Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 17/12/2023 08:18

Budgiegirlbob · 17/12/2023 08:07

Parent rotas can be an excellent volunteer recruitment tool. If all parents have to come along to help on occasion, then sometimes you’ll find a parent or two who really enjoy it, and volunteer a bit more, or even step up every week.

I do accept though that it can be very difficult for some parents - and an individuals circumstances should be taken into account. But it’s quite rare that a family can’t provide any help at all - even if it means sending along a grandparent, aunt, friend etc, having to bring a younger sibling for the evening, or helping at a weekend activity or fundraiser instead.

Or those who can't help are put off joining, as that poster was referring too. She couldn't help so her children couldn't join.

Wobblybobb · 17/12/2023 08:16

I think it's doable depending on your job.
I've been a leader over 10 years, it used to be easier for me to run sessions etc BUT my job has become far more stressful with more hours (over my full time) making it incredibly hard to plan and run sessions. I am the only leader.. we lost 4 after covid.. Ive pleaded with parents to help but none will. I've announced that the group will close by summer if parents don't step up. (Im a full time working line parent with no financial help
or other help with my dc - they come with me to meetings / camp and are now young leaders but I cannot carry this on balancing everything much longer).

as for being middle class.. that is entirely down to your area.. we've had children brought to us from over 15 miles away because of the reputation of the group. I know a local group, because of their location, also has some very affluent members and their camps are amazing due to parents being able to afford more than the average parent. There's also another local group who fundraisers and subsidies the group and their camps because they are in a poorer area and this is the only holiday a year these children have.

Budgiegirlbob · 17/12/2023 08:07

PuttingDownRoots · 17/12/2023 07:50

I think a PP is referring to their local group having a Parent Rota. Some groups enforce these. Not a fan personally... even just a small snapshot we get of our Cubs lives how it could be a stress too far for some families.

Parent rotas can be an excellent volunteer recruitment tool. If all parents have to come along to help on occasion, then sometimes you’ll find a parent or two who really enjoy it, and volunteer a bit more, or even step up every week.

I do accept though that it can be very difficult for some parents - and an individuals circumstances should be taken into account. But it’s quite rare that a family can’t provide any help at all - even if it means sending along a grandparent, aunt, friend etc, having to bring a younger sibling for the evening, or helping at a weekend activity or fundraiser instead.

Pipistrellus · 17/12/2023 07:57

PuttingDownRoots · 17/12/2023 07:50

I think a PP is referring to their local group having a Parent Rota. Some groups enforce these. Not a fan personally... even just a small snapshot we get of our Cubs lives how it could be a stress too far for some families.

Oh OK, it was the way they said 'running a session', like to be the one in charge, not 'helping with a session'. It would be few parents that couldn't help on an occasional night or send a family member in their place. We have a young leader who brings his little cousin and that's every week.

Patchworksack · 17/12/2023 07:55

Surely the only problem is there are not enough volunteers to meet demand? If there is a long waiting list they need another group to open. The solution to that is in your hands.

PuttingDownRoots · 17/12/2023 07:50

I think a PP is referring to their local group having a Parent Rota. Some groups enforce these. Not a fan personally... even just a small snapshot we get of our Cubs lives how it could be a stress too far for some families.

Pipistrellus · 17/12/2023 07:49

Gorggnu · 16/12/2023 21:27

It was running a session or no place in my area - maybe it varies in different areas.

Were they trying to start another night at the time? You wouldn't have a parent of every child running a session.

GirlsAndPenguins · 17/12/2023 07:45

I went to brownies on the council estate I grew up on. Our idea of a camp was sleeping on the floor of community centre where it happened, going to the local park at night and the rough chippy on the way back 😂. Genuinely the least middle class extort my life!

Flopsyj · 17/12/2023 03:03

Gorggnu · 16/12/2023 21:15

Absolutely correct that there are barriers to kids doing brownies/scouts/woodcraft folk type activities.

My 3dc can't do any of these. I'm a lone parent (widow so no DH to help), work full time and commute. I can't volunteer to run a session, so no place for my kids.

The lack of curiosity or understanding in some posts on here about why not everyone can volunteer - and blaming "laziness" - is hurtful and comes across as self-righteous.

I'd gladly contribute financially for someone to run sessions. Why on earth should kids be excluded because of their parent(s)' circumstances?

Volunteering isn’t just ‘running a Section’. Yes that is great, but groups also need a board of trustees, as it a chair, secretary, someone just to voice an opinion etc. some of these roles can take up as little as an hour three times a year, and not one person can tell me they don’t have three hours a year to spare to help, no matter how much else they do! The issue is everyone assumes volunteering with scouts means kids.. but that’s not correct.

Circularargument · 16/12/2023 23:50

It's your area, not the Scouts, and you don't have nearly enough information to make sweeping generalisations about what it's ' always been'. The organisation is over 100 years old!

Wherehas2023gone · 16/12/2023 23:32

My son is currently in scouts in the north east and there is definitely a mix. The leaders are amazing and really inclusive.
Growing up my local cubs and scouts were from all social classes from children in the local primary to cousins of the future king. Everyone was there as an equal in the corrugated iron village hall. That was the brilliant thing about it (apart from I had to go to guides in the next village because I was a girl!)

MaybeDoctor · 16/12/2023 23:23

I know it’s not what you or anyone else wants, but if society is changing then it may be a case of adapt or die?

user284246975787632445 · 16/12/2023 23:04

Or will people still be complaining about Scouting, Guiding and the lack of volunteers and spaces for their children in 2050?

I'm not convinced they'll still exist, certainly not by the end of the century. Society has changed unrecognisably since they were founded.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 22:36

MaybeDoctor · 16/12/2023 22:12

@RedToothBrush
Your tone is a little aggressive. To refer to my post as ‘incoherent’ (meaning incomprehensible or unclear) is patently untrue as it is written very clearly and in comprehensible English. You simply didn’t agree with it.

Anyway, if you look again at my second paragraph you will see that I never used or implied the word ‘employee’. I said ‘contract in’ and ‘self employed’. Small pre-schools and playgroups (who also struggle for both money and volunteers!) sometimes use paid administrative support in this way - I know people who have done this work while being largely a SAHM.

I grew up in Girl Guiding so I am on your team, but just wonder if an alternative to today’s purely volunteer-led model might need to emerge. Society has changed a lot since the movements were first established so change is surely inevitable.

Or will people still be complaining about Scouting, Guiding and the lack of volunteers and spaces for their children in 2050?

I'm not being aggressive. It just makes absolutely no sense and isn't realistic given the state of finances for numerous groups I know. Some can't afford ANYTHING - some are struggling to keep afloat at all. And they tend to be the ones in the least affluent areas too, who certainly couldn't afford to then raise subs to find it - because that would force more into hardship cases which can't be sustained by the rest of the parents.

I'm saying it because I know how desperate finances are for many groups across our district. I know how we've bailed out other groups in the past in various ways.

We are an affluent group by the districts standards. And even we can not afford to fund anyone part time and if we can't it makes it absolutely impossible for any other in the district. Our treasurer is a close friend and I know the state of the books. We have some reserves but we still need to spend it wisely to ensure long term viability. That includes ensuring we have enough money for the maintenance of the building as you point out as being a huge consideration. We have to rely on volunteers. And I don't think we are that unrepresentative.

Given the premise of this thread is about scouts being middle class and out of reach of many working class families, (which I don't think is particularly true) I find suggesting adding additional costs to parents absolutely insane too. It a total missing of the context of the thread.

Beyond that the issue I have really is about parents who think they can just want to buy their way into scouts and then wash their hands of it. If you want a professional organisation like that join cadets. That's not scouting.

Scouting isn't about that at all. It's about community engagement and involvement. And that for me includes parents who understand and value that. The second you allow 'buy in' it kills the ethos of that and kills a huge part of scouting. It comes from leading from example and putting back and then encouraging the kids to do the same. If you miss the point with that, you don't understand scouting at all - it's just another activity after school.

Budgiegirlbob · 16/12/2023 22:33

It was running a session or no place in my area - maybe it varies in different areas

it would be very unusual for a child to be turned away if it was impossible for their parent to help out at the occasional session. That said, there are very few people who genuinely can’t help - even if they need to ask a grandparent, sibling, or adult child to attend in their place. However, if you can genuinely NEVER help, or help in a different way, then it does seem unfair to turn your child away.

However, this is a different situation to allowing a child to jump the waiting list if the parent volunteers to help on a regular basis/be a leader. It’s only fair to allow this , as extra leaders mean the group can continue to operate, or even expand if enough step up.

Dasy2k1 · 16/12/2023 22:20

When Baden Powell started scouting in 1907 he deliberately mixed boys from several social classes for the experimental camp on brownsea island.
We have endeavoured to keep that the case ever since with the children we have (scouting allowed girls in the 90s for all Sections)

Of course most groups will reflect the local population fairly accurately but that's to be expected

And no group wants to have a waiting list. We would much rather open additional sections so we didn't have to have one. But as always we don't have enough adults to run the sections we do have as we would like to let alone open more.

It's honestly doable even while working full time and is very rewarding

MaybeDoctor · 16/12/2023 22:12

@RedToothBrush
Your tone is a little aggressive. To refer to my post as ‘incoherent’ (meaning incomprehensible or unclear) is patently untrue as it is written very clearly and in comprehensible English. You simply didn’t agree with it.

Anyway, if you look again at my second paragraph you will see that I never used or implied the word ‘employee’. I said ‘contract in’ and ‘self employed’. Small pre-schools and playgroups (who also struggle for both money and volunteers!) sometimes use paid administrative support in this way - I know people who have done this work while being largely a SAHM.

I grew up in Girl Guiding so I am on your team, but just wonder if an alternative to today’s purely volunteer-led model might need to emerge. Society has changed a lot since the movements were first established so change is surely inevitable.

Or will people still be complaining about Scouting, Guiding and the lack of volunteers and spaces for their children in 2050?

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 21:28

Gorggnu · 16/12/2023 21:27

It was running a session or no place in my area - maybe it varies in different areas.

Well did you plead your case with hardship due to circumstances?

Yes it's down to individual groups but they will generally be flexible if you do offer something.

Gorggnu · 16/12/2023 21:27

It was running a session or no place in my area - maybe it varies in different areas.

Zanatdy · 16/12/2023 21:25

Not at all in my experience

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 21:25

Gorggnu · 16/12/2023 21:15

Absolutely correct that there are barriers to kids doing brownies/scouts/woodcraft folk type activities.

My 3dc can't do any of these. I'm a lone parent (widow so no DH to help), work full time and commute. I can't volunteer to run a session, so no place for my kids.

The lack of curiosity or understanding in some posts on here about why not everyone can volunteer - and blaming "laziness" - is hurtful and comes across as self-righteous.

I'd gladly contribute financially for someone to run sessions. Why on earth should kids be excluded because of their parent(s)' circumstances?

It's been said multiple times that there are other volunteering roles which are not running a session.

RedToothBrush · 16/12/2023 21:24

MaybeDoctor · 16/12/2023 20:22

What often happens in these situations is that people sail in and say ‘they’ should open up another troop. But who is ‘they’? It is a voluntary organisation after all.

I do also think there may be a case for taking a critical look at some of these voluntary organisations and considering whether it could be useful to contract in some paid help - perhaps on the administrative side? It would take a little while to train someone but then they’ll be worth their weight in gold. Or hiring a self-employed playworker once a week to be permanently part of the ratios?

I looked it up and Scout troops are deemed to be independent charities (although they don’t have to register with the Charity Commission unless they have income/property above a certain level). So perhaps there is a bit more freedom than might be thought possible?

Unfortunately I think the voluntary model has been in a slow decline since two incomes became essential to most households. The ever increasing documentation requirements (quite rightly so around activities involving children) have also been a factor putting off many volunteers. Scouts and Guides struggle to get people. PTAs struggle to get people. Community carnivals and fairs struggle to get organisers. Small charities struggle to get trustees. NCVO has reported an overall decline in volunteers, especially post covid.

The other thing that occurs to me is that many Scout huts and village halls were built in the post war period. Surely this building stock will need replacing in due course?

I am not sure what the solution is to either the volunteer or the building issue but suspect that costs to participants might need to rise sooner or later.

Right so where does the money come from for paid help? And who are these mythical people who can put in these hours? Are they going to be people who have other jobs? Or teenagers who have very little skills to offer?

And as you point out, how do you fund that on top of new building stock? Just at the time when scouting UK got stuffed by last year's jamboree and will be forced to sell off assets? (Which won't be local buildings because they are owned by local groups not scouting UK).

And at the same time this whole conversation is about keeping it accessable to those struggling financially the most... Which if you add in the costs of hiring an employee (wages and NI etc) just makes it more expensive.

Your post is incoherent in its consistency.

Our group successfully raised money for a new building. It involved a lot of fundraising, imagination and making the most of grants and asking businesses for donations. So it's doable. The building was financially viable - then COVID hit and it caused issues. Then the cost of heating the building hit and lots of groups using the building folded because people are struggling to avoid to go to other activities groups. It has to be run like a business in it's own right which isn't easy - it can't afford to support a paid employee. That's in addition to Scouting. So in some respects there's a lot to be said for groups to hire third party buildings so they don't have that additional work.

In terms of leaders and how many hours a week they work, I know several leaders who do / did 60 hours a week plus and still did Scouts AND something else. So I think that's a point that doesn't really stand up either. It's definitely down to mindset not the amount of time people have.

I really do not think there is an alternative model that allows scouting to remain the characteristic of being cheap. It can't carry on without volunteers.

stargirl1701 · 16/12/2023 21:22

I volunteer as 'the badge lady'. I order required badges and pop them into envelopes. I don't attend the meeting. Scouting has lots of admin roles - it's not just about volunteering to run a meeting.

Gorggnu · 16/12/2023 21:15

Absolutely correct that there are barriers to kids doing brownies/scouts/woodcraft folk type activities.

My 3dc can't do any of these. I'm a lone parent (widow so no DH to help), work full time and commute. I can't volunteer to run a session, so no place for my kids.

The lack of curiosity or understanding in some posts on here about why not everyone can volunteer - and blaming "laziness" - is hurtful and comes across as self-righteous.

I'd gladly contribute financially for someone to run sessions. Why on earth should kids be excluded because of their parent(s)' circumstances?

Flopsyj · 16/12/2023 20:46

RidingMyBike · 16/12/2023 20:35

Re volunteer availability and more families needing two incomes - a lot of the Guide/Scout leaders when I was growing up were school teachers. They were used to children and enjoyed working with them, finished work early and had access to a photocopier, which seemed to be the essential criteria then!

Now all my teacher friends seem to work an incredible number of hours, certainly don't finish work halfway through the afternoon and spend their weekends planning and marking. They're just not available in the same way.

One of our leaders is a secondary school leaders. He works particularly long hours as it is a prestigious grammar school but still finds time to attend two different section meetings a week. He brings his lesson planning to camp and does it when the kids go to bed. We have other leaders that work 50hr weeks, shift work, all kinds of things. As someone else has said, leaders are normally people that are already extremely busy people

Swipe left for the next trending thread