Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that with one caveat, being a single parent is actually not necessarily much different to parenting in a couple?

116 replies

Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 19:07

Genuinely interested in opinions on this as I could be totally off the mark. And I suppose unless you’ve experienced both situations (a single parent and parenting in a couple), it’s hard to say maybe?

But my experience… I ALWAYS wanted the standard family set up. I was utterly devastated when my ex left me and my two month old. I could barely function I was so sad. However… by the time she was 6 months I was honestly thriving. I joined baby groups and spent a lot of time with other women with children and noticed that nearly always someone was upset or complaining about their partner/husband. I realised how lucky I was to go home to a quiet house where everything was on my timetable. I had nobody asking why I wasn’t eating dinner with them/why I hadn’t bought dinner/have to ask when they’d be back. Nobody to wake me up if I wanted an early night. Nobody else to consider basically. I never in my life thought I would feel lucky to be in the situation I found myself in but I genuinely was.

I do think the one caveat is money. Ex paid a chunk towards dd despite never actually providing any of her hands on care and does just the one off fun day every so often (yes he’s a gem isn’t he). It’s meant that I haven’t had to spend my income on her at all yet, even with nursery fees his contribution covers it. I’m aware that could change and that I will always live in a state of uncertainty on this to some extent, which is a downside but I suppose you could say that also about being in a couple?

Overall I honestly think on balance I am glad I’ve done the first few hard years with dd alone. I realise this is probably because I am not in love and don’t have someone loving me and caring for me which I am sure many people have. But I do also know my closest friend was married before her ds and blissfully happy. Since their ds things have become very strained. I feel grateful not to have gone through that. I know other men that still behave incredibly selfishly but because they do a night feed or get up with their child once a week they’re seen as a good one in comparison to others.

I genuinely think that broadly speaking women are better off just cracking on on their own timetable. But.. maybe I’m wrong. Maybe I’m yet to experience a proper decent relationship. I certainly won’t have another child unless I feel as sure as I can be that the man is a decent one. And at 36 it looks unlikely I will find someone in time for more dc…

OP posts:
Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 23:42

SALWARP2023 · 14/12/2023 23:32

Surely what really matters is children spending time with both of their parents. OP used the word I a lot. How does DC feel ?

@SALWARP2023 id love it if he had dd half the time. I think that’s what’s best for dd for sure. He won’t though. I’ve tried many many times!

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 14/12/2023 23:36

If I was going to rank from hardest to easiest. (I've only experienced 1, 2, 4, 7 so the rest are guesses)

  1. In relationship, abusive/controlling partner.
  2. Separated, vindictive/lax/controlling ex who is causing harm to DC.
  3. In relationship, unsupportive/lazy/irresponsible partner.
  4. Single, uninvolved ex
  5. Single, trustworthy, adequate or better co-parent
  6. In supportive relationship, partner works away
  7. In supportive relationship
SALWARP2023 · 14/12/2023 23:32

Surely what really matters is children spending time with both of their parents. OP used the word I a lot. How does DC feel ?

StarDolphins · 14/12/2023 23:11

I split up with my ex 2 years ago & it’s been the easiest 2 years of my DD’s life. I feel relaxed & happy & therefore find it much easier. I did everything anyway & it was my house so no disruption.

Had I have had a partner where we worked as a team, I might feel different. Infact, probably wouldn’t be single! Not complaining though. I really like making my own decisions & not having someone thinking they’re ‘the man of the house’ & get to decide everything.

financially, I’m about the same. He never paid towards my mortgage, only half to bills. He pays the min maintenance but my shipping bill has massively reduced.

Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 23:08

I wish I was one of these people who had someone who added to my life! I’ve never really experienced that in a relationship and I guess that’s why I feel like I do about being a single parent. I guess that’s quite sad really!!!

OP posts:
Blessedbethefruitz · 14/12/2023 22:58

I would hate to be a single parent. I need that second person to split the load with (kids are 4 and 1, younger still breastfeeding). But because we both work full time and split the load, he's in charge of food - and we mostly eat separate things at separate times - and would very actively encourage me to go to sleep at 8pm with the kids.

Not having to consider someone else would be nice, but I really appreciate him in our lives, especially for moral support! We have no family or village though.

JaceLancs · 14/12/2023 22:49

I was a lone parent of 2 DC who are now adults
Negatives - low income overall over years due to this has meant I have minimal savings and not much of a pension
I rarely got a break - even when very poorly had no choice but to carry on unless I was actually in hospital
sometimes being the only decision maker is shit - whether it be about how to deal with a stroppy teenager or whether to prioritise a holiday over household repairs
I never got one to one time with either of them
Dealing with emergencies could be a nightmare - on more than one occasion something went wrong thousands of miles from home and I was the only adult
Sometimes I think they grew up too young as they had to step up for me as there was no one else eg I collapsed in a restaurant on holiday and DS had to try and get me back to where we were staying alone whilst DD was left to pay the bill with my cards - they were 13/14 and frightened and couldn’t speak the language
Positives
We are all incredibly close
I flourished in my independence and did far more with my life than I ever expected
I have immense satisfaction knowing I did it all on my own
They are amazing adults
I am very proud

burntoutnurse · 14/12/2023 22:27

I think it very much depends on who you're with.

I was married for 7 years, life was bloody hard and difficult all the time with 3DC

I divorced him and flourished as a single parent for 8 years,

Then I met dp.

He adds to our life and makes life so much easier. When he works away I hate doing it all on my own again for 2 months!

Hesma · 14/12/2023 22:21

Single mum to two here. Eldest is a stroppy teen and youngest has ASD. Lucky you to have it easy. My ex is ok but works away a lot and my family live 100 miles away so no, it bloody hard. Much easier as a couple in my experience.

TheHateIsNotGood · 14/12/2023 22:15

I know nothing other than being an SP, probably because I've found most men too lacking in the 'relationship' dept and medically-affected fertility due to some DV in early adulthood.

Yep, a lot of things are both harder and easier when you're a single person but most things are harder when you're an SP although a few things can be easier.

In my 60s I look around at the 'couples' and see the bits of life made easier but I also see their lifetime of resented compromises and the effects when changes occur - so I'm happy with my steady, unrelenting 'course' as an SP and long-term independent female.

Ittastesvile · 14/12/2023 22:01

I'm glad you are happy.

I've just done two days as a "single parent" (husband away) and it was much harder. But we are a team and tag team to keep on top of everything. Alone, something would have to give (either less attention for dc, messier house etc). I wouldn't be able to be a sahm, which I love. I'd have been in real trouble the week I had coronavirus and was bedridden and needed dh to hold the fort. I'd have to give up my hobby as it would be too many babysitters.

So basically I think good partner is better than single parent, which is better than bad partner.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/12/2023 21:46

Worrying about the finances alone in these very difficult times is very hard. Especially when your ex thinks the COL is a reason to reduce maintenance - rather than rein their own expenses in so as to contribute more to their kids.

It’s very hard when one is sick or has an injury and what to do with the other whilst you’re at an and e etc. Or when you need to go to the office / workplace but your child is sick - and your ex won’t step in because they’re your ex and would probably like to see you fail.

Freetodowhatiwant · 14/12/2023 21:46

It's really really hard being the only adult in the house and doing EVERYTHING for 3 people. All the cooking, all the tidying all the cleaning, all the shopping and planning, all the school admin, all the getting ready for school, all the getting ready for bed, not being able to pop out for a pint of milk if needed, all the emotional load, all the mental load, paying the mortgage all on your own, the bills all on your own, the clothes all on your own, entertaining them, getting them washed regularly, the constant laundry... the list is endless. Whilst I left ExDH so am relatively happy with that aspect of it I would certainly have appreciated someone else taking on their share of all of the above.

Weddingpuzzle · 14/12/2023 21:46

In my 20 years of parenting I've been a complete lone parent of one, a married parent of 3, back to a lone parent of 3 and now married again with a DH who takes an active role in supporting my parenting (but would never claim to be a parent).

I wish I'd had my DC with DH and had him in the newborn phase particularly. I would have had that experience of a shared child with someone who didn't fuck off/break my bones. I think that would have been easier.

If I had to rate my parenting experience I'd say lone parenting one, when I was in my mid twenties and tax credits genuinely helped me, was the easiest. Lone parenting three DC was second. Parenting three young DC with a monster, for a decade, was by far the hardest thing I've ever dealt with.

Willyoujustbequiet · 14/12/2023 21:46

ThickSkinnedSoWhat · 14/12/2023 19:27

Lone parent here of one child. That child has both ASD and SLD. On medication for sleep that hardly ever works. Only break is when child is in school. Child's DF pays fuck all and probably never will because they let him away with it.

No. I don't think it's the same at all. Or similar. Or better. Frankly, it offends me when people suggest it.

I'm in the same boat albeit with more than one DC and I agree with you completely.

It is staggering to me that anyone couldn't think it's anywhere close to being the same.

Elfandwellbeing · 14/12/2023 21:42

You have no financial worries, that plays a significant part in enjoyment of parenting however many adults are involved.

muggart · 14/12/2023 21:41

Singleandproud · 14/12/2023 21:29

@muggart I think the difference nowadays is that if I am unsure of anything I'll come on here or look at other areas of the internet for the answers. I'm not completely on my own as single mothers in the 90s, 80s and before were. That's not to say every parent does that and perhaps your mum wouldn't have used the resource had she had it back then but perhaps she would have and would have had others to sense check decisions with

This is a very good point!

AutumnLeaves333 · 14/12/2023 21:40

I have 3dc and being single isn’t practically any more difficult than being with their dad, he was never at home when they were awake anyway. The thing that is more difficult is that he now has them eow so actually spends more time with them now than ever before and we have very different parenting styles (his parenting style is very much akin to letting an 8 year old with a driving licence and some cash look after your kids for a weekend- lots of fun but no sleep, proper food or tooth brushing), whereas before the kids had just me parenting them and we all knew where we stood with rules and behaviour.

I do get eow to myself to do what ever I want which I’m not ashamed to say I absolutely love after 12 years of literally never spending a day away from my kids.

Money is definitely harder and knowing that as a single parent with 3 dependants I will never be able to buy a home for us which has been my dream for a long time, I’ve found it hard to accept we will always be renting now.

muggart · 14/12/2023 21:38

I took my kids camping this summer and putting up a tent alone was hell. @CapturedLeprechaun

We used to go camping as children and it never occurred to me how hard this must have been for my mum. I will remember to thank her when I speak to her next week.

I do remember every year she'd somehow carry / drag a massive Christmas tree out of the car, up the steps, through the front door and into the living room, all by herself (ok, we'd try to help but realistically we were no help whatsoever). To this day I'm not sure how she managed it!

BertieBotts · 14/12/2023 21:38

It's definitely easier to be on your own with a totally uninvolved ex, or an ex that is a bit annoying but basically trustworthy and who actually looks after the child sometimes, than it is to be in an unsupportive or particularly an abusive relationship. I totally understand what you mean. It's peaceful and nice not having to deal with someone else's bullshit.

And there's a horrible in between limbo as well which is when you've split from an abusive/vindictive/hair raisingly untrustworthy ex and you have to deal with all the fallout from them coming and going, turning up when they like, devastating the child, not knowing if your child is safe when with them, having to deal with abuse at handovers or them using the child against you, winding them up from Disney parenting, you just about get them calm from this and then it's time for contact again etc. That's not as bad as actually being in the relationship but it's shit and extremely stressful.

But I think YABU to say that single parenthood is just like being in a couple. It's nothing at all like it. Being in a supportive relationship is tons easier. It's just SO much easier and nicer. Someone to get excited about tiny little milestones with you. Someone to do the washing up when you're knackered. Someone to be around and give you a break so that you're not doing constant groundhog day up at 6 every day doing the same inane toddler crap every day tied to pick up every day having to make dinner for small humans 3-4 times a day and then get up all night and do it all again tomorrow. That's really hard when it's all on you. It's really hard being the one who has to cover all the illnesses and the appointments and the school holidays on your own. And money isn't a small thing either, it's basically THE thing that causes the statistically lower outcomes for children from single parent households.

Fireandsnuggles · 14/12/2023 21:35

ps I’m a single parent and my experience is different to yours. I find it tough when some coupled folks say to me that I’m lucky to be on my own and not have an annoying/unreliable partner like theirs etc… and at least I can rely on myself…. Meanwhile their lifestyle and regular evening hobbies are facilitated by their partner and not available to me.
So I probably have a vested interest in a more nuanced understanding of the variety of single experiences being out there…..

InflatableSanta · 14/12/2023 21:34

I was quite happy and thriving when it was just me and DS (ex was away most of the time), it was far easier than having a fairly nasty partner in the house. I really enjoyed it and we were happy. It's what made me realise I'm needed to leave my ex!!

It was largely ok when it was me and two young DC, but very definitely exhausting.

The time when it's really tricky as a single parent is when the child is ill or you are ill.

IncompleteSenten · 14/12/2023 21:34

Isn't that really just saying being in a bad relationship is like being single?

Because in a good relationship you work as a team. You are there to support each other, give each other a break, care about each other. You've got someone who will listen to you and who you are always there to listen to as well. You're not alone. It's not all on you. You've got someone who has your back.

Fireandsnuggles · 14/12/2023 21:32

I can see your post is true to your experience but I feel it’s a little misleading to say that having enough money is just one caveat: In another thread about ‘what’s the one thing that made your life easier as a parent’, the thing that came up most I thought was ‘having enough money/being well-off!’ and the widespread benefits it brings.
I think most single parents don’t have the cushion you have.
and I echo another pp that parenting alone without any co-parenting from an ex is quite different! Some people don’t have anyone on hand to help out when they’re ill or run-ragged….. or (perhaps) to babysit so they can also go out without babysitting costs. (Not sure where u are on this tho - you might be similar).

Sunglenim · 14/12/2023 21:31

Silverbirch7 · 14/12/2023 19:45

You don't say how old your child is but it's not just about out single parenting whilst they are little, these things are impactful for life.

If you meet a new partner then you are then into stepparent territory which comes with own issues 🤷‍♀️

@Silverbirch7 4 in jan. I agree that’s an area I worry about. I’d have to be very very sure about someone and I can’t imagine feeling that way.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread