Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
Thelaundryfairyhasbeenassassinated · 14/12/2023 12:08

It would be interesting to know how you are defining the social class of the children. What makes you think you son is the only WC child there? I normally read on mumsnet what the MC think the WC are like. Your son can't be that much different.

I took my daughter to swimming lessons in a very wealthy area. It was the only place I could get her in. She seemed like every other child there (at 5 anyway). Parents careers and flexibility along with the other activities their children did made me aware we was different though.

WombatChocolate · 14/12/2023 12:02

There are a number of things which can work to exclude and include people - even unintentionally and Scouting/Guiding is no different.

  • on the basis of price, most people could afford the subs. It is one of the cheapest weekly activities available and costs less than £3 per week. For some that will be a stretch, but the majority if families could afford that. Most activities within it are also subsidised and as run by volunteers will be cheaper than doing similar activities through school or another provider. Fund raising often happens to cover the majority if cost if things like jamborees for older ones. However, even limited costs will be a barrier for some or the oerceotion that there might be more costs will be a barrier. I think they work hard to try to ensure costs dint exclude people and will waive fees where there is hardship.
  • People/parents tend to send their kids to activities where they perceive similar families will be. In some areas, Scouting has mostly middle class families. This can be because waiting lists are long and middle class families are more geared up to planning extra curricular activities years ahead and it becomes self-perpetuating. In some areas where waiting lists are very long, parents who volunteer to help get their kids prioritised. (I don’t have a problem with this - these groups are often closing down due to a lack of volunteers. If this approach draws in volunteers and keeps groups going, it benefits many young people and not just the volunteers’ kids. Without this, many groups would close). When volunteers have kids in the group, groups can feel a bit different to when groups are not run by parents. Perhaps families if a similar type join and it self perpetuates. Often middle class families have more time and possibly inclination and confidence to volunteer.
  • This said, lots of groups are solidly working class although often at least some of the leaders are not. Lots of groups are connected to Churches or other community groups and run with a specific purpose to help provide activities in working class areas. A real focus on making everything accessible and feel welcoming to all people can be the emphasis. Again it’s self perpetuating and if the group is popular with families in these areas, it will often continue to be as families send their younger siblings and locals hear about the groups or have find memories of them.

People often don’t realise how unwitting things can act as barriers. Lots of middle class families with children who go to the more affluent area school at the door waiting to do pick-up and loudly talking about their holiday plans, future school plans, other extra curriculars might make it daunting to families who feeel they don’t fit. Some groups might run more activities which reflect some kind of class norms and put people off or help people feel more comfortable. I’d say most groups try really hard to be inclusive in terms if activities offered and consideration of orice and creation of an inclusive culture, but it’s less easy to influence who gets the places and if parents (and kids themselves) are welcoming and inclusive or not.

For many middle class families, Scouting is one in a string of extra-curriculars. It might be that working class families are generally doing fewer things or different things, and if there is very much the sense at the sCouts that everyone else does lots of other stuff on other evenings, that could be a barrier.

I actually think Scouting and Guiding are aware if this and do a lot to make it accessible to all, but there are limits to what they as an organisation can do.

Rollingdownland · 14/12/2023 12:02

Absolutely not here. I guess you just live in a very MC area.

pandabear99 · 14/12/2023 12:01

I grew up on the estate in my hometown where you moved when you became new money - so you can show everyone else who never moved away that you 'made it'. Middle class doesn't exist there.

None of them went to Brownies with me. Those girls did Freestyle Disco dancing.

The girls most active in my Brownies group weren't from poverty, but they were FAR from middle class. The actual middle class girls I began to meet later in life had hobbies and extra curriculars I could only dream of.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 11:56

I didn't think such a simple, affordable activity would be as attractive to the middle classes

@Greatballzoffire are you serious?

BeeDavis · 14/12/2023 11:54

I am not middle class, absolutely far far FAR from it and I did Brownies/Scouts etc so YABU.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 14/12/2023 11:54

Not in my region. Yes there are some middle class groups but the majority are in working class areas including areas of significant deprivation.

Our group has a real mixture of kids from diverse backgrounds and we work really hard to make it as inclusive as possible and to ensure that money is not a barrier to activities.

Angrycat2768 · 14/12/2023 11:50

Not where I live, but I guess invite the only group in the area it is bound to he oversubscribed. The answer is for people to volunteer to run a different troupe, but people don't seem to want to do that. We have loads of packs where we live. It is, as you say, a brilliant activity for kids, done cheaply. My DS has been doing it since Beavers, and is now a Young Leader and helps out the Cubs. Should he not have done it because he comes from a ' middle class family?

ilovechocolate07 · 14/12/2023 11:49

Definitely not. In a middle class area you'll get middle class scouts and so on but it is available for all and it cheap in comparison with other activities. Run by volunteers too.

blabla2023 · 14/12/2023 11:46

Ours is accessible to everyone who doesn’t need to work fulltime, has two cars in the family and has no special needs. Absolutely not accessible for parents working fulltime (kind of understandable, but excludes a lot of children), without access to a car at short notice, or children with any sort of special needs.
Very middle -middle class.
Waiting list is 2-3 years.

ns87 · 14/12/2023 11:46

In my area it's for all children and is therefore priced so low.

Hullabaloo31 · 14/12/2023 11:43

Not the case here either, and I'm in the height of gammon toryville location-wise. I'm on the exec for ours, and volunteer, we have such a mix and definitely some families we've been supporting with subs for the past few terms. We have a reasonable waiting list, but it just runs in age order so it doesn't matter how early people put their names down.

Potentialmadcatlady · 14/12/2023 11:43

I was a Scout leader ( became a volunteer then leader so my kids could go) and both my kids went right through to 18. Defo not middle class, poor as church mice.

Smerk · 14/12/2023 11:42

Our group is a mixed bag (leaders and young people) - perhaps 2/3 middle class as it's in a posh bit of London adjacent to a much less posh bit.

We have an enormous waiting list but prioritise looked after children and we offer subsidised subs and events for families who struggle. We also prioritise children with parents who are willing to volunteer.

Have you considered helping? The more volunteers, the more groups can operate and the more young people benefit. I've been a leader ever since my eldest turned 4 and joined Squirrels.

Cryingbutstilltrying · 14/12/2023 11:42

Ds goes to a very diverse group, but we are fortunate in that there is no waiting list even for Beavers as there are so many groups across my area. So all the children who are interested are able to join. He is now a Scout and I would guess the kids come from more affluent families, but I think this is due to an appreciation of the value of the group and parents continuing to encourage after school activities. Other friends have not been interested once they move to secondary school. DD is at Guides and I would say it’s a similar sort of demographic.
If the groups have long waiting lists, parents may offer to become leaders which gets their kids up the list, maybe those are more likely to be middle class? I don’t know. I’m just glad of any parent who comes forward to volunteer no matter who they are.

grumpycow1 · 14/12/2023 11:41

I live in a (what is described as deprived) inner city area and Beavers is definitely NOT like that. For me it’s the only activity I can really afford. £30 for a term as opposed to £13 a class for one activity I was quoted! There was a wait list just because it’s volunteer led and they have to restrict numbers. I don’t have a car so I have to go to the nearest one but maybe if I could afford a car, I would travel to one a bit further away where his friend goes, who knows. Luckily it’s just a 5 min walk.

You can’t base the whole of scouts on your one experience, surely you know that. It’s quite a well known movement so I can imagine it would attract people from all walks of life. If you live in an area where people have to drive/ travel further to get to a scout group it might change the dynamic slightly.

Littlewhitecat · 14/12/2023 11:41

Really odd assumption OP. There is a huge shortage of volunteers so maybe you could volunteer and become a leader so that a 2nd group could open and the waiting list drop? My (middle class) DD is a young leader in Guides having been through Rainbows, Brownies and Guides. Perhaps she shouldn't bother based on your assumptions that this should be an activity for working class people? Without people like her (regardless of class) none of your DCs would be able to attend at all. So unless you volunteer quit your moaning.

Rocksonabeach · 14/12/2023 11:39

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 10:10

Depends where the group is located. We have too in our village... one fir the village children is quite diverse ranging from kids who needed free uniform and subsidised fees to professional families.
The other is attached to the Private school exclusively for their pupils.

Very different vibes!

Totally not here. We have millionaires to free school meals.

AInightingale · 14/12/2023 11:39

In Northern Ireland - I sort of get what you mean. Boys and Girls Brigades were always more the working class option here.

OP posts:
Flatulence · 14/12/2023 11:38

Depends where you live. If you live somewhere with lots of middle class/wealthy people it's going to have kids from those families.
The Brownies/Guides groups I went to as a kid in the 80s and 90s were really mixed, as were the Beavers/Cubs/Scouts. A mix of kids from different schools and backgrounds: some families lived in council housing; some in mansions. It reflected the area, which was also really mixed.
I also used to volunteer with a Brownie group in my area. I live in an urban area and we had kids who'd be dropped off in brand new Range Rovers and who lived in houses worth millions of pounds and other kids who lived in overcrowded, run down, flats. The kids just got on with it, mostly.
Sending your kids to these groups says more about the attitude of the family than their class or income. Families that value their kids taking part in ordinary, inexpensive, community-based, activities - many of which are outdoors - will favour it.
You might - in some groups - get leaders or cliques of kids/parents who inevitably lead to that particular group slanting towards one sort of demographic that's not very reflective of the area - but that's definitely not the norm IME.

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 11:34

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 11:17

@Greatballzoffire he WSJ basically had to be abandoned... mixture of corruption and extreme weather. Its cost British Scouting alone over a million pounds alone I believe.

Oh I wasn't aware, how disappointing for the kids & all involved

OP posts:
Pavane · 14/12/2023 11:31

Not in the city where I live now -- DH was a cub and scout as a child, and their troop (or whatever it's called) hall was firmly in the middle of the very working-class area he grew up in. When DS was a beaver, the cohort seemed to be mainly, like DS, children of working parents who needed their child to go on somewhere after after-school ended once a week.

WrongSwanson · 14/12/2023 11:31

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 14/12/2023 10:54

I'm an Explorer Scout leader (but have done Cubs and Scouts) - our catchment is socioeconomically diverse. We plan our activities to be low cost, and give 9 months notice of larger camps to allow for trickle payments.

I did find it very disturbing that the only people who were interested in attending the (ill fated) World Jamboree last summer were from very affluent households, who had the times/means/resource etc to fund raise £4K. I couldn't get anyone else to sign up, despite promising that the unit would help fundraise. When £100 for a passport is unacheivable, what's the point?

It can hardly be surprising, it's one thing "fundraising" when mum and dad could, at a pinch, top up the difference. Quite another when you struggle to believe you could raise the money. And it's easier to to fundraise in a wealthy area/with wealthy family.

It was probably a good thing given what happened. It must be far more devastating for things to go that badly wrong if you have had to scrimp and save to find the money.

WrongSwanson · 14/12/2023 11:25

Not round here, possibly in some cases.
My relative runs a group in a deprived area and makes sure all the activities are inclusive.

Our local branch is run by a bunch of really arrogant men and most sensible parents pull their children out when they realise so there's never a waiting list

Because groups are volunteer led they are going to vary wildly

Swipe left for the next trending thread