Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a really odd way to do gifts

114 replies

itsgoodtobehome · 15/12/2023 11:04

DH's family's way of doing Christmas gifts goes something like this:
He has a conversation with, say his brother (but can equally apply to anyone in his family). He'll ask what he wants for Christmas. Brother will say, "oh, I bought myself a new cycling jacket a couple of weeks ago, you can get me that. It was £xx." Then he will ask DH what he wants, and DH will give a similar response with a similar monetary value. So in their minds, they have sorted out each others Christmas presents without any money or gifts having actually changed hands. This routine is then repeated with every other member of the family.

IABU to find this bizarre? In my family, we actually go out and buy each other gifts, wrap them and hand them over.

YANBU - this is a very odd way to do things
YABU - this is actually very efficient, saves a lot of hassle, and ends up with the same end result

OP posts:
DottyLottieLou · 16/12/2023 08:01

Me and my sister have a similar arrangement for birthdays. She will buy herself the latest SK book for her birthday and I will do the same for mine. (We don't live near each other) Its tradition 😄

Gizlotsmum · 16/12/2023 07:58

I can absolutely see the logic of this, especially for adults. They get exactly what they want and it’s much easier. Makes it a bit joyless and not fun but if they don’t see each other for Christmas I can sort of get it.

PurpleFlower1983 · 16/12/2023 07:57

It’s much less wasteful and sounds so easy!

BarbaraofSeville · 16/12/2023 07:54

geckofrog · 16/12/2023 07:38

I understand it but it does seem to take the joy out of Christmas day unless they wrap up the item?!

Only if 'unwrapping stuff on Christmas day' is something that gives you joy. To me, it seems completely pointless if you already know what the item is.

To me, the joy of Christmas day is a nice dinner with family, games, a walk, TV and noticing that daylight has started to get longer again.

Presents I can take or leave. I rarely want anything and if I do, I just buy it. The chances of someone else randomly choosing something that I like and it being 'right' is extremely low.

Tohaveandtohold · 16/12/2023 07:54

DH’s family do a secret Santa as well for the adults but with a twist. SIL creates one of these secret Santa websites and gives a maximum price the gifts that’ll be shown and the shops are within a budget. Everyone goes on it and select 2 items as their wish list of what they’ll like for Christmas.
The website gives everyone a name at the end of November and we buy an item from the wish list. The surprise is what they’ll get you from your wish list and who is buying foR you. Christmas is then cheap for everyone and straightforward. We also don’t get together often at Christmas because we live in different countries and this way, everyone still gets a gift from a shop that’s local to them and gets delivered to them.
No one is obligated to buy for kids either as there are currently 4 grandchildren and 3 of them are ours but the grandparents do. Again what they do is give us the money and we buy the gifts and wrap (from them). That way, the children gets what they want as well.

catsanddogsandrabbits · 16/12/2023 07:53

We do similar and have done for years. It's joyful because I'm not spending today for example - the Saturday before Christmas - frantically searching shops, exhausted, for a XYX computer game, a size XS long-sleeved nightshirt in green or blue, (no writing or slogans), a Bosch two-speed multi tool, a small bottle of a perfume "she might like". Etc. I'm not agonising over this one or that one (and actually she/ he / they like neither).

I'm going to have a lovely time with my family today - Christmas joy! No pressure - just a lovely time doing the tree, pre-prepping some Christmas food for the freezer.

And no sinking hearts on Christmas day when in spite of their "How lovely!" you know that it just isn't. And when you open the gloves/ perfume/ airfryer you know you're going to have to live with something that isn't really what you wanted. Almost - but not.

Now we give ourselves license to spend on ourselves and we put a tiny treat under the tree for Christmas morning, (chocolate, crisps, pot of jam type of thing).

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 16/12/2023 07:52

I absolutely hate this idea. But then I don't get the angst about Christmas present buying. It's always pretty unproblematic in my family. Everyone provides a bit of a wish list, with enough room for a bit of personal choice from the giver. Everyone has nice presents, that they actually want, to open on Christmas Day. If it's just a financial transaction, what's the point?

AddieLoggins2 · 16/12/2023 07:45

I do this with a couple of relatives. But I make a rule for myself that I can't use the item until after Christmas (no idea if they do the same). That way the joy is that I have my new thing.

My parents have a systems where they each buy themselves a gift and wrap it, but they don't tell the other what they bought. The surprise on Christmas morning is finding out what they bought for the other person Xmas Grin

geckofrog · 16/12/2023 07:38

I understand it but it does seem to take the joy out of Christmas day unless they wrap up the item?!

nottaotter · 16/12/2023 07:37

Sounds a bit odd, but if it works for them then its a great idea! My sisters and I ask each what we would like, I got my older DS a Kerastase hair mask and my other a set of wine glasses .
I like to buy stuff that is going to be actually be used, if I ever buy blindly for them I always say I don't mind if they re gift.

wideawakeinthemiddleofthenightagain · 16/12/2023 07:32

We increasingly do this. It means you get exactly what you want rather than almost what you want. It saves the disappointment of those years when someone has picked up on your hints of the item you'd like but gets it in a different colour/scent/flavour to what you were dreaming of. This applies to everything from fancy pants bath oil to Lindt balls! Take my mum this year who wants a camera bag. Well that's easy to sort but what colour does she want? Black or navy would be safe but does she want something a bit more fun? If she'd told me the exact item or just bought it herself, it would save me the worry of whether she'll like it, her being too polite to say she'll swap it for a different colour but would have cost the exact same amount. For the family members we don't see at Christmas, we don't bother with gifts at all but just upgrade the experience when we do meet up - go to a slightly fancier restaurant than we might otherwise or something like that.

Ambi · 16/12/2023 07:29

I truly love this idea. Gift giving is an absolute minefield. See MN Xmas Day afternoon and boxing day threads of hurt, sadness and anger over receiving terrible gifts from loved ones.

Me personally, I've gotten very fussy in my old age and hate receiving gifts that aren't right and feel it is a waste of money for the giver and confirms that they don't actually know me at all. I'm polite enough to thank the giver but it is incredibly rare that I have been given something I want and cherish. I used to spend ages finding the right gift for my loved ones and felt it wasn't reciprocated so now everyone gets a big box of chocolates.

Makkacakka · 16/12/2023 07:19

That's how it ended up between us siblings. As adults you buy what you want already. We got fed up of exchanging like that. My uncle will buy himself something, then give it to me to wrap! We have now stopped adult presents for this reason. Now the children get the gifts (we still buy uncle's because he gets for our child).

GarlicMaybeNot · 16/12/2023 07:19

How about just buy what you want for yourself ? You can redirect the money towards something you want and so can everyone else.

But that is EXACTLY what they're doing!

I think it's rather sweet.

JustOneMoreBaileys · 16/12/2023 07:00

They showed how much they loved each other by asking about their cars.

In my family many of the older men do this. Eg my uncle, who is a kind, sensitive thoughtful man who will - happily - talk for hours about your mental health or relationship worries. Always starts the conversation with 'how are you finding that Tiguan?'

Holidayhell22 · 16/12/2023 06:44

A relative if mine has sone this. Gone out and bought several things that they want and then said pick what you want to give me.
I’d still like to wrap the gifts rather than just transfer them the cash if that makes sense.
I always ask them for a link to what they would like as if I just guessed it probably wouldn’t be right.
My ex in-laws never, ever bought gifts we wanted. It was frustrating. So much waste. I would say to dh tell them the children would order X, Y or Z or preferably money towards X as they are older now. No it never happened they bought random stuff which ended up unused, unwanted or given to charity.

Passingthethyme · 16/12/2023 06:29

mondaytosunday · 16/12/2023 01:31

Yes it's odd as where's the pleasure of finding just the right gift and seeing the joy on their faces when they open it?

This is true, although I think most people don't give or get gifts like this

terraced · 16/12/2023 06:23

It would work for me.

rickyrickygrimes · 16/12/2023 05:53

I don’t like ‘surprises gifts at all. So this would suit me just fine.. we aren’t quite there but we do always find out what the person wants and buy exactly that. Can’t bear the waste of the 50 million unwanted ‘magical surprises ’ that are down the charity shop, cluttering up a cupboard or heading to landfill by the time the tree comes down.

BarbaraofSeville · 16/12/2023 05:39

mondaytosunday · 16/12/2023 01:31

Yes it's odd as where's the pleasure of finding just the right gift and seeing the joy on their faces when they open it?

Lots of people find no joy in having to think of what could be the right gift and a lot of the joy is fake anyway.

Inside they're thinking it's the wrong model, colour or design and now they have to use, wear or look at it until it breaks or wears out, whether they can get away with donating, exchanging, regifting or selling it or it'll be cluttering their house up interspersed with getting it out to continue the pretence of liking it every time they're in the company of the person who gave it to them.

It makes no sense for adults with their own money to exchange gifts except perhaps token consumables between partners or very close relatives if it's wanted.

Otherwise, if people want to enjoy the experience of 'having something to open in company' then everyone should buy themselves a gift, wrap it, and then open it together where they can still talk about it, show it off to everyone else and see what others have bought. Everyone gets a gift they want, within their own budget and no time, money or resources wasted.

Gowlett · 16/12/2023 03:41

We do this! Plus maybe an added surprise.

Passingthethyme · 16/12/2023 03:23

Weird, but kind of genius

Pertinentowl · 16/12/2023 02:58

That’s the most brilliant idea I have ever heard

FrozenGhost · 16/12/2023 02:57

You're over thinking it a bit OP. In other words they've agreed not to do gifts, and like to make a little joke about that by having that verbal exchange. They don't go away from the conversation seriously thinking "great, so happy with the present sis/bro got for me".

penjil · 16/12/2023 02:11

mondaytosunday · 16/12/2023 01:31

Yes it's odd as where's the pleasure of finding just the right gift and seeing the joy on their faces when they open it?

They obviously don't find pleasure and joy in that kind of thing.