Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 14:41

If being in the office was beneficial to them they’d come in. Clearly it’s not, whatever you think about your collaborative approach. Instead of putting an arbitrary quota on people how about making it actually worth their time to come in?

LolaSmiles · 15/12/2023 14:40

It's not unreasonable for people to do the job they've signed up for.

If someone signs up to shift work, they don't get to moan that their have shift patterns.
If someone signs up for hybrid 2-3 days on site, they don't get to moan and be awkward about having to go to the office.

If someone wants a fully remote role then they should apply for it, not take a hybrid role and expect to take the piss to get what they want.

People accepting jobs and then deciding that the huge commute doesn't work for them or they want to do the school run or it's not convenient for them, or they'd rather work at home are taking the mick.

Flamesatmytoes · 15/12/2023 14:39

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:34

She'd rather people DID reject the roles if they can't follow the job spec

This, i had other applicants. If i had known they would refuse to come i could have considered a different person for the job but now am stuck with guy who gave his parents address on form but then moved in with his friend 40 miles away his probation period ended

Give them notice then. Honestly, they are holding you to ransom.

AuntieJoyce · 15/12/2023 14:38

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:34

She'd rather people DID reject the roles if they can't follow the job spec

This, i had other applicants. If i had known they would refuse to come i could have considered a different person for the job but now am stuck with guy who gave his parents address on form but then moved in with his friend 40 miles away his probation period ended

I’ve read this and your other posts. My team situation at work sounds similar to yours. I’m sorry but I think there’s no wonder solution- you just need to manage and give these people the bad news that they took a job on the understanding they would come in and they need to do the minimum number of hours in the office

The latest one on our team is wanting short days in the office. Sorry no we ask for a minimum of seven hours work per day.

And don’t hire individuals whose commute will be longer than an hour or so. Whatever they say

Flamesatmytoes · 15/12/2023 14:38

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

Not our experience at all. Our younger team members want to be in the office and work with people, not isolated and remote. On that basis I go to the office every day

elizabethdraper · 15/12/2023 14:38

You are right i could walk 7km with my laptop, keyboard, docking station, mouse, 2 phones, lunch, waterbottle and cup.

What kind of tundle bag would you recommend ?

Edit: just google mapped it 1hr, 20mins walking time

wildernesssw · 15/12/2023 14:37

WompingWillow · 15/12/2023 14:15

New graduates are the ones who did online learning during the pandemic so will often be well aware that in person learning is far more superior to online. Many people are sociable and would rather sit next to a colleague and work rather than work from their bedroom because they house share or live in a home that’s too small to have an office.

Sorry but what a load of bollocks about online learning. I did partial online learning as a mature student - by 3rd year we were back in person for some of it as well as the first half of first year. I did far better with home learning than I ever did having to sit through in person lectures and there's no way in person is "far more superior". We got asked if we wanted to go back in person and the vast majority of my cohort (in fact everybody bar 1) said they'd rather work from home.

In terms of the original point of the thread, it's a difficult one. Whilst I prefer online learning, I prefer in person work even if that means a long commute. What I would say though is do you really need people in person? If not and the work can reasonably be done from home, I can understand them complaining. I think your only option really is to monitor it more (which sucks for you) or specify specific days and times people have to be in.

Since leaving full time education aged 18 - with a huge sigh of relief after many boring hours daydreaming in a classroom - I have since got a degree (a 1st) and Masters (distinction) through distance learning.

The idea that 'in person learning' is far superior to on-line shows a worrying lack of critical thinking skills.

There are too many factors, including personal learning styles, the demands of subject (e.g. use of technical equipement), the measures put in place to support active discussion on-line, to generalise in that way.

I've had the opposite experience to the OP, in that I have been clear about my caring responsibilities during the recruitment process, and been told that the company supports flexibility, and then when I was in post suddenly flexibility was a huge problem and a sign I wasn't committed enough. More than once! I ended up leaving each job after a relatively short period, which was very frustrating as I was absolutely explicit about my commitments before accepting.

Anyway, I would suggest stressing the non-negotiables at every stage of the recruitment process, and planning the days everyone is in the office to ensure that the in-person collaboration takes place. Team meetings, discussion sessions etc, maybe a team lunch. So it isn't a tick box exercise based on 'if everyone is in the office collaboration will spontaneously happen', but structured and planned.

Whyohwhywyoming · 15/12/2023 14:36

Hont1986 · 15/12/2023 13:39

we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office

I hear this line get thrown around a lot by upper management and frankly I've never found that the rank and file employees actually agree. I suspect the real reasoning is somewhere in between "we have to pay to rent and heat the building so we don't want that to be a waste" and "working from home isn't real working, they're just dossing".

I often say the team gets a lot from
collaborative working, but I don’t think the people I manage agree 🤣 we do once a month in person days that are really focussed. People waste a lot of time in offices, and the constant interruptions can be unbearable

Week54 · 15/12/2023 14:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:34

She'd rather people DID reject the roles if they can't follow the job spec

This, i had other applicants. If i had known they would refuse to come i could have considered a different person for the job but now am stuck with guy who gave his parents address on form but then moved in with his friend 40 miles away his probation period ended

OP posts:
Coralsunset · 15/12/2023 14:33

You are being paid to manage these people but you are moaning about it and trying to avoid doing it.

So actually that’s not much different to the staff being paid to come into office and moaning and trying to avoid it.

Do your job and the rest will follow

ClareBlue · 15/12/2023 14:33

@Week54 retired but forgot to tell anybody😁that's the description of a colleague I've been looking for, thanks.

followmyflow · 15/12/2023 14:33

to be honest i think the best solution to this is just to hire people who are local, unfortunately..

elizabethdraper · 15/12/2023 14:32

From Jan we are being asked to go to the office 2 days a month (1st and 3rd Tuesday of the month) which is doable, i guess. However, all my team are all in different offices around the country. I will not be sitting with any members of my team.

In actual fact, I have had to cancel our normal meetings on those days as everyone will be in open plan offices so online meetings wont work.

My office have got rid of our parking spaces, so I will now have to get 2 buses in, so am looking at about a 2 hour commute each way due to traffic and buses not turning up (I live 7km from the office).

The best part is we have down sized office space. They are expecting 700 people to fit in to 470 desks.

My productivity is going to drop off a cliff for those 2 days each month

and will probably have to sit on the floor to work

But you are all right, we need to say nothing and just get on with it

Nanny0gg · 15/12/2023 14:30

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

She'd rather people DID reject the roles if they can't follow the job spec

BIossomtoes · 15/12/2023 14:29

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:00

Week54 actually i have someone in my team who is gagging to say something like this, maybe i will say go ahead

You should. A good strong dose of realism from one of their peers could work wonders.

UsingChangeofName · 15/12/2023 14:28

My company moved office during the pandemic so it's now in a rubbish location that's a pain to get to.

Whereas I can see that is a nightmare for you it really has nothing to do with this thread, where the OP has been very clear she is talking about people who chose to apply for a role a long commute from where they live, even though it was clear they would have to be in the office 1/2 the week.

TinyTear · 15/12/2023 14:28

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

can you stop the generalisation there. I am a woman and go to the office 2 days a week, sometimes 3 and enjoy it. it does not negatively impact me

but like the @Benibidibici OP I have flexibility to leave for school shows, pick ups and events as they know I will make up the time - have been in the company 15 years +

forgotmyusername1 · 15/12/2023 14:28

on interview

I note that you currently live around 2 hours from the office. you would be required to be in the office on either a tue and wed or a wed and thur with the rest of the time working at home. If you were offered the job would you be proposing to commute that journey twice a week or would you be willing to stay in a hotel overnight?

QueenCoconut · 15/12/2023 14:27

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2023 14:24

OP, I think maybe you are too nice! You can get a long, long way managing people with the carrot, and you obviously do that very well…but sometimes you need the stick, or at least the dim possibility of the stick. 😈

The stick is only effective with staff who need to stick to the current employer (desperate, low skilled, too scared to move on, too loyal). Anyone else will just vote with their feet and go for the carrot.

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:27

We have to look at physical samples & discuss/compare as part of the job. They are expensive we don't get like 8 samples that could be sent to individual homes.

It really doesn't work doing it on screen! Its not just bullshit collaboration. We need to be there to do this work. We've already said all the "paperwork" type side of the job can be on screen but we need to do this bit in person, we need to show the trainees how to do this work.

OP posts:
QueenCoconut · 15/12/2023 14:24

Are you making sure that when people come to the office it is actually beneficial to them and the wider team in a measurable way ? Or do they come in after a stressful long commute to then log on to Teams calls straight away that could’ve just as well been done from home? If you tell them they are needed to provide training to less experienced team members is it actually happening when they are in, or is the reality that the team have no questions and your staff just sit there for the leadership optics? Are face to face meetings productive and bring anything to the table that virtual meetings don’t ? Even the most creative industries collaborate successfully online so what is it that makes f2f better in your company? Is it someone's preference based on their personal bias rather than evidence?

Skilled employees are very valuable and in today’s market they have the upper hand, so it’s important to respect their time and ensure that the “need to be in the office” is not just an over -enthusiastic concept of what the leaders perceive the company culture to be.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2023 14:24

OP, I think maybe you are too nice! You can get a long, long way managing people with the carrot, and you obviously do that very well…but sometimes you need the stick, or at least the dim possibility of the stick. 😈

Lifeasiknowitisout · 15/12/2023 14:20

MintJulia · 15/12/2023 14:07

@PastelHouses It isn't bollocks. 97% of single parents are women, and it really does impact us.

Your ignorance is showing..

The whole ‘working in be office disproportionally impacts women’ is really over used and actually misused.

The solution isn’t to make every single role wfh. It’s is impossible to do so. That also doesn’t suit every single parent. The solution is to be as flexible as possible which isn’t just about wfh.

Home working also disproportionatelynegatively impacted women during the pandemic.

Op has explained many times that they are very flexible in many ways.

horseyhorsey17 · 15/12/2023 14:20

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

Totally agree. It's only in the last few years - really since the pandemic - that women have been given the opportunity to work remotely and for people like me, single mums raising children who can't afford to live in bloody London, it's been a godsend. Most knowledge working jobs don't actually need people in the office for two days. The 'collaboration' is really just presenteeism, rebranded by managers who don't want to admit that's what it is. All the stats show that productivity isn't impacted by remote working. It's better for gender equity and the environment. The decision to try and force people into offices isn't driven by data - it's companies who've already paid the lease on expensive buildings who don't want to 'waste their investment'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread