Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
Deliria · 17/12/2023 10:36

9outof10cats · 17/12/2023 10:03

Nah, I think you are the one who misunderstands employment relations.

I have worked for decades and navigated many contract changes, however, I did this through mature discussions with my managers.

I've always followed the appropriate channels instead of simply avoiding commitments, such as not showing up for a night shift because I no longer felt like doing them.

The staff in the OP are simply not bothering to come into the office 2 days a week as per their contract, just because they don't want to. There has not been any negotiation of a contract on their part, just a complete lack of professionalism and entitled that they can do what they want and fuck everyone else.

OP's staff are, regularly asking to come in less.

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 10:06

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 10:03

Christ it's impossible to have an actual normal discussion on this site.

Yes I was sharing MY experience of working in an office, and from discussing pros and cons of WFH with people in real life. Ok, it doesn't apply to YOU and my sincerest apologies for the generalised comment, didn't expect it to be picked apart 😏

Yes yes, it's totally outrageous that someone's discussed a post made on a discussion forum.

Ginmonkeyagain · 17/12/2023 10:06

The complete value of in person learning and communicarion is hard to quantify but is valuable.

I have recently had a very very high preassured and time constrained situation at work where things were changing on an hourly basis and involved a lot of intense collaboration with senior people

Teams chats and the real time editing function of Sharepoint documents definitely helped but the quick discussions and judegments that needed to be made were best in the office.

9outof10cats · 17/12/2023 10:03

Deliria · 17/12/2023 09:28

You misunderstand employment relations - this is an on-ging business negotiation. Contractual T&Cs change over time - they are not fixed for life! Who here, who has been in employment for any length of time, has had their pension terms changed, or had changes made to arrange for performance pay, for example?

Nah, I think you are the one who misunderstands employment relations.

I have worked for decades and navigated many contract changes, however, I did this through mature discussions with my managers.

I've always followed the appropriate channels instead of simply avoiding commitments, such as not showing up for a night shift because I no longer felt like doing them.

The staff in the OP are simply not bothering to come into the office 2 days a week as per their contract, just because they don't want to. There has not been any negotiation of a contract on their part, just a complete lack of professionalism and entitled that they can do what they want and fuck everyone else.

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 10:03

Christ it's impossible to have an actual normal discussion on this site.

Yes I was sharing MY experience of working in an office, and from discussing pros and cons of WFH with people in real life. Ok, it doesn't apply to YOU and my sincerest apologies for the generalised comment, didn't expect it to be picked apart 😏

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 09:55

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:53

I am very much in favour of WFH, but plenty of industries benefit from learning in the office. In my profession people have specialities, but need to learn more widely around their specialities, and they need to learn skills like negotiation. When I was training I learnt huge and invaluable stuff from listening in to colleagues and bosses, and a large part of my weaknesses now stem from how little time I continued to spend in such an environment after qualifying.

Absolutely, plenty do. It's a point that can be made without assuming it's a definite across the board, which the poster I quoted did. Basically, when it comes to this issue, people universalising their own experiences is a bad idea.

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:53

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 09:34

There is definitely a natural knowledge sharing that happens in person that doesn't happen remotely.

This is a generalisation. If you say it's applicable to you in your role and sector, I've no reason not to believe you, but you are not the default.

There's so very much variation even in the sort of role that can be done from anywhere. It makes no sense that people assume what they've seen must be applicable across a very diverse range of roles and industries, much less to people who could have very different characteristics to them.

I am very much in favour of WFH, but plenty of industries benefit from learning in the office. In my profession people have specialities, but need to learn more widely around their specialities, and they need to learn skills like negotiation. When I was training I learnt huge and invaluable stuff from listening in to colleagues and bosses, and a large part of my weaknesses now stem from how little time I continued to spend in such an environment after qualifying.

Deliria · 17/12/2023 09:52

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 17/12/2023 09:40

@Rabiz

It is normal to try to renegotiate your terms and conditions but you have no right to expect it. The employer can refuse.

Exactly.

OP (or her employers) can a) vary the contract (whether formally or informally) or b) move to terminante the contract if terms are being breached.

What OP can't do is 'stop people asking if they can come in less'.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 09:51

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 17/12/2023 09:40

@Rabiz

It is normal to try to renegotiate your terms and conditions but you have no right to expect it. The employer can refuse.

Of course they can refuse. It depends how much they care about holding on to that employee and what the risk is that the employee will leave if they refuse, and how much the refusal will impact the morale and productivity of staff in general, how much time and money it will cost to recruit someone new and how confident they are that they can hire someone at those wages who will be better or different. (Also, any legislative requirements around protected characteristics etc.)

It’s a negotiation, where both sides weigh up the risks and rewards. There is nothing wrong with that and I think women in particular need to speak up and advocate for themselves and know their value, as often men don’t have any qualms about these kind of negotiations.

juicelooseabootthishoose · 17/12/2023 09:46

How long is the probation period?
If a month maybe it is too short? 3 months is standard and I've had 6 months before too.

Its easy to go up an 'act' if you have no intention of hybrid for a month. Much harder for 3 or 6 months.

Extending probation is always an option and can work well for both parties if they are making noises about not wanting to come in. Maybe its not the right position.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 17/12/2023 09:40

@Rabiz

It is normal to try to renegotiate your terms and conditions but you have no right to expect it. The employer can refuse.

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 09:34

There is definitely a natural knowledge sharing that happens in person that doesn't happen remotely.

This is a generalisation. If you say it's applicable to you in your role and sector, I've no reason not to believe you, but you are not the default.

There's so very much variation even in the sort of role that can be done from anywhere. It makes no sense that people assume what they've seen must be applicable across a very diverse range of roles and industries, much less to people who could have very different characteristics to them.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 09:34

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 08:57

I always think it's quite interesting that people being able to exercise choice over where they work is often treated in a different way to other positives of a job such as pensions, better salaries, more holiday etc
I'm not sure it is by many sensible people.

I'd not take a job with Company Pension A and then 4 weeks in decide that the company need to offer me Lola's Personal Pension Scheme that does exactly what I think is best for me.

I didn't work term time only, and then demand that my schools allowed me to take 2 weeks term time holiday because it would have been better or cheaper for me.

Same if I took a hybrid role. I'm signing up to a hybrid work pattern, so wouldn't accept a hybrid job and then refuse to come in, make excuses or be awkward because Big Important Lola would rather not use breakfast club for DC, and it's a bit annoying to do the commute a couple of days a week, and I don't think it's that important to go in.

We accept or decline the employment packages offered, or negotiate before accepting. If some wants to WFH they need to find a job that is WFH.

Disagree with your last paragraph. It’s perfectly normal to renegotiate the terms of your employment beyond your initial contract and people do it all the time. You might ask for all sorts of changes eg a pay rise, for a transfer to another dept, to take on a different type of project or client, to move to PT hours etc.

Given that several people in the office aren’t coming in for the 2 days that were in the contract and nothing has been said about it, they may have concluded that they didn’t need a formal change to the contract to WFH more frequently.

NearlyMonday · 17/12/2023 09:31

I’m in a large public sector organisation. We do 2 days per week in the office, and everyone seems to be happy with that. My commute is approx one hour each way, but because its only two days per week its bearable and I do actually enjoy my office days, it’s healthy to get out of the house and mix with my colleagues.

However we work really well with Teams meetings, and all managed to retain cohesion during COVID (when no one went in for 18 months). Also, we’re spread across 3 large sites and even pre-COVID I only saw a handful of my colleagues f2f on a regular basis.

The mythical water-cooler moments didn’t happen (we all used different water coolers!) so whilst I personally enjoy going in twice per week, I think it’s quite possible to work perfectly well even if you only go in occasionally. I am not a fan of presenteeism

NotExactlySuits · 17/12/2023 09:30

I do agree @taybert and I do sometimes remind myself that my grumbles with presenteeism are a privilege of my 12 years of experience in the job, and the fact I work closely with another person so we constantly communicate about issues. If I was a new start and WFH on my own I might feel quite differently and be desperate for people to come into the office.

There is definitely a natural knowledge sharing that happens in person that doesn't happen remotely.

Deliria · 17/12/2023 09:28

9outof10cats · 17/12/2023 09:13

Facing the responsibilities outlined in the contract you willingly entered into is called fulfilling your commitments. Hardly a case of having 'shit chucked at you'.

You misunderstand employment relations - this is an on-ging business negotiation. Contractual T&Cs change over time - they are not fixed for life! Who here, who has been in employment for any length of time, has had their pension terms changed, or had changes made to arrange for performance pay, for example?

taybert · 17/12/2023 09:27

I think there are some industries where being in the same room as other people has benefits that are quite hard to measure. Sure, if the company is insisting on them being in the office and they sit in a booth with a headset on all day in Teams meetings then there’s a good argument for working from home. My husband works flexibly, leaves early a couple of days to get the kids then logs on at home and does a full day at home (my job can’t be done remotely and my days are 12 hours) but he manages a team of people (who also work flexibly) and being in the room with them has benefits. He can provide ad hoc training and support in real time, he picks up grumbles over coffee, he can troubleshoot on projects as issues crop up. He finds if he isn’t in the office as much for whatever reason that problems tend to show themselves at a later stage and are more difficult to sort. He finds this balance about right, he doesn’t want to be in the office full time but equally wfh full time has downsides too. Equally if he has a member of staff who ends up wfh for a long period he tends to find issues aren’t picked up as they would have been in a collaborative environment.

I’m not sure how you could measure that though and it’s quite difficult to argue that isn’t an attitude of presenteeism.

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:21

BIossomtoes · 17/12/2023 08:59

Nobody said it was social at all. It’s a perk.

It's not a perk if it is compulsory and not wanted.

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 09:20

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:49

Women on here are so quick to moan about the lack of carers. They don't see that insisting on the rights of some limited number of female workers to wfh has such a detrimental effect on the huge armies of women who cannot work from home. Look where the majority of women work, teaching, caring health care professionals, try campaigning for them otherwise society is going to crumble.

I am a teacher! Please read what I said above. There is a recruitment problem in teaching but it is not due to other people WFH.

It’s about behaviour, lack of investment, workload etc. Exacerbated by the general labour shortage we were discussing earlier.

Preventing other people from WFH does nothing to improve the conditions of teachers.

With the low fertility rates however, there will be fewer teachers required, but it’s still important for investment in schools and better conditions to be achieved.

We will need more people in aged care. But again the answer is to improve pay and conditions there, not to make other jobs worse to “match.”

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:19

LolaSmiles · 17/12/2023 08:57

I always think it's quite interesting that people being able to exercise choice over where they work is often treated in a different way to other positives of a job such as pensions, better salaries, more holiday etc
I'm not sure it is by many sensible people.

I'd not take a job with Company Pension A and then 4 weeks in decide that the company need to offer me Lola's Personal Pension Scheme that does exactly what I think is best for me.

I didn't work term time only, and then demand that my schools allowed me to take 2 weeks term time holiday because it would have been better or cheaper for me.

Same if I took a hybrid role. I'm signing up to a hybrid work pattern, so wouldn't accept a hybrid job and then refuse to come in, make excuses or be awkward because Big Important Lola would rather not use breakfast club for DC, and it's a bit annoying to do the commute a couple of days a week, and I don't think it's that important to go in.

We accept or decline the employment packages offered, or negotiate before accepting. If some wants to WFH they need to find a job that is WFH.

That last paragraph is half right.

NO, we negotiate before accepting and after accepting. If someone wants to WFH they have two choices... get a WFH job or get and non-WFH job and try to negotiate it into a WFH job any which legal way you can.

9outof10cats · 17/12/2023 09:13

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:07

So because some people have it really tough in minimum wage jobs then highly skilled professionals capable of earning six figures should suck up whatever shit their boss chucks at them!??!?

Facing the responsibilities outlined in the contract you willingly entered into is called fulfilling your commitments. Hardly a case of having 'shit chucked at you'.

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:12

Rabiz · 17/12/2023 08:13

Of course it is relevant, because I would like to understand the motivations of those who are so vehemently against WFH when other people find it improves their wellbeing. Why are some people so insistently and gleefully predicting that this positive thing will be taken away in the future?

And frequently the opposition is from people who can’t WFH, because they are retired or have an in - person job. Or from managers and companies that are backward-looking and resistant to change., citing problems that could be solved if they cared to try, or worried about their own obsolescence or perceived reduction in status.

It’s not really any type of concern for other human beings, no matter how much people harp on about “the young”. So I just wonder what it is. And I think we should all reflect on our motivations.

In my case, amongst other less important sacrifices, I had a family member lose their life to Covid, and the one good thing that came out of this terrible, awful, nightmarish time, was the WFH revolution.

The environmental benefits, the accessibility for ND, parents, people with disabilities, people living rurally, older people who would have otherwise had to retire. The expansion of options for where young families can choose to live., letting them for the first time be able to buy a proper family house with a garden, instead of a tiny flat in London.

The hours of our lives reclaimed from the misery of commuting, to be spent instead on our families and friends and hobbies.

I can’t WFH, but I want other people to have that choice available, including my children, and I want society to change for the better. Something good came out of this tragedy, and some people want it to be taken away. So I will keep asking these people - why?

Absolutely superb post and I could not agree more.

Startingagainandagain · 17/12/2023 09:11

Well, what I am fed with is employers recruiting staff who live over two hours away (2 hours each way) from the office and have a disability, who made this very clear at the interview stage and promising them that they won't have to commute more than once a month maximum.

Then same employer six months later tells the same employee to come in once a week so they can 'show their face'...

The charity I work for did this to me.

The flexible working was the only reason I took the job as the pay is not great (so it makes no financial sense for me to pay to commute once a week on that salary) and there is little progression available.

So now I am job hunting to leave this role as soon as I can because I don't like being misled...

My point is it is not just employees who are unreasonable when it comes to WFH.

NonPlayerCharacter · 17/12/2023 09:08

Summonedbybees · 17/12/2023 08:39

@NotExactlySuits . I notice you say 'Once you have dropped the kids off'. What are you and all the other women who insist on WFH going to do when schools are sending home classes because they cannot recruit teachers. My granddaughter's nursery has had to send children home because of huge problems with staff recruitment.
It seems that people like you are full of 'don't do as I do, do as I say'
Why should some women get to cosily wfh and yet the great armies of women who do the majority of health care and childcare, don't have the same flexibility.

Because some jobs can be done remotely and others can't, and the way to make a job more attractive is not to make other jobs worse.

If so many people would eschew teaching because they'd rather wfh then the answer would appear to be to pay and treat teachers better rather than remove advantages from other industries. I'm not in PR so I don't get lots of consumer freebies; should we prevent PR people from getting them because my industry doesn't?

AnonnyMouseDave · 17/12/2023 09:07

Xoxoxoxoxoxox · 17/12/2023 07:17

I run Christmas stalls with temp staff and many have long commutes.
They get £10 hr and some have long commutes, one girl travels one hour each way and works 9-6 for 4 days, works another job inBurger King for 2 days and is doing a degree in accounting as well while sending her money to India to support her mother and two children (father died).
Another staff member has a 2hour commute and works for 3 days a week, another commutes for 7 days a week (for a month) for 2 hours each way.
Your staff just seem incredibly privileged to me to be on such high wages and I bet the staff who serve them coffee earning £10 hr commute for just as long and more frequently.
I think you need to put your foot down and insist that it’s a necessity to come in a few days a week for team cohesion.

So because some people have it really tough in minimum wage jobs then highly skilled professionals capable of earning six figures should suck up whatever shit their boss chucks at them!??!?