Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 15:50

Moanyoldmoan · 14/12/2023 15:45

I remember emailing to go on the waiting list when my son was 3 and was firmly told it was closed. I then received a separate email asking for our occupations as there was a possibility we could get moved up the list. I told them it was shameful and I wouldn’t want my child to be involved if that’s the criteria they base entry on

I am another who doesn't believe this.

Moanyoldmoan · 14/12/2023 15:49

I can assure you this is 100% true - I was completely shocked too - my son is 14 now it was a while ago

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 15:49

There is no retirement age.

That would be completely ageist, against the Equalities Act and most importantly would deprive Scouting of many highly experienced, skilled and passionate volunteers.

KingsleyBorder · 14/12/2023 15:46

Moanyoldmoan · 14/12/2023 15:45

I remember emailing to go on the waiting list when my son was 3 and was firmly told it was closed. I then received a separate email asking for our occupations as there was a possibility we could get moved up the list. I told them it was shameful and I wouldn’t want my child to be involved if that’s the criteria they base entry on

I find that very hard to believe.

Moanyoldmoan · 14/12/2023 15:45

I remember emailing to go on the waiting list when my son was 3 and was firmly told it was closed. I then received a separate email asking for our occupations as there was a possibility we could get moved up the list. I told them it was shameful and I wouldn’t want my child to be involved if that’s the criteria they base entry on

CruCru · 14/12/2023 15:45

I think WombatChocolate makes some very good points.

Middle class doesn’t necessarily mean fantastically wealthy … but it can mean well connected and able to plan ahead. If your friend says that they’ve just put their child down for Scouts at age 3 and that the waiting list is 2 years, perhaps you’ll do the same.

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 14:56

WombatChocolate · 14/12/2023 14:01

I’ve found that the MC often like cheap and wholesome activities and flock to them. One reason Sure Start Centres closed was because the people they were targeting for support often weren’t interested and instead the MC wanted to join all the activities - and it wasn’t them that the government wanted to fund and support. Scouting and Guides do lots of outside activities, craft, charity etc. MC families often enjoy these seemingly simple activities and might well attend other stuff too such as swimming lessons, dance, sports classes.

I have also found that often the extremely privileged (boarding school kind of families) are less likely to be involved. Families with live-in Nannies and school hours that keep the kids at school until 6 and beyond often get most of their extra-curricular through school. Quite often they are not so invovled in the local community or community activities…..but generalisation of course.

And I think that most groups/classes and self-perpetuating in terms of the families they attract. People do like to go to things with ‘people like us’ and can feel uncomfortable being with those who might seem a bit different. It’s a shame, but it works in all directions. If there are a choice of local Scout groups , they might keep their local flavour because families who want to go find out about them and choose the one that seems to fit with their friends and ‘type’ of people. We like to think we aren’t bothered by this stuff, but actually most people are on some unwitting level.

Agree with this, the same families are the ones who will have the free meet the author or the free Christmas event booked at the library or local museum.. Always! They're on the mailing list or make it their business to phone & find out!

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 14/12/2023 14:52

There is a Guide group near here where 2 of the leaders are in their 80s. They have done it for 70 years and been involved in Guiding since they were young girls. To be fair, there is also a younger leader too - late 50s. It’s pretty old school in style but keeps attracting new comers.

I think many groups have ageing leaders. Their service is to Scouting and Guiding is absolutely admirable. I do wonder about the future of these organisations and if the younger generation have the same willingness to get involved. I actually think that the Scouting model in many areas of letting parents who volunteer fast track to the front of the queue has saved vast amounts of troops. Although some just volunteer a tiny bit or do a tear or two when their kids are involved (not knocking it - all help useful) others find it becomes a passion and end up serving long beyond when their kids finish. So getting parents invovled has made a huge difference to the organisation. Whether that’s enough long term I don’t know, but it is a huge loss to many areas when these groups shut down due to lack of leaders. Really hope they can keep going and society continues to value Scouting and volunteering.

PhoebesHusband · 14/12/2023 14:50

@Rewis I remember those arguments in the 60s and 70s, often about wearing uniforms. Also because Lord Robert Baden Powell the founder, had been an Army officer in Boer War.
People were 'unable' to understand what he did after he retired from army.

Scouting survived that, it changed and it will continue as long as there are kids wanting to join in the activities.

CurlewKate · 14/12/2023 14:49

@Rewis where are you? Not in the UK, obviously-there aren't any 60 year old women who are ex Scouts here! USA?

CurlewKate · 14/12/2023 14:47

@PhoebesHusband "Leaders have to retire at 65 I think. So 'old farts' get excluded. "

I'm choosing to treat this as crap humour. Can't deal with Mumsnet ageism today. But hey-have a think, huh?

Rewis · 14/12/2023 14:41

I'll also add that historically scouts have had a reputation of being middle class. One of my work placement instructors (now in her 60's) that she wasn't allowed to join the scouts cause that was for the better families. My mom was a scout but aowm of her friends were not allowed to join cause they felt it went against their socialist ideology.

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 14:39

@PhoebesHusband might be a local rule. Or maybe simply that the majority naturally retire. I'm a bit in awe of our Scout leader... he keeps the whole place running. Including our ground maintenance (being a village we have relatively extensive grounds with a field and woodland... the hut is rather decrepit though!)

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 14:39

Soj34 · 14/12/2023 12:45

Someone mentioned wc parents being put off or made to feel left out by the conversations other parents are having. Our cubs group is always running over the time so the parents have quite a while to talk in the waiting area.

My husband said the talk is often about where they're going skiing this year, wild swimming, that sort of thing. So he makes a judgement that they aren't like us. He doesn't care about fitting in though. Our son loves it and that's what's important.

This is pretty much how I made my assessment too, we wait in the corridor for the group to finish. Beavers aren't allowed out to the carpark so need whoever is collecting to physically come in. I listen in but don't have too much to contribute.
It just struck me that the families have loads going on besides the scouts. It's just one of a multitude. And the advantages & opportunities they are getting in scouts they are getting with their families too so it's advantage upon advantage. But that's life.

OP posts:
Rewis · 14/12/2023 14:39

I guess it would depend on thw location. Mine is in the "bad area" of the city. The kids are either working class or on benefits, majority are relatively new immigrants, applies reductions from the association, borrows the equipment, its still the cheapest hobby in area.

Where as my best friend is from more affluent area and they do annual hikes abroad and all types of cool and expensive stuff. But that's because the families in the area are wealthy.

PhoebesHusband · 14/12/2023 14:36

Sorry to mislead, I remember a conversation with a leader who had to retire in late 90s. Perhaps it has changed in the name of equality or because of shortage of Leaders.

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 14:31

@PhoebesHusband no retirement age... our Scout Leader is 73 and going strong! The old GSL only stood down when his eyesight failed... still the Quartermaster. Cub leader is late 60s. Beaver leader is early 60s. I'm the "baby" at 37.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 14:31

SleepingStandingUp · 14/12/2023 13:55

I honestly wouldn't know where to start, even as a newish Beaver Leader. I wouldn't know where to hold it without a lot of research, and where does the start up money come from? Ok so there's other be two parents interested to split the work but how many Beavers is that and shit someone needs to do the books. Now we need a bank account. So there's our two kids and a few more interested but their parents won't help. How do I get nekkers and how do you work out a name for your group and choose a nekker? What insurance do we need and crap what happens if Johnny falls over and has a lump on his head? Should have got first aid training....

It isn't like just inviting some mates round to play is it. Of you have a history of doing it and being in it, it's possibly pretty easy but for a parent who might even be willing to donate an hour or so a week to HELP, expecting them to legally and safety go off and start a group is a big ask

You don't need to start up a separate group. Groups can have more than on section in it.

e.g. our group has 1 x Squirrels, 1 x Beavers, 2 x Cubs and 2 x Scouts

So you don't need to worry about the answers to most of those questions as your current executive committee and GSL will organise the books, the insurance etc.

But as a newish Beaver Leader it sounds like you need to progress some of your training as you do need to know these and it would provide you with some assurance and help with confidence.

PhoebesHusband · 14/12/2023 14:29

@Conkersinautumn , It will vary from area to area, my experience is that most are not closely connected to churches, even if they use church premises. Four Groups I know have own premises on separate land. Safeguarding is taken very seriously, I used to keep the CRB register. We dismissed one leader as he was a bit 'Gung Ho' with young kids. Nothing serious just a bit 1950s.

Leaders have to retire at 65 I think. So 'old farts' get excluded.

It was a challenge when we opened Scouts to girls. But the novelty soon wore off.

CurlewKate · 14/12/2023 14:24

Participation in activities is often governed by money, transport, parent's free time and energy. Which often means that better off/middle class families are disproportionately represented, sadly. Our Scouts are like this because you can only get to meetings by car.

Smerk · 14/12/2023 14:12

Our Squirrel section is at the 24 child max, and Beavers are also at 24 (really the limit for the hut size) so it would be a second weekly meeting required for both. Which is a massive commitment from the leaders even with a couple of parent volunteers each week.

All my helpful DBSed parents are moving up to Beavers after Xmas so I have to start all over again getting the new Squirrel parents engaged.

A PP suggested second hand jumpers - we already resell generic red jumpers + a Squirrels logo badge for new starters at a fraction of the cost of the official jumper from the Scout store.

Sceptre86 · 14/12/2023 14:09

My dd goes to guides so not sure if it's very different to scouts but it's located in our town which was an old mining town. Lots of new housing estates have been built here and the town has gotten a lot bigger. It was typically a working class area but now has a real mix of middle and working class people. The volunteers are all lovely people and go above and beyond. My dd is shy and it has really helped her make friends with other little girls and helped her with confidence and teamwork. She can only go because dh takes her as I work on that day and am not normally home till after she starts. Appreciate it would be hard if both parents are working full time or perhaps shifts but we work around each other so he can take her.

blabla2023 · 14/12/2023 14:09

@BigBoysDontCry that also requires that they all are at the same school, or you live close. Nobody from my kids school went to the same beavers group (2-3 years waiting list, so you can’t change groups). Kids come from 7 different primary school…

WombatChocolate · 14/12/2023 14:09

mn29 · 14/12/2023 13:55

Ours is a mix although we’re in an affluent area and the majority of people here are middle class!
I wonder why you think those who would benefit more “can’t get in the door” because it’s full of kids from wealthy families. Surely if you put your name on the list then you’ve got as much chance of a place as anyone else.

Some types of family are more likely to be thinking ahead about extra curriculars, future schools etc etc. It’s a cultural thing to either think ahead or not. It’s a subtle barrier to entry. Of course no-one is preventing anyone of any background from putting their child’s name down. But word gets round amongst the middle classes when they meet at NCT classes, that you need to get your name down early…so people do it. Some groups miss the memo. Often it’s an example if ‘cultural capital’ and knowing the systems and how to make sure you’re on lists and at the front if the queue.

This is a similar thing to why certain groups apply to take 11+ or organise tutoring or preparation in advance whilst other groups with equally able kids don’t. Some know the system and some just don’t and awarent even aware there’s a system to know until they are on top of it and find they’ve missed the boat and you needed to sign-up years ahead.

There are all kinds of subtle reasons why people are able to or not able to access opportunities. Obvious forms of discrimination are far less common in most things these days. Most organisations are looking to broaden access and are aware of how cost can be a barrier. But it’s the other more subtle things of people feeling ‘thats not for people like us’ which continue as barriers and are very difficult to overcome and often generated by the users if the service more than the providers.

WombatChocolate · 14/12/2023 14:01

I’ve found that the MC often like cheap and wholesome activities and flock to them. One reason Sure Start Centres closed was because the people they were targeting for support often weren’t interested and instead the MC wanted to join all the activities - and it wasn’t them that the government wanted to fund and support. Scouting and Guides do lots of outside activities, craft, charity etc. MC families often enjoy these seemingly simple activities and might well attend other stuff too such as swimming lessons, dance, sports classes.

I have also found that often the extremely privileged (boarding school kind of families) are less likely to be involved. Families with live-in Nannies and school hours that keep the kids at school until 6 and beyond often get most of their extra-curricular through school. Quite often they are not so invovled in the local community or community activities…..but generalisation of course.

And I think that most groups/classes and self-perpetuating in terms of the families they attract. People do like to go to things with ‘people like us’ and can feel uncomfortable being with those who might seem a bit different. It’s a shame, but it works in all directions. If there are a choice of local Scout groups , they might keep their local flavour because families who want to go find out about them and choose the one that seems to fit with their friends and ‘type’ of people. We like to think we aren’t bothered by this stuff, but actually most people are on some unwitting level.