Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a really odd way to do gifts

114 replies

itsgoodtobehome · 15/12/2023 11:04

DH's family's way of doing Christmas gifts goes something like this:
He has a conversation with, say his brother (but can equally apply to anyone in his family). He'll ask what he wants for Christmas. Brother will say, "oh, I bought myself a new cycling jacket a couple of weeks ago, you can get me that. It was £xx." Then he will ask DH what he wants, and DH will give a similar response with a similar monetary value. So in their minds, they have sorted out each others Christmas presents without any money or gifts having actually changed hands. This routine is then repeated with every other member of the family.

IABU to find this bizarre? In my family, we actually go out and buy each other gifts, wrap them and hand them over.

YANBU - this is a very odd way to do things
YABU - this is actually very efficient, saves a lot of hassle, and ends up with the same end result

OP posts:
penjil · 16/12/2023 02:10

CuriousityKilledThePussy · 15/12/2023 11:43

If no money changes hands then they aren't even paying for it? So not actually buying them anything at all. Weird.
I do similar, like "I just got this if you want to buy it from me" kind of thing, but not actually paying for anything is not buying a gift surely?

Of course it is. It's just how you look at it. 😁

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 16/12/2023 01:49

@mondaytosunday think of it this way instead…

  1. the other person HAS got exactly what they want.
  2. you get the joy of knowing that they have got exactly what they want.
  3. you given them the gift of not having to use something they don’t want.
  4. no one has to be embarrassed trying to find a receipt for it to be returned. Or having to find a charity shop willing to take it.
  5. no one finds their gift ending up in a charity shop.
  6. no one has to waste precious time thinking and searching for a specific gift especially not for the awkward person who seemingly never has a hobby and so only gets socks.
  7. no one spends more than their budget allows. In fact you can buy nothing at all if that’s what you want and pay your electric bill instead!
  8. no wasted wrapping paper ending up in the bin or in the tiny recycling bag which then empties itself all over the road on bin day. Creating mess for everyone as the council no longer sweep the roads after the bin lorry.
  9. you aren’t ashamed or embarrassed that you can’t afford to gift something the recipient wants, so end up gifting something no one wants/likes.
  10. no one has to have something they don’t want in their house, for fear of offending someone.
  11. no stress all round, everyone gets and enjoys what they have.

could probably think of lots more reasons .. like no one person gets stuck with buying the gifts for everyone else in the household and beyond (usually the female) but bed is calling!

mondaytosunday · 16/12/2023 01:31

Yes it's odd as where's the pleasure of finding just the right gift and seeing the joy on their faces when they open it?

SD1978 · 16/12/2023 00:46

Everyone gets exactly what they want, and they don't care about having something to open. Works for them.

mumda · 16/12/2023 00:36

Brilliant.

I like to try and buy something just from me but everything else is pre agreed.

MIL always buys things. Which is why we're having a clear out of an unused chocolate fountain that's been in the loft ten years.

Backfromhols · 16/12/2023 00:27

No, it works for them, just go with the flow!

Chimpandcheese · 15/12/2023 16:33

Most of my relatives and I came to agree that it was all getting a bit silly and pointless - we’d got to a similar stage of swapping identical vouchers and giving each other the money for something we bought ourselves. So we now just buy for our own adult kids and the children in the family (up to age 18, by mutual agreement). I think gift giving, especially at Christmas, has got really out of hand, and this works for us. I do like to make more of birthdays though, and tend to do things like taking someone out for lunch, a spa day, theatre, or just flowers or nice chocolates etc depending on budget. I always appreciate it when somebody organises something for me and I can share it with someone else.

Lastexmouse · 15/12/2023 16:03

Agree its a bit bizarre. With DHs family there are a few ppl we never see - but still get presents for their DCs.. and to save the effort of actually swapping presents we agree to buy our DCs a present from them (the family we don't see) up to a certain value .

With my sibling I'll say get us a book by a certain author , or perfume, or get a bathroom set. So there's an element of surprise.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/12/2023 15:54

It's no more odd than people sending each other links saying 'buy me this for Christmas', hinting and hoping people pick up and act on the hint or (usually) wives buying their own Christmas presents then giving them to their DHs to wrap up and mentally tick off 'buy lovely gift for DW' off their to do list with no thought or effort required.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 15/12/2023 15:06

pinkspeakers · 15/12/2023 14:36

I guess it is just acknowledging that for some adults, exchanging Xmas presents makes no sense and everyone is happier not bothering! And making a bit of a joke out of it...

This is spot on. Plus it saves any embarrassment when someone just doesn’t have the money to spare.

phoenixrosehere · 15/12/2023 15:03

Meh. As long as they’re happy. Not sure why it bothers some, that people do gift-giving for Christmas different than them.

Ineedanewsofa · 15/12/2023 14:54

This is me and my DSis - she will ask what DC want for Xmas and at the same time ask “and what have I bought for you?” At which point I’ll say she’s contributed to XYZ thing that I want and she’ll tell me what I’ve bought for her. The conversation usually ends with one of us proclaiming how generous we are 🤣 we refer to it as the Sheldon method and it’s worked for us for years!

pinkspeakers · 15/12/2023 14:36

I guess it is just acknowledging that for some adults, exchanging Xmas presents makes no sense and everyone is happier not bothering! And making a bit of a joke out of it...

BodyKeepingScore · 15/12/2023 14:21

PuttingDownRoots · 15/12/2023 11:31

DH and I do this with each other. However they get given to the giver to wrap and return.

It sounds joyless but its easier than him tracking down odd books etc and me going to outdoor shops or looking at motorbike gear when I barely know one end of the bike from the other.

So you go out and choose your present, then give it to your OH to wrap and then he gives it back to you? What's the point of even wrapping them?

divinededacende · 15/12/2023 14:16

I'm confused, so the brother says "I bought this, you can get me that, it cost his much" and then NO money actually changes hands?

If so, that's a bit weird, what's the point in the conversation?

If your husband does give him the money for it then fair enough. It's still a bit odd but being odd doesn't matter as long as everyone involved comes away happy. Some people just aren't arsed with giving or receiving gifts. It sounds like the accept the social construct of gift giving but have developed their own way of avoiding the work that goes with it. Fair enough.

I love picking presents for people and I'm good at it. My DP is absolutely terrible at it so I have to just give him a list to buy from which means I haven't had a surprise in the last 5 years. Well, I have, sometimes he goes rogue and it ends up with me winning an Oscar for best fake gratitude for a jigsaw... Anyway, my point is, last year I wanted to buy a PS5 in November-ish and I ended up just letting my DP half in for it. I still got a couple of books to open up (from my list) at Christmas but it just made more sense at the time.

HallieRaspberry · 15/12/2023 13:53

Lol my family is the same. My parents ask me to buy what me and my DH want for Xmas, get it delivered to their house and my Mum wraps it and bank transfers me the money (minus the value of anything they bought that I have been told I can gift to them). The only surprise is experienced by my Dad on Xmas day who, like everyone else knows what he is getting, but has no idea what he has supposedly bought anyone else. I find it kind of funny but my friend is horrified by the whole concept.

pastypirate · 15/12/2023 13:50

I think it's great - I have told dp in no uncertain terms that no items should enter the house this year unless they have been requested.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 15/12/2023 13:43

Beyond a bit of wrapping paper, is it really that different to what a lot of people do which is send a link to the specific thing they want, the person buys it, and it gets handed over with no surprise involved at all?

tattygrl · 15/12/2023 13:29

So they're really just identifying items they've each respectively bought that cost roughly the same and assigning them as gifts from the other person, without exchanging money or any items? Very odd to me but as others have said nothing objectively wrong with it. Just seems like there's no point to it 😂

TheChristmasElfCanGoNow · 15/12/2023 12:58

My husband likes this and over the years I have even wrapped it so I have something to unwrap Christmas morning mortally I would like to unwrap a surprise (if the contents was something I wanted). Each to their own.

MechyMagic · 15/12/2023 12:51

I'm going with everyone is unreasonable- it is weird but I like it! 🤣

auburnglow788 · 15/12/2023 12:46

I'm assuming there's a ceiling to what each other is expected to spend?

RaininSummer · 15/12/2023 12:44

Joyless and transactional but if they are all happy no problem. I enjoy choosing gifts for my family and surprises are nice normally.

Sproutier · 15/12/2023 12:44

user1486915549 · 15/12/2023 11:55

My mum banned buying Christmas presents in our large family many years ago. We each buy ourselves something we really wanted and tell the others what we got. Win win.

I like this a lot!

In my head, saying no presents is each receiver giving a little gift of time, effort and money "back" to the giver. It's a nice thing if you want it to be. OP your partner's family is doing a similar sort of thing, albeit in a bit of a convoluted way.

caringcarer · 15/12/2023 12:40

CurlewKate · 15/12/2023 11:16

I was completely thrown when I joined dp's family by two main things. They showed how much they loved each other by asking about their cars. And if you said "what would you like for Christmas?" they told you. Including the shop (this was pre Amazon) and how much it was.

My DH and his brother have these car conversations. I found it baffling tbh but now I see it's not just him then.