Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be ok with race-based segregation?

411 replies

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

OP posts:
Givemepickles · 14/12/2023 10:15

It's absolutely hideous to see people obsessing over race so much that they divide people up by skin colour. My mixed race family and I are appalled by it and would never attend such an event. It sickens me to my stomach. I hate that it's been so ingrained in UK culture now that people here actually think this is reasonable! Genuinely despair for the future of the West.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:14

@RancidRuby @LusaBatoosa White people are in the majority in some areas. I have lived in many places where white people are in the minority. And there was certainly prejudice against them that I saw clear as day (not from all, but it was significant enough to be noteworthy).

This doesn't minimize the experiences of POC who, by and large, have had worse and more if these experiences. But as a "white" woman who is ethnically Jewish, I have been discriminated against on many occasions, you just wouldn't know it if you saw me.

I addressed men and women having groups in my previous post.

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 14/12/2023 10:14

I don't have an issue with the OPs example, it's none of my business and obviously beneficial to the participants.
Although I do wonder about the baby groups, I know black and mixed race Mums are being failed by health services, which is bloody shocking. But would it not be beneficial for mums of all colours to be sharing their experiences, which would highlight any prejudice and failings in their local services. Surely if they are only meeting with women who are experiencing the same then how will the difference be apparent. I realise I'm explaining that badly.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:13

It's all fine and dandy until someone sets up an event for whites only

Groups meeting together to discuss specific matters that affects them in specific contexts as a group is perfectly legitimate. It's not segregation.

The issue I have is an overall assumption is that if you belong in a majority group, there can't possibly be any matters that affect you as a group that you might want to only discuss with people belonging in this group.

The problems are when those selective 'groups' dwell in matters that affect other 'groups' and when some groups are encouraged to meet separately but others are criticized for doing so.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 10:09

@LakeTiticaca well, I have never attended an event that was specifically billed as being "for white people" only. But I'll tell you this... the vast bulk of the work-related events, meetings, activities I have attended over the years have been made up of only white people.

So let's be clear, white only events are the defacto events, whether or not you want to admit that.

Ktime · 14/12/2023 10:05

LakeTiticaca · 14/12/2023 10:00

It's all fine and dandy until someone sets up an event for whites only

Then the shit hits the fan........

Maybe when white people aren’t the gate keepers of BAME progress at work then they can have events.

Ktime · 14/12/2023 10:02

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 09:54

I can understand why POC would want a separate space, including elected officials. A meeting for "African Americans" or "Latino Americans" isn't uncommon. Women and men have similar groups that are mostly accepted.

That said, if people called for a meeting for "Caucasians", this would be viewed as vehemently racist.

I think a private gathering with clear intent to discuss common experiences is ok. But a large-scale social event is exclusionary, especially if it is political in nature. If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified.

But a large-scale social event is exclusionary

It’s 6 BAME people, how’s that a large scale social event?

IncompleteSenten · 14/12/2023 10:02

" If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified."

Yes. And rightly so.

Aamer Rahman (Fear of a Brown Planet) - Reverse Racism

aamerrahman.tumblr.comTwitter: @aamer_rahmanBookings: [email protected]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dw_mRaIHb-M

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:02

LakeTiticaca · 14/12/2023 10:00

It's all fine and dandy until someone sets up an event for whites only

Then the shit hits the fan........

Again, that’s because white people are the majority in those spaces. You cannot ‘exclude’ the majority. Do you also look at women only groups and say ‘if men did this, shit would hit the fan’? Groups for people with disabilities and say ‘if people without disabilities did this, shit would hit the fan’?

IncompleteSenten · 14/12/2023 10:00

You can't ignore the history when looking at these things. It's not segregation and to call it that is a massive insult to people who suffered actual segregation.

LakeTiticaca · 14/12/2023 10:00

It's all fine and dandy until someone sets up an event for whites only

Then the shit hits the fan........

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:00

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 09:54

I can understand why POC would want a separate space, including elected officials. A meeting for "African Americans" or "Latino Americans" isn't uncommon. Women and men have similar groups that are mostly accepted.

That said, if people called for a meeting for "Caucasians", this would be viewed as vehemently racist.

I think a private gathering with clear intent to discuss common experiences is ok. But a large-scale social event is exclusionary, especially if it is political in nature. If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified.

That’s because while people are the majority. You cannot ‘exclude’ the majority. Do you also look at women only groups and say ‘if men did this, they’d be vilified’? Groups for people with disabilities and say ‘if people without disabilities did this, they’d be vilified’?

RancidRuby · 14/12/2023 09:58

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 09:54

I can understand why POC would want a separate space, including elected officials. A meeting for "African Americans" or "Latino Americans" isn't uncommon. Women and men have similar groups that are mostly accepted.

That said, if people called for a meeting for "Caucasians", this would be viewed as vehemently racist.

I think a private gathering with clear intent to discuss common experiences is ok. But a large-scale social event is exclusionary, especially if it is political in nature. If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified.

Are white people in the minority and prejudiced against because of their ethnicity?

Ktime · 14/12/2023 09:57

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only.

Why are you lying and spinning this in to multiple parties OP?

It’s one get together for the 6 BAME people, out of 13 people.

Then there are several parties planned:

'There are multiple ways that we celebrate with everyone. There are several parties where all the entire city council and all of our elected colleagues have been invited to.'

RancidRuby · 14/12/2023 09:57

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:48

To be clear, this is not about people supporting each other and having to get together to have their voice heard, their concerned answered, their cause taken into account.

But the fact is these people are elected, they represent everyone that elected them. Now is the time, and it is their role, to have the hard conversations, not to entrench and divide.

Yes they represent all of the electorate but that doesn't mean they have to be inclusive of the entirety of the electorate at all times. You've not addressed whether you feel similarly about women or LGB only initiatives? How about things aimed solely at the elderly, or children? Can you really not see that certain groups may need specific targeting, because they have unique needs.

MsMarch · 14/12/2023 09:56

lkwhjis · 14/12/2023 09:49

OP, you don’t need to explain. You are not unreasonable at all. These elected officials are usually really shit at their day job. That ls why they try and make themselves look busy with this divisive nonsense.

"These elected officials". Do you mean all of them, or just the black ones?

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 09:56

lkwhjis · 14/12/2023 09:46

It’s white saviour syndrome. Most minorities don’t want to be singled out. They want to be treated like everyone else. Not sure if it’s white guilt or just a fad where the more ‘virtuous’ you are, the more likes you get.

Minorities are obviously not a hive mind, but my DH loves some positive discrimination. Somewhat makes up for all the shit he still has to deal with. Which I am assuming is the point of this event.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 09:55

Ah, of course. People of colour can't possibly represent the WHITE people in their constituencies if they occasionally attend events that are ONLY for people of colour.

But white people absolutely have always done a brilliant job of representing people of colour and it's no problem if they are surrounded by other white people (by choice and coincidence, of course).

Ugh. I don't know why I bother with threads like these. The not so thinly veiled racism is so hideous.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 09:54

I can understand why POC would want a separate space, including elected officials. A meeting for "African Americans" or "Latino Americans" isn't uncommon. Women and men have similar groups that are mostly accepted.

That said, if people called for a meeting for "Caucasians", this would be viewed as vehemently racist.

I think a private gathering with clear intent to discuss common experiences is ok. But a large-scale social event is exclusionary, especially if it is political in nature. If white people did it, they would absolutely be vilified.

lkwhjis · 14/12/2023 09:49

OP, you don’t need to explain. You are not unreasonable at all. These elected officials are usually really shit at their day job. That ls why they try and make themselves look busy with this divisive nonsense.

PaulaPocket · 14/12/2023 09:49

@jbeble - are you from Dixie?

PaulaPocket · 14/12/2023 09:48

PaintAngst · 14/12/2023 09:31

Yes. Though I can't think this post can possibly be anything other than a fairly platant attempt to provoke.

Absolutely. And not very subtle either.

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:48

To be clear, this is not about people supporting each other and having to get together to have their voice heard, their concerned answered, their cause taken into account.

But the fact is these people are elected, they represent everyone that elected them. Now is the time, and it is their role, to have the hard conversations, not to entrench and divide.

OP posts:
lkwhjis · 14/12/2023 09:46

It’s white saviour syndrome. Most minorities don’t want to be singled out. They want to be treated like everyone else. Not sure if it’s white guilt or just a fad where the more ‘virtuous’ you are, the more likes you get.

jencool · 14/12/2023 09:45

YABU on this occasion.