Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
Thesearmsofmine · 14/12/2023 11:22

It depends on the group.
My eldest used to go to one which was very cheap (£2 a week), it was very much a working class group but it wasn’t great, the leaders couldn’t control the kids and they didn’t really do anything at the sessions and it closed.

Now he (and younger siblings) are at another group and it’s like another world, they do so much, it’s brilliant for the kids but it would be inaccessible for some families as they often go to different areas for activities which isn’t doable if you don’t drive or work anything but 9-5 plus some of the activities are payable on top of the usual subs(£5 a week), some are £15/£20 which is a lot especially when you have more than one dc.

gotomomo · 14/12/2023 11:21

It could also be that the "so affordable" fees are out of the reach for the poorest anyway, even subs of £3 is a lot when it's subs or bread & milk!

Clubs tend to reflect where we are - many of our choristers were on free school dinners, apparently this was possibly unique for a robed paid choir, and we got recognition for this, but it reflected the location and our attitude to recruiting, it's easy to approach private or c of e schools only, getting into state schools isn't easy but that gave opportunities to those who benefited more

KingsleyBorder · 14/12/2023 11:20

RudsyFarmer · 14/12/2023 10:25

Hmmmm. I don’t know if that’s true or not.

The only thing I will say is by the time the kids are the age to attend Scouts you get a fair few drop outs because it’s not considered cool anymore.

The boys that continue on do seem to be a certain type of child, and those kids do seem to have the kind of parents who are keen for them to continue going and it becomes a non-negotiable alongside music lessons etc.

So it stands to reason that he younger groups of beavers/cubs might have more of a mix of families and scouts/explorers might have a different demographic.

This is a very good observation. I come from a strong Scouting and Guiding family - my Granny was an honorary Guiding leader into her 90s! and my Dad was a Scout leader.

I remember very strongly how all the cool girls dropped out at around age 13 and it was seen as so uncool and I was desperate to leave as being bullied for it at school, but could not let the family down. I’m glad they made me stick with it though.
our area was very socially diverse but by the end it was definitely the more academic girls who were still going. That did seem to correlate to us being the more middle class ones too.

StillWantingADog · 14/12/2023 11:19

Very mixed where I am, as is the general demographic of the area

of all the extra curricular my kids do it’s probably the cheapest and best value
the camps are FAR cheaper than school residentials.

HailMary1988 · 14/12/2023 11:18

No waiting lists for our village group and the group seems to reflect the village school.

I find the opposite actually - over the years of my children attending it seems that the children who go to private school never come to beavers, cubs or scouts. They seem to start private school and then rarely mix with other children in the village.

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 11:17

@Greatballzoffire he WSJ basically had to be abandoned... mixture of corruption and extreme weather. Its cost British Scouting alone over a million pounds alone I believe.

Suddenlychrimbo · 14/12/2023 11:17

I think in our relatively 'naice' village the leaders of Brownies and Scouts are churchy people who actively try and get as much of a diverse background as possible, especially 'economically'. They see the value in breaking down class barriers and the assumptions that -both ways- families might have.

It's a bit heavy on on the religious aspect sometimes but the groups probably wouldn't exist without them - quite difficult to find willing volunteers these days that aren't connected to the church .

Barnowlsandbluebells · 14/12/2023 11:17

60% of people in the UK are considered to be middle class - why on earth wouldn't scouts be an activity for the average British person?

brunettemic · 14/12/2023 11:15

Weird assumption. Our DS is in Scouts and DD is in Cubs, they love it and it’s a huge range of people that go (I’m making assumptions based on cars, clothes etc!). The waiting list is long because it’s a really good group but others in the area don’t have such long lists.

I think it’s £15/month each, so inexpensive, and for any trip they provide financial support if needed.

To be honest, OP’s post is strange. Waiting list length and financial status have no correlation, unless in her area you can buy your way up the list.

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 11:13

@IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads the one in South Korea? I remember giving a few quid to fundraisers but ds wasn't a member at the time, only got his place in September.. Why was it ill fated?
Amazing experience for the lucky kids but obviously ruled a lot of capable children out of the running

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 14/12/2023 11:12

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 14/12/2023 10:54

I'm an Explorer Scout leader (but have done Cubs and Scouts) - our catchment is socioeconomically diverse. We plan our activities to be low cost, and give 9 months notice of larger camps to allow for trickle payments.

I did find it very disturbing that the only people who were interested in attending the (ill fated) World Jamboree last summer were from very affluent households, who had the times/means/resource etc to fund raise £4K. I couldn't get anyone else to sign up, despite promising that the unit would help fundraise. When £100 for a passport is unacheivable, what's the point?

In fairness, I don't see that trip as the best use of £4k. You could buy my car twice for £4k, and I can neither afford to spend that on a scout trip, nor do I want my son to be fundraising £4k to go on holiday to Korea.

Fundraising for charity is one thing, but this is very different to me.

FictionalCharacter · 14/12/2023 11:11

That isn't the case in our area.
It's for everyone, and of course middle class children are attracted, they enjoy the activities like anyone else.

Lavender14 · 14/12/2023 11:09

It depends on the area the group serves as others have stated. Dh runs our local scout group. Very working class area and they need to be flexible on fees and activity costs to enable local children to attend. The next closest group to that one would be full of very wealthy families and fees are much higher etc. So it just depends.

I guess it's the same as anything though, if you don't have the means to pay fees of any sort then your children couldn't attend.

Throwhandsupintheair · 14/12/2023 11:08

Not those pesky middle classes again! We managed to campaign to get Labour to add VAT to education to punish them for Tory poor management of state education. Now they are fucking up Scouts!

We have to find a way to stop them from putting their kids on the waiting lists of Scout groups. Should we campaign for a special fee so that anyone over a certain amount of income get charged? That way only the kids of low earners and the super rich can go Scouts. That’ll teach them!

Wemetatascoutcamp · 14/12/2023 11:06

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 10:29

Getting rid of waiting lists could be a solution, just opening it up to registration the school year they turn 6 (or 4 for Squirrels). In the areas with long lists you do need to know the system. But again, that's tends to come from who you know rather than class.

Even if you did that you’d still get more registrations that you have spaces for so inevitably you end up with a waiting list? Numbers are capped by TSA so you can’t just keep taking YP in and not all groups can run at maximum numbers it does depend on the number of volunteers/how many children the volunteers feel comfortable with (and this can also vary depending on the needs of the current YP).

We deliberately only took kids names from 5 1/2 for beavers to avoid the folk trying to put babies on the list to try and ensure a place (we paid no heed to that anyway but it meant a less overwhelming list).

To answer the original post I think our group generally represents the make up of our local community so a real mixture of classes. TSA is keen on promoting scouting in deprived areas and has funding ring fenced for areas of deprivation but as PP’s have said thats reliant on adults volunteering in those areas. We find volunteers are either a) parents who want their children to be able to experience scouting or b) adults who really enjoyed their experiences during scouts and want to give something back. Unfortunately there’s rarely enough volunteers to meet the demand for spaces.

Also to add my GF was a scout in the 1930’s then a scout master as an adult and definitely was working class.

reluctantbrit · 14/12/2023 11:05

We are in a very m/c area and therefore the Scout pack DD is in is very m/c too.

In other areas of the borough you have packs where they rely heavily on grants/donations to enable even the basic camps or paid-for activities as the parents can't afford more than the annual subscription.

I am definitely not outdoorsy apart from gentle walks but the Scouts give DD huge skills, experiences she would normally not get, learn to do things she is not that keen but does because the team has to do them and makes lots of friends.

Pluviophile1 · 14/12/2023 11:03

There is a long waiting list for our cub and scout troops because the demand is high. Nothing to do with people travelling from outside areas or from an abundance of middle class families in our area. I'm not sure why middle class families should be less entitled to attend though. Places aren't allocated on a socioeconomic basis.

Availability is dependent on people volunteering as scout leaders and helpers. You could volunteer to help set another group up locally. That might help those children you mention that 'could do with & afford scouts' have a chance of attending.

greenmarsupial · 14/12/2023 11:01

My kids are both in the Scouting and Guiding systems and it strikes me as very middle class.

I don't think it's a cost thing as it's the cheapest thing they do. It's partly because of the idea of prioritising an activity like that. Depending on the number of children in the household, extra curricular activities can be fairly low priority even when cheap. When I worked in a school, we tried really hard to get the FSM children to go to (free) after school clubs but there was often resistance to having a separate/ later pick up time.

The other thing is that you often have to to come up with certain items or equipment fairly last minute. You have to have a fairly organised and affluent house to produce a rolling pin/ apron/ camping equipment at very little notice. The help is there if people want it but again it's a matter of priorities.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 14/12/2023 10:54

I'm an Explorer Scout leader (but have done Cubs and Scouts) - our catchment is socioeconomically diverse. We plan our activities to be low cost, and give 9 months notice of larger camps to allow for trickle payments.

I did find it very disturbing that the only people who were interested in attending the (ill fated) World Jamboree last summer were from very affluent households, who had the times/means/resource etc to fund raise £4K. I couldn't get anyone else to sign up, despite promising that the unit would help fundraise. When £100 for a passport is unacheivable, what's the point?

RudsyFarmer · 14/12/2023 10:49

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:48

Yes the leaders are very middle class.
They are fabulous, a few are grandparents who have been involved in the unit all their lives. The leaders are wonderful, so energetic & organised. My son loves it.

The good old community-minded middle class yes?

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:48

RudsyFarmer · 14/12/2023 10:41

Have you considered it wouldn’t exist at all if it wasn’t for the volunteers? We’ve had a few groups close because no one would step forward to run them. If I think of all the leaders I know, guess what? They are all middle class women and men 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

Yes the leaders are very middle class.
They are fabulous, a few are grandparents who have been involved in the unit all their lives. The leaders are wonderful, so energetic & organised. My son loves it.

OP posts:
DogInATent · 14/12/2023 10:48

It's probably a combination of several things, but boiling down to:

  • A lack of volunteers to run groups creating a hard supervision limit to the number of scouts that can be supported
  • Over subscription for the places available in the few groups in the area
  • Self-selection of those parents prepared to wait it out on a list
One of my colleagues is a Scout Leader. They decided several years ago that if they didn't step up their children wouldn't have the opportunity.
YireosDodeAver · 14/12/2023 10:48

A scout troop doesn't just happen as a spontaneous phenomenon. Volunteers create it. If there's a shortage of spaces in an area with a years-long waiting list then more volunteers are needed to step up and make a new troop happen. When I was a girl guide back in the late 80s the troop I was in was getting so popular it couldn't cope with demand so we bifurcated and half the pack stayed as the original meeting on Thursdays and the other half started meeting on Wednesdays and both were able to take in new members. The volunteer leaders similarly split across the two groups and took on new volunteers. That's what needs to happen in your area @Greatballzoffire and then there are places across all demographics.

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:44

TheYearOfSmallThings · 14/12/2023 10:33

Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.

Are you suggesting that the waiting list doesn't function equally for all families? Or that middle-class families are better at putting their child onto waiting lists rather than assuming they can join whenever they want to? I think there is some truth in the latter one.

I think it's probably the latter, I didn't know either that there would be a waiting list. I went to join my son in beavers two years ago thinking we could just rock up & enroll.
They told me to go online & submit his application. 2 years later he got a place.
If I had known I'd have done it 2 years earlier but I didn't have an knowledge about how it worked..

OP posts:
Dorriethelittlewitch · 14/12/2023 10:43

Ours is very mixed as is the leadership team. I chair the Trustees and we work hard at fundraising/grant applications so we can cover trips and opportunities for all.