Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have declined Christmas invitation from MIL

586 replies

Onesidedagain · 15/12/2023 11:37

Every year MIL hosts. The last time we went was 2013. That’s because that was the year that MIL got her dog.

Since then SIL and BIL have also got a dog, MIL has got a second dog.

I am allergic and terrified as well. I can’t stand the smell of dogs either. We’ve offered for them to see us at our house (minus dogs) on Boxing Day- that’s not good enough. We offered to host last year - no, that’s not ‘the tradition’

Now dh is getting hassled with messages telling him to go - that my allergies and phobias shouldn’t be a barrier to his family Christmas!

OP posts:
Onesidedagain · 16/12/2023 08:40

Awwwwooooga · 16/12/2023 08:35

Just to let you know, the NHS offer therapy for phobias and would do so for dog phobia.

I’ll keep this in mind for my dc who is phobic if they want to address it when older

I don’t think it’s a passed on phobia as one dc loves animals and isn’t scared and both have seen my reaction. I’m also totally fine with spiders yet dc are both totally terrified , same with bees and wasps - so I do think some people have phobias for reasons we just don’t know and would have no matter what they were exposed to so I’m not blaming myself

OP posts:
Onesidedagain · 16/12/2023 08:37

Yes I avoid parks with dogs but we have 2 play parks locally not actually within a bigger park so we go there for swing / slide etc and we have a big garden so they can run about outside , avoiding parks where dogs may be has zero impact on their lives . We also just avoid any dog friendly cafes and pick ones where dogs aren’t allowed it’s not a big deal just takes a few mins thought .

I don’t see how therapy would help - it’s not like I need to be around dogs. It’s not like a spider phobia where there could be one on your house! It’s totally different , I can easily avoid them . My allergy is really bad though and triggers of my asthma if I’m actually indoors with animals so it’s 50/50 mix of phobia and allergy, actually if I’m honest it’s 50% allergy 25% phobia and 25% sensory as the smell makes me want to be sick and the the dog hair etc makes me feel just horrible , I don’t. See how therapy would be a good use of the little spare time I have !

OP posts:
Awwwwooooga · 16/12/2023 08:35

Just to let you know, the NHS offer therapy for phobias and would do so for dog phobia.

KuanKaKu · 16/12/2023 08:28

I would just ask that you turn this around and put yourself in the shoes of in-laws which you may well be one day, what would you do in the situation on one of your DC not coming to the family home for Christmas for ten years?

What goes around, comes around. Think about the bigger picture.

Try to compromise, we can come for post dinner drinks if the dogs are crated or outside the whole time we are there….if they are not willing then you’ve made a reasonable effort.

Ivymom · 16/12/2023 08:11

As someone with a severe cat allergy, I understand why OP is unwilling to spend Christmas at her in-laws’ house. I risk anaphylactic shock every time I go into a house with cats. Taking allergy medicine isn’t enough to ensure my safety and the side effects are horrible. The last time I tried this, after less than a fifteen minute visit, I ended up with my eyes swelled shut, wheezing to the point I had to stay in bed. My in-laws saw me like this, got indoor cats afterwards and complained when I wouldn’t visit inside their homes. We tried to visit, but stay outside in the garden and they would insist on bringing the cats outside and holding them during the visit. My DH refused to visit them at their homes after that. We’ve never taken our children to their homes as my allergy is hereditary and we don’t know how severe it may be for them.

The OP and her DH have offered an alternative where the in-laws can visit for the holiday and not risk the health of OP and one of her children. The in-laws would rather spend it with their dogs than make a compromise that ensures OP and her child don’t end up ill. In my opinion, the OP isn’t the unreasonable one.

Spacemoon · 16/12/2023 07:53

StepAwayFromGoogling · 16/12/2023 06:58

Did I read that correctly? You avoid parks because of your phobia of dogs and don't think it's affecting your children?

I have a phobia of dogs. I used to avoid places like parks until I sent my kids to a school that meant the school run included walking through a park and I had no choice. Before this, my DH (or grandparents) would simply take the kids to the park if that's what they wanted to do - it didn't affect them, as they had lots of time with me doing other fun stuff and it was a good chance for bonding 1 on 1 time for them. I don't need to be everywhere with my children at all times. Children have 2 parents.

The first few months of those school runs was hell and required extensive therapy and a lot of support from family and friends for me to be able to do it. Not everyone has that option and if it's a place they CAN avoid, why shouldn't they?

People completely underestimate some phobias - especially phobias of dogs. I've found people act completely different when I tell them my phobia of spiders for example than they do for my phobia of dogs and it's usually the 'dog people' who cannot possibly wrap their heads around someone being scared of their precious 'baby'.

I would never judge someone for their phobia. But perhaps if you've never suffered a severe phobia (particularly one that is often dismissed) you wouldn't understand.

honeysuckleweeks · 16/12/2023 07:32

BalloonSalesperson · 15/12/2023 12:46

I’m sure they will keep the dogs at bay if you ask

Often people promise that they will, but then they don't.
I have a relative with a German Shepherd. Twice I've visited and she's promised to keep the dog in the back garden. Both times it's run down the garden path towards us, barking. She backtracked and said see how it goes, if it bothers you we'll put in the the back garden later.

Well it's already bothered me to the point I'm not coming in. Cheers.

OT - but I'm always so sad to hear how people hate Shepherds. They are lovely dogs. They innately protect not attack. I've never known a nasty one. And I've known a nasty Golden Retriever. I think it's mostly from movies and TV. They have such an undeserved bad reputation.

Womencanlift · 16/12/2023 07:18

NegativeNelly · 16/12/2023 07:12

Can't you just take some anti allergy meds? It's just a day, think it's a bit mean.

Tell me you don’t know how allergies work without telling me you don’t know….

If you had a nut allergy and someone was forcing you to have the big purple one from the Quality Street tin, would you be happy for someone to say oh go on take a pill so you can eat one, it is Christmas after all.

As a pp said on MN allergies around animals are seen as something you can get over (because it’s an animal) whereas other allergies are understood to be as dangerous as they are

NegativeNelly · 16/12/2023 07:12

Can't you just take some anti allergy meds? It's just a day, think it's a bit mean.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 16/12/2023 06:58

Onesidedagain · 15/12/2023 13:29

One dc is the other isn’t - I don’t have time for therapy for a phobia I can live with. Dogs outside fine I avoid parks and dog friendly cafes etc. that’s why I avoid a house full of dogs too !

Did I read that correctly? You avoid parks because of your phobia of dogs and don't think it's affecting your children?

Womencanlift · 16/12/2023 06:55

adorablecat · 15/12/2023 13:31

You are dodging a bullet by not being there. Dog people are generally weird in other ways.

This is so true. You see it every time on threads about dogs (including this one).

OP says she has an allergy so has a physical reaction which will naturally make you wary of being around them as unsure of how much of a reaction you will have.

Posters will then come on and say take an antihistamine and get a grip as if that’s going to solve it (and of course you wouldn’t have thought of that yourself) 🙄

Eekmystro · 15/12/2023 22:27

It sounds like you don’t want to go there because of the obvious dog issue, your DH isn’t that fussed either. So there shouldn’t be an issue. The issue is purely his family’s issue.

just keep repeating “Thanks for offer but we are staying home this xmas” and DH can visit with DC that want to on Boxing Day for a few hours.

WinterDeWinter · 15/12/2023 22:27

I have two children about whom I've been very worried in the past, btw -so I know whereof I speaketh when I talk about the complex ties of dependency. 😁

WinterDeWinter · 15/12/2023 22:22

They presumably knew she has a phobia of dogs. But they got dogs. I wouldn’t get animals if my DIL had a phobia of them - and then kick off when she won’t come at Christmas. That is just nuts, in my view.

Just wanted to add that the desire to get a dog can be almost irresistible, along the same trajectory (though obviously not literally the same) as the desire to have a child.

I have a relationship with my dog that's genuinely quite central to my wellbeing. That fact is politely hidden by my ironically OTT irritation at the twatness of him/ludicrous babying of him, depending on the time of day/his behaviour. But he really is my dependent/family and I couldn't willingly put him in a scary/stressful situation.

WinterDeWinter · 15/12/2023 22:13

I feel for you and also (on principle only - they sound like arseholes) for them.I know what a phobia feels like and of course you can't just put a brave face on 'just for one day'.

At the same time I couldn't leave my dog alone for more than 2-3 hours and definitely wouldn't put them in the very stressful environment of a kennels (where dogs believe that they have been abandoned) to spend any day with anyone, barring a terminal relative or something like that.

It sounds like they are, as above, arseholes - but is there a way next year to have them to you for a short but very lovely period, so that they could leave their dogs at home for 3 hours and have a really fantastic time at yours?

In the spirit of turning the other cheek on arseholes ;-)

Findinganewme · 15/12/2023 22:07

Can the dogs go into another room whilst you make a quick visit?

Flossflower · 15/12/2023 17:32

Maray1967 · 15/12/2023 14:36

No. They presumably knew she has a phobia of dogs. But they got dogs. I wouldn’t get animals if my DIL had a phobia of them - and then kick off when she won’t come at Christmas. That is just nuts, in my view.

Plus, GPS don’t have the right to demand their grown up DCs with their own families stay for Christmas. We don’t know the history in this case but there have been posts that say that the GPS always had Christmas in their home when they were a young family but still expect the ‘tradition’ to continue when the next generation are now the young families.

That is more or less what I was going to say. I am a grandparent and have to realise that it is now my children’s turn to do their own Christmas Day. We are very lucky that we always get invited.
I too am dog phobic. I have been ever since I was a toddler and was knocked over by an excited large dog. I don’t see this as a problem as I don’t like being around dogs anyway.

RampantIvy · 15/12/2023 16:50

Phobia aside, all these people expecting you to put with feeling ill on Christmas Day because of your allergies are very very unreasonable

Exactly.

hellsBells246 · 15/12/2023 16:45

Tell them you are making your own family traditions! And you will see them somewhere without the dogs...

FirstTimeTTC989 · 15/12/2023 16:36

Phobia aside, all these people expecting you to put with feeling ill on Christmas Day because of your allergies are very very unreasonable. Why is MIL's enjoyment of Christmas more important than yours? Fuck that.

Why should you be uncomfortable on Christmas Day? I have allergies too, antihistamines are not a magic cure, for many people it doesn't cure it for a few hours, just makes it slightly less bad.

MIL is choosing to not see her grandchildren.

Boomboom22 · 15/12/2023 16:16

It's clear from this thread how horrible some dog owners are, they don't care and they don't acknowledge how dangerous their animals are. Just not nice people, anyone who says they prefer dogs to people or compares them to children, or even calls a dog phobia irrational or denies they smell is not a nice person.

Brefugee · 15/12/2023 16:00

Don’t like the smell-well now you’re just sounding like you’re making excuses tbh.

as an excuse it is one i am completely comfortable making. If someone invites me to their house that reeks of dog? sorry, that's a "no can do" from me.

Workway · 15/12/2023 15:44

The hysteria on this thread because someone doesn't like dogs is baffling.

What if it was spiders, rodents? An allergy to nuts that MIL insisted on using while cooking?

I have 2 dogs and sorry OP I might think you're a bit wet for having a phobia of two perfectly friendly dogs but I certainly wouldn't push the issue. Coupled with an allergy to them - I'd either be booking kennels/dog sitter for Christmas day or I'd have accepted that Christmas day had to be done differently - I might suggest booking a restaurant for Christmas dinner so everyone could attend etc

Sounds like they don't want a middle ground they just want a bitch fest!

lesdeluges · 15/12/2023 15:39

They prefer their dogs over you. Your DH should (and possibly does) have your back and stay home with you. You have offered to host minus dogs, but no, that is not enough.

Nothing will ever be enough coming from you though. So do your own thing and DH, you and children have a great Christmas Day as you should.

I wouldn't give it another thought TBH. If DH agrees with you and backs you up there is nothing they can say that will have any impact.

If he dithers that's another matter and they will blame you and manipulate him. Make sure that doesn't happen and you are good to go and enjoy Christmas without these controlling people. There are multiple work arounds, but they want it their way or the highway with or without you. Dogs are not humans.

caramac04 · 15/12/2023 15:34

YANBU. I have dogs and anyone with allergies is likely to be really miserable at my house. Locking the dogs in another room wouldn’t work .
I would not expect someone to feel ill because I choose to have dogs.
Chrismas traditions can be great but not when they are so rigid they impinge on other people’s choices.