9.54
if people called for a meeting for "Caucasians", this would be viewed as vehemently racist. If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified.
10.45
I stand by the statement that if white people had a "White Only" group, they would be vilified. I cannot think of another group where it would be deemed unacceptable.
Me: That’s because while people are the majority. You cannot ‘exclude’ the majority. Do you also look at women only groups and say ‘if men did this, they’d be vilified’? Groups for people with disabilities and say ‘if people without disabilities did this, they’d be vilified’?
You (when you eventually answered, after being asked multiple times): I don't know why a group of neurotypical, able-bodied individuals would want a group free of disabilities. I certainly wouldn't join it if it existed. Would they be vilified for existing? I don't know, because I don't know why it would exist in the first place.
Me: So, in that case, do you know why a ‘Whites Only’ group that excludes minorities would exist in the first place? As you are clearly comfortable making (and standing by) the assertion that they’d be vilified and you apparently only do that if you understand the reason for a group’s existence.
You: gives specious example (I honestly can’t be bothered to find it) and cannot justify it when challenged.
So, exactly as I described: No, you explicitly stated that you didn’t know why a group that excluded the disabled would exist (which is why you wouldn’t make a similar statement re vilification), thus implying that you understood why a Whites Only group would exist. When pressed on this, you attempted to give me a (wholly specious) example of one that might be needed.
We can all copy/paste.