Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Once in a lifetime trip - 3 weeks off school

935 replies

XMissPlacedX · 14/12/2023 20:27

My daughter has always wanted to go to Disney world Florida, but due to funds I've not been able to afford it. She is 14.

Her aunty who is quite well off and has a daughter the same age (my dd's cousin ) goes to Disney world Florida every 2 years and has offered to take my dd next year for 3 weeks.

The problem is it's the first 3 weeks of the school term ( September 2024). I've asked her if there was anyway of going in the summer holidays and she said it would double their cost and it would be cheaper for them to pay the school fine .

What do I do ? Do I say yes or no ? I would love for my dd to go but am not sure how much the fine would be and what impact missing that amount of school would cause.

I'm really torn

OP posts:
PloddingAlong21 · 18/12/2023 06:42

God no, 3 weeks is insane. 1 week can be justified when they’re younger but start of term in GCSE is a hard no for me.

Also, it isn’t once in a lifetime. She has her whole life ahead of her. It’s an expensive holiday yes, but at what cost ultimately? Her education is more important than some rollercoasters. It may be that you can’t ever afford to go but if her aunt goes ask if she can go next trip instead.

as an aside - what about spending money? I went this summer and I’ve been before and America is so wildly unaffordable for everything now you need a LOT of spending money.

Pppppplease · 18/12/2023 06:41

I'd let her go, 10 days off school as 4 of them will be weekends. Flight time is equivelant of around 3 days of that she can use to study. So 1 week to catch up on and knuckle down.
From my own personal experience I bunked majorly of my secondary school life, still managed to pass all my GCSEs and I have a successful career in finance. If you believe she is capable of catching up let her.
At the end of the day, you are her parent, not any of these mumsnetters so you make the final call. I just couldn't imagine telling her no now she knows about it, plus Florida is the best place on earth, she will love it.

Edit: just realised it's 3 weeks, id compromise to 2 weeks if you can, 3 weeks is a little excessive

Volpini · 18/12/2023 06:33

To everyone saying “she’ll catch up” …
I mentioned this post to my very bright, conscientious 14 year old (year 9.) Her reply? “Oh my god. Trying to catch up having had three days off sick in year 7 was massively stressful enough. I can’t imagine being in a situation where I’m deliberately trying to catch up THREE WEEKS. I feel sick just thinking about that.”
In my English Local Authority, anything over 10 unauthorised absences is referred to the LA. 1 unauthorised absence is a half day: 10 unauthorised absences is therefore 5 days off school… there is no way this trip would be authorised, so this amounts to 30 unauthorised absences… It blows my mind that this is a question anyone would even consider.

Luddite26 · 18/12/2023 06:29

TheaBrandt · 18/12/2023 02:32

Also like fuck are the hard pressed teachers going to help her out with missed work either. A friends Dd has missed chunks of year 10 due to mental health and is now unable to catch up. She’s a bright girl gone from top sets to foundation level her mother is worried sick about her life chances now.

Mental health problems impact your life more than lack of education. Tell your friend not to worry so much about this period there are lots of ways of accessing education post 16 if school aren't being so supportive.
My DD had MH problems all through secondary and ended up on an access course to go to uni, got her degree and masters. Still got the MH which still weighs heavy. But education is always there for people to access when they want to.

Fabulousdahlink · 18/12/2023 06:22

My reply exactly. Start of year 10 and GCSE's. Definitely too important to miss. She will not only miss out on the education, but forming new friendships in newly formed GCSE groups. Sends a message to the school that holidays are more important than exams
She's a little too old for Disneyland now, but if she still wants to go...make it a reward for good grades. That way everyones a winner.

alwaystroubleonmn · 18/12/2023 04:18

10 days is a better solution. I wonder if you could find out what topics they are covering in the first 10 days and get her to read over them in the summer holidays - probably unrealistic but I’d try to do a bit especially in Maths as she willl ferl quite lost when she gets back. (Apologies if this has been suggested the thread is too long)

TheaBrandt · 18/12/2023 02:32

Also like fuck are the hard pressed teachers going to help her out with missed work either. A friends Dd has missed chunks of year 10 due to mental health and is now unable to catch up. She’s a bright girl gone from top sets to foundation level her mother is worried sick about her life chances now.

TheaBrandt · 18/12/2023 02:29

It’s not a once in a lifetime trip. She’s literally got her whole life to go - op even says this family go every 2 years.
It’s of zero cultural benefit.
She will miss a chunk of a key year of education that is tested and those results will affect her future.
it gives her a shit message re work ethic / delayed gratification.
it’s simply not possible to get a tutor to cover missed class work for 10 odd subjects likely including practical ones.

Clear divide on this thread between those that value education and want to support their child to succeed in life and can see the “bigger picture” and those that…don’t.

SSE92 · 18/12/2023 02:20

I’d let her go - it’s a once in a lifetime trip, people are saying she could wait and go in 2 years time but what if something else comes up and prevents that from going ahead and she looses her chance. She’ll be a great age for it atm and likely learn so much valuable stuff about herself, other cultures, budgeting etc while she’s there.

To make sure she doesn’t miss so much at School, could you compromise and speak to her teachers and ask for ‘homework’ or study material that she could spend some time doing while away, on the plane and an hour here and there in Florida? Or hire a tutor for a few hours when she’s back to make sure she’s caught up on any classes she needs to hit a certain grade in?

Trust me, allowing her to go will be something she will always be thankful for. So many unexpected things can happen and change the whole course of our lives, but memories made are priceless.

TheaBrandt · 18/12/2023 02:19

Year 10 they do the content that is tested in the GCSEs at the end of year 11. GCSEs are now very content heavy post Gove so they gallop through the work in year 10. Missing chunks is likely to be impactful. Have you ever actually parented a teen?

Am actually wondering if you work for Disney marketing department you sound almost evangelical about it all.

GabriellaFaith · 18/12/2023 01:48

Still not GCSE year 😉

Yes it's just junk food if you walk around and pick food up. But EPCOT do foods from all around the world, and there are amazing dining experiences if you book things like the space centre (cant remember its name, but it's the only space restaurant!) the aquarium dining wasn't new food, but the quality was amazing, and certainly I haven't seen shellfish that big in England. Brilliant sat right next to all the sharks etc, similar to dining in the castles - the beasts castle has such beautiful attention to detail. The girls, for example, each had a cup moulded to look like the character chip. It came with edible paint for them to decorate it. There are so many good fun dining experiences at Magic Kingdom and Animal Kingdom from the rainforest cafe to storybook dining (my fav) and then the culinary experiences at Epcot, especially if there is a festival on. If you follow the space centre you've got a good chance of seeing a rocket whilst there too which we did one night as we were up late to watch the fireworks (they seems to launch really early or late, or maybe just happened that way during our trip!)

Dixiechickonhols · 17/12/2023 23:06

Iwantmyoldnameback · 17/12/2023 23:02

What on earth do you normally eat that your children got to try so many new foods? I can only think of those awful greasy turkey legs that are different to anything we eat over here.
And she's 14 now so 15 next year when the trip is planned.

https://www.disneyfoodblog.com/2023-epcot-food-and-wine-festival-booths-menus-and-food-photos/
I assume poster means food and wine festival at Epcot it will be on in September.

2023 EPCOT Food and Wine Festival Booths, Menus, and FOOD PHOTOS | the disney food blog

The EPCOT Food & Wine Festival is an annual celebration of global cuisine in Disney World! The dates for the 2023 EPCOT Food and Wine Festival were July 27 through November 18, 2023. Stay tuned fo

https://www.disneyfoodblog.com/2023-epcot-food-and-wine-festival-booths-menus-and-food-photos/

Iwantmyoldnameback · 17/12/2023 23:02

GabriellaFaith · 17/12/2023 20:46

Gosh someone's miserable 😂 The daughter is 14, so not a GCSE or anything else major year, plenty of time to catch up on a few weeks. The mum also said she couldn't ever afford anything like this and it's a once in a lifetime trip, I would assume from this that her daughter would also gain a lot from the whole experience as its not common. Going on an aeroplane for example, experiencing a different culture, it will all be part of it.

Our experience of Disney (taking the girls out of school for) was absolutely brilliant. They tried so many new foods, went on a helicopter flight, fed alligators, learnt loads at EPCOT, experienced loads of shows, swam unaided for the first time, one got over her fear of heights pushing herself to go on the rides, we did the typhoon lagoon glow party on their birthdays which they will never forget, we watched better fireworks displays than any in England, marvelled at how they speak English yet have so many different words to us (they counted over 100) and delighted in the magic of meeting princesses, a joy that they sadly will soon outgrow. Too much of our lives is spent sat down working. This is a one off for a few weeks. She can take any reading with her to do on the plane and then catch up with honework afterwards. It's not as dramatic as you make out. Goodness looking back now I wish I had never worried about my own exams so much and I had got to experience what they have!

What on earth do you normally eat that your children got to try so many new foods? I can only think of those awful greasy turkey legs that are different to anything we eat over here.
And she's 14 now so 15 next year when the trip is planned.

Teledeluxe · 17/12/2023 22:58

If she goes she may also get to meet young adults working in cartoon animal costumes, who are probably on minimum wage because they didn’t take school seriously.

notmorezoom · 17/12/2023 21:20

GabriellaFaith · 17/12/2023 20:46

Gosh someone's miserable 😂 The daughter is 14, so not a GCSE or anything else major year, plenty of time to catch up on a few weeks. The mum also said she couldn't ever afford anything like this and it's a once in a lifetime trip, I would assume from this that her daughter would also gain a lot from the whole experience as its not common. Going on an aeroplane for example, experiencing a different culture, it will all be part of it.

Our experience of Disney (taking the girls out of school for) was absolutely brilliant. They tried so many new foods, went on a helicopter flight, fed alligators, learnt loads at EPCOT, experienced loads of shows, swam unaided for the first time, one got over her fear of heights pushing herself to go on the rides, we did the typhoon lagoon glow party on their birthdays which they will never forget, we watched better fireworks displays than any in England, marvelled at how they speak English yet have so many different words to us (they counted over 100) and delighted in the magic of meeting princesses, a joy that they sadly will soon outgrow. Too much of our lives is spent sat down working. This is a one off for a few weeks. She can take any reading with her to do on the plane and then catch up with honework afterwards. It's not as dramatic as you make out. Goodness looking back now I wish I had never worried about my own exams so much and I had got to experience what they have!

swam for the first time and loved meeting princesses - primary age presumably? When missing school still isn't great, but totally different to in the GCSE year.

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2023 21:09

Also you say your kids are of the age to enjoy meeting princesses? So little. We are taking about missing chunks of your gcse course not flipping primary school. Veeerrry different.

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2023 20:59

It’s all so synthetic and man made. We’ve only been to the euro one and the Californian one. My now teens rarely mention either trip neither make the top three of our family holidays together.

Cantbeardarknights · 17/12/2023 20:53

GabriellaFaith · 17/12/2023 20:46

Gosh someone's miserable 😂 The daughter is 14, so not a GCSE or anything else major year, plenty of time to catch up on a few weeks. The mum also said she couldn't ever afford anything like this and it's a once in a lifetime trip, I would assume from this that her daughter would also gain a lot from the whole experience as its not common. Going on an aeroplane for example, experiencing a different culture, it will all be part of it.

Our experience of Disney (taking the girls out of school for) was absolutely brilliant. They tried so many new foods, went on a helicopter flight, fed alligators, learnt loads at EPCOT, experienced loads of shows, swam unaided for the first time, one got over her fear of heights pushing herself to go on the rides, we did the typhoon lagoon glow party on their birthdays which they will never forget, we watched better fireworks displays than any in England, marvelled at how they speak English yet have so many different words to us (they counted over 100) and delighted in the magic of meeting princesses, a joy that they sadly will soon outgrow. Too much of our lives is spent sat down working. This is a one off for a few weeks. She can take any reading with her to do on the plane and then catch up with honework afterwards. It's not as dramatic as you make out. Goodness looking back now I wish I had never worried about my own exams so much and I had got to experience what they have!

Not one part of me could even begin to think that a trip to Disney could in any way count as a necessary or cultural experience.

GabriellaFaith · 17/12/2023 20:46

Gosh someone's miserable 😂 The daughter is 14, so not a GCSE or anything else major year, plenty of time to catch up on a few weeks. The mum also said she couldn't ever afford anything like this and it's a once in a lifetime trip, I would assume from this that her daughter would also gain a lot from the whole experience as its not common. Going on an aeroplane for example, experiencing a different culture, it will all be part of it.

Our experience of Disney (taking the girls out of school for) was absolutely brilliant. They tried so many new foods, went on a helicopter flight, fed alligators, learnt loads at EPCOT, experienced loads of shows, swam unaided for the first time, one got over her fear of heights pushing herself to go on the rides, we did the typhoon lagoon glow party on their birthdays which they will never forget, we watched better fireworks displays than any in England, marvelled at how they speak English yet have so many different words to us (they counted over 100) and delighted in the magic of meeting princesses, a joy that they sadly will soon outgrow. Too much of our lives is spent sat down working. This is a one off for a few weeks. She can take any reading with her to do on the plane and then catch up with honework afterwards. It's not as dramatic as you make out. Goodness looking back now I wish I had never worried about my own exams so much and I had got to experience what they have!

Mikimoto · 17/12/2023 19:24

Blades2 · 17/12/2023 15:43

Firm believer here that the GCSEs are not the be all and end all.

id let mine go on the holiday

....says the failed applicant to Scunthorpe Poly...

ThanksItHasPockets · 17/12/2023 19:22

Absolutely fascinated to learn the grounds on which attendance fines are unlawful @Straightupmom.

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2023 19:21

Oh and if you don’t pay court fines.. you get to go to prison! Such fun!

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2023 18:51

Fun sponge 🙄🙄 you are like the mum in mean girls “I’m a COOL mom I have no rules I’m not like other mums” good luck with that.

StarlightLime · 17/12/2023 18:47

Get to know your rights
🙄