Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be ok with race-based segregation?

411 replies

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

OP posts:
LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 14:39

Thank you for your honesty in your post @SerafinasGoose . Sadly there are not enough people out there like you.

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 14:35

Rackajack · 14/12/2023 13:54

I completely agree with you OP but you won't get many others doing the same. The ones equating it with women's only events..really? It's just another divisive exercise, where white people need to play along with. No, I'm not playing your game, I would be saying as a white elected person. You are either an advocate of cohesion and multiculturalism or you are not. Clearly, this women isn't and should be removed from her post. It's exclusionary and therefore racist. The excuses justifying it, are pathetic.

Please tell us how women only events are different and not divisive.

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 14:24

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 13:10

Oh it is so true. I was a also a boarder here in the UK years ago, when things were way worse, so I have so many stories, but you know what, I have also met and made several fantastic life long friend as have my children. My son truly considers it home. Racists won't win.

Edited

I just moved to the Surrey/London borders from central London. It’s been…interesting. Delighted to learn that there are ladies like you two about.

Rackajack · 14/12/2023 14:10

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:45

@LusaBatoosa I stand by the statement that if white people had a "White Only" group, they would be vilified. I cannot think of another group where it would be deemed unacceptable.

You can't point out something that obvious. All the list of social justice excuses will come rolling out, as they have done already. Question: is there a reason why we are including only whites?
Answer: well, no, not a legal one.

So why should this be any different in this case. The bollocks about sharing experiences is exactly that, bollocks. The only way to fight racism is to be unified. If this group want to share their experiences, their elected positions, shouldn't be the platform.

Rackajack · 14/12/2023 14:07

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 14:06

😂😂

I rest my case.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 14:06

Rackajack · 14/12/2023 13:54

I completely agree with you OP but you won't get many others doing the same. The ones equating it with women's only events..really? It's just another divisive exercise, where white people need to play along with. No, I'm not playing your game, I would be saying as a white elected person. You are either an advocate of cohesion and multiculturalism or you are not. Clearly, this women isn't and should be removed from her post. It's exclusionary and therefore racist. The excuses justifying it, are pathetic.

😂😂

Rackajack · 14/12/2023 13:55

PuttingDownRoots · 14/12/2023 09:04

If she held an event for women to discuss the obstacles they overcame, would you object?

I saw it in a similar way... a minority celebrating their achievement.

Not in the slightest bit comparable.

Rackajack · 14/12/2023 13:54

I completely agree with you OP but you won't get many others doing the same. The ones equating it with women's only events..really? It's just another divisive exercise, where white people need to play along with. No, I'm not playing your game, I would be saying as a white elected person. You are either an advocate of cohesion and multiculturalism or you are not. Clearly, this women isn't and should be removed from her post. It's exclusionary and therefore racist. The excuses justifying it, are pathetic.

SerafinasGoose · 14/12/2023 13:53

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 12:54

Isn't this attitude one of the main attitude with challenge with racism?No, it really isn't. You're reading the same things over and over again and for some reason deciding that you know better. You're evidently not open to learn. There's no point me engaging with you any further. There's already plenty of white people denying racism, you don't need to join in.

I think this is one of the most important posts on this thread.

I've fucked up. I readily admit this. I've had to address whether I hold unconscious bias. As a child I really didn't 'see' colour: I didn't even notice my friends and neighbours were black until one of them was called a racist pejorative at school assembly one day, and I couldn't understand why such words were so hurtful to her. To my eternal shame I once used a phrase in my workplace which had horrible racist connotations of which I was unaware - it had just crept into common parlance - but if I'd just stopped to think about it for a moment I could and should have been aware. Ignorance isn't an excuse. There was an African American woman in the room. I was beyond horrified, and I made it my business to go and look up other such phrases and sear them into my brain so that they never, ever crept into my vocabulary again. I still can't think of that situation without cringeing and my face going hot.

Simply overt racism isn't just it: there are covert instances of it which I'm sure PoC encounter every single day, and which my racial privilege enables me not to see. There is systemic racism. We live in a country in which this exists, therefore we are going to have internalized some of the BS. But it's our own job to unpick this. PoC must be exhausted having to navigate it day in, day out. They are not responsible for others' racism, or for teaching them better behaviour: this is akin to victim blaming and putting all the responsibility for wrongs done to them back onto them. This isn't good enough.

We can't take back what we get wrong. We can learn from it and endeavour not to repeat it. IMO, claiming that we are 'tolerant' (how patronising; who are we to 'tolerate' others), and one of the least racist countries (what are the points of comparison? How can we really know this?) or denying racism exists in the first place is doing no one any favours. A problem can't be addressed if you won't admit the problem is there. And any wally can see that it IS there, and to suggest the contrary is a very hollow claim which is simply not true.

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 13:27

Honestly @Vuurhoutjies . Don't waste your time with that poster.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 13:25

I should stop engaging, but okay, last time:

No, I really didn't say that at all. You have not interpreted my comment has it was meant.

Write better then.

So again, what I said is that due to a number of factors that can influence an outcome, we cannot assume that in all cases, the reason why representation is unbalanced in specific circumstances is inevitably due to racism.

this is difficult to understand (see my "write better then" comment) but I think I get it. And my response is: No we can't assume that in ALL cases lack of representation is due to racism. But those of us who actually pay attention are fully aware that racism, and the longstanding factors that derive from racism, is hugely responsible and plays an outsized role in this lack of representation. From the way black and brown children are likely to be subtly pushed down different career/education paths, to unconscious bias in recruitment and promotion processes, to specific instances of "true" racism.

I was talking about parties held for POC, ect...but about a team/office Christmas party which again is a very different situation. There was no 'gotcha' as you put it.

You still make no sense. It was explained that some companies absolutely DO have parties/celebrations, including at Christmas, for POC or other groups. In your SPECIFIC example of a small team, that might not necessarily be the case but it wouldn't' surprise me if the sub team of POC chose to go out for a Christmas meal separately to the white members of the team. Hard to say because, as previously discussed, everywhere I have worked has been completely dominated by white people. In the case of OP's mayor group, I think it's perfectly reasonable because there is a specific and different need/celebration that is taking place. But I know you disagree.

What if all 10 are invited, but circumstances are that unfortunately, the 4 non-white can't make it at last minute. 1 has sick children and no childcare. 1 doesn't like get together, 1 is I'll themselves and the other's car broke down. So the group is down to only white people. Does this automatically mean that they are all racist?

Such a silly example and you know it. A more accurate example would be that there was a team of 20. Only 2 weren't white. One couldn't make it and the other one pulled out because she/he felt uncomfortable being the only POC in the room. Even if your example DID happen, of course that's not racist. But what's interesting is that it is far more common and likely that even in a team that is racially diverse, the chances of an event somehow landing up being all white is probably MORE likely. Another "coincidence".

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 13:25

I take regular breaks from MN@Vuurhoutjies . I have to protect my mental health at the end of the day, and stay off the threads on racism, if I am not feeling robust enough. Posters constantly denying black, and brown people's reality on here is draining. It is very easy to spot who those posters are though, like the ones on here.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 13:15

You absolutely have suggested that racism is NOT at play in all kinds of situations, including, for example, lack of representation of people of colour in business and at many many events and actiivities in the professional world
No, I really didn't say that at all. You have not interpreted my comment has it was meant.

So again, what I said is that due to a number of factors that can influence an outcome, we cannot assume that in all cases, the reason why representation is unbalanced in specific circumstances is inevitably due to racism.

The office party you provided was not ignored. It was specifically pointed out that some Christmas or other parties are regularly held for POC, LGBT etc. You ignored that as part of your "gotcha" that office parties are always for everyone
except that wasn't an answer to my specific scenario. I was talking about parties held for POC, ect...but about a team/office Christmas party which again is a very different situation. There was no 'gotcha' as you put it.

So I'll elaborate. Working Team of 10, 6 white people/4 non-white. Manager decide to arrange a Xmas get together. He invites the 6 and ignores the 4. Is this acceptable? I think we all agree that it isn't. It is illegal and a stackable offence.

Same team but 6 non-white people, 4 white. Same situation, only 6 invited. Is this ok? Again, it depends on the context, but if it is to celebrate as a team, then it is discrimination too.

What if all 10 are invited, but circumstances are that unfortunately, the 4 non-white can't make it at last minute. 1 has sick children and no childcare. 1 doesn't like get together, 1 is I'll themselves and the other's car broke down. So the group is down to only white people. Does this automatically mean that they are all racist?

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 13:13

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 13:04

I hear you@Myfabby . The gaslighting that goes on is real. It is always everything under the sun, why such, and such happened. It could never be racism, oh no🙄.

No, it's always just "coincidence". The exact same thing "could" happen (or "has happened") to a white person. The fact that it happens to black people x1000 more often... coincidence.

Also, if it wasn't specifically MEANT as a racial slur, it doesn't count. You know that right?! So, if someone calls you a monkey, but they weren't specifically thinking "you are a terrible, inferior, worthless black person" then of COURSE it's not racism. Never.

The fact that my local Waitrose when I lived in Wandsworth was staffed almost exclusively with people of colour and yet, management were all white... TOTALLY coincidental. No racism there at all - after all, the bulk of the staff are not white so of course we're not racist.

I say this a lot - if even my 12 year old DS can come home and tell me that there is a notable difference in how him and his friends are perceived when they're out and about when it's just a group of white boys vs when it's a group of white boys with some black/mixed race boys too.... well, amazing how grown adults are so oblivious.

I need to get off MN today. Between this thread and another one on useless men, I'm losing the will to live.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 13:11

I am sorry you and your son experienced that, @Myfabby. There is no excuse.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 13:10

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 13:03

No no no. Please tell me that's not true. Please?!

I know it is. I'm sorry. I also live in a village in Surrey. If it's any consolation, if I was there, I would have been horrified and outraged. Probably isn't a consolation. I know.

Oh it is so true. I was a also a boarder here in the UK years ago, when things were way worse, so I have so many stories, but you know what, I have also met and made several fantastic life long friend as have my children. My son truly considers it home. Racists won't win.

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 13:04

I hear you@Myfabby . The gaslighting that goes on is real. It is always everything under the sun, why such, and such happened. It could never be racism, oh no🙄.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 13:03

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 13:00

Same sis. Same. Try Black woman living in a tiny predominantly white affluent village in Surrey. But we must accept everything and not complain because 1.it's a privilege to be in the UK; 2.gollywogs aren't offensive , 3 We foam and froth at the mouth 4. We can always go to Rwanda😂5. When a banana is thrown at my son for scoring a winning goal, it was just a angry rival and could have been a satsuma/piece of paper/insert any other random excuse.

No no no. Please tell me that's not true. Please?!

I know it is. I'm sorry. I also live in a village in Surrey. If it's any consolation, if I was there, I would have been horrified and outraged. Probably isn't a consolation. I know.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 13:01

Isn't this attitude one of the main attitude with challenge with racism?No, it really isn't. You're reading the same things over and over again and for some reason deciding that you know better. You're evidently not open to learn. There's no point me engaging with you any further. There's already plenty of white people denying racism, you don't need to join in

I don't know better but ok. You're free to not want to engage further. You've now put me in a category and closed the box it would seem so I guess there's not much else I can say anyway.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 13:01

@vivainsomnia You said people were aggressive. Now you're changing to belittling. But either way, that was you.

You absolutely have suggested that racism is NOT at play in all kinds of situations, including, for example, lack of representation of people of colour in business and at many many events and actiivities in the professional world.

The office party you provided was not ignored. It was specifically pointed out that some Christmas or other parties are regularly held for POC, LGBT etc. You ignored that as part of your "gotcha" that office parties are always for everyone.

The only posts that have been funny are yours. Perhaps that is belittling of me. But I'm afraid I'm struggling to take you seriously.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 13:00

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 12:54

I am just a run of the mill, black woman trying to navigate life, who unfortunately has seen the ugly face of racism too much in my life. Check out Black MN if you have not already😄

Same sis. Same. Try Black woman living in a tiny predominantly white affluent village in Surrey. But we must accept everything and not complain because 1.it's a privilege to be in the UK; 2.gollywogs aren't offensive , 3 We foam and froth at the mouth 4. We can always go to Rwanda😂5. When a banana is thrown at my son for scoring a winning goal, it was just a angry rival and could have been a satsuma/piece of paper/insert any other random excuse.

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 12:58

Neitheronethingnortheother · 14/12/2023 12:54

You know what happened nicely here?

Someone pointed out something could be offensive. You then acknowledged it, apologised, edited it and moved on.

You didn't argue, call that poster hysterical and frothing at the mouth, deny there was an issue, talk over them, tell them they were wrong etc etc etc

You just learnt, corrected and apologised.

If only some other posters on this thread could learn this behaviour

Spot on. Well said.

spookehtooth · 14/12/2023 12:55

@jbeble not really, all you're really getting at is that what I said requires additional clarification.

The bad kind is more about negativity impacting and having power over those not included than those who are.

The "good" kind is supporting those negatively impacted by those not included, and go some way to correcting a power imbalance.

Proof of the real difference is this, in what way do the non-attendees suffer? It's a ridiculously obvious question for the bad kind, you'd fall over yourself for example. For the kind you're upset about, any answer almost certainly is rooted in another oppression, which isn't helped by banning the "good" kind

I put good in quotes because I don't think the "good" kind is a solution, but a reasonable tool to deal with the reality of where we are today.

I'm sure you'll go picking holes, but I'm not playing that game. It'll take a bloody essay to write a water tight answer and we're not writing laws here 🤣🤣🤣

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 12:55

What's most amusing about your posts is that actually, quite a lot of people HAVE explained things. But you dismiss those posts or ignore them or accuse them of being aggressive. It would be funny if it wasn't so sad
I don't think any posts here are amusing. Saying so is belittling, how is that helping?

I also haven't accused all posts of being aggressive at all. I have highlighted the use of aggression (which really was more a case of belittling) that was directed at me soecifically . Not all have been, thankfully, but some responses have been (and then have also become so the other way). I don't think I've hinted in any of my posts that racism exist and is real. I haven't said that these meetings were wrong. I have supported people who meet with those with shared experiences so I do agree with quite a few posts and comments.

The opinion I have shared that differ is that I felt we should focus on the nature of these 'parties' to actually confirm that their purpose was to discuss matters that affect them specifically rather than purposely exclude certain people.
gave the exemple of the office party which has been ignored.

I do indeed dislike generalisations and assumptions made based on one belonging in a specific group. I don't like comments that start with 'black people do, don't, feel, want.....' nor the same points made about 'white people can't, won't, etc ...' Does this mean I'm not listening?

LadyKenya · 14/12/2023 12:54

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 12:50

Don't know you, but I love you 😍

I am just a run of the mill, black woman trying to navigate life, who unfortunately has seen the ugly face of racism too much in my life. Check out Black MN if you have not already😄