Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Scouts is (or always was!) an incredibly middle class activity

341 replies

Greatballzoffire · 14/12/2023 10:05

Just that. Our local one is full of very wealthy families, waiting list are years long & the children that could probably do with & afford scouts can't get in the door.
I always associated scouts as an inexpensive activity that all children can access. Ours seem to be predominantly full of middle class families who travel from other areas to our scout unit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CruCru · 18/12/2023 22:05

I think the place ended up bringing in an online booking system - partly because having people queue from the early hours looks terrible.

user284246975787632445 · 18/12/2023 19:22

That's pretty sad.

CruCru · 18/12/2023 14:39

Ponderingwindow · 17/12/2023 17:35

The subtle barriers are definitely real. I spent hours and hours researching activities well ahead of when my dd will need them. I know which things have waiting lists and which ones will require me to be at my computer at 3am on a random date when they open sign-ups. My calendar already has an alarm set to remind me to set up my computer and supplies the night before and another to wake me at the right time.

anyone can put that level of effort in, but the reality is that kind of planning and obsession is fairly unique to certain groups and personalities

My children used to do preschool gymnastics in Kentish Town. I remember the sign up was at 9:30am so I turned up at 9:15am thinking I’d be miles too early. I was the second to last person to get a spot - the others had been queuing outside since the early morning. Some people had turned up two or three times but hadn’t managed to get a spot (because they just couldn’t turn up that early). I think there was something in the local paper about it a few years ago.

greengreengrass25 · 17/12/2023 22:15

I remember helping on a parent rotation for scouts as did DH.

Ds went to beavers because a friend did and it continued to scouts. It was affiliated with the church. It was very good for him.

It was in a fairly affluent area

NaughtybutNice77 · 17/12/2023 22:08

You're kind of contradicting yourself. You're saying scouts is working class but your title says it isnt. I think what you have is a local group that started off with one or 2 children from middle class families and then their peers and siblings joined. I dont think that's the norm. It's great it's so well subscribed to and that theres someone to run it. Maybe you could consider becoming a scout leader yourself and set up a 2nd troupe if demand is so high. I dare say it would take on a different vibe.

Abbimae · 17/12/2023 18:48

Everything things scouts should be cheap, who exactly do you expect to pay for it?

user284246975787632445 · 17/12/2023 17:46

Which childhood activities require 3am sign-ups? @Ponderingwindow

Ponderingwindow · 17/12/2023 17:35

The subtle barriers are definitely real. I spent hours and hours researching activities well ahead of when my dd will need them. I know which things have waiting lists and which ones will require me to be at my computer at 3am on a random date when they open sign-ups. My calendar already has an alarm set to remind me to set up my computer and supplies the night before and another to wake me at the right time.

anyone can put that level of effort in, but the reality is that kind of planning and obsession is fairly unique to certain groups and personalities

reluctantbrit · 17/12/2023 16:55

@RedToothBrush - our treasurer got Revolut pre-paid credit cards for things like food shops or train tickets. Two of our leaders are only mid-Twenties and don't have big credit card limits and our chair doesn't want them out of pocket.

If the funds on the cards run low, they tell him the expected price and he adds more money.

But that works only because there is enough money in the kitty and the parents paid far enough in advance. So if the camp is on the 15th of a month, parents have to pay by the 1st to ensure funds are there.

Budgiegirlbob · 17/12/2023 12:11

Paying back is mad! We’d never find anyone to do that for those amounts. There are better solutions

There are better solutions, but many groups, including ours, run this way. I just use my credit card for any expenses, and claim it back before the credit card is due. We can request a cash float upfront if necessary, but most of our leaders are happy to claim expenses back. I do appreciate not everyone can, or would want, to do it this way.

A lot depends on the volunteers. Our treasurer (who retired recently) was very old fashioned - did no online banking, all expenses had to be on paper (we couldn’t email them over), claims were paid by cheque etc. We now have a new treasurer and are moving towards online banking, bacs payments etc. But it takes time, and is very dependant on the skills and time that the volunteers have.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 10:48

"I have received very rude emails complaining about sessions starting or finishing late. This has been after repeated requests for help to prevent this from happening. Volunteering for this role takes up a considerable amount of my time and effort and it is somewhat soul destroying to receive ungrateful emails which fail to acknowledge and appreciate the effort that running sessions takes. I hope this explains the situation in full and reinforces the point that unless parents are willing to step up and assist this will continue to happen, which I will make no apology for. There is a simple solution to the problem which I have detailed in full but is outside of my control to enforce"

And send.

MirrorBack · 17/12/2023 10:44

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 10:18

I know a lot of scout leaders don't claim every expense back. They certainly don't claim petrol back.

If we run a camp whoever is buying the food pays the money upfront and then is reimbursed. It's one reason we've done camps with less well off troops in the past because their leaders can't do that as easily as they just don't have the money in the bank to do it and they can't get their treasurers to sign off releasing the money quickly enough from receiving payment from parents who may be paying in installments for camp. Good governance means they have to be so careful about releasing money without a receipt. It can be done but it's risky and it's difficult if you find prices in the supermarket aren't as expected (cos they've gone up or your had to substitute an item due to it being out of stock).

The last one I did was a food shop of £300. It's not insignificant.

Paying back is mad! We’d never find anyone to do that for those amounts. There are better solutions.
We now have a Monzo account to load camp monies into. In general we keep money for each section in Monzo pots, around £200, and section leaders report spends and top up monthly.
Before that we dealt in cash for camps with end of camp balancing of receipts etc.
Paying back is an unnecessary barrier for leader recruitment. I’d never be a leader if I was also using my own account, I’d be in my overdraft every month.

budgiegirl · 17/12/2023 10:43

But as I said- we used to carry boats and kayaks past parents sitting in their cars-some of whom would then complain that we were late finishing! Obviously some would have a good reason-but all of them? Every week?

We get this at cubs, and my DH used to find the same when coaching kids football. Each week he would send an email out asking for help before and after matches to set up/take down goals etc. Rarely did anyone step up to help. But then they'd moan that kick-off was late etc. It was soul-destroying.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 10:22

AyrshireTryer · 17/12/2023 10:20

In some cases yes, but when I went we were all from the same council estate including the leaders. I didn't know you could own your own house when I was a child.

I think this sums it up well. Groups tend to reflect their local area. If you have no contact with district (or beyond) your only reference point is the closest group.

AyrshireTryer · 17/12/2023 10:20

In some cases yes, but when I went we were all from the same council estate including the leaders. I didn't know you could own your own house when I was a child.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 10:18

reluctantbrit · 17/12/2023 10:07

@MaybeDoctor but the groups don't have that money to pay someone.

For each £1 our group gets we have to pay 70p to the district. So all normal activities, hall rental, saving funds for equipment, hardship fund and other expenses are covered with 30% of the actual subscription paid. I know that DH often doesn't bother claiming small expenses back (he is Chief Scout leader/chairman until recently).

That's why it's important the people gift aid as that money stays with the group.

I know a lot of scout leaders don't claim every expense back. They certainly don't claim petrol back.

If we run a camp whoever is buying the food pays the money upfront and then is reimbursed. It's one reason we've done camps with less well off troops in the past because their leaders can't do that as easily as they just don't have the money in the bank to do it and they can't get their treasurers to sign off releasing the money quickly enough from receiving payment from parents who may be paying in installments for camp. Good governance means they have to be so careful about releasing money without a receipt. It can be done but it's risky and it's difficult if you find prices in the supermarket aren't as expected (cos they've gone up or your had to substitute an item due to it being out of stock).

The last one I did was a food shop of £300. It's not insignificant.

CurlewKate · 17/12/2023 10:16

I absolutely get why people can't help. Lots of people can't. Nobody is expecting superhuman efforts-and many people genuinely can't commit to anything regular.

But as I said- we used to carry boats and kayaks past parents sitting in their cars-some of whom would then complain that we were late finishing! Obviously some would have a good reason-but all of them? Every week?

reluctantbrit · 17/12/2023 10:07

@MaybeDoctor but the groups don't have that money to pay someone.

For each £1 our group gets we have to pay 70p to the district. So all normal activities, hall rental, saving funds for equipment, hardship fund and other expenses are covered with 30% of the actual subscription paid. I know that DH often doesn't bother claiming small expenses back (he is Chief Scout leader/chairman until recently).

That's why it's important the people gift aid as that money stays with the group.

BigBoysDontCry · 17/12/2023 09:57

There are a whole variety of things that help, many already mentioned. Also helping to set up camps, helping to pack up, taking tents to dry, shopping, helping with lifts, manning stalls for fundraising, printing and delivering leaflets, going on night walks as an extra pair of hands, ensuring that your DC are doing their share to help others, passing on used kit/uniforms, raising funds etc etc etc.

Even just asking if there us anything you can do after explaining your particular circumstances.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 09:40

RidingMyBike · 17/12/2023 08:56

Being a trustee or similar carries big responsibilities though. It's not just 3 hours of meetings a year, you have to be on top of the paperwork, particularly financial, and be prepared to ask difficult questions, because trustees are responsible and could be at risk of losing their own personal finances if things aren't run properly. I know several people who won't volunteer for this kind of role because of that.

I'm someone who has done about 15 years of volunteering in uniformed organisations, but now I don't. Because of lack of time. My job is full on, involves travel and is unpredictable. I am happy to do ad hoc parent rota type stuff but I fill in gaps. I'm also sandwich generation so have elderly relatives to run around after as well as a child - this is increasingly common now people have kids later in life. You probably can't tell just by looking which of the parents who don't volunteer are also running around after elderly parents and frantically juggling that with work.

I ceased to buy into this a long time ago. You get to know parents. You get to know leaders. It's a mindset thing. It's not a full-time commitment to do one session a term and juggle things for one week in the way it's made out by some here. It's just an excuse.

I get why people don't want to do it weekly, but you grow tired of the excuses for one off requests when you know how much you sacrifice yourself to make things possible for everyone else all the time.

Its bollocks.

RedToothBrush · 17/12/2023 09:36

Budgiegirlbob · 17/12/2023 08:23

Or those who can't help are put off joining, as that poster was referring too. She couldn't help so her children couldn't join

As I said, an individual’s circumstances should be taken into account. No child should be turned away because their parent or another family member can’t help. However, I do think circumstances where a family can truely give no help at all, in any form, are very rare.

This. It's the whole 'i can't possibly do one night because I'd have to bring my other child' nonsense. Well bring your other child then. No one really cares and the kids will love looking after little ones and involving them in most cases and the older will be happy enough sulking in a corner.

It's so rare that people can't rather than it being inconvenient. It's inconvenient to everyone though.

RidingMyBike · 17/12/2023 08:56

Being a trustee or similar carries big responsibilities though. It's not just 3 hours of meetings a year, you have to be on top of the paperwork, particularly financial, and be prepared to ask difficult questions, because trustees are responsible and could be at risk of losing their own personal finances if things aren't run properly. I know several people who won't volunteer for this kind of role because of that.

I'm someone who has done about 15 years of volunteering in uniformed organisations, but now I don't. Because of lack of time. My job is full on, involves travel and is unpredictable. I am happy to do ad hoc parent rota type stuff but I fill in gaps. I'm also sandwich generation so have elderly relatives to run around after as well as a child - this is increasingly common now people have kids later in life. You probably can't tell just by looking which of the parents who don't volunteer are also running around after elderly parents and frantically juggling that with work.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 17/12/2023 08:30

GirlsAndPenguins · 17/12/2023 07:45

I went to brownies on the council estate I grew up on. Our idea of a camp was sleeping on the floor of community centre where it happened, going to the local park at night and the rough chippy on the way back 😂. Genuinely the least middle class extort my life!

My son's cubs had a camp on the floor of the scout hut on Friday! And they have previously gone for a night walk past the waterworks and over the canal to Hackney, and another walk where they had to tick off restaurants of 10 nations and got chips from the last one.

Who needs Korea I say Grin

Budgiegirlbob · 17/12/2023 08:23

Or those who can't help are put off joining, as that poster was referring too. She couldn't help so her children couldn't join

As I said, an individual’s circumstances should be taken into account. No child should be turned away because their parent or another family member can’t help. However, I do think circumstances where a family can truely give no help at all, in any form, are very rare.