeism's sake and it cost MY time and money to do it. So despite commuting for YEARS I now resent every single second of it Grin

i absolutely appreciate that your workers agreed to something, and they should do it. Totally get it. Perhaps it's just harder than they expected, or just a bit more shit. Or just feels completely pointless to them and therefore a waste of time.

I don't know. I think you are in the right btw, I'm not saying you're not. I'm just saying why I find commuting once or twice a week such a ball ache, when it used to be a daily part of life.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 08:13

BIossomtoes · 17/12/2023 07:12

And it’s of no relevance. It was a personal attack.

Of course it is relevant, because I would like to understand the motivations of those who are so vehemently against WFH when other people find it improves their wellbeing. Why are some people so insistently and gleefully predicting that this positive thing will be taken away in the future?

And frequently the opposition is from people who can’t WFH, because they are retired or have an in - person job. Or from managers and companies that are backward-looking and resistant to change., citing problems that could be solved if they cared to try, or worried about their own obsolescence or perceived reduction in status.

It’s not really any type of concern for other human beings, no matter how much people harp on about “the young”. So I just wonder what it is. And I think we should all reflect on our motivations.

In my case, amongst other less important sacrifices, I had a family member lose their life to Covid, and the one good thing that came out of this terrible, awful, nightmarish time, was the WFH revolution.

The environmental benefits, the accessibility for ND, parents, people with disabilities, people living rurally, older people who would have otherwise had to retire. The expansion of options for where young families can choose to live., letting them for the first time be able to buy a proper family house with a garden, instead of a tiny flat in London.

The hours of our lives reclaimed from the misery of commuting, to be spent instead on our families and friends and hobbies.

I can’t WFH, but I want other people to have that choice available, including my children, and I want society to change for the better. Something good came out of this tragedy, and some people want it to be taken away. So I will keep asking these people - why?