Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
sweetpickle23 · 15/12/2023 15:00

Suggestions to make 3 days a week in a key factor in performance and bonus appraisal runs serious risk of being discriminatory.

mumda · 15/12/2023 14:58

What are the key bits they're missing out on by not being in the office?

Bookworm1111 · 15/12/2023 14:57

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:34

She'd rather people DID reject the roles if they can't follow the job spec

This, i had other applicants. If i had known they would refuse to come i could have considered a different person for the job but now am stuck with guy who gave his parents address on form but then moved in with his friend 40 miles away his probation period ended

Have you actually sat them down and reminded them that this is what their contract says and what they applied for?

buellerbuellerbueller · 15/12/2023 14:57

What is clear from this discussion is that there is no right or wrong answer and we can't generalise to specific demographic groups. However, that misses the point. The OP was clear on the T&Cs and, whether the new starts agree or not, they accepted the job on those terms. OP, I think the previous suggestions to mandate the days to be in would have the most impact, as that way people can plan and have structure.

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 14:56

BitchBrigade · 15/12/2023 14:51

There isn't much I wouldn't do for 6 figures TBH. OP's employees have no idea how lucky they have it on 100k only attending 2 days a week.

I say that as someone who finds my 2 days in with 6 hours total commute time on a significantly less, with three kids, extremely east to manage. I am also a massive advocate for WFH if possible, and find the whole "In office for the sake of it, team building, collaboration" bullshit absolutely abhorrent after the world miraculously coped with it fine for two years.

Many if not most jobs in that salary range are hybrid or remote nowadays - software developer, solicitor, senior civil servant, financial services etc. Even barristers aren’t in court in person every day, management consultants are prepping their slides while WFH, etc.

Week54 · 15/12/2023 14:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AnonnyMouseDave · 15/12/2023 14:55

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:52

Can’t you get them to sign an agreement to working at the office 3 days a week when they sign their contract, when any start moaning about it remind them of this and show them what they agreed to and signed if necessary

Contract specifies 2 days minimum per week at office.

Surely you just give them a written warning the first one or two times, and sack them the third... or is your problem - as I strongly suspect - that you know that there is no-one willing to come in two days a week for the salary you are offering and you don't want to pay extra in order to convince people it is worth their while coming in when they don't want to, hate the commute, hate the expense of the commute and hate that they have to stay late to finish work that took ages because they were being interrupted by junior staff needing training (even though they have no training responsibilities in their contract)?

thing47 · 15/12/2023 14:55

I would argue that the large majority of jobs CAN be done remotely

You wouldn't be able to argue that with any of the 4 adult members I live with. All of us in very different careers, none of which could be done remotely. Nothing to do with team building, just that an actual physical presence is required.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 15/12/2023 14:54

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

What bullshit, so if s woman is a surgeon she also has to be fully remote if not she is negatively impacted? OP already said there some flexibility to leave early to pick kids etc but somehow you think women have to be home all day if not they are negatively impacted.

Yes there are jobs that can be done fully remove and there are jobs that require collaboration face to face, you make your decision when applying. In this situation they made it clear the expectations so why did he or she still apply only to then complain?

ToughTitty · 15/12/2023 14:54

I've just sacked someone for this. Made it very clear that the expectation was 4 days a week in the office. 2nd week in, he was trying to cut it to 3, then he started telling me 5 mins before he was due in that he wasn't coming.

Ended up sacking him before the end of his probation. Apparently 'no one' wants people back in the office. He was shocked he was being sacked! We were extremely clear up front and in his contract.

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 14:53

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 14:47

Six figure salaries make it worthwhile for most people...

Work is not just about the benefits to the employee or the employer - it has to work for both sides. If part of the job requires in person collaboration on eg reviews of physical samples in this case or for the development/coaching of juniors then it won't work for both sides in the absence of some in person work.

I mean beneficial to doing the job. OP says the reviewing the samples doesn’t work online but is that just her view - what we don’t know is are the employees happy doing it online? Or are they avoiding that task?

Deliria · 15/12/2023 14:51

You're in a tight labour market in which working practices have rapidly changed. If your colleagues are breaching contractual terms, you remind them, and ultimately you end the contract. But in reality, how willing you are to do that will depend on your propsects of replacing them, and the costs of replacing them. If that looks unappetising - there's your answer. Be graceful about it and you might gain a competitive advantage. The 'going rate' is calculated in terms and conditions as well as salary.

BitchBrigade · 15/12/2023 14:51

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 14:47

Six figure salaries make it worthwhile for most people...

Work is not just about the benefits to the employee or the employer - it has to work for both sides. If part of the job requires in person collaboration on eg reviews of physical samples in this case or for the development/coaching of juniors then it won't work for both sides in the absence of some in person work.

There isn't much I wouldn't do for 6 figures TBH. OP's employees have no idea how lucky they have it on 100k only attending 2 days a week.

I say that as someone who finds my 2 days in with 6 hours total commute time on a significantly less, with three kids, extremely east to manage. I am also a massive advocate for WFH if possible, and find the whole "In office for the sake of it, team building, collaboration" bullshit absolutely abhorrent after the world miraculously coped with it fine for two years.

Workway · 15/12/2023 14:50
  • dock London allowance (if London)
  • make it 3 days per week a key factor in bonus and performance appraisal
  • disciplinary action may be taken for serial offenders

You only need to put one person through one disciplinary and end it with a formal written warning for people to quit or book their ideas up.

I'd make it a bigger percentage factor in your bonuses.

MegMez · 15/12/2023 14:48

I work from home full time, as do my two colleagues. I knew this was the case when I joined and it works well for us. However, I don't think you're being unreasonable. I found a job opportunity recently that really excited me, for more money and in a slightly different industry. However, it said "hybrid" so I contacted them to ask what their expectations were. They said 3 days in London a week. I can't make that work so I just didn't apply. It's as simple as that. If you're very clear in job advertising, in contracts etc, it's not unreasonable. Perhaps it's a case that your employees needed something a bit more solid in terms of expectations. There seems to be some good advice in this thread already.

GnomeDePlume · 15/12/2023 14:48

elizabethdraper · 15/12/2023 14:38

You are right i could walk 7km with my laptop, keyboard, docking station, mouse, 2 phones, lunch, waterbottle and cup.

What kind of tundle bag would you recommend ?

Edit: just google mapped it 1hr, 20mins walking time

Edited

Depending on the area you are walking in don't forget your hi vi's jacket and head torch plus actual torch for seeing where you are putting your feet!

You will also need suitable office shoes and somewhere to clean off and store your walking boots.

A trundle truck or wheelbarrow should do the job.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 14:47

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 14:41

If being in the office was beneficial to them they’d come in. Clearly it’s not, whatever you think about your collaborative approach. Instead of putting an arbitrary quota on people how about making it actually worth their time to come in?

Six figure salaries make it worthwhile for most people...

Work is not just about the benefits to the employee or the employer - it has to work for both sides. If part of the job requires in person collaboration on eg reviews of physical samples in this case or for the development/coaching of juniors then it won't work for both sides in the absence of some in person work.

Flossflower · 15/12/2023 14:47

Could you have a basic salary and a bonus. The bonus only for people who have done their required office days.

AnonnyMouseDave · 15/12/2023 14:46

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:40

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

Im a woman and a parent of young kids and its fine. We genuinely need some time working together as a team including training for our youngest staff, we've worked out 2 days is the minimum we can manage.

Im totally pro flexibility but we need people to come in sometimes & we are super clear on the job ad etc

Do these staff members contracts make clear that training is one of their duties?

In my view you should stop whinging. It is literally the job of employees to try to get the best deal they can for themselves (ideally by managing to blag 5 days working from home a week, whilst getting away with doing zero work and getting promoted). It is your job to try to get them to work hard and do what you want them to, from the office if that's what you want.

Ultimately you need to sack people if they breach the terms and conditions of their employment, and my honest belief is that there is one main reason for your anger. You know that you can't sack these people because the next person you employ will make exactly the same demands to work from home, unless you bribe them with an offer of £30k a year more salary and you don't want to give the next person £30k extra.

The market is allowing these people to whinge because you don't pay them enough to make it worth their while doing exactly what you want with no complaints and they know it.

I know every industry is different but post covid, a year or two back, a friend of mine is in an IT team of around 10, who were all ordered back in the office. The leader of the team said "I've moved to the other end of the country, sorry, I can't come in" and the rest of the team simply said "no" and they all work from home still apart from those who left to get better jobs or to take some time out.

BitchBrigade · 15/12/2023 14:46

After my last comment I will admit (as easy as I find it) that at least half the days spent in the office could easily be spent at home because we are scattered about and barely speak to one another. BUT the other half we absolutely make use of the time by ALL being present and together to work on some of the bigger things and usually always back it up with a team lunch or after work drink.

Realistically though there is nothing we do in the office that we can't do over Teams. Going into the office is just a "nice to have". I get that some jobs have elements that cannot be done effectively over Teams but I would argue that the large majority of jobs CAN be done remotely and a lot of the "collaborative, team building" shite is just that. Shite.

ClareBlue · 15/12/2023 14:44

MintJulia · 15/12/2023 14:13

@PomPomSugar Agreed. In our office, the younger ones, in house shares or small flats WANT to come to a warm spacious office and they tend to live closer.

Yep, all our children under 30 work in offices all week despite having options not to. One doesn't need to attend at all but goes in every day. They don't want to be in their cold house shares and they like the interaction with people when they have moved to cities where they don't know anyone. Def 40 to 55s where this is the main issue. Those that have nice home environments and not looking to learn from colleagues.

Livingtothefull · 15/12/2023 14:44

cheezncrackers · 15/12/2023 13:40

What can I do to stop people doing this?

Only hire people who live locally?

I think the problem with this approach is it could be discriminatory or discourage diversity - eg if the workplace is in an affluent area that some potential candidates can't afford, or if certain demographics are over/underrepresented.

I haven't read all the responses sorry. But if not suggested, on approach could be to include in job applications a question like 'Are you willing and able to attend (workplace address) at least 2 days per week?' Anyone who responds 'no', their application is not progressed.

If they respond 'yes' then refuse to do it once employed then you are fully justified in holding to them to that application statement and follow through with disciplinary action if necessary.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 14:43

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 14:27

We have to look at physical samples & discuss/compare as part of the job. They are expensive we don't get like 8 samples that could be sent to individual homes.

It really doesn't work doing it on screen! Its not just bullshit collaboration. We need to be there to do this work. We've already said all the "paperwork" type side of the job can be on screen but we need to do this bit in person, we need to show the trainees how to do this work.

There are some aspects of many jobs which need people together in person, some learnings which need people together in person.

Our juniors develop much faster when together, able to observe each other and also how their seniors interact with teams, clients etc despite the fact that their jobs could be technically done from anywhere. Its the "soft" components of the job which are hard to learn remotely for us. There is no reason why a hybrid environment can't be successful for everyone and have room also for those who actually need to be near full time remote workers for whatever reason.

Don't change the rules for the group rather than addressing individual problems - that isn't fair and creates resentment amongst the majority trying to make it work. If it makes sense for the business to say "Wednesday is sample review day, everyone in plus one other day" then say that and monitor it.

Take it up with individuals who don't abide by the agreed model and if they whinge about commuting costs the answer ultimately is "tough this is what you applied for". Punishing the group rather than addressing individuals is just in invitation for your best people to leave and the coasters to stay.

wildernesssw · 15/12/2023 14:43

Have you asked them about how they find being in the office, what makes it a positive working place and what gets in the way of them being productive?

It may be just that they are moaning, of course, but it might be the way the workplace and workdays are structured that is causing them to feel they are more productive working at home.

Dweetfidilove · 15/12/2023 14:41

Stick to your guns, OP. The moaners will always find excuses not to come in.

My team is required to be in the office once per month and the same people- same day every month, manage to duck out of coming.

Swipe left for the next trending thread