Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have discharged myself from A&E?

189 replies

AandEnightmare · 15/12/2023 07:03

As the username suggests…

I attended A&E with numbness is my hand, pins and needles in both arms and legs, blurred vision and extreme stuff neck pain.

Stroke nurse was happy it wasn’t a stroke but wanted an MRI as did A&E consultant.

Both concerned about MS and tragically I then urinated myself in the A&E waiting room where I was left on a wooden chair for 8 hours.

i asked for a change of clothes, just a hospital gown and was told until I was seen by a neurologist who agreed to book me in; this wasn’t possible.

I have long covid and extreme fatigue and pain at the best of times and I was in tears in the waiting room crippled in pain and exhaustion and was just told repeatedly that only a neurologist could determine if an MRI was needed as an emergency or as an outpatient and on the time of leaving, after 7 hours, I was number 13 on the list so expected to be seen by this evening.

I will ring my GP as soon as open but I’ve never had such a terrible experience in a hospital in my life!

i feel shocked

OP posts:
Alicesmagicmushroom · 15/12/2023 17:06

@Youdirtysonofagun

Eh?

Of course it’s useless, it’s beyond useless, hence reminding those who have an oh well attitude let’s take a survival kit, this is a developed country as such the services should reflect that.

Labour? Oh, you jest.

I have every right to moan about anything that is standard and dangerous. You should too.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 16:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 15/12/2023 16:47

Bloody NHS survival kit. Please.

Alicesmagicmushroom · 15/12/2023 16:47

Has everyone forgotten we are talking about a national health service in the developed world!!

I agree with all those saying it’s culture is toxic and that’s the issue.

I won’t be convinced otherwise unless the argument comes with a unicorn.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 16:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 15:57

CormorantStrikesBack · 15/12/2023 15:42

The BMA voted against more medical school places because if there were more spaces there would be more new doctors qualifying than the hospitals could support in training places. So there would be unemployed doctors 🤷🏻‍♀️. It’s a chicken and egg situation but there needs to be more doctors in order for there to be more university places. The best way of doing this would be increasing pay and improving conditions so people stopped leaving.

Or we accept that some of the training places need to be done outside of the UK, create partnerships with organisations in other countries, and provide a small bursary to encourage takeup. I know several young people who would love the ability to travel to another country and learn at the same time.

Also, there are some excellent medical schools who take older graduates as career-changers even in their 40s and 50s; cohorts like this who are settled with kids at school could be encouraged straight onto the GP track. If mental health issues are genuinely taking up so much of the NHS's time, folks with some life experience behind them could be very useful in helping patients manage this - some folks go into social work later in life for similar reasons.

OnlyYesterday · 15/12/2023 15:56

OP I'm so sorry this has happened to you. I have been through similar traumatic experiences in A&E and have always been met with a "shrug what do you expect, the NHS is on it's knees" when I bring it up. I hate the attitude that we're supposed to be thankful for everything the NHS provides even when it's utterly traumatic. I hope you can see a medical professional very soon and get the diagnostics and treatment you urgently need. You absolutely do not deserve to have experienced that and it's completely wrong that you did.

CormorantStrikesBack · 15/12/2023 15:42

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 15:10

No, but given the vast amount of tax I pay already for a failing system, I'd rather have a co-pay arrangement when I need it than pump even more money into the existing system that I can't access.

A massive uptick in medical school places would be a start, thousands of talented kids each year are disappointed by not receiving a medicine place at uni, and many of the ones privileged enough to be chosen aren't supported financially to do it & end up dropping out. Which leads to medicine being full of fhe upper/middle classes with no understanding of less privileged lifestyles.

The BMA voted against more medical school places because if there were more spaces there would be more new doctors qualifying than the hospitals could support in training places. So there would be unemployed doctors 🤷🏻‍♀️. It’s a chicken and egg situation but there needs to be more doctors in order for there to be more university places. The best way of doing this would be increasing pay and improving conditions so people stopped leaving.

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 15:10

ISSTIUTNG · 15/12/2023 14:53

Can I ask.... Whoever we want to blame.... Is anybody happy with a developed country having a healthcare system in which we have to rely on volunteers to meet our basic needs? Does anybody genuinely think that the employed staff are happy with it? Why are we not more outraged at the people at the top who can actually do something about that?

No, but given the vast amount of tax I pay already for a failing system, I'd rather have a co-pay arrangement when I need it than pump even more money into the existing system that I can't access.

A massive uptick in medical school places would be a start, thousands of talented kids each year are disappointed by not receiving a medicine place at uni, and many of the ones privileged enough to be chosen aren't supported financially to do it & end up dropping out. Which leads to medicine being full of fhe upper/middle classes with no understanding of less privileged lifestyles.

rainbowunicorn · 15/12/2023 15:07

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 14:49

Love how you can ascertain how I conduct myself at work from a post on mumsnet!
That is why twice this week I have given a hug by patients who told me I was an angel!

I didn't ascertain anything. If you read my post I said I hope that you treated people with more care and compassion than your posts have come across here. You posts have a tone about them that is defeatist in that you accept thats just how it is in the NHS so we all need to just accept it. This is very dehumanising for patients. Sometimes NHS staff are so used to such a low bar being gthe norm that they come across as cold and uncaring when talking about their workplace.
I would like to think that it doesn't carry through to theor interactions with patients. Unfortunately in my experience it does all too often.

ISSTIUTNG · 15/12/2023 14:53

Can I ask.... Whoever we want to blame.... Is anybody happy with a developed country having a healthcare system in which we have to rely on volunteers to meet our basic needs? Does anybody genuinely think that the employed staff are happy with it? Why are we not more outraged at the people at the top who can actually do something about that?

Igglepiggleandhisboat · 15/12/2023 14:50

I have MS.
I went to an and e before I was diagnosed and had similar experiences to you.
usually with MS the symptoms would last days if not weeks or months each time.
if it is MS it’s not urgent and a GP can refer you x

ISSTIUTNG · 15/12/2023 14:50

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 11:22

  1. Student nurse's problem, not yours - there are security guards in our hospital they can call for backup and the students need to learn to manage these on the job.

  2. obviously the priority as they're crashing

  3. Report this situation later as high as it will go - this kind of territorial pissing is a good reason the NHS is up shit creek.

  4. Not much you can do there if psych won't come down to see them, the receptionist could call psych team and give the patient an update about how long it will take, given they're already known to the hospital.

  5. & 6) - receptionist uses the phone to request some scrubs, receptionist finds out how long the wait should be and updates the relatives. Receptionist escalates to overall dept manager if complaint required.

  6. Better communication with ambulance service is needed, if you don't have the resources to handle the resus they should be checking if any other local hospitals do.

There are so many "support services" employed by a hospital that expect to just sit behind a desk 9-5 while others are left to manage. Other organisations dealing with the public have realised that staff need to be up and out there helping customers at the times their services are busiest (including shifts in anti-social hours), and in some cases have removed their desks/offices to facilitate that, implementing a shift service instead. There needs to be some creative thinking going on around what the non-clinical staff are responsible for, as in my experience these are often the ones sat chatting with their faces in the chocolate tins.

You don't seem to understand the fundamental point. Of course drs and nurses and receptionists are resourceful. Of course they utilise other team members where they can but

  1. repeat after me and let it sink in ... There aren't enough staff. Not enough of anyone. You can sit there and tell yourself otherwise as much as you want but I can tell you who's been on the frontline that all staff are spread dangerously too thin

  2. Whether dealt with personally or delegated every single one of the scenarios I gave requires mental energy to risk assess and manage and every single one has the potential to end in serious harm. You can be as obtuse as you like but this shouldn't be difficult to understand

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 14:49

rainbowunicorn · 15/12/2023 10:52

I hope, if you really do work for the NHS that you show a bit more care, empathy and compassion for the people that you interact with than you have shown here.

Love how you can ascertain how I conduct myself at work from a post on mumsnet!
That is why twice this week I have given a hug by patients who told me I was an angel!

shreddednips · 15/12/2023 14:49

stressedoutstudent · 15/12/2023 10:51

We have a HCA stationed at the doors of A&E 24/7. They are there to help people to and from cars, people in chairs that need moving to triage or when called, patients that need assistance to the toilets, to direct people to the correct place when they have come to A&E by mistake, to advise on waiting times, to find a patient if a relative is looking for them, to make sure there is always fresh water and cordials available and a hot drink and sandwich if people have been waiting a long time.

Its a very easy change to make in large departments, 1 HCA based in the waiting room to assist patients needs. The OP would not have had any issues getting support and clothing if departments all followed suit. There are ways to manage problems that are currently unfixable in the short term.

They do this at our local A&E I think, as last time I took my DS they had a HCA in the waiting room the whole time we were there. I have no idea if it's feasible in every hospital but they made all the difference in the world. It was still an enormous wait and there were lots of very elderly/unwell patients waiting in chairs but at least there was someone ensuring they had food/water/safe access to a toilet and generally checking they were ok.

QueenCamilla · 15/12/2023 14:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

No volunteer would be able to help me in my situation that night in the A&E. I needed morphine to stop my heart rate from going into overdrive from pain, I needed to lay down, I needed to see a doctor (are you surprised?) and I needed an urgent surgery under general anaesthetic.

A volunteer could have given me a blanket to stop me from shivering whilst sleeping on the tiles I suppose... 🤔

tattygrl · 15/12/2023 14:26

biter · 15/12/2023 10:31

Your experience OP is awful.

My observation of NHS services I use is that people in it are knackered, overwhelmed and in some cases just not suited to the job.

I've seen the effects of this chronic chaos in the corporate world and the symptoms are generally

  • Iow productivity - can't cope so I'll do the least I can as I'm exhausted
  • firefighting - I'll do what's right in front of me now or to who shouts loudest
  • not fixing broken systems - I'm too overwhelmed to think strategically or plan so I'll move to a permanent reactive mode

This is normal human behaviour. The only ways to address it are

  • give people breaks and time off to recoup energy or they break, go off sick and don't come back
  • have strategic leadership that takes a long view and fixes the high impact issues first
  • look systemically at the issues
  • draft in temporary additional resources to free up the people who know how things work, to fix them
  • make radical changes to processes.

We are in a state of permanent crisis management at the moment and there is no quick fix.

People saying that labour won't fix it are partially right - there is no overnight fix BUT they are more likely to revoke the ridiculous immigration policies that are stopping / discouraging/ making more difficult for overseas workers to work in the NHS in the UK to help us make a start.

Money will make a difference and there is A LOT of money in this country that could be diverted to NHS.

They can put incentives in place to encourage people to work in the vacant posts through free training.

They can clear student debt for nurses and re introduce the bursaries the Tories got rid of

  • they can make sure that NHS has proper supplies in place that are not bought through ridiculously inflated contract prices
  • they can (as in the 50s) give financial incentives for overseas people to come and train
  • they can build affordable homes for lower paid staff to work in

The cyclical Tory approach to healthcare is privatisation by stealth. They've been doing it for years and years. They know that if they say it outright that there will be uproar so they do it sneakily. They don't care that people suffer. As soon as they need care they wither pay for it or get bumped up the list - remember when Boris fecking Johnson had covid and was put into ICU even though he wasn't Ill enough at the time. But they prioritised him and he got better with early intervention. Something that many were denied. Bastard.

I'd also like to add that as frustrated as we all are with the situation we really must rally behind our NHS staff and complain, complain complain so that the evidence is there as to what is broken, what matters to us and what needs to change so that when the bastard cynical tories are out we know where to start.

Fantastic points well made. NHS nurses are working in a nightmare of a system right now.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 14:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

QueenCamilla · 15/12/2023 14:07

After 13h of crying and pleading for help in the A&E (I wasn't even triaged at that point), sleeping on the floor tiles when I couldn't sit upright anymore, I collapsed on my way to the toilets. Fellow patients picked me up and brought me to the nurse station and I crawled on my stomach and elbows right in there amongst them and dialled 999...

I asked for an ambulance or any sort of medical aid. The (very confused!) 999 operator put me through to some intensive care official who put in his own call to the hospital. Well I never! Despite the cat-bum faces of the A&E nurses, I was seen by a doctor within minutes of that call, I got morphine for pain relief when I was unable to get Ibuprofen for 14h, I was given use of a small couch in a side room so I don't have to sit on my gynecological abscess, even a cup of hot tea appeared. I was soon admitted to gyne ward and given my own room to have a sleep in, in what was a very quiet department with barely any patients in. I was allowed to rest until the consultants were in and soon after that I had a life-saving surgery.

The insight I gained from dialling 999 from the floor of the A&E is this: there is no scarcity of resources or time at the hands of the A&E staff - it was all there (and more!) when the management intervened. However, there is very real rot of humanity present that needs managing acutely and urgently.

alloalloallo · 15/12/2023 13:49

OP ’m sorry you had such a horrible experience and I hope you can find out what is going on.

I had to take my daughter to an OOH GP appointment recently. We were sent by 111 as she was experiencing some nasty symptoms after an endoscopy.

It was about 9pm on a Saturday night so I was fully expecting it to be a shitshow, but was not expecting how much of a shitshow it actually was.

Usually, the OOH GP and ED waiting rooms are in totally separate areas, but it was so busy they’d turned the ED waiting room into a temporary ED ward and ED and OOH GP were sharing a waiting area.

We were lucky and seen pretty quickly. The longest wait was for a chest x-ray so we were in an out in 3 hours

It was packed. There were no spare chairs. The queue to check in for ED was out the door and was so the entire time we were there. 2 ambulance crews were there for over an hour waiting to check in/hand over their patients. Staff were run ragged, none of them stopped. Patients were sat in the waiting area with IVs as there were no cubicles or beds available. A lady I was talking to had been there for 15 hours as they were waiting for a bed for her.

There were a couple of staff looking after everyone in the waiting room as best they could but it was just horrendous. It was firefighting. They couldn’t give actual care as there were just too few of them and too many people waiting.

It’s unsustainable and dangerous for patients and staff.

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 13:47

stressedoutstudent · 15/12/2023 13:00

I agree, We have volunteers, but they literally do directions, taking relatives to the correct areas, and teas/coffees. They cant do anything that involves direct contact with patients or cleaning of bodily fluids. However, a HCA based there can. Our HCA's are absolutely amazing, their clinical knowledge is incredible, and being on the door managing the waiting room is exactly the kind of role they can take on. Having someone in uniform in the public wait areas attending to patients also massively improves patient satisfaction. Its such a workable solution to an ever growing problem i dont see why all trusts arent utilising HCA's into roles like this. Receptionist dont have time to care for the needs of patients waiting, but a dedicated HCA can.

Edited

This sounds like a great solution - I've met some great HCAs during my time in hospital and most of them still have the compassion to do it.

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 15/12/2023 13:46

LakieLady · 15/12/2023 09:51

So sorry you had to go through this, OP, it was appalling.

But it's made me wonder just why A&E is so stretched these days, and whether the difficulties people experience in getting GP appointments means they end up at A&E in desperation.

There appear to be problems at the other end of the process, too. Many patients can't be discharged as soon as they're medically fit because they're awaiting social care assessments and care plans. Adult social care is also under huge pressure because of staff shortages and budget cuts, so that can take several days (although I have heard of one case taking 6 weeks, that's beyond my comprehension).

Every day that someone medically fit for discharge is occupying a bed unnecessarily, that's a bed that can't be used for someone who needs admission, and ultimately that can mean another person stuck in A&E unnecessarily. And while they are there they will need staff to monitor them, which makes inroads into the time they can spend on other patients.

None of this is actually new. A friend of mine spent 36 hours waiting on a trolley in A&E because there were no beds in 1995.

Imo, the whole process, from A&E to admission & discharge needs to be looked at.

@LakieLady it goes back much further than the mid 90’s, I worked in the NHS from the early 1970’s to 2015, it’s continued to get progressively worse since I left.
Ageing population, lack of staff, paucity of community services including social care, dropping numbers of GPs (our practice has gone from 3 full time GPs to 2 very part time, a paramedic on one day and practice nurses trying to fill the gaps) or GPs moving into more lucrative work.
I don’t know what the answer is, private medical care relies on NHS hospitals for emergency and critical interventions.

LardyCakeAgain · 15/12/2023 13:43

HoppingPavlova · 15/12/2023 12:39

@LardyCakeAgain This is exactly the type of scenario that a first-aid trained volunteer force could help with, there are plenty of folks out here who want to help make the NHS better but need to be directed to what's needed, as per in the pandemic. Charity shops could provide a wardrobe of spare tracksuit bottoms & t-shirts that would otherwise go to recycling, the NHS could provide wet wipes, sick bags, incontinence pads & whatever else to be distributed by volunteer greeters/gophers. Providing this stuff up front would even save them staff time & resources having to clean up blood, piss/poo & vomit from the waiting area

Won’t work as fraught with peril and a litigious nightmare. Let’s say with OP, she wets herself and a volunteer is pulled between trying to get OP new clothes, someone else who is vomiting a sick bag and tissues and then someone else stops them to say their child has suddenly gone sleepy. The volunteer goes and tells someone about the sleepy child and then gets distracted with also managing the vomit bag, going to find tissues as the supply seems to have run out, and then remembers OP needs dry clothes and gets them. But they forget to flag to the right people OP has wet herself with no feeling of doing so. Turns out OP has EC and undertakes medical litigation down the track because this was not picked up in time before permanent damage occurs because she was still sitting there 10hrs later and the volunteer never told anyone. Nightmare. Complete. Fucking. Nightmare. Do you have any idea how much time litigation takes up? A fuck tonne. You can’t chance this happening due to volunteers.

It's this superior "can't do" attitude that stops any new ideas and improvements in the NHS. The tasks suggested here would be expected of a care assistant in a nursing home, who are often not medical professionals and given the bare minimum of basic training. Not even any lifting - nothing that couldn't be done by a trained volunteer. Do you honestly think there will be fewer complaints and litigation from patients who are neglected in a waiting room and left to sit in their own piss and shit, with the resulting skin infections & ulcers? Or there would be fewer litigation cases from patients who died on their own on a trolley, vs ones being checked on ny volunteers who could raise the alarm sooner?

Don't forget nurses never used to have degrees either, years ago they learned on the job and used common sense to manage their patients....

fliptopbin · 15/12/2023 13:40

I was admitted to hospital last week with a suspected kidney infection, and after they had taken vlood, I offered to sleep in the car until tjete was space for ne in Surgical Assessment Unit. As it was, I got a phone call at 5am to say that my bloods were borderline for infection, but that I had a kidney stone. They said that under any normal circumstance they would keep me 8n for pain control, but these are not normal times, so its just a case of grit my teeth and get on with it.
The plan is to do an outpatient procedure to zap it, but that is likely to be months. I tried to get a gp appointment , but there is nothing before January.
Before anyone says it, I know that nobody ever died of pain. Also, since it was standing room in the waiting room, I probably saved a life thstvg

Parker231 · 15/12/2023 13:27

CaroleSinger · 15/12/2023 08:16

Does it really take a Dr 13 hours to see one group if patients in A&E? Surely they can get through patients quicker than that? It makes you wonder what they are actually doing while everyone is sat there for hours. It creates more an image of taking all the time 8n the world rather than being run off feet. How did we get here? It wasn't that long ago you just walked in and got seen. There were no 4 or 6 hour waits.

More patients wanting to be seen but less staff and beds.