Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be ok with race-based segregation?

411 replies

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

OP posts:
Oliotya · 14/12/2023 12:54

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:43

If you view being challenged on racism as aggression, then that's on you
Is it? So back to 'it's your problem not mine'. Isn't this attitude one of the main attitude with challenge with racism?

How is that different to telling a non-white person that their feelings are not justified and therefore it's on them to deal with it?

I'm opened to learn and accept my perception to be challenged. It's hard though to listen to strangers who appear to only be interested in proving those who see the world differently to them that they are wrong and nothing they think or feel are worth any consideration.

It's shutting them down just like too many people still shut down minorities because their feelings are not worthy of being heard.

Isn't this attitude one of the main attitude with challenge with racism?No, it really isn't. You're reading the same things over and over again and for some reason deciding that you know better. You're evidently not open to learn. There's no point me engaging with you any further. There's already plenty of white people denying racism, you don't need to join in.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 14/12/2023 12:54

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:49

apologies- I have luckily been able to edit that. I think you could have made your point without referencing the N word though

You know what happened nicely here?

Someone pointed out something could be offensive. You then acknowledged it, apologised, edited it and moved on.

You didn't argue, call that poster hysterical and frothing at the mouth, deny there was an issue, talk over them, tell them they were wrong etc etc etc

You just learnt, corrected and apologised.

If only some other posters on this thread could learn this behaviour

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 12:51

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:39

@LusaBatoosa "I personally do not feel the need for an all white group, no. Somebody else might, and they may have completely valid reasons. I am not fighting for an exclusive white group." 10:50am.

9.54
if people called for a meeting for "Caucasians", this would be viewed as vehemently racist. If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified.

10.45
I stand by the statement that if white people had a "White Only" group, they would be vilified. I cannot think of another group where it would be deemed unacceptable.

Me: That’s because while people are the majority. You cannot ‘exclude’ the majority. Do you also look at women only groups and say ‘if men did this, they’d be vilified’? Groups for people with disabilities and say ‘if people without disabilities did this, they’d be vilified’?

You (when you eventually answered, after being asked multiple times): I don't know why a group of neurotypical, able-bodied individuals would want a group free of disabilities. I certainly wouldn't join it if it existed. Would they be vilified for existing? I don't know, because I don't know why it would exist in the first place.

Me: So, in that case, do you know why a ‘Whites Only’ group that excludes minorities would exist in the first place? As you are clearly comfortable making (and standing by) the assertion that they’d be vilified and you apparently only do that if you understand the reason for a group’s existence.

You: gives specious example (I honestly can’t be bothered to find it) and cannot justify it when challenged.

So, exactly as I described: No, you explicitly stated that you didn’t know why a group that excluded the disabled would exist (which is why you wouldn’t make a similar statement re vilification), thus implying that you understood why a Whites Only group would exist. When pressed on this, you attempted to give me a (wholly specious) example of one that might be needed.

We can all copy/paste.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:50

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 12:48

You are really too much now. You could have made your point without having to highlight the rest. Stop it. You are really showing yourself, as you have with every post that you write.

Don't know you, but I love you 😍

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:49

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:46

@Myfabby Please do not use the word "retarded". I'm sure you didn't mean to use it in a derogatory fashion, but it is akin to the N word for a different group.

apologies- I have luckily been able to edit that. I think you could have made your point without referencing the N word though

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 12:48

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:46

@Myfabby Please do not use the word "retarded". I'm sure you didn't mean to use it in a derogatory fashion, but it is akin to the N word for a different group.

You are really too much now. You could have made your point without having to highlight the rest. Stop it. You are really showing yourself, as you have with every post that you write.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:46

@Myfabby Please do not use the word "retarded". I'm sure you didn't mean to use it in a derogatory fashion, but it is akin to the N word for a different group.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:44

@Vuurhoutjies

But perhaps you think that they are all from black women and so you're just applying the "aggressive black woman" trope without even realising it.

Thank you!

100%. Hence the derogatory frothing from the mouth nonsense

The issue with racists is they are so see through, so utterly dumb and sing from the same illogical hymn sheet.

At least be creative, be intelligent. Be good at what you do. It's really awful to be mediocre at racist. Such a low existence.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:43

If you view being challenged on racism as aggression, then that's on you
Is it? So back to 'it's your problem not mine'. Isn't this attitude one of the main attitude with challenge with racism?

How is that different to telling a non-white person that their feelings are not justified and therefore it's on them to deal with it?

I'm opened to learn and accept my perception to be challenged. It's hard though to listen to strangers who appear to only be interested in proving those who see the world differently to them that they are wrong and nothing they think or feel are worth any consideration.

It's shutting them down just like too many people still shut down minorities because their feelings are not worthy of being heard.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:39

@LusaBatoosa "I personally do not feel the need for an all white group, no. Somebody else might, and they may have completely valid reasons. I am not fighting for an exclusive white group." 10:50am.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 12:38

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:02

So you want BAME people to explain to you why you shouldn't be racist? There's not enough information readily accessible for you, you need them to spell it out for you?
I'm always puzzled how those who preach anti racism are often the least tolerant ones in the way they share their views. Aggressive attitude really goes against tolerance.

I consider that learning and knowledge is forever evolving. It's not a case of learning the truth but being open minded and listening to every individual's needs.

I hate putting people in boxes and hate being put in a box. I am not white. Well I am but this is not a word I would ever use to describe myself because it doesn't define me. I am so much more than 'white'. So I don't ever make assumptions on anyone else because of their skin colour. I don't assume they must been persecuted, regularly discriminated, racially abused because they might or might not have. I would listen to their personal experience and empathise.

I suppose that a poor black person living in a predominantly white area is going to experience a very different life than those who have been educated in private school, earning a high income living in a diverse area.

Everywhere in the world, people like to mix with others who share similar experience, that's totally normal. The key issue here is that these get together are referred to as 'parties'. Until we understand the context of these 'parties', who are we to judge if they are appropriate or not?

What's most amusing about your posts is that actually, quite a lot of people HAVE explained things. But you dismiss those posts or ignore them or accuse them of being aggressive. It would be funny if it wasn't so sad.

So there's a no win. You complain when you're told to actually do the work yourself. You complain and dispute things when people tell what is happening/their perceptions etc. You ignore a great deal.

The point is that you aren't interested in "evolving" your thinking and you haven't "listened" to a single other point of view on this thread.

I'm white. I also do not define myself by my whiteness. I'd be a complete moron if I didn't accept that my whiteness has impacted all sorts of things throughout my life. I'm also a mother, I do not define myself as a mother. But again, being a mother impacts a great deal of how I interact with the world and my experiences and I'd be an idiot if I didn't acknowledge that either.

You also have a very low tolerance for robust discussion if you think these posts have been aggressive. But perhaps you think that they are all from black women and so you're just applying the "aggressive black woman" trope without even realising it.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:35

jbeble · 14/12/2023 12:34

The above is precisely why I don't think we gain anything by dividing ourselves further.

Segregation is when other people force it on you, this is free choice.
You could argue that segregationist laws were the free choice of those who voted for them, would that make them right?

😂😂😂

jbeble · 14/12/2023 12:34

spookehtooth · 14/12/2023 12:25

Segregation is when other people force it on you, this is free choice. It's purpose isn't to separate, either, but for a minority to network and support each other.

You should be more concerned about the wealthy and powerful minority, and their parties and business connections. They have a profound impact on our whole society. Some of those groups collaborate to write laws for the rest of us. The recent, highly oppressive, anti protest laws in the UK were written this way via one of their "think tanks". Just as our climate starts to breakdown, and the world looks more politically unstable and violent. What a coincidence, hey?

Edited

The above is precisely why I don't think we gain anything by dividing ourselves further.

Segregation is when other people force it on you, this is free choice.
You could argue that segregationist laws were the free choice of those who voted for them, would that make them right?

OP posts:
LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 12:34

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:17

@LusaBatoosa That was not at all a claim that white people are oppressed. I explicitly stated that I do not know why such a group would exist. But other people might, and I would not deny them their experiences and the right to share them with those who share commonalities.

No, you explicitly stated that you didn’t know why a group that excluded the disabled would exist (which is why you wouldn’t make a similar statement re vilification), thus implying that you understood why a Whites Only group would exist. When pressed on this, you attempted to give me a (wholly specious) example of one that might be needed.

It’s all still up there.

LateAF · 14/12/2023 12:34

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 10:43

Just to clarify, I definitely don't think that. I was being very sarcastic.

Yes sorry I was aware of your sarcasm- was just adding to it!

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 12:29

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:19

Where exactly is the aggression in that sentence?
I find the expression 'spelling out for you' quite rude, but it's the overall tone of the messages and other things said.

You're whiteness may not define you, but whether you acknowledge it or not, it's a large part of your lived experience
Of course, but so are many other things. I don't define myself by any only. It's all my experiences that make me who I am.

I guess I feel more comfortable treating people as individuals with a group of characteristics made of all their experiences than the assumptions I make because of one characteristic.

Intersectionality is not a new concept and I’m fairly certain that everyone who has interacted with you on this thread is a proponent.

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 12:25

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:19

Where exactly is the aggression in that sentence?
I find the expression 'spelling out for you' quite rude, but it's the overall tone of the messages and other things said.

You're whiteness may not define you, but whether you acknowledge it or not, it's a large part of your lived experience
Of course, but so are many other things. I don't define myself by any only. It's all my experiences that make me who I am.

I guess I feel more comfortable treating people as individuals with a group of characteristics made of all their experiences than the assumptions I make because of one characteristic.

If you view being challenged on racism as aggression, then that's on you.
Surely you can understand that being able to ignore race is a very white privilege? It's not that hard to grasp with a basic understanding of history and a bit of listening.

spookehtooth · 14/12/2023 12:25

Segregation is when other people force it on you, this is free choice. It's purpose isn't to separate, either, but for a minority to network and support each other.

You should be more concerned about the wealthy and powerful minority, and their parties and business connections. They have a profound impact on our whole society. Some of those groups collaborate to write laws for the rest of us. The recent, highly oppressive, anti protest laws in the UK were written this way via one of their "think tanks". Just as our climate starts to breakdown, and the world looks more politically unstable and violent. What a coincidence, hey?

SerafinasGoose · 14/12/2023 12:21

Zampa · 14/12/2023 09:06

It's not segregation. It's recognising the different experiences of POC.

You only have to look at the threads in the Black Mumsnetters forum to see white people telling others that they're wrong about their lived experience.

I imagine it's nice for a group of Black elected officials to get together to share experiences.

That is this site's shame.

I haven't seen it on the black Mumsnetters' forum precisely because I don't go there to even read, let alone take the liberty of commenting. That isn't my space. It's a tiny corner of a huge site and it's sad to see this disrespected.

It must be very wearying constantly to have your experiences talked over as though others, who don't share them, know better.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:19

Where exactly is the aggression in that sentence?
I find the expression 'spelling out for you' quite rude, but it's the overall tone of the messages and other things said.

You're whiteness may not define you, but whether you acknowledge it or not, it's a large part of your lived experience
Of course, but so are many other things. I don't define myself by any only. It's all my experiences that make me who I am.

I guess I feel more comfortable treating people as individuals with a group of characteristics made of all their experiences than the assumptions I make because of one characteristic.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:17

@LusaBatoosa That was not at all a claim that white people are oppressed. I explicitly stated that I do not know why such a group would exist. But other people might, and I would not deny them their experiences and the right to share them with those who share commonalities.

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 12:14

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 12:08

I didn't see anyone claiming that "white people are oppressed". There were, however, several posters who insinuated prejudice where there was none.

You: ‘If white people did this, they’d be vilified.’

Pluvia · 14/12/2023 12:14

velveteen79 · 14/12/2023 11:57

According to the poll, 48% of people reading this thread who voted agree with the OP. That is approximately 166 out of 347 voters at the time of writing.

What poll? I don't have a poll come up. So that will be another vote against the proposition.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

still here i see...😂

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 12:12

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 11:35

@LusaBatoosa I have a friend who was sexually assaulted by a gang because she was white. Perhaps she would be more comfortable speaking in group therapy to women who also experienced this type of offence?

Such a group would have multiple qualifying factors, including gender and being the victim of a crime. I asked about a ‘Whites Only’ group. Excellent reach, but please answer the actual question.