Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be ok with race-based segregation?

411 replies

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:36

@Myfabby so have you found one website that says that she was correct yet.

Please post the link.

ghostyslovesheets · 14/12/2023 17:36

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:33

@myfabby yes everyone. I've looked through forty different sites now. Not one of them have said she was right.

Everyone of them is saying that she was divisive.

And that it was a stupid and dangerous move for her. As now she will be asked to step down.

Can you see any website anywhere saying she was correct.

I can't find one. If you can , please post the link

I just don't understand what it is you think she, personally has to apologise for though

Is it continuing the established tradition of a Black Elected party?

Her aid accidently send the email to everyone rather than the invitees?

Of her aid then retracting the invite with an apology?

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 17:35

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:33

@myfabby yes everyone. I've looked through forty different sites now. Not one of them have said she was right.

Everyone of them is saying that she was divisive.

And that it was a stupid and dangerous move for her. As now she will be asked to step down.

Can you see any website anywhere saying she was correct.

I can't find one. If you can , please post the link

40!

wow!

You might as well start your PhD on this.

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:33

@myfabby yes everyone. I've looked through forty different sites now. Not one of them have said she was right.

Everyone of them is saying that she was divisive.

And that it was a stupid and dangerous move for her. As now she will be asked to step down.

Can you see any website anywhere saying she was correct.

I can't find one. If you can , please post the link

ghostyslovesheets · 14/12/2023 17:32

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:24

@ghostyslovesheets you write very selectively to suit what you want to say.

I see you selectively only quoted the white people who said that they weren't upset at being uninvited.

I see you left out the white people who said that they WERE upset at being univited, and that they found it divisive

well that's because I didn't find any - but you keep on telling her she's wrong and hurt the white peoples feels - I'm sure she reads MN

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 17:30

Fox News doesn’t count as everyone. It doesn’t count as news.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 17:29

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:26

@Queucumber she is not allowed to invite whoever she likes.

I see that you seem to be choosing to overlook that this has become a massive scandal, with everyone online saying that she was wrong. It's on the news sites everywhere. Everyone is saying she was wrong.

everyone online?
I guess repeating it ad infinitum makes it true.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 14/12/2023 17:29

Is it really everyone though?

Neitheronethingnortheother · 14/12/2023 17:28

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:26

@Queucumber she is not allowed to invite whoever she likes.

I see that you seem to be choosing to overlook that this has become a massive scandal, with everyone online saying that she was wrong. It's on the news sites everywhere. Everyone is saying she was wrong.

Well I mean mot everyone is saying she is wrong

Some people are not saying anything at all

Some people are saying its not an issue

Some.people are saying it is an issue

But the one thing that can be definitely said is that not everyone is saying she is wrong or else this thread would have been very boring

Or perhaps people of colour aren't included in "everyone"? Or the white people who have said they have no issues with it? Does everyone only mean everyone you agree with?

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 14/12/2023 17:26

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 17:18

I’m all for sending her some Ferrero Rocher for her pyramids - I’m assuming it’s like an Ambassador’s reception but with smaller arrangements.

Oooh I love those. DH always gets a huge tray at Christmas from work and by the time DD and I have done a move on them he gets about 2 Grin >eyes them up under tree <

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:26

@Queucumber she is not allowed to invite whoever she likes.

I see that you seem to be choosing to overlook that this has become a massive scandal, with everyone online saying that she was wrong. It's on the news sites everywhere. Everyone is saying she was wrong.

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:24

@ghostyslovesheets you write very selectively to suit what you want to say.

I see you selectively only quoted the white people who said that they weren't upset at being uninvited.

I see you left out the white people who said that they WERE upset at being univited, and that they found it divisive

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 17:23

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 17:18

I’m all for sending her some Ferrero Rocher for her pyramids - I’m assuming it’s like an Ambassador’s reception but with smaller arrangements.

Mme, with these Rocher you're really spoiling us.

This has been such a great thread honestly. Wit and lucid articulation from some fab women! My faith in humanity is restored...

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 17:18

I’m all for sending her some Ferrero Rocher for her pyramids - I’m assuming it’s like an Ambassador’s reception but with smaller arrangements.

MagentaRocks · 14/12/2023 17:17

I am totally disgusted by some of the racist views on here and I am actually quite angry about it. I can’t even imagine how a POC must feel to go through this shit every day. If people can’t see the need for minority groups to have things for themselves then I really can’t see an end to discrimination.

I would love to see a day where we don’t need support groups for minorities, where big company’s and public services don’t need an inclusivity or diversity department but from reading many of the views on here today I can’t see that happening.

If I come across a thread in black Mumsnetters I do sometimes want to add to the thread but there is sometimes something in the OP asking for non black people to not respond, so I don’t, not even to go on and say something positive because they need that space to vent, chat, rant etc.

White privilege is very much a thing and I know I have white privilege. It is just a shame that people can equate one racist comment against a white person as being the same as a life time of racist comments to a black person, or a gathering for solely black people verses a gathering for solely white people.It in no way compares.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 17:15

ghostyslovesheets · 14/12/2023 17:12

@Mooshamoo just to reassure you, given how upset you are on behalf of the white city councillors of Boston - a quick google will tell you this:

It's an annual even that one one has ever had an issue with
The email was sent mistakenly by an AID not the mayor - a follow up was sent 15 mins later addressing the error - and apologising.

According to the Mail (of all papers) the poor white staff responded with quotes such as 'there was no apology needed' ' it would take more than that to offend me' and 'lots of people hold different parties for different groups - it's a non issue'

hope that helps you feel better for them.

Falling in love with so many on this thread today.

My boyfriend will not be amused😂

Neitheronethingnortheother · 14/12/2023 17:14

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 17:11

It’s ludicrous. The mayor is allowed to have parties and invite whoever she likes. It’s not a work event.

Michelle Wu made history in 2021 after being elected as mayor of Boston, becoming the first woman and person of colour elected to the position in almost 200 years. 200 years without a woman or a person of colour. I’d say they really need to be having those parties.

Exactly

It's rather ludicrous to see people bleating on about "not discriminating by race at work" when you are talking about a position that's only been held by white men for 200 years

ghostyslovesheets · 14/12/2023 17:12

@Mooshamoo just to reassure you, given how upset you are on behalf of the white city councillors of Boston - a quick google will tell you this:

It's an annual even that one one has ever had an issue with
The email was sent mistakenly by an AID not the mayor - a follow up was sent 15 mins later addressing the error - and apologising.

According to the Mail (of all papers) the poor white staff responded with quotes such as 'there was no apology needed' ' it would take more than that to offend me' and 'lots of people hold different parties for different groups - it's a non issue'

hope that helps you feel better for them.

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 17:11

It’s ludicrous. The mayor is allowed to have parties and invite whoever she likes. It’s not a work event.

Michelle Wu made history in 2021 after being elected as mayor of Boston, becoming the first woman and person of colour elected to the position in almost 200 years. 200 years without a woman or a person of colour. I’d say they really need to be having those parties.

SerafinasGoose · 14/12/2023 17:06

I'd like to say I'm flabbergasted that people are really creating the false equivalence between the rightness of a black only sorority as opposed to a white only one, but given the state of this site recently I can't say it has come as a surprise.

And a false equivalence is precisely what it is. An exclusive black-only sorority is not the same thing as an exclusive white-only one. Anyone in any doubt of this, or who persists in seeing the two issues as precisely the same with no nuances or differing variables dividing the two, is either painfully ignorant or being wilfully obtuse.

Black sorority members were strictly a minority, if not banned outright, until very recently. Also, sororities are often very closely tied up with economic privilege. Those who were 'banned' were those who were statistically far less likely ever to have been members in the first place. And in the US, PoC are one group who are less likely to be economically privileged.

What is the need for an all-white sorority serving the dominant and more powerful race? Who needs the safety and protection of such a space?

Apply to the same question as to the need for an all-black sorority for those who are not racially privileged and have suffered oppression and racism because of their skin pigmentation. Why would they need the safety, protection and shared experience afforded by that space?

Are those needs exactly the same, and is anyone who suggests otherwise 'racist?' Dear gods. The ignorance is almost painful.

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:04

@Queucumber you are not allowed by law to discriminate by race at a place of work.

These people all worked together.

That is why this mayor is facing huge backlash

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 17:02

@YireosDodeAver you said women are allowed to have women only meetings.

Are they allowed to have women only meetings at a place of work though, like this incident?

These people all worked together on the council. She invited all of the workers, then specifically uninvited the white people.

ghostyslovesheets · 14/12/2023 16:59

I also lean towards the view that shouting about the actions of a black woman repeatedly with ' you are wrong, it's wrong, admit you are wrong, it's bad, white peoples feels where hurt' online is also oppressive - as would be constant references to 'well black people do THIS and it's just as bad' 'Look at this I saw on Youtube it's just as bad'.

Queucumber · 14/12/2023 16:59

YireosDodeAver · 14/12/2023 16:56

For the same reason that it's ok for women to have women-only meetings, for gay people to have gay-people-only meetings etc. If you don't understand why people without a particular privilege need to sometimes have space and time away from people who do have that privilege then you simply have no idea how privileged you are.

If you don't understand why people without a particular privilege need to sometimes have space and time away from people who do have that privilege then look at this thread! It’s all the evidence you’d need to see why such groups exist.

YireosDodeAver · 14/12/2023 16:56

Mooshamoo · 14/12/2023 15:52

I don't think it's okay.

Would it be okay to have a whites only meeting? No it wouldn't.

Why are they allowed to have a black people only meeting?

For the same reason that it's ok for women to have women-only meetings, for gay people to have gay-people-only meetings etc. If you don't understand why people without a particular privilege need to sometimes have space and time away from people who do have that privilege then you simply have no idea how privileged you are.