Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have declined Christmas invitation from MIL

586 replies

Onesidedagain · 15/12/2023 11:37

Every year MIL hosts. The last time we went was 2013. That’s because that was the year that MIL got her dog.

Since then SIL and BIL have also got a dog, MIL has got a second dog.

I am allergic and terrified as well. I can’t stand the smell of dogs either. We’ve offered for them to see us at our house (minus dogs) on Boxing Day- that’s not good enough. We offered to host last year - no, that’s not ‘the tradition’

Now dh is getting hassled with messages telling him to go - that my allergies and phobias shouldn’t be a barrier to his family Christmas!

OP posts:
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/12/2023 19:42

Bamboobzled · 17/12/2023 19:32

Is it an actual full blown allergy likely to cause you admission to hospital or an intolerance? I have an intolerance but have a dog (one that doesn't shed hair everywhere). I have friends who do take anti histamines and are fine with dogs but others who are truly allergic. My confusion in your situation is why it's suddenly a thing after ten years, have none of you gone over for ten years?

The second sentence in the OP is "The last time we went was 2013." So yes, we have been told that they have not gone to MiL on Christmas Day for ten years.

The fuss this year is because the PiL are going to downsize next year and MiL wants to revive the tradition of all her children gathered round her in her house, and to hell with her son's tradition that he and his wife and children spend Christmas day at home: she is the only one who matters. Her tradition has not happened for ten years. (I haven't noticed how old OP's children are, if she has told us, but it's possible that one or more of them has never spent Christmas Day at Granny's house.)

It you click on "see all" at the bottom of the post at the top of the page, which is the first post, it brings up all the OP's posts and you can read everything that she has told us. I find this useful to remind me about things a few pages back, even though I am not going to check for the children's ages.

Bamboobzled · 17/12/2023 19:32

Is it an actual full blown allergy likely to cause you admission to hospital or an intolerance? I have an intolerance but have a dog (one that doesn't shed hair everywhere). I have friends who do take anti histamines and are fine with dogs but others who are truly allergic. My confusion in your situation is why it's suddenly a thing after ten years, have none of you gone over for ten years?

chaosmaker · 17/12/2023 18:57

Thanks for the update @Onesidedagain . Your husband is fab and hopefully you won't be pestered by them again.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/12/2023 18:49

You know about your allergy. You know nothing about the allergy suffered by the OP. (Certain dogs, eh? Fascinating.)

The MiL similarly has known for ten years that her daughter-in-law cannot safely be in a house with dogs and has done nothing at all to alter the situation.

It seems clear that OP's family is quite happy with the tradition they have enjoyed for the past ten years: Christmas in their own house. Her husband's mother wants to have a different tradition; that, with deference, is not on OP to deal with except that MiL is making such a stinkin' fuss and kafuffle at her.

Not to mention anyone expecting another family to alter their plans for Christmas at seven days' notice is a pita by definition.

Winnipeg23 · 17/12/2023 18:41

To be fair MIL sounds awful. 10/10 to Ur husband tho for standing his ground and just saying what he wants. Sounds like u got a good one there. Enjoy ur Christmas ⛄🎁

Callyem · 17/12/2023 18:38

Why so much emphasis on Christmas being one day? It is perfectly reasonable for families to have their own Christmas Day and to see wider family on Boxing day. Allergy or no allergy, phobia or no phobia.

pikkumyy77 · 17/12/2023 18:36

Oaktree55 · 17/12/2023 15:41

What's interesting about this thread is the complete lack of acknowledgement that the children have wider family. I have plenty of relatives I dislike, find awkward etc but I put up with difficulties as it is important our children see their wider family especially at important times where other families get together. There is a lot of selfishness coming across in reponses. It is generally in children's interest to mix with their extended family.

What is interesting to me about this comment is that it had more projection than a 12 screen cinema.

Just because OP and her children don’t see grandma in the doghouse over Christmas does not mean the children don’t or can’t have a lovely relationship with the wider family—even with grandma. My Own grandparents came to us for holidays every year as they lived far away and I had a great relationship with them by phone and (in those days letter) in between.

If grandma etc.. want a warm relationship with the grandkids it starts with caring enough about their mother to gracefully create memories in a safe space for DH’s entire family. The children are not toys to be brought to amuse grandma but are members of the extended family whose need for parents who are safe/healthy need to be respected.

pikkumyy77 · 17/12/2023 18:29

Is she planning to decline for the rest of their lives? Maybe family is getting fed up with it.

So what? Visiting people in their homes is not a moral or social imperative. Not if the location is unsafe. The OP isn’t obligated to accept this summons whether year 1 or year 20. Who are these i hospitable hosts to be “fed up”?

sunglassesonthetable · 17/12/2023 18:26

*Why would you rather accuse OP and her child of exaggerating up a potentially life threatening allergy than accept that this could result in OP and her child needing emergency treatment?

I don’t get it.*

Agree. Still not clear why this poster knows more about OP's health than the OP ?

🤷‍♀️

sunglassesonthetable · 17/12/2023 18:24

Is she planning to decline for the rest of their lives? Maybe family is getting fed up with it.

Is the family going ignore OPs needs for the rest of their lives. Be totally inflexible with regard to location and dogs?

Littlegoth · 17/12/2023 18:24

Oaktree55 · 17/12/2023 15:58

Turn this into a standard family dispute of I'd rather they came to me or rather not see them at Christmas at all and that's fine, happening all over the UK, but don't seek sympathy over some exaggerated health issue it's ridiculous.

Why would you rather accuse OP and her child of exaggerating up a potentially life threatening allergy than accept that this could result in OP and her child needing emergency treatment?

I don’t get it.

Please do let me know so that I understand how to protect my kids from this ignorance. Other than just drumming into them that other people are dicks.

BeenThereDoneThatGotTheTshirt89 · 17/12/2023 18:21

Not true, I have a severe allergy to certain dogs, I have prescribed medication that I take before going to their houses, so I know what I am taking about. In regards to the phobia it's not going to be solved in a week but it's been 10 years, been plenty of time to seek help. Christmas is same time every year, not as if she didn't know it was coming.

Is she planning to decline for the rest of their lives? Maybe family is getting fed up with it.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 18:20

Oaktree55 · 17/12/2023 15:41

What's interesting about this thread is the complete lack of acknowledgement that the children have wider family. I have plenty of relatives I dislike, find awkward etc but I put up with difficulties as it is important our children see their wider family especially at important times where other families get together. There is a lot of selfishness coming across in reponses. It is generally in children's interest to mix with their extended family.

MIL is capable of going to her son's house. She doesn't want to. Cos big Christmas at her house and to hell with those with allergies.

Yeah ok... I can go with the utterly selfish angle.

AuntMarch · 17/12/2023 18:19

It's been 10 years, at this point the tradition is you guys not going. You are not being unreasonable, and nor have you been any other year.
You've offered an alternative, it's on them if they aren't willing to accept it.

Nipsmum · 17/12/2023 18:10

Don't let mil tell you what to do. Stick to saying no of your husband agrees with you. Don't be bullied.

Anisette · 17/12/2023 18:09

BeenThereDoneThatGotTheTshirt89 · 17/12/2023 18:02

Take an anti allergy tablet. I"m severely allergic to certain dander. However I take medication before going to those with those dogs.

With the phobia you need to make seek some help, 10 years not spending with family is hard. Can they not keep the dogs in another part of the house for you you while you are there?

An "anti-allergy" tablet won't be enough for a severe allergy when she's n a house full of dog hairs. Self-evidently she's not going to get over the phobia within the next week.

BeenThereDoneThatGotTheTshirt89 · 17/12/2023 18:02

Take an anti allergy tablet. I"m severely allergic to certain dander. However I take medication before going to those with those dogs.

With the phobia you need to make seek some help, 10 years not spending with family is hard. Can they not keep the dogs in another part of the house for you you while you are there?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/12/2023 16:24

It all does bring us back round to a very basic question about hospitality: when somebody has been invited to another person's house, whose welfare should be more important: that of the host, or that of the guest?

I personally feel that the onus is on the host to make the guest feel comfortable, not on the guest to pander to the host. If the host makes the guest unsafe and expects the guest to suck it up, that is being a bad host.

So that would be the end of this discussion, as far as I am concerned: the host in this case clearly doesn't give a stuff about the comfort of her guests, so she's a lousy host and they need feel no obligation to pander to her by being present.

BusyMummyWrites · 17/12/2023 16:22

sunglassesonthetable · 17/12/2023 16:17

Many people you come across in day to day living will be covered in dog hair be that queing for a coffee, at work, getting petrol. To pretend that the allergy is severe that simple separation of the pets and general hoovering/cleanliness won't solve this issue is being disingenuous.

How do YOU know all that?

See above post - it is not an allergy in response to the odd stray dog hair… it’s to do with allergens that build up and become concentrated in an enclosed environment. Often saliva and dander is where the allergens are, so you need to be in the pets home environment to trigger it.

NoTouch · 17/12/2023 16:18

As a dog lover I would say YANBU, no way would I be spending Christmas exposing myself to an allergen that made me feel so unwell.

The way my dh would deal with it is keep it factual. The dogs are a health issue for you, and being with his wife and dc on Christmas day is his priority. He completely understands it is disappointing for her plans and you all wish it was different but it is what it is and neither is negotiable and he will not discuss further.

Say you would all love to meet but it will need to be outside their home or at yours without the dogs, or dh can visit alone on another date that suits them both.

sunglassesonthetable · 17/12/2023 16:17

Many people you come across in day to day living will be covered in dog hair be that queing for a coffee, at work, getting petrol. To pretend that the allergy is severe that simple separation of the pets and general hoovering/cleanliness won't solve this issue is being disingenuous.

How do YOU know all that?

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/12/2023 16:16

"General hoovering" will not necessarily solve anything. Dander goes straight through an ordinary hoover, which merely spreads it around the room a bit in the air before it settles back into the carpet. In order to get rid of it, you need a specialist hoover with very much finer filters than yer standard machine has. I don't feel confident that MiL has a HEPA hoover: she doesn't need one herself, and clearly doesn't really believe that OP has a serious allergy, so why would she have shelled out extra?

sunglassesonthetable · 17/12/2023 16:15

As I have said before if guests have animal allergies I separate the pets from the guest and ensure furniture etc hoovered. Not diffficult.

Fabulous.

Don't think MiL and family sound as if they are about to do that.

BusyMummyWrites · 17/12/2023 16:14

Oaktree55 · 17/12/2023 15:45

Well I am assuming the OP isn't housebound and has a fairly normal life. If so she will come in contact with several dogs/dog hair throughout the day and therefore I doubt her allergy includes not being able to breathe! There are many dogs about not just at her MIL and they are pretty hard to avoid in normal day to day life!

Yet another comment that shows the poster has no understanding of allergies/allergic asthma. I go about the world in the knowledge I will encounter people with guinea pigs. I even go to pets-at-home to buy dogfood and walk past the small animal pens. However, whenever I cleaned out our guinea pigs’s pen I ended up with the paramedics sitting in my lounge until the small hours with oxygen and counting the inhaler puffs on a 15 minute cycle or, occasionally, hospitalised. We rehomed the Guinea pigs. There is a distinct difference between a small or passing encounter and being in a dangerously allergen-dense and enclosed environment for hours on end (or even just for the 10 mins it takes to clean a GP pen). My husband is similarly afflicted by cats - an evening in a house with cats and he can end up unable to breathe for several days or hospitalised - but he can still stop and pet a cat on his walk to work, so long as he washes his hands afterwards.

phoenixrosehere · 17/12/2023 16:02

Oaktree55 · 17/12/2023 15:54

Many people you come across in day to day living will be covered in dog hair be that queing for a coffee, at work, getting petrol. To pretend that the allergy is severe that simple separation of the pets and general hoovering/cleanliness won't solve this issue is being disingenuous. I don't doubt there are a minority of people with extreme allergies but they are not living normal lives. Many many people have standard allergies to many things they don't curtail their day to day living or their families!

To pretend that the allergy is severe that simple separation of the pets and general hoovering/cleanliness won't solve this issue is being disingenuous.

That onus is on her in-laws though and considering how dismissive they are of her allergies, what makes you think they will go out of their way to do that nor have they offered to do so or to keep the dogs in a separate area from what OP has posted?