Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have declined Christmas invitation from MIL

586 replies

Onesidedagain · 15/12/2023 11:37

Every year MIL hosts. The last time we went was 2013. That’s because that was the year that MIL got her dog.

Since then SIL and BIL have also got a dog, MIL has got a second dog.

I am allergic and terrified as well. I can’t stand the smell of dogs either. We’ve offered for them to see us at our house (minus dogs) on Boxing Day- that’s not good enough. We offered to host last year - no, that’s not ‘the tradition’

Now dh is getting hassled with messages telling him to go - that my allergies and phobias shouldn’t be a barrier to his family Christmas!

OP posts:
sunglassesonthetable · 16/12/2023 12:00

Honestly what are some people like?

MiL wants this, wants that.....

Soz DiL has a medical condition.

Adapt or suck it up.

They're foot stamping OP. 🤦‍♀️ They're meant to be grown ups no?

Flossflower · 16/12/2023 11:56

Littlegoth · 16/12/2023 11:01

The allergy is enough though, given that’s the bit that could make her dead.

Absolutely and Christmas would be the worse time to need urgent medical care.

wronginalltherightways · 16/12/2023 11:33

Bbm18 · 16/12/2023 10:58

Absolutely not unreasonable!

I think ab important thing to remember here is no one should be forced to go somewhere, regardless if the reasons! The OPS reasons are health related and perfectly reasonable in itself. But if she just didn’t want to go, that would be ok too! It’s her Christmas too, it’s her child’s Christmas too, they would like to do what they would like to do! Why is there something wrong with that! Made worse by the fact that’s no compromise, I’d dig my heels in as far as possible!

I agree.

I see so many grandparents that would never have dreamed of spending their Christmases anywhere other than in their own home with their children when they were raising, but now expect their now grown up children to do otherwise with their own children. The hypocrisy is rampant.

rainbowstardrops · 16/12/2023 11:32

I wouldn't go either OP! They know you have an allergy and a phobia/sensory issues, so they're being totally unfair to either expect you to just suck it up, or for your DH to miss Christmas Day with his wife and children!!!
You've tried to compromise and offered to host, so it's their fault that they're making an issue out of this.
Why haven't they suggested a pub or restaurant in previous years?
Your DH going over on Boxing Day is perfectly ok but not Christmas Day.

Bingobatman · 16/12/2023 11:17

Personally I think even not liking the smell is enough reason! I am extremely sensitive to smells and sadly cannot stay anywhere with strong smells of dogs. I wish I could! And yes, to some degree you can get used to the smell but by that time I am very nauseous and often have a headache.
I’m fine with dogs outside.
similarly I cannot be around my MIL as she covers herself with perfume which makes me vomit (yes, literally). She doesn’t wear it around me but it is all over her clothes. I am dreading Christmas because she will be there and since she refrains from pumping the ghastly stench all over herself while she is with us I feel that it would be rude to ask her to make sure her clothes and coat etc are smell free. Also, perhaps more importantly, she wouldn’t be able to tell if it was or wasn’t! But I feel like I’m being constantly punched in the face by the smell; it gives me a headache and makes me irrationally angry. I can tell if she is in a room just by standing outside it. She’s a nice lady, lives by herself, makes an effort with us, etc so I’ll just keep my distance, air the rooms discreetly and get on with it.
But for you, OP, with your allergies, phobia as well as dislike of the smell, YANBU at all staying away. Worth having the phobia looked at though, as PP have mentioned.

pam290358 · 16/12/2023 11:17

Rightsraptor · 16/12/2023 11:08

This isn't about dogs. This is a power play by your MiL.

She's trying every which way she can to hang onto her son and he, like many others, isn't telling her she has to let go.

Once you've got married/partnered up/had children - in short, founded your own family, then that family takes priority. Your original family has to take a back seat.

That is not to say, of course, that you ignore or treat your original family badly or whatever but their wishes are not paramount. In laws need to accept this. Clearly many find it next to impossible, as we see here.

Your DH needs to explain a few things to his mum & family and then stick to his guns.

This. It does sound as though her DH has been supportive, but if as the OP has said, he’s now getting messages hassling him to find a solution, maybe this is his opportunity to do what you suggest, explain the problem in detail and then let them get on with it.

daisychain01 · 16/12/2023 11:14

There is ample evidence that long term use of antihistamines is not good for eye health, memory and later in life potential contribution towards dementia.

all this just to please someone who won't compromise. If it was me there'd be no way on earth I'd put myself in that situation when the reasonable alternative is to not be around animals that give the symptoms in the first place.

why isn't a restaurant meal an option, with everyone chipping in with their family contribution. Probably not because the DM wants her own way or the highway.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/12/2023 11:13

Littlegoth · 16/12/2023 11:01

The allergy is enough though, given that’s the bit that could make her dead.

Agree. A lot of posters glossing over that. There are different levels of allergy and it sounds as though OP’s is quite severe. Not all allergies respond to medication either, and the meds can cause drowsiness and have other side effects. Not sure why people are advocating that the OP make herself ill on Christmas Day just to please people who clearly put their dogs before everything and everyone else. And why are people lecturing her about passing on her fear to her DC when she’s made it clear that he has the same allergy ? The fear is rooted in the allergy if it’s severe enough. Nothing to do with the OP ‘passing it on’. So much victim blaming going on.

JassyRadlett · 16/12/2023 11:10

TheFlis · 16/12/2023 10:05

But what do you expect them to do with their dogs while you host? They can’t leave them at home all day and dog sitters over Christmas usually have to be booked months and months in advance.

And that's their choice. OP's done the right thing and invited them as their home isn't hospitable to people with allergies, which is also a choice they made. They should have the grace not to moan, hassle and manipulate about the consequences of that choice.

ChaoticCrumble · 16/12/2023 11:08

As you have seen many people don't take dog allergies seriously at all. Even if it 'wouldn't kill you' it's really an unpleasant way to spend a day, antihistamines barely take the edge off. (They would help me for an hour max and I don't have asthma). They will probably never change (inlaws or mumsnet!)

Rightsraptor · 16/12/2023 11:08

This isn't about dogs. This is a power play by your MiL.

She's trying every which way she can to hang onto her son and he, like many others, isn't telling her she has to let go.

Once you've got married/partnered up/had children - in short, founded your own family, then that family takes priority. Your original family has to take a back seat.

That is not to say, of course, that you ignore or treat your original family badly or whatever but their wishes are not paramount. In laws need to accept this. Clearly many find it next to impossible, as we see here.

Your DH needs to explain a few things to his mum & family and then stick to his guns.

phoenixrosehere · 16/12/2023 11:04

Popwentmybrain · 16/12/2023 10:54

Go or don’t go it’s up to you. But just admit to them you don’t want to and don’t make excuses. 10 years not having Christmas with my family would be very upsetting to me and them. You don’t have to agree to the whole time. I am allergic to cats but still go to visit a family member I love dearly who has 2. There are scales of allergy from anaphylactic which is super dangerous to a bit of an itch/sneeze. I have asthma and cats make me wheeze and scratch my skin, watery eyes etc but a lifetime of an allergy means you know what will help to manage unless so extreme/anaphylaxis means you must avoid at all costs. Smells are everywhere and part of life, there are ways to cope with them. Having read all your replies to comments you don’t really want to deal with any of your issues. Many have suggested help for your phobia which you seem resistant to and don’t accept that you could have passed this to your child - one of your children could easily be more attuned to your reactions and attitudes than the other. Phobias aren’t something anyone is born with and shouldn’t be let slide in children when they can be dealt with. You are allowing it that they will also spend their life limiting or tailoring their activities. From the tone of all your replies you didn’t want to hear any suggestions to help just agreement that it was unreasonable that your husbands family want to spend a Christmas with him. It is unreasonable that they won’t come to you even for Boxing Day but very reasonable that they would want to spend Christmas with him and his family.

Her reasons are quite legitimate and I wouldn’t expect someone to just lump it and spend their time focusing on not being ill to make me happy.

It’s ridiculous for her in-laws to expect things to magically change because they want it to and be frustrated having known this about her to begin with. They are being upset and frustrated at the wrong person. Her DH can go around if he really wanted to, but he chooses not to as is his right.

He says he sees his parents plenty throughout the year and doesn’t want to drive there and back without being able to have a drink if I read correctly.

It’s sad some posters think someone should be ill on Christmas for the sake of others when they don’t have to.

I bet even if she did go, they would still moan if she had to leave straight after due to her allergies.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/12/2023 11:04

Popwentmybrain · 16/12/2023 10:54

Go or don’t go it’s up to you. But just admit to them you don’t want to and don’t make excuses. 10 years not having Christmas with my family would be very upsetting to me and them. You don’t have to agree to the whole time. I am allergic to cats but still go to visit a family member I love dearly who has 2. There are scales of allergy from anaphylactic which is super dangerous to a bit of an itch/sneeze. I have asthma and cats make me wheeze and scratch my skin, watery eyes etc but a lifetime of an allergy means you know what will help to manage unless so extreme/anaphylaxis means you must avoid at all costs. Smells are everywhere and part of life, there are ways to cope with them. Having read all your replies to comments you don’t really want to deal with any of your issues. Many have suggested help for your phobia which you seem resistant to and don’t accept that you could have passed this to your child - one of your children could easily be more attuned to your reactions and attitudes than the other. Phobias aren’t something anyone is born with and shouldn’t be let slide in children when they can be dealt with. You are allowing it that they will also spend their life limiting or tailoring their activities. From the tone of all your replies you didn’t want to hear any suggestions to help just agreement that it was unreasonable that your husbands family want to spend a Christmas with him. It is unreasonable that they won’t come to you even for Boxing Day but very reasonable that they would want to spend Christmas with him and his family.

Where do you think the OP is making excuses. You’re banging on about the phobia, and not addressing the issue of, from what the OP has said, is a pretty severe allergy. And why should she accept that it is she who has passed on her ‘phobia’ to her child, who also has an allergy ? For some, the allergy is so severe that it can trigger the fear at an early age, which is what appears to have happened to the OP. you’re minimising what’s happening here, and actually blaming the OP.

Littlegoth · 16/12/2023 11:01

Moveoverdarlin · 16/12/2023 09:52

It’s 100 percent affecting your daily life! You haven’t been to a close relatives house in 10 years! Your DH can’t spend Christmas Day with his parents! But you seem fairly determined not to go or get help so you just have to suck it up I suppose and put up with their nagging.

Your child who is also afraid will encounter many situations in their life where they will be faced with dogs.

I can understand why your in-laws are frustrated - it’s not just your allergy, you also have a phobia, and you don’t like the smell, it’s pretty resolute you’re not going, so not sure what you’re after here.

The allergy is enough though, given that’s the bit that could make her dead.

Bbm18 · 16/12/2023 10:58

Absolutely not unreasonable!

I think ab important thing to remember here is no one should be forced to go somewhere, regardless if the reasons! The OPS reasons are health related and perfectly reasonable in itself. But if she just didn’t want to go, that would be ok too! It’s her Christmas too, it’s her child’s Christmas too, they would like to do what they would like to do! Why is there something wrong with that! Made worse by the fact that’s no compromise, I’d dig my heels in as far as possible!

daisychain01 · 16/12/2023 10:56

Onesidedagain · 16/12/2023 10:40

I do recognise I have a real issue and it’s not just an allergy issue it’s more. I have tried really hard to compromise over the years with MIL but the bottom line is she wants everyone there or at the very least Dh there for actual Christmas Day

Well, then it's up to your DH to decide if he wants to be there with his wider family on Christmas Day. It's pointless you getting involved.

If his DM is so incapable of compromise and won't accept having her son round on Boxing Day then there is nothing more you can contribute to the conversation., you'll be tying yourself in knots. She's obviously not prepared to have an adult discussion.

wronginalltherightways · 16/12/2023 10:55

YANBU

They are choosing their extended family dogs over seeing OP and her family on Christmas Day.

It really is that simple.

OP cannot be in a room with dogs. People who don't have severe phobias don't seem to understand that. And her allergies and like-child compound the situation.

They could pop round on the day themselves, as OP has invited them.
Or they could leave their own dogs at home and the dog that lives there could be put in a room or sent to one of the other houses for a few hours.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/12/2023 10:55

TheFlis · 16/12/2023 10:05

But what do you expect them to do with their dogs while you host? They can’t leave them at home all day and dog sitters over Christmas usually have to be booked months and months in advance.

But if this has been going on for ten years, surely if the in laws were serious about finding a solution, they’ve had plenty of opportunity to book those dog sitters well in advance ? Or come to a compromise that doesn’t involve the OP being distressed by their presence.

Sartre · 16/12/2023 10:54

YANBU. Weird they’ve asked every year for a decade and still don’t realise you’re allergic to dogs so can’t visit their house because they have a dog. It’s like knowing someone has a peanut allergy but still offering them a peanut butter sandwich every day for 10 years.

Popwentmybrain · 16/12/2023 10:54

Go or don’t go it’s up to you. But just admit to them you don’t want to and don’t make excuses. 10 years not having Christmas with my family would be very upsetting to me and them. You don’t have to agree to the whole time. I am allergic to cats but still go to visit a family member I love dearly who has 2. There are scales of allergy from anaphylactic which is super dangerous to a bit of an itch/sneeze. I have asthma and cats make me wheeze and scratch my skin, watery eyes etc but a lifetime of an allergy means you know what will help to manage unless so extreme/anaphylaxis means you must avoid at all costs. Smells are everywhere and part of life, there are ways to cope with them. Having read all your replies to comments you don’t really want to deal with any of your issues. Many have suggested help for your phobia which you seem resistant to and don’t accept that you could have passed this to your child - one of your children could easily be more attuned to your reactions and attitudes than the other. Phobias aren’t something anyone is born with and shouldn’t be let slide in children when they can be dealt with. You are allowing it that they will also spend their life limiting or tailoring their activities. From the tone of all your replies you didn’t want to hear any suggestions to help just agreement that it was unreasonable that your husbands family want to spend a Christmas with him. It is unreasonable that they won’t come to you even for Boxing Day but very reasonable that they would want to spend Christmas with him and his family.

Rosscameasdoody · 16/12/2023 10:52

Crumblecakes · 15/12/2023 11:42

I think maybe you can take some anti-allergy tablets and go? 10 years is a long time to not see his family on Christmas, I’m sure they will keep the dogs at bay if you ask. Would you not want to see your family on Xmas day for 10 years?
If not your husband can pop over for and hour or 2

Allergy tablets don’t work for everyone and they can cause drowsiness and other side effects. And they won’t help with the fear of the dogs. It’s not as though the OP and her DH haven’t suggested other solutions, but the family seem to be coming from an all or nothing position, which isn’t helpful. There should be a compromise somewhere in between I think.

Pipsquiggle · 16/12/2023 10:49

Every time your DH has been asked about coming round at Christmas, does he say.

'No we cannot go into any house with dogs in it. My DW & DC are allergic'

CruCru · 16/12/2023 10:48

I've read the OP's posts and some (but not all) of the other posts.

Honestly, the assumption that anyone who is allergic / doesn't like dogs needs to "get over it" is a UK thing. Not wanting to spend time near someone's dog is not like refusing to hang out with one of their children.

I like dogs but my Dad (who is now dead) hated them. I don't think it was a phobia - he just couldn't understand why anyone would have such a creature living in their house.

Onesidedagain · 16/12/2023 10:40

I do recognise I have a real issue and it’s not just an allergy issue it’s more. I have tried really hard to compromise over the years with MIL but the bottom line is she wants everyone there or at the very least Dh there for actual Christmas Day

OP posts:
Onesidedagain · 16/12/2023 10:39

As a child I was on daily antihistamines and had really bad asthma issues , in the end some of the pets were rehomed to other family members and plans to get more when older ones passed were forgotten as I just couldn’t cope. I even had issues at school as sat next to a boy and I would keep vomiting and getting sent home - it was the smell of dog - we found out he had 3 dogs at home and I was just having a reaction to the strong smell from sitting next to him ! So it’s a real problem in multiple areas for me

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread