Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have discharged myself from A&E?

189 replies

AandEnightmare · 15/12/2023 07:03

As the username suggests…

I attended A&E with numbness is my hand, pins and needles in both arms and legs, blurred vision and extreme stuff neck pain.

Stroke nurse was happy it wasn’t a stroke but wanted an MRI as did A&E consultant.

Both concerned about MS and tragically I then urinated myself in the A&E waiting room where I was left on a wooden chair for 8 hours.

i asked for a change of clothes, just a hospital gown and was told until I was seen by a neurologist who agreed to book me in; this wasn’t possible.

I have long covid and extreme fatigue and pain at the best of times and I was in tears in the waiting room crippled in pain and exhaustion and was just told repeatedly that only a neurologist could determine if an MRI was needed as an emergency or as an outpatient and on the time of leaving, after 7 hours, I was number 13 on the list so expected to be seen by this evening.

I will ring my GP as soon as open but I’ve never had such a terrible experience in a hospital in my life!

i feel shocked

OP posts:
Shannith · 15/12/2023 11:05

AandEnightmare · 15/12/2023 07:25

Thank you for your kind responses
No I wasn’t aware it has happened until it was too late
I told the receptionist straight away and she said “ Ok I’ll update the system “
An hour later I asked if I could have a gown because I was wet and she said no as there are no cubicles available so you can’t have a gown to wear in the emergency area.

It really was awful - I think I’ll have to contact PALS

Symptoms are slightly there as in pins and needles but no numbness now

On a train with patchy WiFi but I hope someone has said this.

Not knowing you are unrinating combined with your other symptoms is a huge red flag for Cauda equina

You need an urgent mri referral - like today - make sure you highlight this to the GP or A&E if you go back.

My GP suspected it because I was having similar symptoms and was very very firm that if I weed without realising it - it was a medical emergency

Mrsttcno1 · 15/12/2023 11:04

ISSTIUTNG · 15/12/2023 10:57

So many utterly arrogant people who don't have a clue what it's like to work for the NHS right now. Let me give you a not unrealistic scenario of a junior doctor/nurse working in ED

  1. A drunken trouble maker is pointing his finger threateningly at the timid new student nurse at the desk and is swearing at her

  2. you've just been told that that patient who you triaged earlier with a headache has become unresponsive

  3. you're trying to refer a patient with abdominal pain to the wards. Medics and surgeons are both refusing to accept the patient as they feel it's the other team's problem. The shift leader is putting you under pressure to get the patient out of ED as it's so busy

  4. The teenager who came in earlier after self harming is still actively suicidal is getting fed up of waiting and saying they're going to self-discharge. They are known to social services due to previous reports of domestic violence

  5. elderly patient's relatives come to inform you that their mum has just soiled herself badly

  6. another elderly patient's family come to the desk furious that their relative patient has been waiting for a hospital trolley for hours and want to escalate a complaint right now

  7. You've just been told that there's 2 patients about to come into rescuss via ambulance after a serious RTA

It's not unheard of for all the above or similar to be happening at the same time. To the oracles on here pray do tell how are you going to manage all of the above? Which is priority? Is there anything you as an individual can do to manage this safely and humanely or is the real issue perhaps that no earthborn person is capable of doing so? Do we perhaps need more staff and funding? Or shall we just keep blaming the only people who are willing to turn themselves inside out to keep the NHS running rather than addressing the real issue?

Edited

Absolutely this!!

Floralsofa · 15/12/2023 11:03

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 11:01

So your answer is not to bother? Again, the op wasn't expecting a nurse to help, that's not what she said. The receptionists are in charge of that waiting room and be aware of what to do when a patient is in distress. I'm sure the OP would have preferred to hear "We can get you something from lost property / scrubs but it will take an hour" than the "tough luck" approach taken by the receptionist, and it may be that she would have stayed to be seen.

I have two local NHS hospitals - one is excellent and one is dreadful. The difference appears to be that the good one has high expectations on staff to keep patients comfortable while they wait, and they appeal in the local press for volunteers to join as escorts, visitors and general "gopher" help (unfortunately they wouldn't take me while I'm still working full time, they're oversubscribed). The dreadful one is the biggest and best funded in the area; no volunteer scheme, lots of money spent on artwork anf paint jobs, while patients are treated as pests at best. Last time I went there on my own, unable to stand or advocate for myself, and the receptionists allowed a drunk man to continually sexually harass me in the waiting room, right in front of them. It was terrifying.

How on earth was her answer 'not to bother'? Do you always have the comprehension of a 5 year old?

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 11:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

So your answer is not to bother? Again, the op wasn't expecting a nurse to help, that's not what she said. The receptionists are in charge of that waiting room and be aware of what to do when a patient is in distress. I'm sure the OP would have preferred to hear "We can get you something from lost property / scrubs but it will take an hour" than the "tough luck" approach taken by the receptionist, and it may be that she would have stayed to be seen.

I have two local NHS hospitals - one is excellent and one is dreadful. The difference appears to be that the good one has high expectations on staff to keep patients comfortable while they wait, and they appeal in the local press for volunteers to join as escorts, visitors and general "gopher" help (unfortunately they wouldn't take me while I'm still working full time, they're oversubscribed). The dreadful one is the biggest and best funded in the area; no volunteer scheme, lots of money spent on artwork anf paint jobs, while patients are treated as pests at best. Last time I went there on my own, unable to stand or advocate for myself, and the receptionists allowed a drunk man to continually sexually harass me in the waiting room, right in front of them. It was terrifying.

ISSTIUTNG · 15/12/2023 10:57

So many utterly arrogant people who don't have a clue what it's like to work for the NHS right now. Let me give you a not unrealistic scenario of a junior doctor/nurse working in ED

  1. A drunken trouble maker is pointing his finger threateningly at the timid new student nurse at the desk and is swearing at her

  2. you've just been told that that patient who you triaged earlier with a headache has become unresponsive

  3. you're trying to refer a patient with abdominal pain to the wards. Medics and surgeons are both refusing to accept the patient as they feel it's the other team's problem. The shift leader is putting you under pressure to get the patient out of ED as it's so busy

  4. The teenager who came in earlier after self harming is still actively suicidal is getting fed up of waiting and saying they're going to self-discharge. They are known to social services due to previous reports of domestic violence

  5. elderly patient's relatives come to inform you that their mum has just soiled herself badly

  6. another elderly patient's family come to the desk furious that their relative patient has been waiting for a hospital trolley for hours and want to escalate a complaint right now

  7. You've just been told that there's 2 patients about to come into rescuss via ambulance after a serious RTA

It's not unheard of for all the above or similar to be happening at the same time. To the oracles on here pray do tell how are you going to manage all of the above? Which is priority? Is there anything you as an individual can do to manage this safely and humanely or is the real issue perhaps that no earthborn person is capable of doing so? Do we perhaps need more staff and funding? Or shall we just keep blaming the only people who are willing to turn themselves inside out to keep the NHS running rather than addressing the real issue?

Floralsofa · 15/12/2023 10:55

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 10:40

I could and I would, but having worked in a nursing union for years, I don't want to work with the sort of tossers who are already there and bombproof, yet to be removed for conduct/capability. The amount of stuff, including severe bullying and gross incompetence, the NHS trusts and NMC let slide and do nothing about is abhorrent. Private sector HCAs and Nurses in the UK actually have worse pay and conditions than the NHS, including pension etc, but their hospitals have higher expectations of behaviour and take the nurses who actually want to do the job.

Let me tell you, private hospitals are struggling more for staff than the NHS and will take anyone with a PIN and a pulse.

There's a reason Ramsey HC is in the top 10 organisations for 'Never Events', despite dealing with much fewer procedures than any of the trusts.

rainbowunicorn · 15/12/2023 10:52

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 07:44

Yes I can, its isn't acceptable, but what do you expect staff to do?

There were over 100 people in the dept I work in, we have 50 cubicles, patients are being nursed in corridor's for 24 hours, it it himilitating for them and harrowing for staff, it isn't nursing, its firefighting, but what do expect staff to do?
Where do you suggest we put patients?

I hope, if you really do work for the NHS that you show a bit more care, empathy and compassion for the people that you interact with than you have shown here.

stressedoutstudent · 15/12/2023 10:51

We have a HCA stationed at the doors of A&E 24/7. They are there to help people to and from cars, people in chairs that need moving to triage or when called, patients that need assistance to the toilets, to direct people to the correct place when they have come to A&E by mistake, to advise on waiting times, to find a patient if a relative is looking for them, to make sure there is always fresh water and cordials available and a hot drink and sandwich if people have been waiting a long time.

Its a very easy change to make in large departments, 1 HCA based in the waiting room to assist patients needs. The OP would not have had any issues getting support and clothing if departments all followed suit. There are ways to manage problems that are currently unfixable in the short term.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 10:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Missingmyusername · 15/12/2023 10:43

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 15/12/2023 07:39

Can you put yourself in the OP’s shoes, and hear yourself?

I think widowtwanky was blunt, but accurate. When you discharge from A&E that’s the end of that.

Did you only tell the receptionist though? Then she put it on the system- lord knows when someone will see that. This is the state of our NHS.

There’s a usually a toilet in A&E but not gowns. It wouldn’t have taken a minute to get a gown, but the receptionist may not be able to leave her station. They should have gowns to hand perhaps for emergencies.

I hope your condition amounts to nothing serious OP and you get seen soon. I am sorry this happened to you.

lesdeluges · 15/12/2023 10:40

So so sorry that you were treated so inhumanely, it is an absolute disgrace. Even if you cannot be seen immediately and have a long wait, a kind word and an update now and then works wonders for sick and scared patients. That doesn't cost anything.

I often feel that under the Foreign Aid contribution, we are giving billions in taxpayer money to countries that have "Third World" conditions especially in healthcare, but it looks to me that our own health system needs that money far more now, and indeed healthcare in some of these "Third World" areas is far more superior to our own now.

The pendulum needs to swing back a bit I think.

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 10:40

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 09:21

I love the way people who don't work in the NHS or in A&E all have so many ideas about how it could work far more effectively if we just did such and such, why don't you all come and work here then ????
Tell us how it could all be done so much easier

I could and I would, but having worked in a nursing union for years, I don't want to work with the sort of tossers who are already there and bombproof, yet to be removed for conduct/capability. The amount of stuff, including severe bullying and gross incompetence, the NHS trusts and NMC let slide and do nothing about is abhorrent. Private sector HCAs and Nurses in the UK actually have worse pay and conditions than the NHS, including pension etc, but their hospitals have higher expectations of behaviour and take the nurses who actually want to do the job.

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 15/12/2023 10:37

9outof10cats · 15/12/2023 09:17

So many NHS armchair critics who have no idea of the reality of working in ED.

I worked on a ward, where staff would frequently get sent to ED to work due to staff shortages. I hated it and whenever I was told I was being moved I would be filled with anxiety.

It's not as simple as saying 'just do it' and as hard as it is to imagine sometimes there is simply no time and no free staff to deal with the personal care of patients - because you have life-threatening issues to deal with which take priority.

Sitting in urine is humiliating and should not happen, but will not kill someone. Someone who has come in with breathing problems, desaturating, but combative and pulling off their oxygen mask when left unattended is and nurses have to prioritize based on clinical need.

Please, if you think you can do better go and train as a nurse and show us all how it should be done.

Lol really . Seems you know me !?
Ive worked in all the busy wards in many hospitals . A&e . CCU, Respiratory. I think that covers two pints you made .

  1. Breathing problem. 2. Telling me what to train as . Not once ever did I leave anyone in urinated clothes. There is good and bad in the nhs and I know which one I am .

Peole can train all they like not every nurse has compassion (clearly)

HoppingPavlova · 15/12/2023 10:36

@CaroleSinger Does it really take a Dr 13 hours to see one group if patients in A&E? Surely they can get through patients quicker than that? It makes you wonder what they are actually doing while everyone is sat there for hours. It creates more an image of taking all the time 8n the world rather than being run off feet. How did we get here? It wasn't that long ago you just walked in and got seen. There were no 4 or 6 hour waits

Gee Carole, you’ve clued on and solved some mysteries there. Yep, no reason why the Dr’s can’t whizz through - a quick glance is surely enough. In fact they aren’t even doing that. The secret is they are all out the back in a room watching Grey’s Anatomy together complete with nachos and beers. That’s why it takes so long. Ffs.

I bet you are also one of these people who complain bitterly when they hear some conversation and laughter coming from the station. The fact is most people can’t take proper breaks, and to try and keep things moving, after working 15hrs straight and ducking to the loo twice during, taking 1 x 10mins to sneak some crisps and down a can of soft drink and God forbid chat and laugh while doing it, gives people like you the heebies. I know you.

And Carole, as for ‘what’s changed’ - apart from A&E Dr’s now being a bunch of lazy people who seemingly don’t bother with any throughput - could it be that the guts have fundamentally been ripped out of the health system, so things that were adequately addressed in community health previously are no longer, pushing those people through A&E instead? I wonder!

Finally, the reality is, someone sitting in their wee is not great. It is however not life-threatening whereas many other things being dealt with are. Yes, this can be an indicator of something more serious requiring more urgent prioritisation, among all the other urgent priorities, but the beef there seems to lie with communication. It’s not at all clear whether admin passed that on or not and what transpired so that’s where any feedback would lie. It’s also not clear why they couldn’t have fetched a blanket. The chairs are uncomfortable, yes, but it’s not a hotel and if you think of what goes through a wait area, they need to be designed for quick, easy and thorough cleaning/sanitising as necessary (plus space under), which is rarely compatible with comfort.

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 10:33

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 08:00

OP said she told the receptionist, not a nurse, the nurses may not even have known, yet are supposed to deal with it?

Being a human being, I would have gotten up from my desk and found a solution for her, even if it was to give her my own cardi to wear around her bottom half. I've worked in retail before and had lots of customers with medical episodes, including vomit & bodily fluids, you don't just shrug and say "sorry too busy", even if your till queue is full. I'd expect far more critical thinking from someone working in healthcare, even as just admin.

RandomButtons · 15/12/2023 10:32

LakieLady · 15/12/2023 09:51

So sorry you had to go through this, OP, it was appalling.

But it's made me wonder just why A&E is so stretched these days, and whether the difficulties people experience in getting GP appointments means they end up at A&E in desperation.

There appear to be problems at the other end of the process, too. Many patients can't be discharged as soon as they're medically fit because they're awaiting social care assessments and care plans. Adult social care is also under huge pressure because of staff shortages and budget cuts, so that can take several days (although I have heard of one case taking 6 weeks, that's beyond my comprehension).

Every day that someone medically fit for discharge is occupying a bed unnecessarily, that's a bed that can't be used for someone who needs admission, and ultimately that can mean another person stuck in A&E unnecessarily. And while they are there they will need staff to monitor them, which makes inroads into the time they can spend on other patients.

None of this is actually new. A friend of mine spent 36 hours waiting on a trolley in A&E because there were no beds in 1995.

Imo, the whole process, from A&E to admission & discharge needs to be looked at.

The fact that the government ordered many A&E departments to shut in late 90’s early 200’s is something that people have forgotten.

Rhe population has grown massively since then. We knew we were walking into a disaster.

Goatymum · 15/12/2023 10:32

I waited in a&e to see a doctor (bloods/ecg) had been done) from around 9pm to 9am on a v uncomfortable plastic chair. At about 7.45am I was the next to be seen, but a Dr came out to say they had to do their paperwork so no patients would be called until 9am. I was starving so dh and I went to get a bit of food, but when I came back around 8.45 I had been called twice - wtf! Eventually was seen with others leapfrogging me and saw a ‘baby’ dr who had no idea what was going on with me but I asked for scan and got it and then waited til approx 11am to get results.
I went to GP and she’s further referred, plus bloods came back w low ferritin so now on iron tabs.
You should’ve been able to put scrubs or gown on if you’d wet yourself. That is dereliction of care, surely.

CHRIS003 · 15/12/2023 10:32

comfyoldcardi · 15/12/2023 10:05

Gp should do urgent referral to neurologist. That is if you can get near a gp.

I must be lucky where I live - I see posts like this all the time - people not being able to get a GP appointment.
My surgery isn't brilliant by any means but - you can usually get a phone appointment same day - they have patient access app so you can book appointments and they also have a text service where you can message for advice on none urgent care - they also have an option to send you to same day emergency care unit at the hospital if necessary my husband as had to use this in the past- ok the hospital is 20 miles away ! But the service is available and also you can use the text service to send a picture of problem ( obviously not for intimate issues ) - and u usually get a call from gp within a couple of hours- also if you can't see the gp they can usually get u in over the phone with a nurse practioner who will have a gp overseeing her anyway so u can get the dr if needed. Ours is a very busy surgery probably the biggest in town.

biter · 15/12/2023 10:31

Your experience OP is awful.

My observation of NHS services I use is that people in it are knackered, overwhelmed and in some cases just not suited to the job.

I've seen the effects of this chronic chaos in the corporate world and the symptoms are generally

  • Iow productivity - can't cope so I'll do the least I can as I'm exhausted
  • firefighting - I'll do what's right in front of me now or to who shouts loudest
  • not fixing broken systems - I'm too overwhelmed to think strategically or plan so I'll move to a permanent reactive mode

This is normal human behaviour. The only ways to address it are

  • give people breaks and time off to recoup energy or they break, go off sick and don't come back
  • have strategic leadership that takes a long view and fixes the high impact issues first
  • look systemically at the issues
  • draft in temporary additional resources to free up the people who know how things work, to fix them
  • make radical changes to processes.

We are in a state of permanent crisis management at the moment and there is no quick fix.

People saying that labour won't fix it are partially right - there is no overnight fix BUT they are more likely to revoke the ridiculous immigration policies that are stopping / discouraging/ making more difficult for overseas workers to work in the NHS in the UK to help us make a start.

Money will make a difference and there is A LOT of money in this country that could be diverted to NHS.

They can put incentives in place to encourage people to work in the vacant posts through free training.

They can clear student debt for nurses and re introduce the bursaries the Tories got rid of

  • they can make sure that NHS has proper supplies in place that are not bought through ridiculously inflated contract prices
  • they can (as in the 50s) give financial incentives for overseas people to come and train
  • they can build affordable homes for lower paid staff to work in

The cyclical Tory approach to healthcare is privatisation by stealth. They've been doing it for years and years. They know that if they say it outright that there will be uproar so they do it sneakily. They don't care that people suffer. As soon as they need care they wither pay for it or get bumped up the list - remember when Boris fecking Johnson had covid and was put into ICU even though he wasn't Ill enough at the time. But they prioritised him and he got better with early intervention. Something that many were denied. Bastard.

I'd also like to add that as frustrated as we all are with the situation we really must rally behind our NHS staff and complain, complain complain so that the evidence is there as to what is broken, what matters to us and what needs to change so that when the bastard cynical tories are out we know where to start.

IHS · 15/12/2023 10:31

honeysuckleweeks · 15/12/2023 09:46

Hopefully this isn't a double post.
I am sad that the NHS has apparently broken down. Less than a decade ago I took my DS18 to Charing Cross and they could not have been kinder or quicker helping him. Within 10 minutes he was in a bed and on a drip. It is a reciprocal arrangement with Australia - so you British people would get the exact same treatment here. No cost either way. I'm surprised that things have gone down hill so fast .

Too many people turning up at A&E because they can't access a GP. During covid, GP practices discovered that they could avoid seeing any patients at all and have stuck to that role since. Obviously, they're seeing some people, but not as it was before. Some practices are very dysfunctional and there aren't enough GPs in any case.

Kittylala · 15/12/2023 10:29

I would have left as soon as urinated especially if no change of clothes were avaliable. Or you could have called a friend to bring clothes. You can't blame the hospital.

cezannesapple · 15/12/2023 10:23

OP, have you taken in what people have been saying about weeing yourself without being aware of it can be something very serious? I agree sitting on a hard chair for 7 hours is not pleasant and they should have given you a gown, you could have changed in the toilets. However, if you have something potentially very serious you should go back and stress about not having control over weeing. Take a change of clothes, snacks, drinks and a cushion, whatever you need, but do get that MRI.

Gnomegnomegnome · 15/12/2023 10:21

@widowtwankywashroom while you are busy explaining how it is not the fault of the nurses (I don’t think op said it was) you have forgotten that it is not the fault of the patient either.
You are right that it is very unlikely that the team that op needed to see were in overnight but this was not communicated to op (by anyone!). Op was told that she needed further investigation and was left to sit in her own urine. That’s not acceptable.

I love the way people who don't work in the NHS or in A&E all have so many ideas about how it could work far more effectively if we just did such and such, why don't you all come and work here then ????
Tell us how it could all be done so much easier

I am also an NHS nurse and have worked in A and E. What could be done to make it more effective? In this case communication!

stressedoutstudent · 15/12/2023 10:20

Im an A&E nurse and pressures are higher now than they ever were even in covid. Waiting hours and hours in waiting rooms is sadly the norm these days and completely unavoidable.

However, you 100% should have been offered a change of clothes and facilities to clean yourself up a bit and assistance if needed. As well as the standard gowns, my dept has a store room full of donated clothing for patient who dont have suitable clothing to return home in. It is very well stocked with generous donations from the community. Please, please complain about this as that needs to change in your local department.

Awaiting a consultant to make a decision is also the norm - as in your case a consultant w3ould need to review those scans before you left. An A&E dr would not be able to read and give a diagnosis like that, it would have to be neurology, so neurology would have to site the scan. Only neurology would have their own ward of patients, own surgeries, own clinics and out patients, so waiting for them to make a decision on whether they can fit you in there and then is the only way. Nights often only 1 neurology dr would be on call to cover the wards and emergencies. So frustrating for you as the patient, i fully understand, but A&E staff couldnt do anything other than wait either in that situation.

As far as the post asking why it takes so long, its not just down to drs in A&E, its flow throughout the entire hospitals. Dr's need a private area to see a patient when they walk in (so only considering walk in patients) this area generally known as ambulatory, if a decision to admit is made, they need somewhere within A&E to wait until a bed is available for them, this is the Majors, they then leave majors to go to a ward. If wards cant discharge, theres no flow through majors, which holds up ambulatory. Even if the person in ambulatory is waiting for a minor injury they could go home with after treatment, that cubicle is needed. And its all good saying, well keep some open just for minor injuries, that is tried, then you have an influx of patients requiring immediate treatments and the rooms have to be used and the minor injuries are left waiting.

A&E department waits arent just down to an increase in visitors to the department, but flow throughout the entire hospital, alot of which is held up by social care - or the lack there of, and many many other complex factors.

But please do not think its just staff not working hard enough, A&E is the hardest job ive had in my life, its the only place ive worked as a nurse where i have truly had no choice but to miss breaks, to work 14 hours with no break and have to be back on shift 10 hours later and do it all again, to go home and cry because i know i havent done enough for all my patients because 1 patient was so acutely poorly but the was no where to move them too and my other 6 patients suffered as a result. To go into work and know im going to get verbal and physical abuse from patients who as so frustrated for reason completely beyond my control but im the only person they are seeing to take it out on. But its also the most rewarding area of nursing i have ever done - when the systems work.

Guttedme · 15/12/2023 10:18

I don't think people realise the state of A&E at present, where I work there is a 14 hour wait to see a Dr!

Oh I can believe it, arrived in A&E mid January 6pm on a Friday night - by 1am they were then just taking me seriously with a second doctor, (thank the lord) admitted to a ward at around 5am Saturday morning. My poor Dad sat with me this entire time. This was an express service compared to the time before. MRI Saturday next day at lunch time. Fortunately the suspected Cauda Equina turned out to be Cervical Myelopathy (sorry OP it all started with one moment of a stiff neck before going on to be present as a sore back)

When I went to A&E evening previously on 1st January (really didn't want to but bodily functions down below failed me) it was said 30 hours if a bed was needed.

All look very stressful to me and I just remember the GP saying in early January (regardless of the hospital referral made which just got batted back as I did self referral to physio) if it gets worse you do have to go to A&E.