Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have declined Christmas invitation from MIL

586 replies

Onesidedagain · 15/12/2023 11:37

Every year MIL hosts. The last time we went was 2013. That’s because that was the year that MIL got her dog.

Since then SIL and BIL have also got a dog, MIL has got a second dog.

I am allergic and terrified as well. I can’t stand the smell of dogs either. We’ve offered for them to see us at our house (minus dogs) on Boxing Day- that’s not good enough. We offered to host last year - no, that’s not ‘the tradition’

Now dh is getting hassled with messages telling him to go - that my allergies and phobias shouldn’t be a barrier to his family Christmas!

OP posts:
Ilovecleaning · 17/12/2023 09:21

Other people’s pets can be a total PITA and, over the years, I have avoided visiting some people who have cats or dogs. Cats trying to jump on your lap, bed down and leave hairs on your clothes. Yapping dogs. Dogs jumping up, bringing you their toys, licking you… yuk.
Gooey-eyed owners not having the basic sense to realise that not everyone who visits wants to be jumped on, slobbered on and harassed.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 09:20

harriethoyle · 17/12/2023 09:03

Because I suggested that someone with a disabling phobia get some help for it?

Cool story bro.

Hmmm I rather think that having severe reactions to dogs and being afraid of having a severe reaction isn't really an irrational fear (phobia) but actually a fear which is self preservationary.

Fear comes from a need to protect yourself. It's is evolutionary and a rational response to a threat. If we didn't have fear, we'd kill ourselves and humans would have died out a long time ago. A phobia is when that fear is out of control and goes beyond the actual risk and becomes a problem in its own right which can limit your life in other ways. More simply put a phobia is an inability to correctly assess a risk.

The OP does not have a phobia. She's used the word because that's what other people understand as an extreme fear but it's actually an incorrect use of the word. There is a risk to her health and wellbeing which she understands from previous experience. Her desire to avoid is therefore totally understandable and rational.

We wouldn't ask people to risk their health to spend time with family at Christmas. We wouldn't tell them to go and have psychological training (brainwashing) to ignore the risks to their health and put the demands of others over their physical needs.

What it boils down to to a large extent on this thread is belief. People who do not believe that allergies to dogs are real. This is despite evidence to the contrary. That's ideological bullshit that they want to push onto others because they think suffers are liars.

That's conspiracy level claptrap. I have no time for people like this who refuse to believe.

phoenixrosehere · 17/12/2023 09:08

harriethoyle · 17/12/2023 09:03

Because I suggested that someone with a disabling phobia get some help for it?

Cool story bro.

Again, how is it a phobia when it causes severe allergic reactions? It’s not irrational for her to avoid dogs due to her circumstances so not a phobia.

harriethoyle · 17/12/2023 09:03

Mommywomb · 17/12/2023 01:41

Definitely sounded like one!
😂

Because I suggested that someone with a disabling phobia get some help for it?

Cool story bro.

Ilovecleaning · 17/12/2023 09:01

harriethoyle · 15/12/2023 11:53

You need to get some help with your phobia, particularly seeing you appear to have passed it on to one of your DC.

Is this victim blaming…?

Properjob · 17/12/2023 08:57

I am totally on your side OP. You dont need 'fixing' to fit in with dog obsessives. And thankfully your DH is too, bet he's very pleased that he doesn't have to go either! Enjoy your family Xmas free from dogs. Some of us can manage to go for a walk without one.

SumthingAndNuthing · 17/12/2023 08:43

Are people being deliberately obtuse or just not reading the OP’s posts? Being around dogs and cats triggers @Onesidedagain‘s asthma. People can die if they have a severe asthma attack.

My mum died when I was 10 years old as an asthma attack lead to a heart attack. She left 5 young children as orphans.

OP, you are not being unreasonable. I hope you have a lovely Christmas 🎄

CadhlaWren · 17/12/2023 08:22

Yanbu.

If I was mil I would have accepted your offer to host, and would have looked into care for the dogs.

It’s wild to me that she expects DH to leave you, and your dc but she won’t leave her dogs.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 17/12/2023 08:20

@Dejavue You’ll be better off starting your own thread but for what it’s worth, You want Christmas your way so make it happen.
Set some ground rules. Start now. Tell DH his daughter and her boyfriend are welcome to stay but they need reminding that this is your house, not a hotel or a doss house and should appreciate your hospitality and will be expected to help out and if he won’t I’d do it my self. This goes for all of them , get all of them help out, they clear up after themselves, help out with cooking and cleaning, the boyfriend included, Don’t wait on them hand and foot. If they don’t like it that can stay elsewhere.

Whoonearthevenareyou · 17/12/2023 08:18

I don't get why people are asking why OPs DH can't see "his family" at Christmas. His family are his wife and his DC and yes, he should be with them, his family.
We never went anywhere after we had our first DC. Christmas is time for being with your family and once you have a partner and DC they are your family. DH needs to put a stop to the badgering and say thank you but we are staying home as we always do (10 years is always tbh) No reasons, no explanation. Merry Christmas.

JassyRadlett · 17/12/2023 08:16

Mommywomb · 17/12/2023 01:36

no! Phobias are not just irrelevant because you have not encountered them!
my mom is severally phobic to dogs- she had seen a dog devouring someone when she was very young and can’t just get over it even after therapy- so it’s not oh phobia pfff they are irrelevant. They are not a minor thing for a person with them!

I think the PP is saying that in this case the phobia is a red herring - even without the phobia, OP is allergic and therefore can't go.

I don't think they're saying that phobias are irrelevant in general - it was more of a riposte to all the dopey "just get over with your phobia" posts. As OP says, even if she invested the time and money and was successful in doing that, she'd still be allergic to dogs.

changeme4this · 17/12/2023 08:12

Is there any chance what your OH says to you is opposite/in contrast to what he is telling his family?

thus they have stepped up the invite to you?

Littlegoth · 17/12/2023 08:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Real allergies - I would cry with laughter over this. We have real allergies in this house too- to nuts and to dogs.

There’s no hierarchy over whose allergy is likely to make them dead faster. You should know better. There are no mild allergies, just mild reactions. Until the reactions aren’t mild. You are either lying about the family allergies or you haven’t been listening at clinic.

phoenixrosehere · 17/12/2023 08:00

Ukrainebaby23 · 17/12/2023 05:19

I think you should work on your phobias but confronting them at Christmas will not be helpful.
Having allergies to animals, presume cats also? is one issue, is it a hay-fever type or life threatening reaction type,?
Having phobias plus allergies which are probably intrinsically linked needs professional help for the sake of your DC and yourself, bit it won't be a quick fix.

Christmas should be on neutral pet free territory until you've made some progress, but I think both sides need a bit of compromise and they can't expect you to just fit in.

OP has answered these questions in later posts and one of her DC is also allergic to dogs.

OP, you’re doing a disservice to yourself calling your aversion to dogs a phobia. A phobia is an irrational fear, you avoiding dogs because they make you ill is not irrational! Anyone knowingly submitting themselves to something that makes them ill would be seen as ridiculous.

I wouldn’t want to be around people who thinks anyone should knowingly harm themselves to please others who can’t consider them or compromise.

For ten years you have declined. If the requests for your DH to join the family have intensified this year there is likely to be a reason for it. I would suspect that she fears it might be someone’s last Christmas - that someone in the family is ill. Or perhaps she fears she is getting too old to host the whole family and this might be the last time she is able to do it. Whereas you seem to have made it all about the dogs I doubt that it is in her mind. She simply wants what she sees as a traditional Christmas.

The MIL has mentioned OP’s allergies and If that is the case that MIL thinks that it is someone’s last Christmas, she should tell her son that upfront, instead of bombarding him with messages about him choosing to stay home on Christmas Day with his wife and children. He can go over on Boxing Day if he wants to.

The DH is making the choice not to go. He’s a grown adult and can decide for himself where he spends Christmas Day. If his mother can’t respect that, that’s her problem. OP is irrelevant in this situation because she is not stopping him from going nor can make him go if he doesn’t want to. He is making that choice but his family seems to rather blame OP knowing she has had this allergy for years and that one of their children does too.

Littlegoth · 17/12/2023 07:58

CantFindMyMarbles · 16/12/2023 20:48

Take some antihistamine’s and you’ll be fine. The amount of people that walk around with animal dander on the en in immense including people you are friends with, work with etc.

Exactly what I’m talking about. Loads and loads of posts on here about why this won’t work, but people still have a blinkered determination to ignore how dangerous allergies are.

Alwaystryingtoohard · 17/12/2023 05:53

Trying to get my head around the range of viewpoints on this thread…

OP- allergic, phobic of dogs. Cannot go to MIL house. Will host MIL at their house. Expected to make herself & child exposed to likely allergic reaction, and therefore illness and fear (irrational or not, it doesn’t matter, it’s a real fear they have). on Christmas Day, to suit other members of family.

MIL- wants to see DS & DGC (& possibly DIL) has dogs, doesn’t want to or can’t kennel them over Christmas and wants Christmas at home with other family members around too. Could leave them for a couple
of hours to visit OP. Will not do this. Fair enough. Some suggestions of it being someone’s last christmas playing about. Yes it may be, and that is awful if it is the case, but this is unavoidable and MIL could compromise
slightly and attend OP’s for a couple of hours if so. Doesn’t want to? Fair enough!

DH- wants to be at home with family. Wants a drink. Is allowed to feel like this and enjoy
Christmas as he wants. Could pop over to MIL alone for a couple of hours on Christmas Day, but wants to be with DW & children. Could pop over Boxing Day - probably would if he wanted to!

Regardless of illness, phobias…

OP & DH & children are entitled to have a family
christmas at home as they wish to spend it. Want to spend Christmas together & illness-free.

MIL & rest of family are entitled to have a family
Christmas at MIL’s house as they wish to spend it. Want to spend Christmas together & with their dogs.

Nothing wrong with either side here. It’s one day. Celebrate christmas across the Christmas period with them just not at their house. Grown adults are free to make their own decisions, other people are free to feel how they do about it.

OP has offered a compromise so that her and DC are not potentially quite ill and in fear, MIL doesn’t want to. Fine on both sides!

And as an aside… I wouldn’t want to spend Christmas with someone who dismissed my allergies / phobias (again, very real problems to individuals, regardless of how other people view the severity / reality of them) and happily had me sat in their house knowing I was suffering to give them a merry Christmas.

Ukrainebaby23 · 17/12/2023 05:19

I think you should work on your phobias but confronting them at Christmas will not be helpful.
Having allergies to animals, presume cats also? is one issue, is it a hay-fever type or life threatening reaction type,?
Having phobias plus allergies which are probably intrinsically linked needs professional help for the sake of your DC and yourself, bit it won't be a quick fix.

Christmas should be on neutral pet free territory until you've made some progress, but I think both sides need a bit of compromise and they can't expect you to just fit in.

Propertyshmoperty · 17/12/2023 02:11

Crumblecakes · 15/12/2023 11:42

I think maybe you can take some anti-allergy tablets and go? 10 years is a long time to not see his family on Christmas, I’m sure they will keep the dogs at bay if you ask. Would you not want to see your family on Xmas day for 10 years?
If not your husband can pop over for and hour or 2

I love dogs and have grown up with dogs but I have developed an allergy so bad that sometimes even with anti-histimines my chest and throat closes up, especially around the breed I was brought up with and my family still own.

Its not that easy.

I do still try with antihistimines with well ventilated rooms that have been hoovered ahead of time of dander and the dogs aren't play fighting, but if I'm in a small room, where the dogs are allowed on furniture and jumping around I am totally fucked and will need a day to recover if my chest closes up (which is pretty frightening to be honest) I also don't have a phobia of dogs but if I was expected to have dinner in a room of spiders for xmas I would pretty much fuck that off, allergy or not.

Chaos86 · 17/12/2023 01:53

You are definitely not being unreasonable! You have a family of your own and don’t want a miserable Xmas day with a swollen face and itchy eyes etc. your husband is his own person, if he doesn’t care to visit that’s on him, I hate how it’s always the woman that’s blamed. Have a lovely Xmas with your family xx

Mommywomb · 17/12/2023 01:52

Mrschickenn · 16/12/2023 13:39

I think this sounds like a made up allergy to try and get away with the phobia. I also think having passed this fear onto one of your children, you’re really unfair and need to get help. I don’t trust people who don’t like dogs, but would always trust a dog not liking a person. You and now your child are seriously missing out on the amazing animals they are

and hello mother in law- please take your head out for once in a while under the rock you’re living to see real human beings!

Mommywomb · 17/12/2023 01:41

harriethoyle · 16/12/2023 19:25

Ha! I'm 40, child free by choice and very definitely not a mother in law 🙄

Definitely sounded like one!
😂

SheSaidHummingbird · 17/12/2023 01:39

"I think people just are how they are when it comes to phobias."

No. There is a triggering episode.

Mommywomb · 17/12/2023 01:36

soemptyinside · 15/12/2023 12:15

I think the phobia is irrelevant, TBH. You have an allergy.

If you didn't have DC, I'd say he should go on his own every other year, but as you do... it makes sense you do your own thing together as a family. YANBU.

no! Phobias are not just irrelevant because you have not encountered them!
my mom is severally phobic to dogs- she had seen a dog devouring someone when she was very young and can’t just get over it even after therapy- so it’s not oh phobia pfff they are irrelevant. They are not a minor thing for a person with them!

GrannyRose15 · 17/12/2023 01:04

It sounds to me as though there is something else going on here that is not clear from the posts. For ten years your MIL has invited you to spend Christmas at hers with the rest of your DHs family. For ten years you have declined. If the requests for your DH to join the family have intensified this year there is likely to be a reason for it. I would suspect that she fears it might be someone’s last Christmas - that someone in the family is ill. Or perhaps she fears she is getting too old to host the whole family and this might be the last time she is able to do it. Whereas you seem to have made it all about the dogs I doubt that it is in her mind. She simply wants what she sees as a traditional Christmas. There is no harm in that. It is of course entirely up to you what you do. But I think you are being unfair suggesting that MIL is being awkward simply because she hasn’t put you at the centre of her Christmas arrangements.

SapphireSeptember · 17/12/2023 00:21

Mrschickenn · 16/12/2023 13:39

I think this sounds like a made up allergy to try and get away with the phobia. I also think having passed this fear onto one of your children, you’re really unfair and need to get help. I don’t trust people who don’t like dogs, but would always trust a dog not liking a person. You and now your child are seriously missing out on the amazing animals they are

Try telling that to my friend, some of her kids are so allergic to dogs it could kill them, (they have epi pens.) OP is not unreasonable to want to keep away from something that makes her seriously ill. I get dreadful hayfever, but I can't avoid pollen in the spring/summer, so I find ways to mitigate it, like having a shower as soon as I get home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread