Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have declined Christmas invitation from MIL

586 replies

Onesidedagain · 15/12/2023 11:37

Every year MIL hosts. The last time we went was 2013. That’s because that was the year that MIL got her dog.

Since then SIL and BIL have also got a dog, MIL has got a second dog.

I am allergic and terrified as well. I can’t stand the smell of dogs either. We’ve offered for them to see us at our house (minus dogs) on Boxing Day- that’s not good enough. We offered to host last year - no, that’s not ‘the tradition’

Now dh is getting hassled with messages telling him to go - that my allergies and phobias shouldn’t be a barrier to his family Christmas!

OP posts:
SapphireSeptember · 20/12/2023 11:21

Reidie · 17/12/2023 13:25

You are being unreasonable . Take an antihistamine and get over yourself . Dogs are family 🎄

Antihistamines don't always work, and sometimes come with nasty side effects. Also I know at least one person who's allergic to them as well, so how would that work?

Rosscameasdoody · 20/12/2023 09:53

wronginalltherightways · 19/12/2023 16:56

How can you identify someone who hasn't read the thread without saying they haven't read the thread.🙄

Irritating isn’t it. The points about medication and visiting the environment in which the dogs live have been done to death throughout the thread, and still people fill up the posting space, repeating ad nauseam. If only there was some way to see all of the OP’s updates before posting. Oh, wait………….

Rosscameasdoody · 20/12/2023 09:46

NMOB · 19/12/2023 19:37

I think you are perfectly reasonable to decline based on your allergy & phobia.
However, it’s not reasonable to be annoyed that your offer of hosting is not accepted. Realistically you can’t expect the rest of the family to find dog sitters for Christmas Day or to leave their dogs alone for hours & not drink so as to drive home to care for the dogs.

is this an issue the rest of the year for family events ? Can you never go to your MIL’s?
it would be sad to be missing out based on a phobia ( assuming an antihistamine would make it possible to be around dogs in theory ) & I would definitely suggest getting your DC help for the phobia at the very least. It’s pretty prohibitive to go through life scared of dogs - a lot of families have one & more workplaces , cafes etc now allow dogs.

Edited

Why can’t OP expect them to find dog sitters or make other arrangements ? The family has known for ten years that OP has the allergy and have done nothing about facilitating Christmas without the dogs. They’re expecting OP and her family to make all the accommodations needed so that MiL can play at having a ‘traditional’ family Christmas, when in fact the tradition hasn’t existed for ten years.

And as has been explained numerous times, her allergy is severe, so medication would only work for a short time. It’s not just the dogs, it’s the environment in which they live, so it would make any visit uncomfortable. You also seem to have missed the fact that her son also has the same allergy, not just a phobia. Allergies and phobias go hand in hand. If the effects of the allergy are severe, the body develops the phobia as a kind of ‘prompt’ to stay away from the source of the discomfort. So therapy to address the phobia would be pretty pointless - it wouldn’t facilitate them welcoming dogs into their personal space because the allergy still exists.

SummerPeach · 20/12/2023 09:24

NMOB · 19/12/2023 19:37

I think you are perfectly reasonable to decline based on your allergy & phobia.
However, it’s not reasonable to be annoyed that your offer of hosting is not accepted. Realistically you can’t expect the rest of the family to find dog sitters for Christmas Day or to leave their dogs alone for hours & not drink so as to drive home to care for the dogs.

is this an issue the rest of the year for family events ? Can you never go to your MIL’s?
it would be sad to be missing out based on a phobia ( assuming an antihistamine would make it possible to be around dogs in theory ) & I would definitely suggest getting your DC help for the phobia at the very least. It’s pretty prohibitive to go through life scared of dogs - a lot of families have one & more workplaces , cafes etc now allow dogs.

Edited

Sometimes phobias are perfectly rational and keep us safe.
I have a phobia of dogs myself because of a family walk in the woods turning into watching my little brother almost being mauled to death by a dog who bounded out from the trees without a lead and no recall and a STUPID IRRESPONSIBLE owner.
I also know two lovely little girls who now do not have a father because he died from being bitten by a dog.

SummerPeach · 20/12/2023 07:12

NMOB · 19/12/2023 19:37

I think you are perfectly reasonable to decline based on your allergy & phobia.
However, it’s not reasonable to be annoyed that your offer of hosting is not accepted. Realistically you can’t expect the rest of the family to find dog sitters for Christmas Day or to leave their dogs alone for hours & not drink so as to drive home to care for the dogs.

is this an issue the rest of the year for family events ? Can you never go to your MIL’s?
it would be sad to be missing out based on a phobia ( assuming an antihistamine would make it possible to be around dogs in theory ) & I would definitely suggest getting your DC help for the phobia at the very least. It’s pretty prohibitive to go through life scared of dogs - a lot of families have one & more workplaces , cafes etc now allow dogs.

Edited

if the family really saw it as a priority to all be together for Christmas - then the compromise is no dogs!!
OP has no intention of being around dogs and that is completely reasonable and acceptable.
Dogs are animals, they can go to kennels or a dog sitter.
if DH’s family is seriously choosing their dogs as company for Christmas rather than daughter in law and grandkids - it speaks volumes tbh and is insulting to say the least. If it were me, I’d just be like ok forget it then - Enjoy your mongrel companions! See you some other time at a location which is dogfree.

pikkumyy77 · 19/12/2023 19:42

NMOB · 19/12/2023 19:37

I think you are perfectly reasonable to decline based on your allergy & phobia.
However, it’s not reasonable to be annoyed that your offer of hosting is not accepted. Realistically you can’t expect the rest of the family to find dog sitters for Christmas Day or to leave their dogs alone for hours & not drink so as to drive home to care for the dogs.

is this an issue the rest of the year for family events ? Can you never go to your MIL’s?
it would be sad to be missing out based on a phobia ( assuming an antihistamine would make it possible to be around dogs in theory ) & I would definitely suggest getting your DC help for the phobia at the very least. It’s pretty prohibitive to go through life scared of dogs - a lot of families have one & more workplaces , cafes etc now allow dogs.

Edited

Why the insistence on even handedly finding fault with both sides. OP offered a compromise but it was rejected. if she is annoyed it is because her MIL won’t engage in a good faith negotiation in which each side offers s compromise and is willing to accept a partial success. Instead the MIL is continuing to browbeat OP snd her DH so MIL gets what she wants with no regard to OPs family’s stated needs/wants.

NMOB · 19/12/2023 19:37

I think you are perfectly reasonable to decline based on your allergy & phobia.
However, it’s not reasonable to be annoyed that your offer of hosting is not accepted. Realistically you can’t expect the rest of the family to find dog sitters for Christmas Day or to leave their dogs alone for hours & not drink so as to drive home to care for the dogs.

is this an issue the rest of the year for family events ? Can you never go to your MIL’s?
it would be sad to be missing out based on a phobia ( assuming an antihistamine would make it possible to be around dogs in theory ) & I would definitely suggest getting your DC help for the phobia at the very least. It’s pretty prohibitive to go through life scared of dogs - a lot of families have one & more workplaces , cafes etc now allow dogs.

wronginalltherightways · 19/12/2023 16:56

BeenThereDoneThatGotTheTshirt89 · 17/12/2023 18:02

Take an anti allergy tablet. I"m severely allergic to certain dander. However I take medication before going to those with those dogs.

With the phobia you need to make seek some help, 10 years not spending with family is hard. Can they not keep the dogs in another part of the house for you you while you are there?

How can you identify someone who hasn't read the thread without saying they haven't read the thread.🙄

Mommywomb · 19/12/2023 15:19

Rosscameasdoody · 19/12/2023 00:31

These points have been addressed one by one throughout the thread - numerous times. Medication doesn’t always work for allergies as severe as this and if it does, only for a short time - not to mention the side effects. And it’s not just OP - her son has the same allergy. And the phobia is as a result of the allergy. Not being able to breathe in the presence of dogs triggers a fear defence response in the body - how exactly is that unreasonable ?

@Scotland32 YABU- no smell?!?! We bought a house where previous owners had two dogs- very clean people tbh but I couldn’t bear the smell when we moved! Having a dog makes you nose blind but it’s doesn’t mean that there is no smell!
also phobias are not as simple as you think they are- it’s like oh you’re claustrophobic- you’re being unreasonable and just get in this bunker for a day or two! It doesn’t work like that!

Madamum18 · 19/12/2023 10:17

Onesidedagain · 16/12/2023 09:09

Because this year she is bombarding dh with messages saying he shouldn’t miss out on ‘his’ Christmas ! He has said to her that he wants to be with the dc. In previous years he’s seen them all on Boxing Day but it’s not enough for her. He’s had messages from his siblings too ! It just seems more intense this year-we do see them over the festive period it’s just I can’t be in a house with multiple dogs and we prefer to have Christmas Day altogether

She needs to stop it!! This is YOUR Christmas too as in your family! Tell her that as she is not willing to compromise then she will have to accept the consequences because HIS Christmas and wishes are to be with his children

Rosscameasdoody · 19/12/2023 00:35

LakieLady · 18/12/2023 13:10

If I was dog phobic, now that dogs seem to be around a lot more, eg in pubs, on public transport, shops etc, I would be inclined to get treatment if I could.

I used to be badly bird phobic, so much so that I once fainted on unexpectedly encountering a macaw in a shop. I used to have to cross the road if there was a pigeon on the pavement, couldn't have a picnic in a park or a meal in a pub garden and once had to get an Asda security guard to chase a seagull off the roof of my car so I could get in it. When it got to the point that I feared I might have to give up driving, because the urge to duck and cover my face if a bird flew towards the windscreen was becoming almost impossible to resist, my GP referred me for therapy.

Six sessions of CBT was all it took to reduce it to a manageable level, although I'd still be reluctant to visit a house where they had a bird flying loose. And I didn't realise how stressful constantly being hyper-vigilant when out and about had got until wasn't like it any more.

I'd recommend it to anyone who's seriously phobic about anything relatively commonplace.

But once again, the OP is severely allergic to dogs, so why would she go to such lengths to overcome the phobia associated with that ? She still can’t go near them. And phobia associated with allergy is a naturally occurring bodily response designed to protect the sufferer.

Rosscameasdoody · 19/12/2023 00:31

Scotland32 · 18/12/2023 18:14

Allergy - YANBU (but you can take medication on the day surely?)
‘Phobia’ - YABU (especially to pass this onto your children - you can easily get help to get over this)
Disliking the smell of dogs - YABU (no need to stick your nose on them. I have only ever been to one doggy house that smells bad)

These points have been addressed one by one throughout the thread - numerous times. Medication doesn’t always work for allergies as severe as this and if it does, only for a short time - not to mention the side effects. And it’s not just OP - her son has the same allergy. And the phobia is as a result of the allergy. Not being able to breathe in the presence of dogs triggers a fear defence response in the body - how exactly is that unreasonable ?

juice92 · 18/12/2023 22:44

We have a family member who is (pretty severely) allergic to cats, we have cats so he would never come to our house. Taking a tablet doesn't really help him and even if we put the cats in another room, were super careful with the hoovering etc etc he would still have a reaction and could end up very unwell. I wouldn't expect him to somehow 'get over it', he can't. To add a phobia in the mix makes it even worse.

Ewock · 18/12/2023 21:50

Oaktree55 · 17/12/2023 15:45

Well I am assuming the OP isn't housebound and has a fairly normal life. If so she will come in contact with several dogs/dog hair throughout the day and therefore I doubt her allergy includes not being able to breathe! There are many dogs about not just at her MIL and they are pretty hard to avoid in normal day to day life!

My dad has allergies to pet hair and yes it does mean he is unable to breathe. He can not go in places which are pet friendly, so will avoid certain pubs, cafes etc. If they go on holiday he has to ensure where they are staying has never had dogs there and the list goes on. He can take steroids and antihistamines which will reduce it slightly but these make him rather out-of it and the side effects aren't fun.
So for him and many others they can not be in a house where a dog lives, not them being difficult just a fact of their life. Yes it's awkward at times but it is what it is.
Generally coming into contact outside is not an issue my dad won't pet animals, so very easy to avoid in daily life when you have no choice.

maddiemookins16mum · 18/12/2023 21:47

CalistoNoSolo · 15/12/2023 11:39

Why can't he go on his own?

Meanwhile back in the real world…….

wysen · 18/12/2023 20:59

You are being unreasonable . Take an antihistamine and get over yourself . Dogs are family

I'm utterly shocked and appalled by some of the ignorant comments on this thread, such as the one above. What is it about posting anonymously that brings out pure nastiness in people?

Some of these comments are spiteful, rude, and totally uncalled for.
The OP has an allergy to dogs that could potentially be really serious. She's not being a "princess"
Honestly I despair

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/12/2023 19:01

You can take medication for a day. And so can one of your children.

And if it doesn't work, as for many people it doesn't, well, you can just have a super Christmas rushing your child (who suffers from the same allergy) into hospital for emergency treatment. Won't that be jolly fun!

Scotland32 · 18/12/2023 18:14

Allergy - YANBU (but you can take medication on the day surely?)
‘Phobia’ - YABU (especially to pass this onto your children - you can easily get help to get over this)
Disliking the smell of dogs - YABU (no need to stick your nose on them. I have only ever been to one doggy house that smells bad)

My3dahliasarebloominlovely · 18/12/2023 13:38

Reidie · 17/12/2023 13:25

You are being unreasonable . Take an antihistamine and get over yourself . Dogs are family 🎄

What the actual fuck? OP isn't just inconvenienced by her allergies, they could make her extremely ill or even worse. She's phobic because of her allergies- it's her body protecting itself. As it is, the smallest trace could give her massive reactions, not always alleviated by an antihistamine tablet. This is a major issue.
I'm glad your DH is in your corner for this, OP

LakieLady · 18/12/2023 13:10

MrsSlocombesCat · 15/12/2023 12:28

I also have a phobia of dogs and I don’t think anyone should be obliged to have treatment. I don’t want to overcome my phobia because I don’t want to be around dogs. It’s not like a phobia of spiders, dogs can hurt you and be aggressive which is what caused my phobia in the first place. As the OP is also allergic why should she have to overcome the phobia? It doesn’t make any sense.

If I was dog phobic, now that dogs seem to be around a lot more, eg in pubs, on public transport, shops etc, I would be inclined to get treatment if I could.

I used to be badly bird phobic, so much so that I once fainted on unexpectedly encountering a macaw in a shop. I used to have to cross the road if there was a pigeon on the pavement, couldn't have a picnic in a park or a meal in a pub garden and once had to get an Asda security guard to chase a seagull off the roof of my car so I could get in it. When it got to the point that I feared I might have to give up driving, because the urge to duck and cover my face if a bird flew towards the windscreen was becoming almost impossible to resist, my GP referred me for therapy.

Six sessions of CBT was all it took to reduce it to a manageable level, although I'd still be reluctant to visit a house where they had a bird flying loose. And I didn't realise how stressful constantly being hyper-vigilant when out and about had got until wasn't like it any more.

I'd recommend it to anyone who's seriously phobic about anything relatively commonplace.

LookItsMeAgain · 18/12/2023 12:34

Onesidedagain · 17/12/2023 12:28

After a phone call last night from FIL to dh where he explained how upset MIL is dh asked outright ‘is someone ill?’ To be told no. The issue is that they will be downsizing next year and MIL just wants to see everyone together on Christmas Day for the last time in the house.

It's not your place to fix that issue for her though.

She is welcome to visit you - without her dogs - if she really wanted to see you all.

She doesn't want to be inconvenienced by having to put herself out over Christmas to do that so there you have your answer.

SummerPeach · 18/12/2023 12:25

Reidie · 18/12/2023 06:30

I’m happy when my loved ones are happy . Simple as . We all have to put up with situations that aren’t ideal that’s life we go through it making the best of everything and finding the positive in everything rather than mothering about having to spend time with people and a few dogs . We will have to agree to differ 🤓

You’re happy when your loved ones are happy. Exactly. Therefore if you love your grandkids and daughter and law and your son, you wouldn’t dream of forcing them into a situation which makes them all feel unwell or uncomfortable.

SummerPeach · 18/12/2023 12:23

mollyminniemo · 18/12/2023 06:14

Even if people aren’t allergic to dogs being in a house or more than 2 dogs can be very full on/ annoying/ smelly for non dog owners especially on what should be a very special
occasion. YANBU.

Correct. Not all people adore dogs. And that doesn’t require any explanation.

Goldiemummy · 18/12/2023 11:13

#CalistoNoSolo
Seriously? They're a family unit and they want to be together.

Goldiemummy · 18/12/2023 11:09

Seriously? They're a family unit. They want to be together.