Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be losing the will to live with staff who chosen a job with a long commute & then complain about it

644 replies

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:21

I work in a well paid industry - think 6 figure salaries.

We've made really clear through hiring processes that roles are hybrid, not remote, we as a team really get a lot from collaborative working so we expect 2 days a week in the central office. There's flex about which days but we ask that people try to mostly hit the core days of tues/weds/thurs. As a line manager I'm not watching the clock and we are happy to play around with what time people start & finish - eg. One guy leaves at 4.30 to collect his kids by 5.30 & this is fine.

We've hired 3 people this year and made all this clear and they're all grumbling about their commutes and regularly asking to come in less. We offer what we can in terms of flexibility but when we insist we need them in 2 days, they are basically sulking. Its clear one of them in particular never had any intention of coming to the office more than a day or so every 2-3 weeks and expected to get away with remote working.

Its really frustrating. We were honest about what we needed and people just seem to think they can insist.

Why do people do this? One lady has moved 2 hours from our city 3 years ago, and during that time consistently keeps applying for and taking jobs here rather than in the large city where she now lives. Her husband also works in our industry and between them they'll have an income of £200k plus, so they aren't forced to live in a cheaper area.

Its really shit for me to have to go through the unpleasant process of monitoring people's attendance & imposing formal consequences etc (I'm not that kind of manager at all) because they took a job they don't want to turn up for.

What can I do to stop people doing this?

OP posts:
WhickDittington · 15/12/2023 16:35

A lot of work today is collaborative - especially in what we might call the "knowledge economy" , and there's a huge amount of research to suggest that physical presence & co-location is an aid to that collaboration, especially in the serendipity of a casual chat with someone that turns into something more concrete.

I also find that if I need to check in informally with a colleague about a matter that is confidential, or more easily sorted in a face to face chat, being in-person is far superior to email or even Teams.

AnonnyMouseDave · 15/12/2023 16:33

UsingChangeofName · 15/12/2023 16:29

By "flaky" you mean "those who have clear standards of what they want from an employer and won't take second best"

or maybe

'Those who understand that they have signed a contract to work in a particular way, but think they can actually do something completely different' ?

No, I was referring to the people who didn't accept the job and the PP was describing as flakey because they refused to sign the TS and Cs on offer.

JFDIYOLO · 15/12/2023 16:32

Is it stone cold clear from the start in the job description, recruitment messaging, interview, contract, onboarding, training, mentoring, probation, line manager 1-1s etc that it's hybrid not remote? And that the requirement can change?

Do you actually need them in - or is it that the kings and queens want their courts around them again?

Is there actual evidence that their physical presence = productivity, delivery and results?

Does the requirement include a salary that acknowledges the cost of travelling? My current salary is way less than my previous one - only now I walk to work every day whereas previously I was up at 6 for a London commute at £££ per month. Result.

And as a manager your role does involve monitoring and managing attendance - should you take a role with an element you don't want to do?

AnonnyMouseDave · 15/12/2023 16:32

AngryBird6122 · 15/12/2023 15:19

When you are at that level though, the working terms will be something like 9-5, when it really, really isn't 9-5. If someone wants to leave early to do the school run but then is up all evening working, so what?

I found it really funny when DH boss questioned him about being in at 10 after dropping the kids off when officially he starts at 9 (DH works late a lot, works weekends, has done an overnight stint once to get a project done) DH just said, so, you want me to work my contracted hours then? Boss 'yes' DH ok, so you don't want me to do anything after 5pm? Boss.....silence.

When I was a lot younger I had a job where I always turned up 5 minutes late... and I got lunch from a sandwich shop two minutes from the office, and worked past my contracted hours of 6pm. Guess what happened when the boss made a fuss about being in for 9am? I started - literally - going home for lunch every single day and taking the full hour, and leaving on the dot at 6. And left 6 months later!

ReturnfromtheStars · 15/12/2023 16:31

Ooh what do you do? What are those samples? Is it chocolate tasting?

UsingChangeofName · 15/12/2023 16:29

By "flaky" you mean "those who have clear standards of what they want from an employer and won't take second best"

or maybe

'Those who understand that they have signed a contract to work in a particular way, but think they can actually do something completely different' ?

AnonnyMouseDave · 15/12/2023 16:28

Ficklebricks · 15/12/2023 15:13

We have this issue. We now make people sign a hybrid working agreement along with their contract to set out exactly what's expected of them. It works well as a filter for the flaky ones, they usually reject the job offer when they see that.

By "flaky" you mean "those who have clear standards of what they want from an employer and won't take second best"

NonPlayerCharacter · 15/12/2023 16:27

As a slight aside, this is some pretty hard proof that the size of your salary isn't always an indication of how hard you work. Going to an office twice a week, with flexibility, is really not a huge demand for a top 5% salary.

millymog11 · 15/12/2023 16:27

There is also the cost of living/inflation which affects the man on the street - which is ignored in terms of what that gets you by people who just throw out "six figure salary" as if those magic three words answers all and every living expense concern anyone could ever have in any circumstances and for any career/job demands......

Bunnycat101 · 15/12/2023 16:26

I personally like once a week, can tolerate two but won’t go more than that for London commuting jobs. I’ve noticed that office days work best if the team are there and sat together- everyone seems to manage this well for one day and then are dotted around doing other days so often still spend a day in the office sat on teams. If people are genuinely using the office well then it feels worth it. When people are just sat there talking into headsets and not each other it feels a bit pointless and performative .

BIossomtoes · 15/12/2023 16:25

It’s going to be a huge wake up call to a lot of people if we go into recession and unemployment starts to rise again. The workforce calling the shots is a luxury resulting from full employment, if and when times get hard again - and it’s looking to me like they will - things will change very rapidly.

Kangaboo · 15/12/2023 16:24

I don't know what's going on with these entitled workers OP but if you pay me 100K+ I will be definitely be in your office twice a week!

Katbum · 15/12/2023 16:23

Face to face conversations ‘we were clear that the team is hybrid and you are expected to attend work at a minimum of 2 days per week. For at least one week a month that should be 3. If you are not willing to do this, then it will be a disciplinary matter.’ Then manage out those who won’t comply with a reasonable management instruction, which is a gross misconduct offence.

Ascubudr · 15/12/2023 16:19

This so much. We were slightly ahead of the curve prepandemic DH WFH on Tuesdays and Thursdays or Fridays. I WOTH Weds-Fri it was only way to make it fair.

millymog11 · 15/12/2023 16:18

" I think some of the problem is people applying for jobs in one city with the idea that they can live anywhere on the planet because of wfh."

Yes to the above
OP also needs to be totally honest about what kind of quality of life the salary they are offering would give someone who lives within a very comfortable commute of their office (eg can walk it or get there in less than half an hour) compared with the quality of life (cost of housing etc) they would get for the same job but living further away.

Honestly, it is never reflected in the salary is it? The companies / managers just moan as if to say "it should be as it was pre pandemic" or "young people are so lazy and ungrateful" yada yada.

The truth is there will be people willing to do what you want and be in the office when you want them to be but they won't be the cream of the crop in terms of the best people to employ because they will find something more flexible.

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 16:14

BIossomtoes · 15/12/2023 16:11

We didn’t have vacancies. 🤷‍♀️

You say that like you imagine it helps your point.

Do you really think that everyone was fine with working in person as a norm, that nobody ever got excluded because of caring responsibilities, location, neurodivergence, disability? Because it's one thing you not having clocked it at the time, you'd have had plenty of company there. But to still think that as we stare down the barrel of 2024 is something else again.

There always have been and still are organisations who could fill all their vacancies two or three times over. Some employers are just more attractive than others. It seldom tells us much about the wider picture.

Blueblell · 15/12/2023 16:14

If it is to collaborate then the days should be set so that everyone is in on the same days to collaborate. I think some of the problem is people applying for jobs in one city with the idea that they can live anywhere on the planet because of wfh. It’s a bit draconian but perhaps during the recruitment process the question of how and how long their commute will actually be and then that be taken into consideration when hiring.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 15/12/2023 16:14

Benibidibici · 15/12/2023 13:47

Office working is becoming increasingly obsolete and younger people are actively rejecting roles that are office based.

Our trainees have been most disappointed as the people they are supposed to learn with aren't coming in. Its a hard job to learn 100% remotely. We lost trainees during covid for this reason.

This is our experience too, we have failed to retain graduates for the periods where senior staff were not working in the office.

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 16:13

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2023 16:05

This is ignoring everything OP has said. She has no problem with the motivated and committed ( and I think would be glad to replace the whiners if they left of their own accord.)

btw , defining ‘loyalty’ as some sort of weakness is….curious.

There was actually an article in the FT last week about how loyalty isn’t always a good thing. https://www.ft.com/content/be583262-8bc7-4ad0-884c-792656093c22

Why staff loyalty is not always a good thing

Faithful workers are inclined to invest more time and effort in their jobs. But it’s not all rosy

https://www.ft.com/content/be583262-8bc7-4ad0-884c-792656093c22

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 16:12

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 16:08

Its nothing to do with the technical ability to use Teams or similar. Its the missed opportunity to observe more experienced people as they do the job, to hear the conversations, to have them at hand to ask "stupid" questions.

As I said upthread - our juniors who had to work on site during covid have progressed must faster than those forced to work in isolation. Its the juniors who are least likely to want to WFH as they are at a stage in career where then need to learn by observation, don't have comfy and warm home offices and derive a lot of their social life by building friendships at work.

It’s not necessarily about technical ability. It’s about understanding the new workplace culture of IM, screen sharing, video calls, collaborative online tools etc. There is no excuse for not senior staff passing things on ad hoc or not having ongoing casual conversations with their employees in a world with IM.

BIossomtoes · 15/12/2023 16:11

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 15:56

No, we 'all' didn't. You just didn't notice the ones who weren't there.

We didn’t have vacancies. 🤷‍♀️

elizabethdraper · 15/12/2023 16:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

No, i have a shoulder injury

Getting to work isnt an issue, it is the fact i need to cancel all my daily meetings while in the office resulting in a complete loss productivity not just for me but my team.

Not being able to liase with my team except by email or teams chat function

TrashedSofa · 15/12/2023 16:08

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/12/2023 16:05

This is ignoring everything OP has said. She has no problem with the motivated and committed ( and I think would be glad to replace the whiners if they left of their own accord.)

btw , defining ‘loyalty’ as some sort of weakness is….curious.

OP would no doubt be glad to replace them. The question she'll have to ask herself is whether she realistically could. The fact that this has happened with every single new staff member they've had in 2023 does suggest this might simply be the norm for new recruits in the industry now, rather than just the employer choosing badly.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/12/2023 16:08

Spaghettieis · 15/12/2023 15:58

Anyone who can’t work Teams well enough to pass on their knowledge isn’t someone who’s worth learning from IMO.

Young people benefit from the choice of place to live that remote work allows.

Its nothing to do with the technical ability to use Teams or similar. Its the missed opportunity to observe more experienced people as they do the job, to hear the conversations, to have them at hand to ask "stupid" questions.

As I said upthread - our juniors who had to work on site during covid have progressed must faster than those forced to work in isolation. Its the juniors who are least likely to want to WFH as they are at a stage in career where then need to learn by observation, don't have comfy and warm home offices and derive a lot of their social life by building friendships at work.

millymog11 · 15/12/2023 16:07

OP not read the whole thread but read a number of your replies.

Noted that you have said you will only hire from CVs with local addresses but that staff move away after they have been hired.

I think that recruitment goes both ways. If you think you have found someone who will be a total asset to the company, whose CV you are impressed with, who shows commitment to their work, who you can see will fit in with the team.
It is not just the candidate who needs to be honest.

You need to look the above perfect-on-paper candidate in the eyes and say, before you offer them a job "if you do not do the following minimum time within the following weekly days every single week in the office, bums-on-seats, then that will be considered a disciplinary matter and ultimately we will let you go. You will have to sign up to that as an express condition of your employment"

The candidate signs up to that condition before you offer them a job.

If you dream candidate says no I will not do that, you accept it and do not try to persuade them otherwise.

If your dream candidate accepts that condition and then renages on that commitment after starting work, you fire them (you cannot have one rule for one and another rule for another). All of the senior managers need to work to the same pattern (you cannot expect juniors to do it if no one senior (including you) is ever in the office).

The stress and financial cost (in terms of lost salary and expenses arising from working from the office) of daily commute is enormous.

You are justified in demanding it but you have to stand by that in all ways.