Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
blabla2023 · 15/12/2023 09:07

@PuttingDownRoots that’s the official line. but in the end it depends on the group leader, and with 2-3 years waiting lists you can’t change.
My son was at 8 years old very much marked as a “looser”, so we left. Absolutely no consideration…

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 15/12/2023 09:06

jocktamsonsbairn · 14/12/2023 23:04

Not read full thread but I agree with original post. We were priced out of scouts! The free or reasonably priced local camps were great then they started going overseas. DS wasn't getting all the camping badges and couldn't go on to be a leader or whatever it was due to having less overnight stays. When they told me it was "only" an extra £240 a month for 10 months for him to go camping g to Ireland then Switzerland before kit and camp specific hoodies, kilts etc etc we had to stop. Single parent with no financial support so it was unaffordable. We live in quite a deprived area and by the time we got to scouts it was middle class and upwards only. Beavers started out being very inclusive of the local community. Such a shame.

Ours have never done a foreign trip (except for jamboree)

week long camps and activities are around £200-£300

weekend camps are around £15-£40 depending where they go.
they have a minibus to take them and loads of spare kit.

And all of that can be free or subsidised at ours.

this thread just shows my point above, it’s like anything with multiple units, they differ, wildly.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 15/12/2023 09:01

CurlewKate · 15/12/2023 08:52

"Scouting is not a class based activity and ever child no matter what background, race, religion etc is treated the same. Sounds like the OP mindset is more the issue than anything"

In simplistic terms, Scouting is indeed open to all. But it's honestly not helpful to brush the hidden barriers to participation in any activity under the carpet. This doesn't just apply to Scouts, of course-it applies to any activity. For example- if you're already involved in Scouting you'll know that the big, expensive trips to Jamborees and things like that are few and far between and only a couple of kids go. But looking from the outside, it would be easy to think "I can't afford that-it's not for us." Our Scouts was only really accessible by car-and finished late. So very difficult for single parents, or night workers. Free uniform is often available- but asking for and accepting free stuff can be a huge hurdle. It's complicated.

That’s completely it

feeling like you can ask is a huge hurdle. No one wants to feel like charity.

ultimately scouts is like anything with multiple units, he it shops, schools, doctors, hospitals etc etc. Some are better than others, some are more inclusive than others. Chuck in the volunteer aspect and you’ve why it differs so much.

Cla43 · 15/12/2023 08:59

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:14

@PuttingDownRoots ours is the only one around here so it attracts from neighbouring villages. DS joined the Beavers in September & it's definitely not people like us! It's a lovely group, he's made friends with lovely girls & boys. The volunteers do trojen work to give the children amazing experiences all in their own time.
Maybe it was my own mindset, I didn't think such a simple, affordable activity would be as attractive to the middle classes

I’m not sure if we’d have the same idea of what middle class is but a simple affordable activity is exactly the sort of thing most middle class people I know are up for, like camping etc. The late Queen did brownies as a child I believe so it’s obviously always had a reputation as good wholesome activity for children. We would probably class ourselves and village as middle class, generally work on professional jobs like nurses and teachers, accountants, social workers etc but most of us don’t have much money. Enough to not have to worry about food and clothes for our children and have decent housing but definitely not much left over after that

BigBoysDontCry · 15/12/2023 08:58

When joining and at each point of moving group, the leaders have always had a discreet conversation about fees and uniforms and trips and the support they are able to offer. I presume they do this with everyone as we don't particularly give off an impoverished vibe. I guess that makes it easier to agree that you need support rather than specifically needing to ask. It does however mean that you've had to take that first step and put yourself out there to join. I'm sure there is information like that on the website too.

CurlewKate · 15/12/2023 08:52

"Scouting is not a class based activity and ever child no matter what background, race, religion etc is treated the same. Sounds like the OP mindset is more the issue than anything"

In simplistic terms, Scouting is indeed open to all. But it's honestly not helpful to brush the hidden barriers to participation in any activity under the carpet. This doesn't just apply to Scouts, of course-it applies to any activity. For example- if you're already involved in Scouting you'll know that the big, expensive trips to Jamborees and things like that are few and far between and only a couple of kids go. But looking from the outside, it would be easy to think "I can't afford that-it's not for us." Our Scouts was only really accessible by car-and finished late. So very difficult for single parents, or night workers. Free uniform is often available- but asking for and accepting free stuff can be a huge hurdle. It's complicated.

BigBoysDontCry · 15/12/2023 08:45

DS has the Queens scout award, he was able to use some of his DofE for that.

Ours have even done movie nights sleeping in the hall. Completely no cost, they bring some snacks in to share but wouldn't be turned away if they couldn't bring anything.

PuttingDownRoots · 15/12/2023 08:41

To get the top awards...
Beavers need 2 nights away in two years
Cubs need 3 nights away in three years
Scouts need 8 nights away in 3.5 years (including the expedition).

They don't need to go on week long camps miles away!

The Kings Scout Award and Explorer belt do require more but there is lots to do without getting those awards... they are extremely difficult for a reason

reluctantbrit · 15/12/2023 07:53

jocktamsonsbairn · 14/12/2023 23:04

Not read full thread but I agree with original post. We were priced out of scouts! The free or reasonably priced local camps were great then they started going overseas. DS wasn't getting all the camping badges and couldn't go on to be a leader or whatever it was due to having less overnight stays. When they told me it was "only" an extra £240 a month for 10 months for him to go camping g to Ireland then Switzerland before kit and camp specific hoodies, kilts etc etc we had to stop. Single parent with no financial support so it was unaffordable. We live in quite a deprived area and by the time we got to scouts it was middle class and upwards only. Beavers started out being very inclusive of the local community. Such a shame.

That is ridiculous.

Even our very m/c group only does a foreign trip every 4-5 years and then it's 18 months of small payments.
Maybe 1/3 of the group only goes.

Weeklong camps are around £500-600 in Summer and may be half of the children go.

While certain badges are linked to number of overnight stays, our group always did local ones and in some cases only food was required to pay as the location was free.

I think your leaders are trying to hard to impress.

Flopsyj · 15/12/2023 05:48

Scout volunteers have no more time than anyone else, it’s a mindset thing, not a class thing! Every scout leader at my group works full time and has a family, as well as volunteering. We are in a working class town and are constantly struggling for help. We have a lots of kids with non working / stay at home parents, not one of them has the time to help apparently! Scouting is very much open to all, if we do a high priced activity then we will fund raise for it, but children have to attend that fundraiser in to benefit from it to make it fair. We have free second hand uniform for those that need it. Scouting is not a class based activity and ever child no matter what background, race, religion etc is treated the same. Sounds like the OP mindset is more the issue than anything

blabla2023 · 15/12/2023 05:29

@jocktamsonsbairn similar to us , only for us it wasn’t money (we didn’t get that far), but (mild!!) special needs. No long camping trips from age 8, no badges. So why he could gave gone to the weekly sessions, he could not get most badges.
He went to a mainstream school, no ehcs, so relatively mild special needs. But several nights camping were not possible.

Bookworm39 · 15/12/2023 02:21

My son decided to apply for and got selected for the world scout Jamboree in Korea. We aren't affluent - far from it. I don't work as I'm an unpaid carer for his brother so we dont have spare money. My son worked extremely hard to fundraise despite having his own SEN issues and is still paying the amount back to us (we paid it using money left to him by a grandparent passing away). He did stalls, wrote to organisations to ask for funding and grants, and sold a lot of his old things on ebay. It wasn't just open to affluent parents - anyone could apply and be selected and work hard to go. And we live in a deprived region of the UK so it's not like he could charge some of the very high prices for things that others seemed to be doing!

SleepingStandingUp · 15/12/2023 00:39

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 14:31

You don't need to start up a separate group. Groups can have more than on section in it.

e.g. our group has 1 x Squirrels, 1 x Beavers, 2 x Cubs and 2 x Scouts

So you don't need to worry about the answers to most of those questions as your current executive committee and GSL will organise the books, the insurance etc.

But as a newish Beaver Leader it sounds like you need to progress some of your training as you do need to know these and it would provide you with some assurance and help with confidence.

Edited

I'm not important enough to know these, I'm not THE beaver leader, just an assistant one. But I do have the first aid training 😁

Benibidibici · 14/12/2023 23:23

Where I am if anything its the reverse. Its much more affordable than amost any other activity and has a high proportion of low income kids.

jocktamsonsbairn · 14/12/2023 23:04

Not read full thread but I agree with original post. We were priced out of scouts! The free or reasonably priced local camps were great then they started going overseas. DS wasn't getting all the camping badges and couldn't go on to be a leader or whatever it was due to having less overnight stays. When they told me it was "only" an extra £240 a month for 10 months for him to go camping g to Ireland then Switzerland before kit and camp specific hoodies, kilts etc etc we had to stop. Single parent with no financial support so it was unaffordable. We live in quite a deprived area and by the time we got to scouts it was middle class and upwards only. Beavers started out being very inclusive of the local community. Such a shame.

CynicalToad · 14/12/2023 22:54

For the very first Scout Camp on Brownsea Island, Baden Powell literally got children from different social backgrounds and mixed them up for a week. One of the great things about Scouting is that kids from different schools and areas get to know each other. Most groups and districts will be able to offer support to those struggling to afford activities but they don't necessarily know who needs help so be sure to have a chat with the leaders if that's something you need.

Anna79ishere · 14/12/2023 22:27

Why everything in the uk needs to be about class?!
scouts are worldwide and everywhere else they attract kids from all type of backgrounds, that’s the point of the group as well. How come in the Uk it should be an activity for WC or actually for just one class?
I find the obsession with classes so much puzzling, I do not get it

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 21:30

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 15:49

There is no retirement age.

That would be completely ageist, against the Equalities Act and most importantly would deprive Scouting of many highly experienced, skilled and passionate volunteers.

Glad to hear it. Our children have so much to learn from the older generation.

OP posts:
Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 21:28

PhoebesHusband · 14/12/2023 14:50

@Rewis I remember those arguments in the 60s and 70s, often about wearing uniforms. Also because Lord Robert Baden Powell the founder, had been an Army officer in Boer War.
People were 'unable' to understand what he did after he retired from army.

Scouting survived that, it changed and it will continue as long as there are kids wanting to join in the activities.

I guess when I think of scouts I think of Bear Grylls (who has written a book about "How to be a Scout") & posh toff Ben Fogle 😊

OP posts:
Leah5678 · 14/12/2023 19:30

Op it's likely you live in a wealthy area hence the people going to your local scouts are wealthier. It's really that simple.
Forgive me for assuming but you're probably not poor yourself so I'm not sure why you are complaining about scouts being too middle class, when you are (probably) a middle class family sending your kid to scouts

WombatChocolate · 14/12/2023 19:22

I agree that many people would be very fazed by organising or running activities for a bunch of pretty wild children. It’s Scouts not school and there’s definitely scope and need for letting off steam, but being able to organise and control a big group isn’t something that comes easily to all people. Leadership skills from being in certain roles at work will mean some people are more confident to volunteer than others.

And again it’s cultural to either get involved ir nit amongst different groups. As someone else said, certain groups are much less likely to volunteer for the PTA or to go on a school trip or anything like that. There’s a mixture of reasons - some are working and have no flexibility, some have small children at home which makes it difficult or are the only adult ir quite simply would never consider it as something for them. Some people are happy for their kids to attend things but also are a bit sneery towards the adult volunteers who help run the things as ‘dogooders’ or sometimes are very appreciative but just don’t think it’s the kind of thing they could do. With volunteering a lot is about having confidence in yourself to get involved, make decisions and often to provide leadership. Not everyone has this confidence or these skills. Many could develop them but just see it as being for a different group in society to do.

I’m picturing Phyllis the midwife in ‘call the midwife’ and her Scout troop in the 1960s. She was a skilled and qualified woman who was used to organising people and taking control in her professional life. The midwives took control with the mums-to-be that they worked with and it was a time when those mums-to-be didn’t expect to have much input but to be told what to do. Certainly in Guiding, until recently, many of the leaders were teachers and other professionals. A slightly teacherish manner or certainly ability to manage a large group of rowdy kids is needed to organise the kids and move things along. It’s not going to be everyone’s kind of thing and that’s fair enough. Even helping in the background rather than running things might be quite daunting for lots of people, as might mixing with adults you don’t know well to be part of a team.

user284246975787632445 · 14/12/2023 19:12

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 18:54

In my experience, the biggest barrier in volunteering with Scouts will be confidence.

First you have the fact its 20 or so children. If you have no experience, the idea of controlling that many children is daunting. Not just behaviour, but any additional needs, any medical conditions, any illness...

Then there's the skills part. In recent weeks I've taught CPR, how to make a cup of tea, electric circuits, Christmas card making, reef knots...

Then there's the paperwork. And your own training.

It all adds up. Once you've been doing it a while, its less scary. But at first, it can be overwhelming. Especially if you have no experience of Scouts.

Its not as easy as just starting a new section! You need people to learn from.

Nevermind the prospect of dealing with 20+ sets of parents...

Pipistrellus · 14/12/2023 19:00

Its not as easy as just starting a new section! You need people to learn from.

I'm not sure how it generally works but I'd think an experienced leader could move to the new night, and new leaders then split between both nights. The new night may be a better fit for some current families, then fill the spots from the waiting list. I don't see that it need be all new leaders and children.

BigBoysDontCry · 14/12/2023 18:59

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 14/12/2023 18:42

That’s not the case around me scout groups are run the majority by tradesman, the most working class, grown up on council estates, following dads footsteps into the trade people. They are able to add in the flexibility to enable volunteering.

yes there’s groups within our district that are very very middle class. But it’s a very sweeping statement, when it’s just your area

it is always the same people that volunteer for scouts, for the PTA, guides etc.

Never underestimate the mental load if your struggling financially, sometimes there just isn’t room to volunteer

As I said, I grew up in poverty as did DH. My parents always worked and there wasn't a benefit system anyway. We had groups locally run by a wide range of locals. Our brown owl was a barmaid who worked with my mum.

I was answering that mc people can outsource and therefore that's how they make time. That's not my experience. As I also said earlier, there might be lots of reasons why people from the social housing estate don't volunteer for scouts but I don't believe lack of time is the most likely reason.

greengreengrass25 · 14/12/2023 18:58

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 14/12/2023 18:05

It's not that wealthy people have more time, it's that they make more time.

they can afford to make time by buying in help, cleaners etc

I think a big part of it is “it’s not for people like us”
it was for my family growing up, it was also met with raised eyebrows by my family when I sent mine. It’s absolutely been the making of my kids though.

as for the driving to activities. I do get that, leaders do ask parents to car share or ask if they need lifts. In my experience those that are struggling the most are the last to ask. I’ve mentioned discreetly to the leaders about one family I knew were struggling, they now don’t pay for camps or subs. But they have to know to help and there’s no getting around that

I don't think that is always the case

It depends on your definition of MC

Swipe left for the next trending thread