Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
NotSorry · 14/12/2023 14:01

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:55

I honestly wouldn't know where to start, even as a newish Beaver Leader. I wouldn't know where to hold it without a lot of research, and where does the start up money come from? Ok so there's other be two parents interested to split the work but how many Beavers is that and shit someone needs to do the books. Now we need a bank account. So there's our two kids and a few more interested but their parents won't help. How do I get nekkers and how do you work out a name for your group and choose a nekker? What insurance do we need and crap what happens if Johnny falls over and has a lump on his head? Should have got first aid training....

It isn't like just inviting some mates round to play is it. Of you have a history of doing it and being in it, it's possibly pretty easy but for a parent who might even be willing to donate an hour or so a week to HELP, expecting them to legally and safety go off and start a group is a big ask

You don't just get thrown in at the deep end. Your District Commissioner is there to support new start-ups, all the other leaders are usually very helpful and there is a start-up fund from scouting HQ. You also get lots of training, including first aid. If you wanted to start a section, I'd start by contacting your local HQ. You can go onto scouts.org and say you want to volunteer and they will contact you.

https://www.scouts.org.uk/volunteer/volunteer-enquiry-form/

BigBoysDontCry · 14/12/2023 14:00

We used to organise lift shares all the time and when DC were beavers age and a were working parents we took turns at basically feeding 4 after school to get them all ready for beavers and dropped off/collected. That meant sorting it basically once a month. But it requires effort and coordination.

Pipistrellus · 14/12/2023 13:58

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:55

I honestly wouldn't know where to start, even as a newish Beaver Leader. I wouldn't know where to hold it without a lot of research, and where does the start up money come from? Ok so there's other be two parents interested to split the work but how many Beavers is that and shit someone needs to do the books. Now we need a bank account. So there's our two kids and a few more interested but their parents won't help. How do I get nekkers and how do you work out a name for your group and choose a nekker? What insurance do we need and crap what happens if Johnny falls over and has a lump on his head? Should have got first aid training....

It isn't like just inviting some mates round to play is it. Of you have a history of doing it and being in it, it's possibly pretty easy but for a parent who might even be willing to donate an hour or so a week to HELP, expecting them to legally and safety go off and start a group is a big ask

It would just be another night for the same scout group. Ours has two beaver nights, two cubs, two scouts.

Pipistrellus · 14/12/2023 13:57

blabla2023 · 14/12/2023 13:50

@SleepingStandingUp they do ask for parental involvement during normal work hours (wednesday 10 am to sort out equipment/clean the hut/…) and love to do surprise changes of location to some woodlands 20 min drive away….
Children (cubs upwards) who can’t go to camps (5 nights in a tent) can’t get badges etc. Many kids with disabilities can’t do 5 night in a tent without a carer, or deal with frequent last minute changes of plan

Edited

Is that all parents required on the weekday 10am or can you help in other ways? I have had no issues driving with only one car being a single parent, though yes no car would require organising lifts with other parents.

mn29 · 14/12/2023 13:55

Ours is a mix although we’re in an affluent area and the majority of people here are middle class!
I wonder why you think those who would benefit more “can’t get in the door” because it’s full of kids from wealthy families. Surely if you put your name on the list then you’ve got as much chance of a place as anyone else.

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:55

bridgetreilly · 14/12/2023 12:50

If the waiting lists are so long, why aren’t more parents getting together to set up a second group?

I honestly wouldn't know where to start, even as a newish Beaver Leader. I wouldn't know where to hold it without a lot of research, and where does the start up money come from? Ok so there's other be two parents interested to split the work but how many Beavers is that and shit someone needs to do the books. Now we need a bank account. So there's our two kids and a few more interested but their parents won't help. How do I get nekkers and how do you work out a name for your group and choose a nekker? What insurance do we need and crap what happens if Johnny falls over and has a lump on his head? Should have got first aid training....

It isn't like just inviting some mates round to play is it. Of you have a history of doing it and being in it, it's possibly pretty easy but for a parent who might even be willing to donate an hour or so a week to HELP, expecting them to legally and safety go off and start a group is a big ask

NotSorry · 14/12/2023 13:53

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:48

Why do you need all that? Why are kids with additional needs excluded?

They're not - I'm a cub leader and in the 12 or so years I've been doing it we've had lots of children with additional needs (all different types) along with several children in foster care. There are a lot of myths on this thread. However, the shortage of leaders is not a myth - I lost 3 leaders in the last 12 months due to house moves and I've not got anyone to replace them, so I have to keep my numbers down to cope.

BigBoysDontCry · 14/12/2023 13:53

It's not that wealthy people have more time, it's that they make more time.

There might be less single parents, but often they have moved for jobs and don't always have other family to help. Whereas often even the single household families have family support nearby in the social housing estate.

I don't know what the answer is as often there is good support for other local initiatives on the scheme like community council etc.

Maybe they do think Scouts is posh and not for them if there is no history of having a local troup? I grew up in a rough city estate and went to brownies and had a choice of groups, brothers went to a mix of cubs/Scouts and Boys brigade.

So I would never see it as a mc activity but maybe if I grew up without there being groups on the estate maybe I'd think differently? DH grew up in an industrial village and feels same as me but his group was more mixed as the village also had managers and a "posh" street.

Conkersinautumn · 14/12/2023 13:52

My parents, both from working class families met through scouts / guides which were heavily enmeshed with church communities. Which is why I've always avoided it for.my own children. I don't feel safeguarding is adequate, particularly when they are so desperate for volunteers. But not a class thing.

PhoebesHusband · 14/12/2023 13:52

@Smerk Do you use external instructors for activities? Climbing, sailing, kayaking type stuff. Local unit did that, the Scouts and Ventures got a higher standard that way. Weekends it took pressure off usual Leaders.

Quisto · 14/12/2023 13:51

No waiting list here, we could do with more children at every level. Most are local to schools with 25% fsm kids. There are camps, but there is a fund for people who can't afford them, and fundraising for more expensive events. Quite a mixed cohort, but all very friendly. Lift sharing is regularly offered and arranged.

blabla2023 · 14/12/2023 13:50

@SleepingStandingUp they do ask for parental involvement during normal work hours (wednesday 10 am to sort out equipment/clean the hut/…) and love to do surprise changes of location to some woodlands 20 min drive away….
Children (cubs upwards) who can’t go to camps (5 nights in a tent) can’t get badges etc. Many kids with disabilities can’t do 5 night in a tent without a carer, or deal with frequent last minute changes of plan

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:50

Smerk · 14/12/2023 13:38

This thread has made me think about how we can make our group more accessible to lower income families. We have already had a request to operate minibus transport to camp (not very accessible on public transport) which we've put in place for Spring.

Opening a second section is not an option for us without a serious increase in leaders as we'd need duplicates of all sections to accommodate the additional children as they age up in Beavers, Cubs, Scouts etc. Our section needs 5 adults for a normal meeting and 7 for a trip as it is (if we had full attendance).

We already open up our trips and camps to neighbouring groups in lower income areas with fewer leaders and children. We also advertise these groups to parents wishing to join our waiting list but most prefer to wait for our group.

Is there anything else we could realistically do?

How many Beavers do you have? I wouldn't limit Beaver size based on current Cub staff etc. parent volunteers will or can move with their kids. O didn't buy if it meant he wouldn't have had a space, I would. Would have screwed Beavers a little short term if I left but I'd have done both until a replacement was dound

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:48

blabla2023 · 14/12/2023 11:46

Ours is accessible to everyone who doesn’t need to work fulltime, has two cars in the family and has no special needs. Absolutely not accessible for parents working fulltime (kind of understandable, but excludes a lot of children), without access to a car at short notice, or children with any sort of special needs.
Very middle -middle class.
Waiting list is 2-3 years.

Edited

Why do you need all that? Why are kids with additional needs excluded?

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:47

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:48

Yes the leaders are very middle class.
They are fabulous, a few are grandparents who have been involved in the unit all their lives. The leaders are wonderful, so energetic & organised. My son loves it.

I do think there's an element of self perpetuation. We joined because I wanted him to, my nephew joined cos we were there. My twins will go to Squirrels. I volunteer. Another volunteer comes with her daughter and two class mates joined because their friend went. So that's a little glut and because the two adults are WC, that glut is. I imagine that volunteers will pull in their own circle to a degree, waiting lists aside (we've only just started one)

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 13:46

Smerk · 14/12/2023 13:38

This thread has made me think about how we can make our group more accessible to lower income families. We have already had a request to operate minibus transport to camp (not very accessible on public transport) which we've put in place for Spring.

Opening a second section is not an option for us without a serious increase in leaders as we'd need duplicates of all sections to accommodate the additional children as they age up in Beavers, Cubs, Scouts etc. Our section needs 5 adults for a normal meeting and 7 for a trip as it is (if we had full attendance).

We already open up our trips and camps to neighbouring groups in lower income areas with fewer leaders and children. We also advertise these groups to parents wishing to join our waiting list but most prefer to wait for our group.

Is there anything else we could realistically do?

We offer a monthly fee payment option instead of termly, and have free second hand uniform available. (Separate to discounted fees if someone can't afford to oay)

Smerk · 14/12/2023 13:38

This thread has made me think about how we can make our group more accessible to lower income families. We have already had a request to operate minibus transport to camp (not very accessible on public transport) which we've put in place for Spring.

Opening a second section is not an option for us without a serious increase in leaders as we'd need duplicates of all sections to accommodate the additional children as they age up in Beavers, Cubs, Scouts etc. Our section needs 5 adults for a normal meeting and 7 for a trip as it is (if we had full attendance).

We already open up our trips and camps to neighbouring groups in lower income areas with fewer leaders and children. We also advertise these groups to parents wishing to join our waiting list but most prefer to wait for our group.

Is there anything else we could realistically do?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 14/12/2023 13:36

Mine have done scouts (I never did as it wasn’t for people like “us”).
I felt like you did, but actually as I’ve got to know people within the entire scout world it’s not been the case at all.
volunteers tend to be wealthier as they have the time and the knowledge.

it Does seem very very area dependant, our area group has some incredibly wealthy areas and their scouts and leaders reflect the “jolly hockey sticks” type. Other areas the volunteers are self employed tradesman, so typically working class.

give it time, get involved if you feel you can. It’s been just incredible for my children, and my family. I never thought ours would be “my sort of people”, but they absolutely are.

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 13:33

Georgie870 · 14/12/2023 13:30

Not the case here. Our subs per term ar £12! Per term! Very popular and accessible to families from all walks of life and represented in the children who attend. Amazing group

Do they have an external source of income? I don't that even covers the annual fee to HQ... (which covers insurance, training etc)

ETA... its £38 in 2024

Georgie870 · 14/12/2023 13:30

Not the case here. Our subs per term ar £12! Per term! Very popular and accessible to families from all walks of life and represented in the children who attend. Amazing group

Shinyandnew1 · 14/12/2023 13:27

didn't think such a simple, affordable activity would be as attractive to the middle classes

You seem to be suggesting that people with more money wouldn’t like scouting because it’s affordable?! That’s a really odd mindset. People choose to do things for reasons other than the cost. Maybe they like the values? The range of activities? The fact it’s after school rather than 8am on a Sunday morning? The fact that you don’t need to be especially coordinated or ‘good’ at anything to be it, unlike football or karate?

Saying that only skint people should do scouting is a very odd mindset.

jemenfous37 · 14/12/2023 13:23

Having a pop at the MCs MNs OP?
Nice try

Sdpbody · 14/12/2023 13:22

My DD6 goes to Rainbows. When she was almost 5, I put her name on the waiting list as you have to be 5 to join. They said she was unlikely to get a space as they have an 18 month waiting list. There are 46 girls on the waiting list.
I asked if I could volunteer so she could skip the queue, and she started the week after she turned 5.

In our unit of 15, 3 go to private school, 10 go to two different outstanding school around a 0.5 miles away and 2 go to the good school next to the scouts hut. I would say 75% of the children will be MC and all live in two parent households. We live in a affluent area, with a choice of excellent schools. None of the 15 children are on FSM and none of them have EAL. All can read and write to their appropriate levels.

If you travel 3 miles down the road in the same town, the Rainbows is not oversubscribed at all. The children in that catchment area have a choice of 3 good schools, two of which have a BU, and all of them are in lower income areas. They have a higher than average FSM, EAL and many of them get support with fees. Almost all of them will be WC.

Area completely dictates how MC or WC a unit will be.

Our units termly fees are £50 instead of £30 for the latter unit. With the additional fees, we hold an outing once a term (rock climbing, zumba classes, cinema, pantomimes etc), and have an outside agency come to see us once a term, such as an animal holder, or Elsa for their Christmas party).

blabla2023 · 14/12/2023 13:21

@FlatterNow for ours, you needed a car available as last minute notifications “meeting will be at xyz, 20 min drive away, children who don’t join won’t qualify for the badge“ were fairly common. same with requirements like help to clean the scout hall thingy (of course at 10 on a workday!) etc. We stopped, it wasn’t possible to do all these things.

Ponderingwindow · 14/12/2023 13:10

There is no real waiting list in our area because every time a new age cohort comes up, the parents of that group just create a new unit.

I guess that supports your point op, it’s a very middle class school catchment area. The parents are expected to volunteer and they do. Other groups might not have the same time or the money to offset the costs of volunteering.

Swipe left for the next trending thread