Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that with one caveat, being a single parent is actually not necessarily much different to parenting in a couple?

116 replies

Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 19:07

Genuinely interested in opinions on this as I could be totally off the mark. And I suppose unless you’ve experienced both situations (a single parent and parenting in a couple), it’s hard to say maybe?

But my experience… I ALWAYS wanted the standard family set up. I was utterly devastated when my ex left me and my two month old. I could barely function I was so sad. However… by the time she was 6 months I was honestly thriving. I joined baby groups and spent a lot of time with other women with children and noticed that nearly always someone was upset or complaining about their partner/husband. I realised how lucky I was to go home to a quiet house where everything was on my timetable. I had nobody asking why I wasn’t eating dinner with them/why I hadn’t bought dinner/have to ask when they’d be back. Nobody to wake me up if I wanted an early night. Nobody else to consider basically. I never in my life thought I would feel lucky to be in the situation I found myself in but I genuinely was.

I do think the one caveat is money. Ex paid a chunk towards dd despite never actually providing any of her hands on care and does just the one off fun day every so often (yes he’s a gem isn’t he). It’s meant that I haven’t had to spend my income on her at all yet, even with nursery fees his contribution covers it. I’m aware that could change and that I will always live in a state of uncertainty on this to some extent, which is a downside but I suppose you could say that also about being in a couple?

Overall I honestly think on balance I am glad I’ve done the first few hard years with dd alone. I realise this is probably because I am not in love and don’t have someone loving me and caring for me which I am sure many people have. But I do also know my closest friend was married before her ds and blissfully happy. Since their ds things have become very strained. I feel grateful not to have gone through that. I know other men that still behave incredibly selfishly but because they do a night feed or get up with their child once a week they’re seen as a good one in comparison to others.

I genuinely think that broadly speaking women are better off just cracking on on their own timetable. But.. maybe I’m wrong. Maybe I’m yet to experience a proper decent relationship. I certainly won’t have another child unless I feel as sure as I can be that the man is a decent one. And at 36 it looks unlikely I will find someone in time for more dc…

OP posts:
iolaus · 14/12/2023 21:31

It seems like your title is saying that it's not much different and then your post is saying how much better (and different) it is than if you had stayed with your ex

Not to say that either situation is harder/easier/better/worse but it is different

Circe7 · 14/12/2023 21:31

CapturedLeprechaun · 14/12/2023 20:45

I was married. Am now a single parent who works full time, with a 5,7&9yr old, and no family help.

ExH was a useless fuckwit and I much much prefer being a single parent. I love it in fact.

HOWEVER, it's harder in many different ways, and not just financially.

One of the kids has a football match that starts 9am on a Sunday morning and is 45 mins away? Everyone has to be up dressed and out the door to all go. If you had two parents, one would take the football child, the other parent could stay at home with the little ones.

One kid gets sick and needs an A&E trip in the middle of the night, and you all have to go together as there's no-one to have the other kids. Ditto for any activities/kids parties etc. Everyone has to go together all the time.

And even the useless husbands will sometimes do jobs like bringing the Christmas tree down from the loft, or mowing the lawn, or building new furniture, or sharing the long drives when you go on holiday. As a single parent, you have to do EVERYTHING yourself. I took my kids camping this summer and putting up a tent alone was hell.

Also, when you're sick and have kids, there's no one to pick up the slack.

This is so true. You can’t have any jobs that you hate / can’t do. I’ve taught myself to do a lot of diy which I couldn’t do before but it takes me ages. My ex was pretty useless but would move heavy stuff around and do a bit of diy etc. I spent last night fixing my hoover which is the sort of random job he might have done. I’m impressed by the tent - haven’t attempted that yet.

Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 21:30

@talkingteapots so so nice to read that you have ended up in such a wonderful position. And you sound lovely too.

OP posts:
Singleandproud · 14/12/2023 21:29

@muggart I think the difference nowadays is that if I am unsure of anything I'll come on here or look at other areas of the internet for the answers. I'm not completely on my own as single mothers in the 90s, 80s and before were. That's not to say every parent does that and perhaps your mum wouldn't have used the resource had she had it back then but perhaps she would have and would have had others to sense check decisions with

Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 21:28

@muggart this is something I often wonder… I always hope I’m doing my best but without someone there a lot of the time, there’s nobody to call me out. I do have a lot of friends and family around me but that’s not the same as having someone in the same house all the time. It’s an interesting point and I do try and question myself as much as possible, I suppose there’s not much more I can do.

@StarlightLime ridiculous because you don’t agree with it? I am simply sharing my experience, as I said I have no comparison with couple parenting and would like to experience that. Not sure how that makes this a ridiculous thread!

OP posts:
ChristmasPuddingPie · 14/12/2023 21:27

No but then you have one child. I have 4 and no it isn’t easier. Makes me laugh when people say it is. I’ve not had a night away from mine in 6 years and I’m at breaking point.

talkingteapots · 14/12/2023 21:25

I've experienced both...

My single parenting was on the extreme side, I had a 2 year old and 4 year old, the dad disappeared off with the army and my family were useless so I live 300 miles from them. I had no help, I was a single parent, single person, no car, no home, no job... it was HARD! Carrying shopping with two kids in tow, fitting what I could in the pushchair, begging and crying on estate agents floors that I would pay rent if they would please rent to me (always discriminated against for being on benefits). I cuddled my children and cried on the floor of council offices for a home - all they would do is say to private rent, but no one would rent to me... it was HARD!

Then, when my youngest started school, I had time. Time to get a job and time to date!
Because of this, I am now married with a 3rd child, we live in a million pound house mortgage free, we have a property business giving us a nice income, we have a couple of cars, my husband and I do school runs every day together. Life is not as hard as it used to be..

(To add, we built this life together after making good business investments and I had saved money from my job).

The young girl with two kids who was discriminated against by the estate agents is now the woman they call when they want some commission from a house they try to sell me!

I don't use estate agents. I sell my houses myself and I ask owners directly. I will never use an estate agent again after what I went through as a young mum.....

It was incredibly hard and difficult being a single parent for me. As oppose to having someone now.

StarlightLime · 14/12/2023 21:25

No. I don't think it's the same at all. Or similar. Or better. Frankly, it offends me when people suggest it.
Agree. Ridiculous thread, op.

muggart · 14/12/2023 21:24

Do you have any family support @Sunglenim ?

Single parenting seems very hard to me. I was raised by a single parent who had no family support and I think the biggest problem was that she had nobody to share the emotional load with, and there was nobody around to notice if she was making parenting mistakes. Just small things, like when my DB broke his fingers and it went unnoticed for nearly a week because she thought he was being a wimp. She was always constantly angry and stressed, and lashed out at us frequently but there was nobody who noticed who could tell her that she was damaging us.

I think we all need a second person to keep our behaviour in check.

myphoneisbroken · 14/12/2023 21:24

I am a single parent to one child and have also found it to be a really positive experience. There is a lovely dynamic to one parent-one child. The only thing I would say is that as I have got older (late 40s now), I can really see the difference in my standard of living to people who are in couples. (I don't get any money from DC's dad.) But it's worth it for me for the quality of life that doing my own thing provides. A lot of women I know are in relationships with grumpy men who don't pull their weight and I thank my lucky stars that that's not me.

VikingLady · 14/12/2023 21:21

My DCs both have SEN that mean school, nursery and babysitters are not options. Without DH I'd never, ever get a break. No buying bras without entertaining kids in the fitting rooms, no nights out with friends (though I'm only averaging one per five years), no quiet cuppa in a cafe for an hour.

If my kids were neurotypical I'd be better off single. Financially too.

Benibidibici · 14/12/2023 21:21

I hate the thought of dragging one to the others extra curricular activity particularly the young lively one who will not appreciate watching the older one have fun while he has to sit and be quiet with me. If I had my husband at home then I could leave him there and have some quality one to one time.

Even in a couple this happens loads, usually if one parent is taking kids to things after school, the other parent is at work.

Cupcakekiller · 14/12/2023 21:21

There are a lot of other factors involved that affect all the experiences so I can't claim to speak to everyone- money, support network, childcare, careers, mental health, ages and temperaments of the children, additional needs, health etc.

Cupcakekiller · 14/12/2023 21:18

Over the past 17 years, I've parented as a completely lone parent (with no input in anyway from the other parent), living with a co-parent and as a single parent with shared custody 50/50. They are all vastly different, completely disparate experiences. My personal favourite is 50/50 shared custody but there are pros and cons to all of them but they are very very different.

Ketzele · 14/12/2023 21:14

I have definitely found it easier parenting my two solo than it was with my needy, narcissistic, abusive ex. And also better financially since said ex didn't work or do childcare or cook or clean.

I expect my mum would say the same as her ex was a violent cheating alcoholic.

But I look at my friends who are in decent relationships and see what a difference that makes. Mutual support, money and time. The time to do things like help with housework, go out at the weekend because you got the chores done in the week, time to actually down tools when you're ill. And money to have a car, holidays etc.

I'm happy being single and my kids are doing great. But resources do matter and two parents generally have more to give than one.

Circe7 · 14/12/2023 21:12

I’m a single parent to a 1 and 3 year old with very limited support from their dad. There are things I like about it - I’m generally pretty happy - but practically it is completely different to being with a supportive partner (which mine wasn’t particularly). I’m utterly exhausted after only 1.5 years of it. You’re one person doing the work which two people might struggle with.

It’s mostly that I simply don’t have time to do everything I need to. And also that you have to keep going through everything- my worst experiences as a single parent have been baby, toddler and me all having norovirus and a day where I had a car accident and had to sort out all the logistics of that and get a replacement car etc. whilst really shaky and looking after children.

I’m lucky in that money isn’t a huge concern for me as I have quite a high paying career but the flip side is working a lot to catch up when children are in bed. Money is often a huge issue for single parents though and must make parenting so much harder even in small ways like not being able to go to paid activities or paying for extra childcare or help.

I think one child would be much more manageable. I’ve felt a lot of guilt around not being able to meet both my children’s needs or wants simultaneously. For example, I can’t take both mine swimming and a lot of experiences are a bit compromised unless I can find someone to come along with us. I only manage bedtime by distracting 3 year old with tv. I delayed taking the baby to a&e once because it would have involved getting 2 year old up and having them both there with me for hours. Equally nearby family willing to help in an emergency would make a big difference.

Ortila · 14/12/2023 21:06

Glad it's working out for you OP.

Long term the logistics get problematic - can't go anywhere alone, can't leave the house in the evening without a babysitter, childcare costs and arrangements are full on and last for 12 years, no swapping pickups and drop offs with another person. You get sick, you get tired, you break your leg - no matter, no days off for you. Boiler goes tits up, car breaks down, shower springs a leak - woman the fuck up and sort it out because no one else will. There isn't even anyone else there to run through your options. And ofc the maintenance - which is nowhere close to a second income - only lasts until kid is 18 at which point you're too old to get eg a second job.

Vettrianofan · 14/12/2023 21:04

I'd be utterly f*cked without DH as part of the family unit due to two children with additional needs, and having chronic health issues myself. I couldn't really cope without his support. Just being honest 🤷🏻 life isn't a breeze. I have several children though.

Ternbeach · 14/12/2023 20:48

I think it’s down to the partner surely. I have 3 children and would really struggle without dh, because we split a lot of things. Eg. One of us does dinner while the other cleans, take turns going out, or having one on one time with the dc, split school runs and nursery runs, split bedtimes etc. It would be a lot harder on my own, but then again some of the partners on here sound so useless I’d say you’re right in their cases.

CapturedLeprechaun · 14/12/2023 20:45

I was married. Am now a single parent who works full time, with a 5,7&9yr old, and no family help.

ExH was a useless fuckwit and I much much prefer being a single parent. I love it in fact.

HOWEVER, it's harder in many different ways, and not just financially.

One of the kids has a football match that starts 9am on a Sunday morning and is 45 mins away? Everyone has to be up dressed and out the door to all go. If you had two parents, one would take the football child, the other parent could stay at home with the little ones.

One kid gets sick and needs an A&E trip in the middle of the night, and you all have to go together as there's no-one to have the other kids. Ditto for any activities/kids parties etc. Everyone has to go together all the time.

And even the useless husbands will sometimes do jobs like bringing the Christmas tree down from the loft, or mowing the lawn, or building new furniture, or sharing the long drives when you go on holiday. As a single parent, you have to do EVERYTHING yourself. I took my kids camping this summer and putting up a tent alone was hell.

Also, when you're sick and have kids, there's no one to pick up the slack.

Littlemissnikib · 14/12/2023 20:41

I was married and we split up when my boys were 6 and 8. It’s been hard, both boys have ASD (one in special Ed and one with EHCP in mainstream).

But in a lot of ways life has been soooo much easier since we split up!!! I don’t feel resentment that he’s done nothing in the house or our disagreements on how to parent, or generally how lazy he is etc. I now have two children instead of three!!!! I’ve now been on my own for over 7 years and, quite frankly, can’t see me living with anyone/getting married ever again!

Guardian12 · 14/12/2023 20:36

You must have had an easy baby, I have a 6 month old and would have gone insane if I had to do this alone. I’m barely keeping my head above water as it is. She is totally full on and cries if she’s left alone in her bouncer or crib even for 2 minutes. And she is a terrible sleeper. The only time I can do things like shower, cook or nap is when my husband is home.

medianewbie · 14/12/2023 20:35

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 14/12/2023 19:27

Lone parent here of one child. That child has both ASD and SLD. On medication for sleep that hardly ever works. Only break is when child is in school. Child's DF pays fuck all and probably never will because they let him away with it.

No. I don't think it's the same at all. Or similar. Or better. Frankly, it offends me when people suggest it.

This.
I'm a (now) lone parent of two young people with Autism, SLD & Clinical Anxiety (had the 2nd before I realised 2nd had these issues). No support, no money, no daycare / overnights. Nothing. Obviously I'm at rhe extreme end of circumstances but no, it's not the same. Or even close.

fuckssaaaaake · 14/12/2023 20:27

I mean, if you don't have a douche husband then this is all void

Fionaville · 14/12/2023 20:21

I actually think that like anything in life, everybody is different, so will thrive in different set ups.
I'm happily married and have been for 20+ years. I've got a good one, who incidentally was raised by a single mum. She did a great job raising a strong, considerate and caring family man, which I've thanked her for! Our kids have definitely benefitted from having such a hands on, caring dad, certainly more than just the financial aspect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread