Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
Donnaloveskebabs · 16/12/2023 08:42

We have an active unit with 150 odd kids and two groups at every stage. We have lots of leaders but have had to work very hard to say to joining parents you must join as leaders if we are to continue.
The camaraderie is amazing but it’s been a slog, but at least we have five leaders in our beavers alone and we only have to do a couple of sessions each term. (No idea about the other groups though.)
The parents who have joined as leaders are all from mostly affluent backgrounds and as much as we want to be inclusive - we need to prioritise kids of people who will lead.
There are lots of local units around here so lots of choice thankfully.

Bluebelle100 · 16/12/2023 08:32

Get involved and volunteer I did to ensure my x 3 children experienced some wonderful chances to partake in a string of activities. I was a full time working mother and managed it. I might add I was behind the scene volunteer doing hall/camp hire and website work. I would have loved to have been a leader but couldn't guarantee to attend week in week out plus all the planning and prep. I will be forever grateful to my local scout group for what they gave my children.

Pipistrellus · 16/12/2023 08:21

Ours has managed to start a new beavers night and squirrels section in recent years so there are parents out there that are willing. It sounds like you have lazy disinterested ones in your group. I think prioritising children with willing parents is the way to go.

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 06:53

@Pipistrellus "I meant parents (or grandparents or older siblings) to step up and be leaders and others weekly parent helpers. If there is a long waiting list then surely some should be willing?"

<hollow laugh> Parents at ours used to sit in their cars and watch as we carried the boats to the boat house. Even after emails begging for help.

Pipistrellus · 16/12/2023 05:36

Ours managed to open a second beaver unit and also squirrels in the last five years, now two groups each of scouts, cubs and beavers and one squirrels, it can be done.

Pipistrellus · 16/12/2023 05:31

Easier said than done though. Most groups struggle to recruit enough leaders to run the sections they already have - even with the offer of prioritising children if their parents step up - where are they going to find the extra volunteers they need to open a second night?

I meant parents (or grandparents or older siblings) to step up and be leaders and others weekly parent helpers. If there is a long waiting list then surely some should be willing?

Budgiegirlbob · 16/12/2023 00:41

People coming from all over other areas to join your Scout Group isn't right

Its fair though if, as the OP said, there are no other scout groups in a 20 mile radius.

I'd say there needs to be another night started and prioritise children if their parents are willing to step up and be leaders or weekly helpers

Easier said than done though. Most groups struggle to recruit enough leaders to run the sections they already have - even with the offer of prioritising children if their parents step up - where are they going to find the extra volunteers they need to open a second night?

Parentalalienation · 15/12/2023 23:35

My parents were very much working class, today they'd be in barely above minimum wage jobs if they were still doing similar jobs. They both lived for their scout volunteer commitments.
We were very definitely the poor people in the scout and guide troops, looking back my parents were providing this 'club' equivalent to children of teachers, lawyers, police, doctors etc.

ftp · 15/12/2023 23:08

Yes, it is usually great value for money, and now there is an availability of 2nd hand uniforms, and often support funds even for those, there should be wider access, if only we could get more leaders to add children to roll, and open new units.

There does tend to be access for those who are prepared to volunteer at some level, which is possibly why you have the situation in your area, but there is full support and financial help for anyone who wants to start a new unit, and there is nothing stopping you putting a child's name down - however, you do find that those "in the know" put names down at birth to obtain a place - your then get a self- fulfilling prophesy whereby people do not try because they believe they will not get in.
We have a dearth of leaders in both Scouts and Guides and many are run just by one or 2, which is not really enough, and many are people who run more than one unit, which can be insufficient number to offer the full range of experience.

The common reasons are "too busy", but if more people could just take parts of the time, more units would thrive (bookkeeping, record keeping, badge sorting, waiting list management can all be done in own time; shopping, craft prep can be less than regular activities; outing organisation or fundraising can be a one off, and perhaps once a term support, or offering your own skills for an activity once every couple of years)

I have just retired after 36 years of Rainbow Guides - started for my own daughter. It has taken me all of 6 years to find replacements, who are both former Rainbows of my unit, bringing their own daughters.
The camaraderie, training and skill development are great for leaders (and for the CV), but parents and the recently retired make great leaders too.

Mysa74 · 15/12/2023 22:48

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 10:17

There is no doubt that more well off families can take more advantage of all the opportunities though. DH is shortly taking some Scouts to Poland.. its a couple of hundred for the flights alone (very cheap once there) so some self excluded immediately

Children shouldn't be excluded like that though... At my group we'd organise it so that the cost is subsidised through through group fund raising that everyone helps to take part in, our local charity car park, quiz nights, duck races, raffles, bag packing at the local supermarkets, jack petchy awards etc.

MumChp · 15/12/2023 22:35

Not the case here.
All sort of childrenand it a cheap activity too.
But more grown up volunteers needed!

threatmatrix · 15/12/2023 22:29

Hid forbid middle class children have something to do. Jesus.

Pipistrellus · 15/12/2023 22:00

penjil · 15/12/2023 18:28

Op, if you want to prioritise local children, then can you not have a "catchment area" unofficially?

People coming from all over other areas to join your Scout Group isn't right.

It doesn't seem right to exclude children if it is their nearest group though, only at the point that another group is closer.

I'd say there needs to be another night started and prioritise children if their parents are willing to step up and be leaders or weekly helpers.

IncognitoIsMyFavouriteWord · 15/12/2023 20:15

Hahaha, definitely not. Very working class, DS started in cubs and went to scouts.

Sillyname63 · 15/12/2023 19:59

I would not say middle class, but it can get expensive ,with the cost of uniform, subs, camping trips, sponsorship when they are doing some activities etc. My daughter used to go to Brownies and Guides and it all mounted up. If you have more than one child going it is a good amount but then again most children's activities are expensive if you are limited budget.

penjil · 15/12/2023 18:28

Op, if you want to prioritise local children, then can you not have a "catchment area" unofficially?

People coming from all over other areas to join your Scout Group isn't right.

penjil · 15/12/2023 18:26

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 10:17

There is no doubt that more well off families can take more advantage of all the opportunities though. DH is shortly taking some Scouts to Poland.. its a couple of hundred for the flights alone (very cheap once there) so some self excluded immediately

A couple of hundred pounds to fly to Poland?!

I don't think so.....

RedToothBrush · 15/12/2023 16:16

CurlewKate · 15/12/2023 11:40

@BigBoysDontCry "But the fact remains that not everyone has unsurmountable barriers, some just can't be bothered unless all effort is removed."

Yeah, well. Presumably this mindset exists in all social groups and demographics. How about we stop using it as an excuse to justify ignoring the real barriers many people face? Well done for overcoming the issues you had. Shame it didn't make you more, rather than less willing to offer a hand to others.

But the problem remains this - a lack of leaders and the sheer amount of volunteer hours needed to run a successful group.

The biggest barrier of all is there being no one to run a group. Then no one gets to do scouting at all regardless of class.

If you want to get involved, you'll find a place in Scouting by offering that help.

The truth is we simply couldn't keep the group going if we didn't ask all parents to contribute in some way. We don't expect everyone to become a full on leader.

Asking all parents to contribute is the fairest way to do it - we cant pretend there's no work. And the trouble with making too many exceptions is that the pushy middle class types are the ones who try to take the piss on it most.

To my knowledge there's only been a couple of people who have been problematic with not understanding this issues and refusing to contributr. One I knew well enough to know that the bullshit she was coming out with about having no time was just laziness - she was married, lived two streets away and worked part time. The kid ultimately ended up having his place removed because she kicked off at being asked to do something (she'd been asked multiple times previously and she'd been told that if she didn't make an effort they'd rescind the place).

We've also found that the most affluent parents are also the ones who often emotionally neglect their kids round here and think they can buy their way out of helping. We can't afford to do this, because volunteer time is the most valuable currency to us.

We argue that a single mum with a couple of kids might not be able to run a night. There's no reason they can't help with admin at a time that suits them though. That's how we try to keep it fair and keep the work load down for other group members who do more directly with the kids. We are willing to give to those who struggle and we do financially help some who attend.

We try and help out other groups which aren't as well off too. It's good for all the kids - they get to mix and get to share equipment.

There is no simple solution to this. Since Covid ALL scout groups have struggled for volunteers and cash. A lot of the old leaders used the opportunity to finally give it up. And Covid financially screwed everyone - Scouting UK was forced to sell off assets and some groups folded. Then there was the great debacle of last year in South Korea.

Groups have to be financially viable and sustainable. They also have to have enough volunteers to keep going.

CruCru · 15/12/2023 16:14

Bigcat25 · 15/12/2023 14:28

Op, perhaps you could talk to the organizers about prioritizing the local kids, or kids who cannot afford other activities. It sounds like like the area could use another group of scouts, so maybe you could encourage that?

You are mistaken in thinking the middle class wouldn't be interested in scouts though.

By “encourage that”, do you mean set one up herself? I know that this sounds a bit snippy but telling thinly spread scout volunteers that they need to provide another group without offering to make this happen may go down badly.

When I’ve volunteered, one of the things that drove me crackers was people telling me how to volunteer in a more effective / satisfactory way without offering to help in any way. How would you prioritise local children or children who can’t afford other activities? Put in place a cut off distance (like school applications)? Have a maximum parental income? These are hard to do for a volunteer.

Bigcat25 · 15/12/2023 14:28

Op, perhaps you could talk to the organizers about prioritizing the local kids, or kids who cannot afford other activities. It sounds like like the area could use another group of scouts, so maybe you could encourage that?

You are mistaken in thinking the middle class wouldn't be interested in scouts though.

EWAB · 15/12/2023 14:03

Both my sons were scouts and eldest one volunteers for Explorers. I wouldn’t say it was exclusively middle class.
My youngest one is nearly 18 now. When they were going through Beavers, cubs and Scouts ( and youngest one with football) I paid in cash weekly.
Now everywhere is cashless and more pertinently paid at least half-termly in advance. I think this puts a lot of pressure on people especially those in non-professional jobs.
My cousin who has younger kids, is really, really middle-class struggles with finding money for extra-curriculars for three kids upfront for a term.

CurlewKate · 15/12/2023 13:46

Sorry-wrong thread!

CurlewKate · 15/12/2023 13:45

Herod doesn't appear in the Nativity story.

Chickenkeev · 15/12/2023 12:09

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 15/12/2023 12:00

No absolutely not.

Traditionally it was a cheap activity that taught useful skills. Lots of working class kids went, especially the children of skilled manual type workers.

It may have been out of reach of those on very low incomes, but when I was a brownie and my friends were cubs subs were 20p which wouldn't have bought you a half of lager, probably about the cost of a mars bar.

Uniform was always handed down and sold second hand.

Probably one of the most accessible hobbies/activities when I was growing up and when my parents were growing up. It is very sad if that has changed.

When i went about 30 years ago, it was expensive. It wasn't trying to be, but it was hard when you were poor. That said, i don't think people got left out of activities because of money.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 15/12/2023 12:00

No absolutely not.

Traditionally it was a cheap activity that taught useful skills. Lots of working class kids went, especially the children of skilled manual type workers.

It may have been out of reach of those on very low incomes, but when I was a brownie and my friends were cubs subs were 20p which wouldn't have bought you a half of lager, probably about the cost of a mars bar.

Uniform was always handed down and sold second hand.

Probably one of the most accessible hobbies/activities when I was growing up and when my parents were growing up. It is very sad if that has changed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread