Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how on earth to raise a child bilingual?

248 replies

EstherE · 15/12/2023 10:58

DH is from country X, I am English and we live in England. DH’s family only speak their language, my family only speak English. I speak X language but not perfectly fluently. We want to move back to X, but it won’t be for ten years or more.

How can we raise our child to be bilingual so they can communicate with their paternal family integrate when we move back? I don’t know anyone who’s done it successfully, and we can’t send our child to an X language school as they’re only in London, or boarding schools.

OP posts:
Tandora · 17/12/2023 21:21

ClareBlue · 17/12/2023 21:15

This is an interesting thread. Never been in the situation, but what effect does not responding to children's needs unless they use a specific language have on them. So everywhere they communicate in one language including with their dad, but with their mother they get nothing unless they use a different method of communicating.
How does that work for communication beyond just learning language.
I'm interested because we have family doing Irish/English this way. They have Irish at school though and seem to talk to friends in both languages.

I’ve never heard of that method. Seems a bit punitive to me? 🤔

TheWayTheLightFalls · 17/12/2023 21:18

This is an interesting thread. Never been in the situation, but what effect does not responding to children's needs unless they use a specific language have on them.

Maybe you mean something else but - it teaches them that they need to verbalise their wants in x language in order to communicate.

reluctantbrit · 17/12/2023 21:17

German here but DD was born here and her main lanuage is English.

We speak 95% German at home, the only difference is when it comes to school work and when we have friends over.
She was in nursery 4 days/week from 9 months onwards.

In younger years, TV was mainly German, as were books/audiobooks and music (nursery rhyme/toddler music).

She alwys understood 100% but replied in English.

She is now 16, can speak, write and read German. Got an 8 in GCSE as an additional exam. Has proper conversations with her grandparents and other family when we are visiting. She has spent twice a week alone in the Summer holidays in a riding camp.

We went to farm stay holidays when she was younger so she had to speak German with other children too young to learn English in school. On holiday she went to German speaking kid clubs.

So bascially, lots of exposure and constant practice. Don't get discouraged when English comes in. Speak X's language at home (good practice for you as well), holidays and children TV/books to get your child's passive learning up.

ClareBlue · 17/12/2023 21:15

This is an interesting thread. Never been in the situation, but what effect does not responding to children's needs unless they use a specific language have on them. So everywhere they communicate in one language including with their dad, but with their mother they get nothing unless they use a different method of communicating.
How does that work for communication beyond just learning language.
I'm interested because we have family doing Irish/English this way. They have Irish at school though and seem to talk to friends in both languages.

beanontoast · 17/12/2023 21:11

I’m so envious of all your languages. I really wish I could speak another language. Some very lucky kids about

QueSyrahSyrah · 17/12/2023 21:10

My friends have totally bilingual English / Romanian children. Mum speaks to them only in Romanian, Dad only in English.

It does help that both parents are fluent in both languages.

JLou08 · 17/12/2023 21:09

Use mainly x language in the home (you and DH talk to each other in this language around baby from early age) and English outside the home. I've not done it myself but I work with children and a lot of Eastern European children I worked with did it this way and were fluent in both languages from an early age.

Montegufoni2017 · 17/12/2023 21:00

Don’t make either the ‘second language’ you speak English, husband speaks X. Consistently, all the time, everyday and make it completely habitual.

Tandora · 17/12/2023 20:49

Trickedbyadoughnut · 15/12/2023 12:43

I started a thesis on bilingualism (has to stop because of finances) and it's very common for children to refuse to speak one parent's language, up to adolescence and even adulthood. All language learned in childhood is actually stored in the same place in the brain and can therefore be recalled much more easily at a future point, even when not practised.

Whereas once we get to adolescence, we start storing new languages in a different part of the brain, making acquisition much more difficult. It's impossible to say at 4 or 5 that the bilingual education has "failed" (and, in fact, it almost certainly hasn't).

This is exactly it! It only genuinely fails where the parent becomes discouraged (because the child only responds in - say- English), and gives up. In my view it can also create problems if you push it too hard by insisting they reply in a particular language when they are still little.

beanontoast · 17/12/2023 20:42

Tandora · 17/12/2023 20:40

I voted YABu because OP seemed to be panicking that this was hard, but it’s really not. I know loads of people who grew up bi or even tri lingual. My kids are bilingual.
you just need each parent to speak their native language and not worry too much - especially when they are young - about what they speak when they reply . Just stick with it and they will learn.

Fair enough, thought it seemed harsh as OP was asking for advice and obviously really values the second language/has learnt it herself etc

KnittingKnewbie · 17/12/2023 20:41

A family member lived in a different country, let's say France. She spoke to her DC in her (imperfect) French, not in English which was her native tongue. Father not in the picture. The DC grew up speaking poor French and poor English as neither language was taught correctly at home. By taught I mean "used"

Tandora · 17/12/2023 20:40

beanontoast · 17/12/2023 20:26

Would love to know why anyone has voted you’re being unreasonable here

I voted YABu because OP seemed to be panicking that this was hard, but it’s really not. I know loads of people who grew up bi or even tri lingual. My kids are bilingual.
you just need each parent to speak their native language and not worry too much - especially when they are young - about what they speak when they reply . Just stick with it and they will learn.

LMBK · 17/12/2023 20:36

I must say thay I disagree that it doesn't work being a bilingual child growing up where each parent speaks their own! We did have yearly visits to France however which helped! We wereencouraged to watch TV programmes and films in French and my papa read us French bedtime stories. But as a teacher where most of my class don't have English as a first language and parents from different countries there are many children succeeding to be trilingual.

Tandora · 17/12/2023 20:35

EstherE · 15/12/2023 11:28

Our friends’ children do understand the other language but will only ever reply in English. Though this is better than not understanding it at all, they’re completely unconfident in speaking and can’t/won’t communicate with family in the other language, so I (and their parents!) don’t count it as being successful.

I know a lot of it will come down to the personality of the child but I want to set patterns as early as possible, especially as we plan to move there whilst the child is still young.

How old are the children though?
I think it’s normal that they would reply in English, but if they understand the other language this is what is important and over time they will start to speak it, especially if you move.

Personally I think it’s easy. My children are bilingual. Just make sure your DH speaks his language.

Sophie89j · 17/12/2023 20:29

I speak welsh to our 19 month old, have done since baby and he understands both English and Welsh. I’m not fluent but at least he learns the basics with me and then can learn more fluent when school age.

beanontoast · 17/12/2023 20:26

Would love to know why anyone has voted you’re being unreasonable here

Silverfoxlady · 17/12/2023 20:21

I also failed to teach my children in my mother tongue, I remember trying when they were babies and they would give me the oddest looks, it was a little of an effort as well because I have forgotten a lot of the language. So sad really.

What I would mention, that working within a preschool setting it can be really daunting for children who don’t understand English to be put in the setting. I feel sorry for them, because they are surrounded by adults and children that are not making any sense while struggling with settling in. We try using their own language by having key words but sometimes the way we pronounce words just leaves them baffled, I feel like I am butchering their language!

On the positive side, once they reach primary school age most children seem to catch up and do pretty well. So it is just the initial shock of going to preschool and making friends is quite difficult when they are the only ones speaking their language. Maybe looking into an international school would be the way forward, as someone mentioned they did.

Maybe87 · 17/12/2023 20:09

I’m in the same situation OP and I have been told the solution is to be persistent. If the child responds in English to DH then he should say “I cannot understand, speak to me in X language”. It worked for a family that I know that dad is Greek, mum is Polish and child has been raised in London so he speaks English as well. Another thing you can try is find a childminder that speaks the language and spend time with the DC for a few hours a week

Starterlocs · 17/12/2023 19:56

From direct personal experience, we grew up in a bilingual household. Similar OPOL but to a lesser extent. We watched some TV in the second language but attended school speaking in our mother tongue.

We then moved to another country where we had to speak the second language. By the end of the summer we had both picked up our second language sufficiently to both speak and start writing in it. Age approx 7 & 9. The problem then became staying in touch with our mother tongue - I took classes in mine in secondary and these were a breeze for me. My younger DS did not and as a result the fluency and confidence is a lot lower.

I'd point out that I don't particularly enjoy reading in my mother tongue, nor would I be able to do formal business in it, but it is perfectly adequate for day to day, reading the newspapers, travelling etc.

I'm following with interest because OPOL is not working here as neither my DH or I speak each other's mother tongues, or speak consistently to our child in those languages. I probably do it more than DH does but it is very superficial.

greengirlgang · 17/12/2023 19:55

At school they will always speak English. They will also do so with most friends.

Advice: At home always speak x language and over the weekends spend time with people from x country who speak the language and have a community of people that speak x language that also have children DC can play with - who invite you to parties and events etc (you know weddings, play dates, the odd theme park trip). If you can afford to holidays at x country at least once a year.

The main thing is for DC to hear the language or speak the language on a regular basis.

This is coming from someone that grew up bilingual.

ThisIsntThe80sPat · 17/12/2023 19:44

I'm am english speaker, DH is German. We live in Germany. I only speak English, DH only speaks German. Our eldest is 3 and can speak both really well.

AlbatrosStrike · 17/12/2023 19:36

You should both speak X language to the child (or as much as you can, OP if you’re not fluent).

Your DC will pick up English from nursery/play groups/school/ other relatives very fast anyway. I know families where neither parent is a native English speaker and the children speak English perfectly even though it’s never spoken at home, so that is not a worry. Just focus on language X.

Shieldmaiden01 · 17/12/2023 19:26

We've managed to do this successfully with our children. DH only speaks with them in his language (since they were born). He also gives them lessons from the curriculum in his country and we watch a lot of TV from there. I have a high level in the language but mainly speak with them in English. All children fluent in both languages.

Dependabledentures · 17/12/2023 19:11

In my experience its harder when. Its the man who is the non native speaker to get it sorted in early years as they don't do as much of the language development to make them fully bilingual by 5. They said lots of things help us. Eg if it'd fren h
Access to French nursery groups in that language is best but if not that, then an intro group ie French lessons for English toddlers .
Disney plus in French
French friends to hang out with so its normal to hang out in French-
If you cant find that then lots of interactive zooming with relatives
Both speak French at home as much as possible.
Just keep doing it through them refusing. We get a lot of stop speakiing French mummy. I just carry on.

It's not perfect he won't speak sentences but understands a lot. We start Saturday school soon age 4 so helping this helps and lots of trips to dad's family.

Justanothermum42 · 17/12/2023 19:10

Bilingual family here. You both speak X language at home. Nursery, school etc will be English. Kids will have no problems swapping from one to other. One thing to bear in mind - they may start speaking a bit later than usual because they need more time processing both languages. But it’s the best thing ever. Both of mine speak, read and write in another language and spend long time there is summers. It helps them with Spanish and French in school (my native language has nothing to do with with French or Spanish. ) Hubby does not speak my language either, but the fact that I speak to them ALL TGE TIME makes all the difference. Good luck x

Swipe left for the next trending thread