Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have discharged myself from A&E?

189 replies

AandEnightmare · 15/12/2023 07:03

As the username suggests…

I attended A&E with numbness is my hand, pins and needles in both arms and legs, blurred vision and extreme stuff neck pain.

Stroke nurse was happy it wasn’t a stroke but wanted an MRI as did A&E consultant.

Both concerned about MS and tragically I then urinated myself in the A&E waiting room where I was left on a wooden chair for 8 hours.

i asked for a change of clothes, just a hospital gown and was told until I was seen by a neurologist who agreed to book me in; this wasn’t possible.

I have long covid and extreme fatigue and pain at the best of times and I was in tears in the waiting room crippled in pain and exhaustion and was just told repeatedly that only a neurologist could determine if an MRI was needed as an emergency or as an outpatient and on the time of leaving, after 7 hours, I was number 13 on the list so expected to be seen by this evening.

I will ring my GP as soon as open but I’ve never had such a terrible experience in a hospital in my life!

i feel shocked

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SausageCasseroles · 17/12/2023 14:00

No agree there. It's run down for so long hasn't it? I have no idea what the answer will be.

But it's awful now.... and I can't see what the future will look like 😬.

I genuinely now wish we earnt enough for private health care.

widowtwankywashroom · 17/12/2023 12:58

SausageCasseroles · 17/12/2023 10:58

Oh widow I agree completely. There's a crisis that needs addressing on so many levels isn't there. Improving cmconditions/reducing caseloads/physically not closing A and E wards/more staff...

But is that going to happen!?

I can almost belive the conspiracy theories that torys are running nhs into the ground so that there "has" tk be another system...

I genuinely don't know what the future holds, it's frightening.

But the laughable thing is, if Labour get in, everyone thinks it's going to change over night!

SausageCasseroles · 17/12/2023 10:58

Oh widow I agree completely. There's a crisis that needs addressing on so many levels isn't there. Improving cmconditions/reducing caseloads/physically not closing A and E wards/more staff...

But is that going to happen!?

I can almost belive the conspiracy theories that torys are running nhs into the ground so that there "has" tk be another system...

widowtwankywashroom · 17/12/2023 10:42

SausageCasseroles · 17/12/2023 08:09

A and E was SO busy when we were in (I mentioned earlier at one point it said it would be 13 hours til we were seen but couldn't go home to get some sleep)

Once we'd been triaged a hca did come round every so often to do peoples obs. In the waiting room. It was like an extension of the (very overcrowded, top to tail beds in corridor) A and E.

It felt like somethinf out of a film or what were shown about "developing countries".

This system really isn't okay. I don't know if it needs more hospitals built with growing population? Or GPS actually giving appointments? Or what. Our A and E is due to be closed....

Who is going to staff these new hospitals?
There aren't enough GP to cover patients demands.

widowtwankywashroom · 17/12/2023 10:39

Evilspiritgin · 17/12/2023 09:41

It’s a shame that a doctor or nurse being caring in the nhs is now a minority and not the majority as it should be.

i wonder if they should go back to training nurses on the job

You do realise 50% of nurse training is on the wards don't you??

OT Degree
Pharmacist Degree
Physio Degree
Dr Degree
Dietician Degree

Most of the people in the team have degree but you want to go backwards, why shouldn't the nurse, who is doing the hands the majority of the work, not have a degree?
Countless evidence over the years have shown having degree educated nurses improves patient outcomes!

LardyCakeAgain · 17/12/2023 10:24

ShowOfHands · 17/12/2023 09:55

I was in A&E in July. I waited 7hrs for stitches and then another hour for a tetanus shot. I bled through my bandages 3 times whilst waiting, dripping blood all over myself and the floor. When I asked for the bandages to be changed for the third time, the triage nurse rolled his eyes and pointed at a chair, where he changed the dressing in silence. He was pretty rough with me as well and I winced (I needed 7 stitches, it was quite a nasty wound). He muttered "for fuck's sake" as I moved back to the main waiting area. No other words from him. I felt like leaving, but the bleeding wouldn't stop and I needed medical attention. He was the same with a miscarrying woman, a woman who had been mauled by a dog, a man bleeding really heavily and grey with it, a woman who was clearly deeply in the middle of a psychotic break and on and on and on.

I understand he was probably tired and burnt out but he was rolling his eyes and huffing. No speaking to anybody. We could hear him grumbling to himself about "fuck this" and "fuck that". Clearly, he needed somebody to care for him as well. The whole thing was completely and utterly broken.

This is absolutely a management issue. I get that they're exhausted, but lots of people have jobs where they deal with the angry/distressed public for long hours or double shifts, and if they spoke to them like that they'd be fired for being unprofessional. Its expected to at least keep a veneer of civility which seems to be lacking in the NHS in many areas. Nurses and doctors don't have the monopoly on hard, understaffed, important jobs. You only have to read the NMC hearing outcomes each month to see what kind of behaviour is tolerated.

ShowOfHands · 17/12/2023 09:55

I was in A&E in July. I waited 7hrs for stitches and then another hour for a tetanus shot. I bled through my bandages 3 times whilst waiting, dripping blood all over myself and the floor. When I asked for the bandages to be changed for the third time, the triage nurse rolled his eyes and pointed at a chair, where he changed the dressing in silence. He was pretty rough with me as well and I winced (I needed 7 stitches, it was quite a nasty wound). He muttered "for fuck's sake" as I moved back to the main waiting area. No other words from him. I felt like leaving, but the bleeding wouldn't stop and I needed medical attention. He was the same with a miscarrying woman, a woman who had been mauled by a dog, a man bleeding really heavily and grey with it, a woman who was clearly deeply in the middle of a psychotic break and on and on and on.

I understand he was probably tired and burnt out but he was rolling his eyes and huffing. No speaking to anybody. We could hear him grumbling to himself about "fuck this" and "fuck that". Clearly, he needed somebody to care for him as well. The whole thing was completely and utterly broken.

Evilspiritgin · 17/12/2023 09:41

It’s a shame that a doctor or nurse being caring in the nhs is now a minority and not the majority as it should be.

i wonder if they should go back to training nurses on the job

SausageCasseroles · 17/12/2023 08:09

A and E was SO busy when we were in (I mentioned earlier at one point it said it would be 13 hours til we were seen but couldn't go home to get some sleep)

Once we'd been triaged a hca did come round every so often to do peoples obs. In the waiting room. It was like an extension of the (very overcrowded, top to tail beds in corridor) A and E.

It felt like somethinf out of a film or what were shown about "developing countries".

This system really isn't okay. I don't know if it needs more hospitals built with growing population? Or GPS actually giving appointments? Or what. Our A and E is due to be closed....

HoppingPavlova · 17/12/2023 00:15

I have no idea why people with such low reading comprehension have decided that I'm suggesting they should be nursing in the waiting room!

For ffs no one is saying they should be nursing in the waiting room. We are all 100% clear on that. What we are also 100% clear on is that putting them in a position of handing out sick bags and new clothes is fraught with peril in a legal sense. They are volunteers. There is no indemnity in this situation. Someone tells them they need a sick bag and why. The volunteer says ‘poor thing, here’s your sick bag, let me know if you need another’. Then they wander off to hand out clothes. However, part of that ‘why’ is extremely relevant and medically may be a flag. But the volunteer does not pass that part of the conversation on because they didn’t realise it was significant. Ditto for the person who wets themselves, is it that they are there with a possible broken foot and physically can’t get to the loo so wet themselves (no issue and no one needs to know), or they have wet themselves and didn’t realise they were doing it until wet (could indicate a serious issue). Will a volunteer provide such a quiz to people, what if they get it wrong and make an incorrect judgement and don’t pass over relevant information. They are not employed, this is not covered when the shit hits the fan in a court when someone decides to sue and fingers are pointed. Because a volunteer (who is not accountable, nor covered)is now doing a job that someone who should be accountable or covered is doing. It’s simple. Nothing wrong with anyone’s comprehension. The issue is lack of EMPLOYED people who should be doing this. The problem is there is no budget to address this. But it is clear volunteers can’t fill this gap. They can however, not interact with patients and make cups of tea or whatnot, and show someone the way from the front door to radiology for example. If the patient collapses on the way they have a call instruction but may not interact with the patient in the same way they would be able to do so as a random on the street for example. It’s for legal reasons.

Completely different scenario to rescuing someone on a mountain, or looking for someone missing in a forest if you want to as a volunteer. Different legal scenarios as part of such volunteer organisations or as a random with hand up to help.

LardyCakeAgain · 16/12/2023 12:23

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2023 12:22

Gosh aren't you full of Christmas cheer.

What??? 😆 honestly....

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2023 12:22

Gosh aren't you full of Christmas cheer.

LardyCakeAgain · 16/12/2023 12:20

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2023 12:15

@LardyCakeAgain the RNLI and Mpuntain Rescue are not funded through National Insirance Contributions. They may receive some relatively low funding through taxation.

The point about volunteers is that caring/nursing shoukd be rendered by paid staff who are accountable for their actions and are covered by indemnity insurance.

My suggestion wasn't about caring though was it? I suggested they could have stores of sick bags, donated clean clothes, and be a greeter/gopher. I have no idea why people with such low reading comprehension have decided that I'm suggesting they should be nursing in the waiting room!

RosesAndHellebores · 16/12/2023 12:15

@LardyCakeAgain the RNLI and Mpuntain Rescue are not funded through National Insirance Contributions. They may receive some relatively low funding through taxation.

The point about volunteers is that caring/nursing shoukd be rendered by paid staff who are accountable for their actions and are covered by indemnity insurance.

LardyCakeAgain · 16/12/2023 12:10

HoppingPavlova · 16/12/2023 01:05

@LardyCakeAgain It's this superior "can't do" attitude that stops any new ideas and improvements in the NHS. The tasks suggested here would be expected of a care assistant in a nursing home, who are often not medical professionals and given the bare minimum of basic training. Not even any lifting - nothing that couldn't be done by a trained volunteer. Do you honestly think there will be fewer complaints and litigation from patients who are neglected in a waiting room and left to sit in their own piss and shit, with the resulting skin infections & ulcers? Or there would be fewer litigation cases from patients who died on their own on a trolley, vs ones being checked on ny volunteers who could raise the alarm sooner

The bit you have missed is the HCA in a nursing home is EMPLOYED. There is no issue in them undertaking tasks you describe, as they are employed, they have undergone required training, all good. They have responsibilities, that can be enforced, because they are employed. This is not the case with volunteers. You can’t make them have the responsibility of the group you are comparing them to. So what you are really saying is employ HCA’s not volunteers, big difference in a medico-legal sense there! Then it becomes a case of where does the money for all of these HCA’s come from. What bit do you cut back on to bring these on, because it WILL come out of your budget, I can assure you there won’t be any extra for them. So more HCA’s and less nurses or Dr’s, take your pick. Then, you really will need them as the wait time will be even longer again so not sure how that solved the problem?

As for your claim of people dying on trolleys in hallways and the waiting room……… While I’m sure it exists (as I never fail to be surprised), I personally haven’t known of an institution where a nurse didn’t go out and have a subtle whip around at intervals to make sure any significant change in clinical presentation was missed. You can’t have people dying in waiting areas and corridor trolleys - do you know what an absolute drama that would cause? Paperwork and meetings for years. Accordingly, this is usually factored in with staffing and tasks. Just because they are not talking to you individually does not mean you have not had an eye cast over you.

As for suing because you got ulcers and infections from a sitting in a waiting room, get a grip. Takes more than that, usually a sustained period such as people in nursing homes or babies where it is not a once off soiling and being left for hours, but consistently soiling and being left for a while on a routine basis. I used adult incontinence pants for years after having kids as I ended up with all sorts of incontinence and unlike my early days where I could hold a wee for over 12hrs if flat out, no way I could hold it for 10mins, and no generally you can’t just duck to the loo when you need. I’d be in heavily soiled ‘nappies’ for hours at a time, probably more unpleasant for others than me at times to be frank. Nothing a good clean with wet wipes and then shower when you get home can’t fix, no harm done. Sitting soiled for several hours as a one off is honestly not the absolute end of the world. Having said that no idea why reception couldn’t give OP a blanket to sit on, usually plenty of those spare.

The RNLI are crewed by volunteers, Mountain Rescue teams are crewed by volunteers, etc., and they work in some of the most dangerous scenarios imaginable. The whole insurance argument is a red herring, but the BMA & Nursing unions love it because they think volunteers will erode their pay and conditions. They only give a toss about their staff, not patients.

HoppingPavlova · 16/12/2023 01:05

@LardyCakeAgain It's this superior "can't do" attitude that stops any new ideas and improvements in the NHS. The tasks suggested here would be expected of a care assistant in a nursing home, who are often not medical professionals and given the bare minimum of basic training. Not even any lifting - nothing that couldn't be done by a trained volunteer. Do you honestly think there will be fewer complaints and litigation from patients who are neglected in a waiting room and left to sit in their own piss and shit, with the resulting skin infections & ulcers? Or there would be fewer litigation cases from patients who died on their own on a trolley, vs ones being checked on ny volunteers who could raise the alarm sooner

The bit you have missed is the HCA in a nursing home is EMPLOYED. There is no issue in them undertaking tasks you describe, as they are employed, they have undergone required training, all good. They have responsibilities, that can be enforced, because they are employed. This is not the case with volunteers. You can’t make them have the responsibility of the group you are comparing them to. So what you are really saying is employ HCA’s not volunteers, big difference in a medico-legal sense there! Then it becomes a case of where does the money for all of these HCA’s come from. What bit do you cut back on to bring these on, because it WILL come out of your budget, I can assure you there won’t be any extra for them. So more HCA’s and less nurses or Dr’s, take your pick. Then, you really will need them as the wait time will be even longer again so not sure how that solved the problem?

As for your claim of people dying on trolleys in hallways and the waiting room……… While I’m sure it exists (as I never fail to be surprised), I personally haven’t known of an institution where a nurse didn’t go out and have a subtle whip around at intervals to make sure any significant change in clinical presentation was missed. You can’t have people dying in waiting areas and corridor trolleys - do you know what an absolute drama that would cause? Paperwork and meetings for years. Accordingly, this is usually factored in with staffing and tasks. Just because they are not talking to you individually does not mean you have not had an eye cast over you.

As for suing because you got ulcers and infections from a sitting in a waiting room, get a grip. Takes more than that, usually a sustained period such as people in nursing homes or babies where it is not a once off soiling and being left for hours, but consistently soiling and being left for a while on a routine basis. I used adult incontinence pants for years after having kids as I ended up with all sorts of incontinence and unlike my early days where I could hold a wee for over 12hrs if flat out, no way I could hold it for 10mins, and no generally you can’t just duck to the loo when you need. I’d be in heavily soiled ‘nappies’ for hours at a time, probably more unpleasant for others than me at times to be frank. Nothing a good clean with wet wipes and then shower when you get home can’t fix, no harm done. Sitting soiled for several hours as a one off is honestly not the absolute end of the world. Having said that no idea why reception couldn’t give OP a blanket to sit on, usually plenty of those spare.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 21:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

justasking111 · 15/12/2023 18:54

I would definitely take an overnight bag, drinks, etc. my neighbour and his wife sat there for 32 hours. They were then moved to another area for tea and toast. He'd had a stroke, was in for three weeks.

sleepyscientist · 15/12/2023 18:51

@NotQuiteHere it a very valid question

*forced discharges to relatives - you can't do that
*seeing patients in open areas as no cubicles - you can't do that
*port-a-cabins - council rejects
*ANP/PA/Paramedics in primary care - you can't do that
*higher taxes - you can't do that
*Telephone/econsult - you can't do that what about the elderly!

What is the NHS meant to do? Honestly I would rather be seen in public by a AHCP get a script/referral and be out of there quickly than wait to be seen in private by a Dr. But that's my choice, I don't really want to pay more tax for a better service as that impacts on my quality of life daily vs a bad 48hrs in A&E which will be forgotten in days.

Short term I think patients need to be encouraged to take a relative and overnight bag if they can.

We need to invest in training new health care professionals, upskilling the ones we have, invest in recruitment/retention from existing budgets and defining scopes of practice and have a more nurse lead service to reduce doctor waits. Some kind of career structure that values experience vs the current education system so people stay and want to make the system better and expand scope of practice.

It's a massive task that requires a change of mind set from both HCP's and the public, it's probably going to get worse before it gets better.

NotQuiteHere · 15/12/2023 18:00

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 07:44

Yes I can, its isn't acceptable, but what do you expect staff to do?

There were over 100 people in the dept I work in, we have 50 cubicles, patients are being nursed in corridor's for 24 hours, it it himilitating for them and harrowing for staff, it isn't nursing, its firefighting, but what do expect staff to do?
Where do you suggest we put patients?

what do you expect staff to do?

It is this attitude that is killing NHS more than understaffing and lack of resources.

Youdirtysonofagun · 15/12/2023 18:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Cheeseplantalltheway · 15/12/2023 17:55

That's awful OP. İt's a lack of basic human decency, basic care.

Flowers
widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 17:51

orangeguy · 15/12/2023 17:49

Actually read the thread

I posted that at 07.25.
I had and have continued to read the thread!

orangeguy · 15/12/2023 17:49

widowtwankywashroom · 15/12/2023 07:35

I don't think people realise the state of A&E at present, where I work there is a 14 hour wait to see a Dr!

You were seen by a nurse and a Dr who were happy it wasn't a stroke etc, but that an MRI was needed, I presume a a Neurologist wasn't on? Did you attend overnight? Not all specialities are covered 24hrs a day.

So it seems from this you were seen pretty quickly? Once an acute event ruled out you were then waiting for a specialist?

It is awful you were sat in a chair, but if all the cubicles were taken, where do you expect them to put you?

As for urinating yourself, agree, very humiliating, but staff don't have changes of clothes, yes a gown should have been offered etc.

This should have been highlighted to staff as it can be a sign of Cauda Eqina - which is an emergency

However if you have discharged yourself you have terminated that episode of care and you will now have to wait for your GP to refer you

Edited

Actually read the thread

Alicesmagicmushroom · 15/12/2023 17:08

Sub standard I should say…