Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have discharged myself from A&E?

189 replies

AandEnightmare · 15/12/2023 07:03

As the username suggests…

I attended A&E with numbness is my hand, pins and needles in both arms and legs, blurred vision and extreme stuff neck pain.

Stroke nurse was happy it wasn’t a stroke but wanted an MRI as did A&E consultant.

Both concerned about MS and tragically I then urinated myself in the A&E waiting room where I was left on a wooden chair for 8 hours.

i asked for a change of clothes, just a hospital gown and was told until I was seen by a neurologist who agreed to book me in; this wasn’t possible.

I have long covid and extreme fatigue and pain at the best of times and I was in tears in the waiting room crippled in pain and exhaustion and was just told repeatedly that only a neurologist could determine if an MRI was needed as an emergency or as an outpatient and on the time of leaving, after 7 hours, I was number 13 on the list so expected to be seen by this evening.

I will ring my GP as soon as open but I’ve never had such a terrible experience in a hospital in my life!

i feel shocked

OP posts:
CHRIS003 · 15/12/2023 10:18

You wouldn't get an MRI scan done as an emergency during the night - a Ct scan yes - are you sure it wasn't a ct scan you were promised ?

Sparklfairy · 15/12/2023 10:13

The state of the NHS now, we accept the wait even if we're not happy about it.

What you must not accept is being left in your own urine. It would have taken nothing for them to let you change into a hospital gown. That is so so awful, I'm so sorry.

It's humiliating and inhumane and absolutely warrants a complaint. There's no excuse, I don't care how rushed off their feet the nurses were. To chuck you a gown and show you where the loos were to clean yourself up isn't exactly asking for the moon on a stick.

Axlcat · 15/12/2023 10:09

On the question of MS. These can be symptoms of a relapse yes. But I imagine could also be many other things too. IF it is MS it is important to diagnose asap - someone up thread said that it’s a slow progression but actually the sooner diagnosis and access to medication, the better prospect of delaying progression. I would suggest going through your GP and requesting an urgent MRI.

comfyoldcardi · 15/12/2023 10:05

Gp should do urgent referral to neurologist. That is if you can get near a gp.

Dagbonunion · 15/12/2023 10:02

How old are you?Worth seeing your GP for an urgent MRI of head and spine abd referral to Neurologist, as ED will unlikely make this referral.

LuluBlakey1 · 15/12/2023 10:02

Yet, you can decide you need an MRI, fill a form in online and pay for it and have one privately within days with no Dr involved at all.

My neighbour has just done so. Is on a waiting list for an appointment (referred by practice physio) re:hip. GP has not seen or spoken to him. Waited 6 months so far. Nothing.

Went online, private MRI ÂŁ500. Slots available at our local hospital. Filled in form - gave reason 'hip pain'. Had MRI days later at 6pm. 3 days later report arrived. Seeing consultant (privately) to discuss results today . Whole process has taken 2 weeks.

No involvement of a Dr at all so far.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 10:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 15/12/2023 09:56

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 08:56

I am not justifying it
I hate the way patients are left for hours on end
But if the PT wets themselves in the w/room and the nurses aren't aware, what do you expect then to do?

The nursing staff should have been told by the receptionist. There should be escalation systems in place - this is basic management stuff.

And you should have responded to the OP with compassion, or not responded at all.

Perhaps you responded as you did because you are exhausted and burned out, though, and are also in need of compassion.

LakieLady · 15/12/2023 09:51

So sorry you had to go through this, OP, it was appalling.

But it's made me wonder just why A&E is so stretched these days, and whether the difficulties people experience in getting GP appointments means they end up at A&E in desperation.

There appear to be problems at the other end of the process, too. Many patients can't be discharged as soon as they're medically fit because they're awaiting social care assessments and care plans. Adult social care is also under huge pressure because of staff shortages and budget cuts, so that can take several days (although I have heard of one case taking 6 weeks, that's beyond my comprehension).

Every day that someone medically fit for discharge is occupying a bed unnecessarily, that's a bed that can't be used for someone who needs admission, and ultimately that can mean another person stuck in A&E unnecessarily. And while they are there they will need staff to monitor them, which makes inroads into the time they can spend on other patients.

None of this is actually new. A friend of mine spent 36 hours waiting on a trolley in A&E because there were no beds in 1995.

Imo, the whole process, from A&E to admission & discharge needs to be looked at.

Blushingm · 15/12/2023 09:46

CaroleSinger · 15/12/2023 08:16

Does it really take a Dr 13 hours to see one group if patients in A&E? Surely they can get through patients quicker than that? It makes you wonder what they are actually doing while everyone is sat there for hours. It creates more an image of taking all the time 8n the world rather than being run off feet. How did we get here? It wasn't that long ago you just walked in and got seen. There were no 4 or 6 hour waits.

That's only the cohort in the waiting area - they would have had resus full of very very ill patients, plus majors and minors plus corridor patient who were all possibly more ill than those in the waiting area and so would have been a priority

honeysuckleweeks · 15/12/2023 09:46

Hopefully this isn't a double post.
I am sad that the NHS has apparently broken down. Less than a decade ago I took my DS18 to Charing Cross and they could not have been kinder or quicker helping him. Within 10 minutes he was in a bed and on a drip. It is a reciprocal arrangement with Australia - so you British people would get the exact same treatment here. No cost either way. I'm surprised that things have gone down hill so fast .

Peablockfeathers · 15/12/2023 09:34

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 07:35

I don't think people realise the state of A&E at present, where I work there is a 14 hour wait to see a Dr!

You were seen by a nurse and a Dr who were happy it wasn't a stroke etc, but that an MRI was needed, I presume a a Neurologist wasn't on? Did you attend overnight? Not all specialities are covered 24hrs a day.

So it seems from this you were seen pretty quickly? Once an acute event ruled out you were then waiting for a specialist?

It is awful you were sat in a chair, but if all the cubicles were taken, where do you expect them to put you?

As for urinating yourself, agree, very humiliating, but staff don't have changes of clothes, yes a gown should have been offered etc.

This should have been highlighted to staff as it can be a sign of Cauda Eqina - which is an emergency

However if you have discharged yourself you have terminated that episode of care and you will now have to wait for your GP to refer you

Edited

I mean I work in healthcare and so understand from our side how dire things are and how everyone is doing the best they can (well, most). But it doesn't mean that we should view experiences like OPs as acceptable, its outrageous that an adult in this country who is already struggling, anxious and scared should be left humiliated and sat in urine soaked clothes for hours because computer says no. There are always gowns about, we would have found one and seen if OP was able to safely get to the toilet to get changed if nowhere else.

RudsyFarmer · 15/12/2023 09:30

My rather was left in his feaces stained clothes in hospital for hours during admittance. I kept asking if he could be helped and was constantly ignored.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 09:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mrsttcno1 · 15/12/2023 09:27

9outof10cats · 15/12/2023 09:17

So many NHS armchair critics who have no idea of the reality of working in ED.

I worked on a ward, where staff would frequently get sent to ED to work due to staff shortages. I hated it and whenever I was told I was being moved I would be filled with anxiety.

It's not as simple as saying 'just do it' and as hard as it is to imagine sometimes there is simply no time and no free staff to deal with the personal care of patients - because you have life-threatening issues to deal with which take priority.

Sitting in urine is humiliating and should not happen, but will not kill someone. Someone who has come in with breathing problems, desaturating, but combative and pulling off their oxygen mask when left unattended is and nurses have to prioritize based on clinical need.

Please, if you think you can do better go and train as a nurse and show us all how it should be done.

100% this.

I truly feel for OP and it is a true testament to the state of the NHS currently. In an ideal world, or even just in a normal world, absolutely you would hope that there patient comfort is key and that there would be enough staff to keep everyone comfortable while waiting. BUT the reality is, as this poster has said, there are much more urgent and critical issues to deal with constantly. The hospital, especially in A&E, are there to deal with the medical issues at hand and to treat the EMERGENCY. This does mean that patient comfort while waiting is the sacrifice, and while everybody is quick to complain about that, I can’t imagine anyone would choose to argue that given the choice between patient comfort & a patient emergency, patient comfort should come first. It’s a sad state of affairs, but that is where we are at.

I can sympathise having had a trip to A&E recently for a family member with pneumonia. We were sat in the waiting room for 10 hours before finally being seen, even when we were seen it was on a bed in a corridor, she needed to be admitted but we were just told there is literally no beds free on the wards- it’s uncomfortable, it’s not ideal, and it’s clear that for issues of comfort while waiting you have to look after yourself/have family look after you. The A&E staff will treat you medically, but you/your family are responsible for your comfort.

Stressfordays · 15/12/2023 09:27

The state of the NHS is awful, I left the NHS 7 years ago and went into private healthcare due to this. When I worked in ED, I'd often have a very poorly patient in one bay and need to walk through a bunch of other relatively stable patients to get to the meds cupboard. I'd have to put my head down and quickly walk past all the shouts of 'nurse!' to get my critically I'll patient what they need and run back. It was like something out of a war zone. I imagine it is much worse now.

I'm sorry you went through that OP, it's terrible. It's not safe and it's not fair.

RandomButtons · 15/12/2023 09:26

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 09:23

I love it when people say don't vote tory and have the impression under labour everything is going to be so much better that the money tree will appear, that departments will be fully staffed, it isn't going to happen no matter who is in bloody charge

The hospitals and NHS in Wales are as a whole in a way worse condition than in England.

Labour are not the golden ticket people think they are.

rorret · 15/12/2023 09:25

I am so sorry OP that is terrible.

I think you need to go back though as others have said.

Please do complain when you feel strong enough.

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 09:23

justasking111 · 15/12/2023 09:07

I agree about the urinating without realising it is very concerning you must go back to the hospital.

Wales had been labour forever our NHS is in a worse state than ever before

I love it when people say don't vote tory and have the impression under labour everything is going to be so much better that the money tree will appear, that departments will be fully staffed, it isn't going to happen no matter who is in bloody charge

SheIsStuck23 · 15/12/2023 09:22

I took my 5 year old to A&E about 6 months ago on the advice of 111 due to a 15 hour episode of persistent vomiting, lethargy and reduced urination.

I got to the Paediatric A&E at about 10pm and the waiting room was totally full. There were at least 25 infants/toddlers/children waiting to be seen and it was chaos. There were no chairs available so parents were sat on the floor with their sick child in their arms. One woman was even sitting on the floor outside the entry because there was nowhere else for her to wait.

We got triaged very quickly and my son had a low blood sugar so he was started on a dioralyte fluid challenge and we were called back into triage an hour later to have it re-checked and thankfully it had risen to more normal levels and he’d passed a little bit of urine by this point too.

The Sister told me there was an 8 hour wait to be seen and that if she were me she would just take my son home. She said all the doctors would do is give him the quick once over and send him home with a stash load of dioralyte.

She gave me a box of dioralyte from a cupboard in the triage room and said that it was my choice whether to stay or not but if not then to continue with the dioralyte at home.

I went back to the waiting room to see it was even more full and understandably I had lost my seat. It was now gone midnight and I was having to stand up whilst trying to balance my heavy 5 year old in one arm, my handbag in the other whilst trying to measure out and give dioralyte every 10 minutes. My son was exhausted and I was exhausted.

I knew I wouldn’t be able to maintain this for 8 hours and so I left.

My son was absolutely fine and by the next day it was as though he’d never been ill.

It was a horrific experience and I couldn’t believe the way the system was working.

The Sister who dealt with us was lovely and very apologetic and understanding and I’m sure she and the other nurses felt so disappointed that this was the only quality of service they were able to offer.

I’m sorry you went through something so awful OP and I agree that PALS is a good option. I hope you get to the bottom of things soon and it doesn’t turn out to be anything to worry about.

Twiglets1 · 15/12/2023 09:22

Sorry to hear your awful experience @AandEnightmare

I would have done the same thing, gone home. I have a lot of respect for the NHS and most of the people who work there. My husband works in the NHS so we totally support it. BUT I would be scared to rely on its services these days. I’m honestly thinking about taking out private healthcare insurance though I used to not believe in it. I appreciate it’s not the answer and especially in an emergency situation but the NHS is on its knees.

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 09:21

I love the way people who don't work in the NHS or in A&E all have so many ideas about how it could work far more effectively if we just did such and such, why don't you all come and work here then ????
Tell us how it could all be done so much easier

PropertyManager · 15/12/2023 09:19

I've had to hang around hospital a lot recently with elderly parents, and I noticed quite a bit of people of all ages waiting for incontinence issues to be dealt with.

I queried this with a doctor, who explained that urine is in effect sterile when it leaves the body (if no UTI of course) and as such, although smelly/uncomfortable, in the short term poses no real risk to anyone, hence when they are busy or short staffed it just gets left.

Personally I think thats a rather cold scientific respose and doesn't take the psycological or comfort needs of the patient into account.

In terms of discharging yourself, I have two friends with MS, it's a very, very slow disease, not an accident or an emergency, I would expect it to be diagnosed by GP and hospital appointments, so you can go that route sounds sensible as they ruled out stroke, only benefit you would have got waiting in A&E is that, though painful waiting, you would have had the MRI that night rather than being in a waiting pattern.

9outof10cats · 15/12/2023 09:17

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 15/12/2023 08:47

Take the women to a toilet and change her. Just do something . You shouldn’t be working where you are then should you . Leaving a patient in urinated clothes you are the nhs problem .

Why do you work in care ?

So many NHS armchair critics who have no idea of the reality of working in ED.

I worked on a ward, where staff would frequently get sent to ED to work due to staff shortages. I hated it and whenever I was told I was being moved I would be filled with anxiety.

It's not as simple as saying 'just do it' and as hard as it is to imagine sometimes there is simply no time and no free staff to deal with the personal care of patients - because you have life-threatening issues to deal with which take priority.

Sitting in urine is humiliating and should not happen, but will not kill someone. Someone who has come in with breathing problems, desaturating, but combative and pulling off their oxygen mask when left unattended is and nurses have to prioritize based on clinical need.

Please, if you think you can do better go and train as a nurse and show us all how it should be done.

LIZS · 15/12/2023 09:14

So sorry this happened to you. Absolutely complain via pals. Was there anyone who could have brought you a bag in ? I'm not sure you will get any easier or quicker route via your gp though, it does sound like an urgent-care/ a and e referral.