Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
RidingMyBike · 16/12/2023 20:35

Re volunteer availability and more families needing two incomes - a lot of the Guide/Scout leaders when I was growing up were school teachers. They were used to children and enjoyed working with them, finished work early and had access to a photocopier, which seemed to be the essential criteria then!

Now all my teacher friends seem to work an incredible number of hours, certainly don't finish work halfway through the afternoon and spend their weekends planning and marking. They're just not available in the same way.

MaybeDoctor · 16/12/2023 20:22

What often happens in these situations is that people sail in and say ‘they’ should open up another troop. But who is ‘they’? It is a voluntary organisation after all.

I do also think there may be a case for taking a critical look at some of these voluntary organisations and considering whether it could be useful to contract in some paid help - perhaps on the administrative side? It would take a little while to train someone but then they’ll be worth their weight in gold. Or hiring a self-employed playworker once a week to be permanently part of the ratios?

I looked it up and Scout troops are deemed to be independent charities (although they don’t have to register with the Charity Commission unless they have income/property above a certain level). So perhaps there is a bit more freedom than might be thought possible?

Unfortunately I think the voluntary model has been in a slow decline since two incomes became essential to most households. The ever increasing documentation requirements (quite rightly so around activities involving children) have also been a factor putting off many volunteers. Scouts and Guides struggle to get people. PTAs struggle to get people. Community carnivals and fairs struggle to get organisers. Small charities struggle to get trustees. NCVO has reported an overall decline in volunteers, especially post covid.

The other thing that occurs to me is that many Scout huts and village halls were built in the post war period. Surely this building stock will need replacing in due course?

I am not sure what the solution is to either the volunteer or the building issue but suspect that costs to participants might need to rise sooner or later.

ItcanbeDone · 16/12/2023 18:51

Around my way our kids jumped to the front of a very long queue because my Husband volunteered to be a scout leader, which guarentees your child a place. We still had to pay £10 a month per child, but they have a lot of fun, and as we home ed our kids, we wanted them to be part of lots of groups to see other kids. Btw we live nr Chequers and it was pretty Tory-esque, now thanks to HS2 fudging up so much of the local landscape, old cottages and messing people about, not so much!

greengreengrass25 · 16/12/2023 18:03

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 13:00

I have to say that there's a issue over the working class v middle class thing to a degree on this too.

Some of the people struggling financially the most aren't necessarily those of a lower social class or from working class families.

We know that a bunch of middle class families locally are more stretched in terms of disposable income because they've mortgaged themselves to the hilts and then been stuffed by the interest rate rise. They haven't been eligible for financial benefits because they earn too much but can't drop their commitments either. Whereas some of the more working class families have been hit hard but actually come out with more disposable income. And this is especially true for middle class families with three or more kids compared to working class families with one kid.

It doesn't necessarily follow that your class automatically means you have more money for extra activities these days. That's actually a contributing factor as to why some people want benefits cut because they see people on low income ls and benefits financially more secure than themselves who work full time and pay for child care.

Very good point

MrsAvocet · 16/12/2023 16:23

People do put unreasonable demands on volunteers and sometimes I think we need to remind them - and ourselves - that we are volunteers and that we are entitled to set boundaries.
Not Scouting, but I'm a volunteer at a couple of Sports Clubs and I'm getting much better at saying no in my old age. I do care and I put a lot of time and energy into my volunteering but I won't be emotionally blackmailed into doing things that risk my own wellbeing anymore.

budgiegirl · 16/12/2023 15:41

They can't make us at the moment. That might change on a couple of years

I doubt they'll ever be able to make you open a Squirrel Drey. If District puts too much pressure on all ready over stretched groups, they'll lose the volunteers that they already have. I know our lovely GSL would walk if they put that sort of pressure on her. Luckily our DC is very supportive of his groups, and listens to what the leaders need.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 13:03

PuttingDownRoots · 16/12/2023 10:14

They can't make us at the moment. That might change on a couple of years.

District didn't even have the courtesy to tell us another local group was closing and they were directing the kids to us... we found out out when we had a multitude of transfer requests... which we couldn't fulfill.

We cover 5 primary schools and one secondary now.

No they still can't make you.

It's a volunteer organisation. They can pressure you but the word 'no' remains no.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 13:00

I have to say that there's a issue over the working class v middle class thing to a degree on this too.

Some of the people struggling financially the most aren't necessarily those of a lower social class or from working class families.

We know that a bunch of middle class families locally are more stretched in terms of disposable income because they've mortgaged themselves to the hilts and then been stuffed by the interest rate rise. They haven't been eligible for financial benefits because they earn too much but can't drop their commitments either. Whereas some of the more working class families have been hit hard but actually come out with more disposable income. And this is especially true for middle class families with three or more kids compared to working class families with one kid.

It doesn't necessarily follow that your class automatically means you have more money for extra activities these days. That's actually a contributing factor as to why some people want benefits cut because they see people on low income ls and benefits financially more secure than themselves who work full time and pay for child care.

DaphneMoo · 16/12/2023 11:16

Dc's scout group is mixed, it is very affordable including most camps. I have taken other scouts to camps if travel an issue and also donate outgrown camping gear and uniform ( not alone with this) so there is always a free supply available. What is needed is parents willing to take them when they are small. I have toyed with the idea of setting up a local group to take kids to and fro scouts and sourcing uniform / fees. I think it would be an excellent thing for some children with positive outcomes at minimal expenditure. ( I am not someone who volunteers for anything really but I have seen what a positive impact scouts has had for my dc who have had a tricky start in live, exposed to domestic abuse, paternal criminality, alcohol and drug use leading to prison and death)

Pipistrellus · 16/12/2023 11:13

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 11:06

@Pipistrellus "I'm a single parent, low income. My children are not privileged."

Privilege is not just about income.

Well back to the title we are not middle class. Our family has experienced disadvantage. Few families are genuinely unable to help out in any way.

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 11:06

@Pipistrellus "I'm a single parent, low income. My children are not privileged."

Privilege is not just about income.

Sartre · 16/12/2023 11:05

I disagree. It’s an extremely inexpensive hobby compared to many. My DC went before covid for a year or so and I’m almost certain it was about £10 a month for them to attend and camps were £20 or something. The most expensive part was the uniform.

Lots of other extracurricular clubs cost a fortune like swimming, dance etc.

Pipistrellus · 16/12/2023 11:02

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 09:16

@Pipistrellus "It sounds like you have lazy disinterested ones in your group. I think prioritising children with willing parents is the way to go."

Well, it is if you don't think Scouting is about more than giving privileged children more privilege......

I'm a single parent, low income. My children are not privileged.

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 10:21

@RedToothBrush "If you are too lazy to even get out your car when you are there, then I'm sorry but I don't give two shits about what class a kid is."

Me neither. I still occasionally see those parents in the supermarket and want to ram them with my trolley! 🤣 I remember one who actually emailed to complain about the session ending late......

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 10:17

Nobody has to buy uniform at our Scouts. And people who do buy it are strongly asked to donate it when their kids outgrow or leave.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 10:16

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 09:16

@Pipistrellus "It sounds like you have lazy disinterested ones in your group. I think prioritising children with willing parents is the way to go."

Well, it is if you don't think Scouting is about more than giving privileged children more privilege......

And the leaders left get burn out and quit so the group folds and no one gets to do anything any more and all future opportunities are gone too.

All because parents can't be arsed to even get out their cars and help.

It's that sole destroying stuff that kills off leaders.

If you are too lazy to even get out your car when you are there, then I'm sorry but I don't give two shits about what class a kid is. It's inexcusable. Sitting in your car expecting others to do all the work for you is the very height of privilege and entitlement.

I would be sending some really shitty emails out about it and spelling it out that you were quite happy to let the group go under if people don't step up. Maybe cancel a session or two because of a 'lack of leaders'.

Scouting is all about getting involved. It has to be.

It is impossible to be sustainable if families don't get involved. Not with the amount of paperwork and risk assessing as well as planning and running nights.

Budgiegirlbob · 16/12/2023 10:14

*Why open a squirrel unit if you don't want to?

We aren't keen on the idea because it's so hard to get leaders for Beavers as it is.

If you are getting pressure from District just tell them to sling it. They can't make you*

This. I really wouldn’t worry about opening a Squirrel section if you can’t/don’t want to. We’re certainly not going to in our group!

PuttingDownRoots · 16/12/2023 10:14

They can't make us at the moment. That might change on a couple of years.

District didn't even have the courtesy to tell us another local group was closing and they were directing the kids to us... we found out out when we had a multitude of transfer requests... which we couldn't fulfill.

We cover 5 primary schools and one secondary now.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 10:08

PuttingDownRoots · 16/12/2023 09:54

To put it into context the stats from our Scout group

Adult leaders... 5
Occasional helpers... 2
Other non leader adults regularly involved behind the scenes.. 4
Adults who will help when asked but no DBS... 4 or 5
Scouts... 22
Cubs... 23
Beavers 24

(All sections counted as Full due to section planning).

We are stretched too thin. We are dreading the expectation of opening Squirrels section.

Why open a squirrel unit if you don't want to?

We aren't keen on the idea because it's so hard to get leaders for Beavers as it is.

If you are getting pressure from District just tell them to sling it. They can't make you.

PuttingDownRoots · 16/12/2023 09:54

To put it into context the stats from our Scout group

Adult leaders... 5
Occasional helpers... 2
Other non leader adults regularly involved behind the scenes.. 4
Adults who will help when asked but no DBS... 4 or 5
Scouts... 22
Cubs... 23
Beavers 24

(All sections counted as Full due to section planning).

We are stretched too thin. We are dreading the expectation of opening Squirrels section.

Budgiegirlbob · 16/12/2023 09:45

Uniform is expensive, especially if the unit specifies they need all of it including trousers/leggings and hat

Most scout groups will only specify a need to buy the top - so jumper or shirt. Parents might be asked to pay for the necker too, although many groups include this in their subs. Anything else, IMO, should be an optional extra.

However, I agree with you if you are talking about Rainbows or Brownies though. We had to buy top, hoodie and leggings when my DD joined rainbows, and it wasn’t cheap!

Budgiegirlbob · 16/12/2023 09:33

I meant parents (or grandparents or older siblings) to step up and be leaders and others weekly parent helpers. If there is a long waiting list then surely some should be willing?

I understood what you meant - but, at least in my area, recruiting parents is very difficult. We regularly offer for children to skip the waiting list inn return for weekly help, but very few take up the offer.

Ours managed to open a second beaver unit and also squirrels in the last five years, now two groups each of scouts, cubs and beavers and one squirrels, it can be done

I’m not saying it can’t, but it’s rarely as easy as ‘just ask parents to step up*. It generally takes either a surplus of current leaders (rare) or a big recruitment drive. And given how stretched for leaders many groups are, current leaders may not have to time, energy , or resources to do this.

The average scout volunteer, according to the Scout Association, stays an average of 2 years. So recruitment is a constant battle. I’m lucky with my cub pack to have enough leaders at the moment, but we’re losing one soon when his child moves on to scouts. And the group as a whole lacks enough leaders. We certainly would struggle to open another section.

CurlewKate · 16/12/2023 09:16

@Pipistrellus "It sounds like you have lazy disinterested ones in your group. I think prioritising children with willing parents is the way to go."

Well, it is if you don't think Scouting is about more than giving privileged children more privilege......

RidingMyBike · 16/12/2023 09:03

Uniform is expensive, especially if the unit specifies they need all of it including trousers/leggings and hat. One unit we were with had a thriving secondhand thing going on where you could pick up the next size cheaply (or probably free if necessary) BUT that depended on the leader's good relationship with the church as she had cupboards in the hall to keep it in and her free time to sort into sizes, find what someone had asked for etc.

Our current unit has barely any storage space in the church hall and doesn't offer any secondhand uniform. But they do only ask them to have the hoodie or the t shirt.

RidingMyBike · 16/12/2023 08:46

It is in the area we relocated to. We moved into quite a deprived area and tried to transfer DD into Rainbows - the only units were much further away in better off neighbourhoods!

Some of it is knowledge/awareness - I’d been a volunteer with Guides for years so knew I wanted her to do it so got her onto a waiting list as a baby. When I mentioned it to other parents at the play area after school not many had heard of Rainbows (particularly those from another country), had no idea what was involved or lacked the ability/time to get them to meetings. A 4.30pm start somewhere a drive away without public transport excludes a lot.

And more MC type jobs are more likely to offer employer-supported volunteering which helps people attend training, go to camp without using annual leave. It’s one of the reasons I stopped volunteering as I just couldn’t keep up with what the other Guiders did as they had a lot of employer support for preparation and events. Especially for younger age groups the meetings start early which makes it very difficult to fit around many jobs. Someone in insecure shift or zero wage work isn’t going to have employer support for volunteering either.

The Brownies were now at runs during university term time as several of the leaders are students. But that also means a more MC/university-focussed area.

Swipe left for the next trending thread