Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2023 16:05

QueenCoconut · 15/12/2023 14:27

The stick is only effective with staff who need to stick to the current employer (desperate, low skilled, too scared to move on, too loyal). Anyone else will just vote with their feet and go for the carrot.

This is ignoring everything OP has said. She has no problem with the motivated and committed ( and I think would be glad to replace the whiners if they left of their own accord.)

btw , defining ‘loyalty’ as some sort of weakness is….curious.

KievLoverTwo · 15/12/2023 16:01

What can I do to stop people doing this?

Tell people at interview stage that you have had to take disciplinary action against staff members not adhering to the two day a week rule.

That should scare off anyone who thinks they might be able to get away with it.

Grimchmas · 15/12/2023 15:58

OP I would start with belt and braces - advert, interview, contract all clear that at least 2 days out of Tu/W/Th in the office every single working week is essential for the role and not going to change. Spell it out and get their clear affirmative verbal commitment to it in interview, and when sending over contract to sign also send a seperate letter about hybrid working practices that formally states the same, reinforces that this is a contractual obligation as per section 3.4 whatever of their contract, and that this is non-negotiable either now or in the future. Get them to sign and return that letter at the same time as the contract.

Then get clear on your company performance policy (which everybody should have access to from the get go) and implement it. Monitor attendance on something like a basic spreadsheet. On Thursdays or Friday every week email the offenders to ask why they weren't in as per contractual obligation and forward them a copy of the letter with their signature on it. In fact I'd probably prefer that they supply their office days in advance the previous week - sticking their initials on the relevant day in a shared outlook calendar works for my team.

If they consistently underperform then start informal/formal disciplinary proceedings. Follow through with these right up to dismissal if needed.

I know it's not a pleasant part of your job, but it IS a part of your job. I know you wish it weren't necessary but it is - your position in relation to this isn't dissimilar to their position in relation to WFH. You need to get on with that part of your job just as much as they need to get on with coming in to the office, as per their contract.

Abouttoblow · 15/12/2023 15:58

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

What a stupid comment.

If people are "rejecting roles that are office based" OP wouldn't have this issue.

The question is why are people accepting roles that require some time spent in the office then complaining about having to spend some time in the office.

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 15:58

Abra1t · 15/12/2023 15:47

Yes. Younger employees need to be in an office with older and more experienced people to learn soft skills they can't learn at home.

If you're an older employee, you benefited from this. The people you 'learned' from had to come in every single day. We were only rarely allowed to work from home because the technology wasn't there.

Anyone who can’t work Teams well enough to pass on their knowledge isn’t someone who’s worth learning from IMO.

Young people benefit from the choice of place to live that remote work allows.

IceandIndigo · 15/12/2023 15:57

I work hybrid under a similar arrangement - we’re supposed to be in the office 2 days a week. I do this without complaining, it’s in my contract, but I do find myself increasingly frustrated at the 1.5hrs/ day I spend commuting, time that on my homeworking days I can use for all manner of other things. Also, a significant portion of office time is spent on Teams meetings, which are so much easier to do from home. TBH I think I could get all the same collaboration benefits by a much less frequent office visit, maybe once a fortnight, especially if it was coordinated with other team members and there was a conscious agreement not to schedule remote meetings on those days. I suspect your employees are coming to the same realisation, they understand the expectation but aren’t convinced of the benefits of an arbitrary two days rule.

tttigress · 15/12/2023 15:56

This reminds me of a colleague that was now thankfully left our company.

He was fine with the commute until COVID struck, then reluctant to return to the office, when he was told he needed to be in 3 days a week. He started to count working on the train as part of his day (he self certified this) So even on the days he was meant to be in the office, he would physically only be there 11am-4pm.

He has switched jobs now, but the new job has the same commute!

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 15:56

BIossomtoes · 15/12/2023 15:54

But somehow we all managed it. For decades. Entire careers.

No, we 'all' didn't. You just didn't notice the ones who weren't there.

Charlize43 · 15/12/2023 15:55

Not very effective management if you've only just recruited but didn't specify that the job was hybrid with the expectation of X days working from home. I'd say next time be more specific in (a) the advert, and (b) the interview.

BIossomtoes · 15/12/2023 15:54

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 15:51

Alternatively, if you're an older employee you were fucked over by this because insistence on in person work disadvantaged and sometimes even excluded whole cohorts of people. But we did a very bad job of noticing that, as a society, before the 2020s.

But somehow we all managed it. For decades. Entire careers.

Abra1t · 15/12/2023 15:53

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 15:51

Alternatively, if you're an older employee you were fucked over by this because insistence on in person work disadvantaged and sometimes even excluded whole cohorts of people. But we did a very bad job of noticing that, as a society, before the 2020s.

Yup, one of them was me. Impossible to work FT in the office once I had a baby and a long commute. At that time there was barely email. I made a life-enhancing but financially costly decision to freelance and my very modest pension pot shows the impact of that.

Xtraincome · 15/12/2023 15:51

I would like to apply to this 6 figure job please and will attend the office 2 days per week, every week!!

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 15:51

Abra1t · 15/12/2023 15:47

Yes. Younger employees need to be in an office with older and more experienced people to learn soft skills they can't learn at home.

If you're an older employee, you benefited from this. The people you 'learned' from had to come in every single day. We were only rarely allowed to work from home because the technology wasn't there.

Alternatively, if you're an older employee you were fucked over by this because insistence on in person work disadvantaged and sometimes even excluded whole cohorts of people. But we did a very bad job of noticing that, as a society, before the 2020s.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 15:50

BitchBrigade · 15/12/2023 14:51

There isn't much I wouldn't do for 6 figures TBH. OP's employees have no idea how lucky they have it on 100k only attending 2 days a week.

I say that as someone who finds my 2 days in with 6 hours total commute time on a significantly less, with three kids, extremely east to manage. I am also a massive advocate for WFH if possible, and find the whole "In office for the sake of it, team building, collaboration" bullshit absolutely abhorrent after the world miraculously coped with it fine for two years.

I agree there is a lot of "in the office for collaboration" bullshit. I look for specific reasons/examples from people saying this.

In theory there is no aspect of my job which I couldn't do remotely and have worked with multi location teams and clients for decades. However learning new skills and relationship building with clients are both a lot faster with some in person face time.

I had a couple of teams working on site throughout the pandemic due to security requirements at the client site. The difference in progression for the juniors I had on site vs those having to work remotely was very marked. This also means that people like me need to suck it up and do my share of time in person with them - its part of our responsibility to the juniors.
The other place I still make sure to be in person is building relationships with new clients. Again - nothing really I can't do across collaboration tools but its simply much faster to do it in person and speed matters.

I'd echo the comments up thread as well - our juniors often want to be together and meeting their seniors for casual conversations. Its the more experienced staff who opt to wfh more often which is fine so long as they do their share of in person time to coach the next generation.

NonPlayerCharacter · 15/12/2023 15:49

Livingtothefull · 15/12/2023 14:44

I think the problem with this approach is it could be discriminatory or discourage diversity - eg if the workplace is in an affluent area that some potential candidates can't afford, or if certain demographics are over/underrepresented.

I haven't read all the responses sorry. But if not suggested, on approach could be to include in job applications a question like 'Are you willing and able to attend (workplace address) at least 2 days per week?' Anyone who responds 'no', their application is not progressed.

If they respond 'yes' then refuse to do it once employed then you are fully justified in holding to them to that application statement and follow through with disciplinary action if necessary.

I think the problem with this approach is it could be discriminatory or discourage diversity

Is that not true of any job that requires people to be at a particular site regularly? Any office-based or hybrid job?

Rabiz · 15/12/2023 15:49

Hont1986 · 15/12/2023 13:39

we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office

I hear this line get thrown around a lot by upper management and frankly I've never found that the rank and file employees actually agree. I suspect the real reasoning is somewhere in between "we have to pay to rent and heat the building so we don't want that to be a waste" and "working from home isn't real working, they're just dossing".

Obviously these 3 team members don’t feel like they get much from coming in to the office, otherwise they would be keener to do it.

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 15:49

PeloMom · 15/12/2023 15:42

@sweetpickle23@BlueberryVelvet it is bollocks because these people shouldn’t look for and accept jobs that require to be in the office if they don’t want to go. And yes, more and more companies are starting to require people to go back to the office and lots of flexibility is being removed as people have really been taking advantage.

i’m also an employer and throughout the recruiting process and in the contracts we clearly state 50% work in the office with which I’ve been quite understanding but it’s becoming increasingly important to enforce it due to the nature of the business. And although it’s clearly spelled out people are still taking advantage and moaning they have to do it. Fortunately where I am now it’s an employer’s market.

You being in an employer's market means you're in a position to enforce your 'shoulds'. The fact that OPs organisation have a 100% this year rate of new staff not having it suggests they aren't as advantageously positioned.

There isn't any evidence that more and more companies are requiring people back in and removing flexibility, incidentally. The most recent ONS figures suggest there's been no clear upward or downward trend in remote work since the pandemic restrictions ended. There are of course anecdotal examples of some having done it, but it's evidently been balanced out elsewhere.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 15/12/2023 15:48

Seems we have learned little from Covid.

My team is is on similar set up but nobody needs to be in the office at all, it’s an exercise in optics.

Load of BS if you ask me as we are far more productive when not being treated like school children.

HTH

PS I have a colleague who takes doggie sick days and none of us are remotely interested as it doesn’t impact our work in the slightest.

Abra1t · 15/12/2023 15:47

Q2C4 · 15/12/2023 13:50

My firm are finding that 100% remote roles disproportionately negatively impact junior positions due to the loss of spontaneous on the job learning / networking opportunities which cannot be replicated in a WFH context.

Yes. Younger employees need to be in an office with older and more experienced people to learn soft skills they can't learn at home.

If you're an older employee, you benefited from this. The people you 'learned' from had to come in every single day. We were only rarely allowed to work from home because the technology wasn't there.

PeloMom · 15/12/2023 15:42

@sweetpickle23@BlueberryVelvet it is bollocks because these people shouldn’t look for and accept jobs that require to be in the office if they don’t want to go. And yes, more and more companies are starting to require people to go back to the office and lots of flexibility is being removed as people have really been taking advantage.

i’m also an employer and throughout the recruiting process and in the contracts we clearly state 50% work in the office with which I’ve been quite understanding but it’s becoming increasingly important to enforce it due to the nature of the business. And although it’s clearly spelled out people are still taking advantage and moaning they have to do it. Fortunately where I am now it’s an employer’s market.

moomoomoo27 · 15/12/2023 15:41

From the other side of it.

I was headhunted for a job and promised the world, I knew it was a long commute. But according to Google it was 40 minutes and realistically there were always roadworks, road closures, diversions, accidents, lorries, traffic etc that made it over an hour on the regular and at times over 2 hours each way. I didn't know that before I started the job, nor did I know what impact it would have on my mental health. I had to give up everything else I had going on during the week because of having so little time to get my own stuff done and having to go to bed so early. I didn't get to go out for dinner with my DH any more, all my friends would go to the pub and I couldn't go, I would miss all the industry and networking events important to my career because going to anything evening-based was impossible. I had time to make dinner and do chores and then I had to go to bed.

It was also a job I could do from home, but (pre covid) was allowed zero working from home time despite saying verbally it would be possible, at the meeting to offer me the job.

I loved the role and the people, but 2-4 hrs a day commuting was far too much. If I wanted that I'd have worked in London for a much higher salary.

Knowing people's income doesn't mean you know how much their disposable income is. Offering them a job doesn't mean you get to dictate where they live. I didn't want to move because it would have been to a worse area in a worse house away from all my friends and family and with fewer services, I certainly wouldn't have wanted to move my DH away from all that just for my job. With kids involved it's even worse.

The fact you are calling it "getting away with working from home" and having to "monitor attendance" means that either you don't think they're doing the amount of work they should be, or that they really aren't doing the amount of work they should be. So which is it? If it's the second they need to be disciplined etc/encouraged to find a job that suits them better. If it's the first you need to get the idea out of your head that working from home means people aren't working.

Also actively monitoring attendance is what you do for children at school, not responsible working adults. You're wasting your time doing it or you're part of a toxic culture.

If they are good employees and they take a 5 min extra break working from home for xyz, that still costs the company less than paying you to waste your time on attendance chores that school secretaries and year 6 pupils do.

HouseChainDrama · 15/12/2023 15:41

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

I don't think you understand what a job is do you?

HouseChainDrama · 15/12/2023 15:40

BlueberryVelvet · 15/12/2023 13:30

Your “collaborative working” approach universally negatively impacts women and the environment and so perhaps listen to your staff rather than imposing arbitrary quotas on them.

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

It doesn't adversely impact women unless they have partners who don't their half of childcare. Which is on them to fix, not the employer. Women still to stop accepting so little from men

NigelHarmansNewWife · 15/12/2023 15:39

We have hybrid working and are supposed to be in the office 3 days a week. Core hours are 9-4. We're also not supposed to routinely work Mondays and Fridays from home. Some people stick to the rules religiously. Some work 5 days in the office. Some are in once in a blue moon, but you do have to question what value there is to coming in if no one on your team is in the office. Travel for work should be counted as a day in the office.

You have to enforce the being in the office properly. I do think some people have an inflated sense of how important they are to their employer, especially as we've all heard that it's become increasingly difficult to recruit, and think they're so valuable they can get away with doing what they like.

Itsnotallaboutyoulikeyouthink · 15/12/2023 15:38

I have been delivering training this year and the undertones to the training has all been about the fact that they are asked to come into the office for that training. This is despite the fact that we have to be in on a weekly basis anyway or whenever required. People take working for home as a given now and get arsey should they be asked to come in. Combine that with a general disgusting attitude from staff then it makes the workplace a really enjoyable place (not).