Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be ok with race-based segregation?

411 replies

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

OP posts:
Oliotya · 14/12/2023 10:36

Smellslikesummer · 14/12/2023 10:26

I thought the rule of thumb was that it is ok to discriminate when the purpose is to empower a minority (black politicians, women in tech, etc).

But in the case of a baby group I genuinely don’t get it. One of the few things that women share universally. I would go as far as saying that if a woman only feels comfortable going to a playgroup limited to her race then she has a racism issue.

if a woman only feels comfortable going to a playgroup limited to her race then she has a racism issue.

Wow. Just wow. Peak victim blaming right here.
BAME people take note - racism is only an issue if you let it be.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:35

There are areas with almost zero diversity. If you go to events in those areas, they will only have white people. Even in ‘diverse’ areas of industries, there are often very few non-white people
It doesn't take much to understand that there is a difference between groups that are made up of majorities and groups that exclude minorities. Two totally different things.

The problem with exclusive groups is how are we ever going to learn about other groups if we focus on issues only affecting ourselves? Tolerance grows with knowledge and knowledge grows with focusing on others, not just ourselves.

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:33

C1N1C · 14/12/2023 10:20

I guess this all depends on the individual.

If you feel you're underrepresented, have a day for your 'type'. If you want to blend in and be treated equally, then these days are promoting segregation.

And it will never be popular when someone highlights the obvious... Black days but no white days. Female-exclusive events but no male exclusive events. LGBTQ+ events but no heterosexual events. It used to be that the white male may have had advantages, but now inclusivity quotas mean he's often the last to be employed

So, racism, sexism and homophobia would disappear if the people affected just stopped talking about them? That’s your logic?

It used to be that the white male may have had advantages, but now inclusivity quotas mean he's often the last to be employed

Statistically, straight white men are still very much top of the heap, so that’s nonsense.

Laiste · 14/12/2023 10:33

They're having a party.

They're not plotting world take over 🙄

UncleHerbie · 14/12/2023 10:31

Comedycook · 14/12/2023 09:34

Yes but the pp said it was for black or mixed race babies...rather than specifically mums of that race .. I'm a white woman with mixed race dc. Could I have gone along?

As it was a group for black and mixed race “babies”, I’m assuming you’d be an ideal group member as a mother with a mixed race child

YireosDodeAver · 14/12/2023 10:31

It's segregation if there's a different event for white elected representatives only. If the event for People of Colour is an extra, and there are no events or spaces they are excluded from, due to colour, then it's not segregation it's additional support recognising the additional challenges that black and other minority ethnicity people face in all aspects of their life and work including in this case specifically their work acting as an elected representative.

Smellslikesummer · 14/12/2023 10:31

Ktime · 14/12/2023 09:38

Only yesterday the news was talking about how left behind black and Asian mothers are in healthcare.

One example was black women being 2 years behind white women in getting fertility help.

Breastfeeding will be another area where black mums will just be expected to get on with it without help.

Breastfeeding will be another area where black mums will just be expected to get on with it without help I’m genuinely surprised to read this. My experience was that we are all expected to get on with it. I really can’t think of any support I received from health visitors etc - they would guilt mums for not breastfeeding but not help.

Startingagainandagain · 14/12/2023 10:30

Would you have the same reaction if this was a women-only event? an event for LGBTQ+ people? or an event where disabled people can get together and talk about the specific issues they face?

There is still a lot of issues with racism, especially in the USA, and people from some communities come across discrimination/lack of representation in the workplace.

So I can completely understand the logic in this type of event and of wanting a safe space to celebrate their achievements and have frank discussions.

No need to overthink everything and be 'professionally outraged' all the time...

I am white and I can completely accept that I will never fully understand the barriers and the negativity that people who are from other backgrounds face.

It is completely fine by me that they would want to have networking events that don't include people like me.

It is also really daft to compare this to ''if white people did this'. As always you have to look at the wider context: white people in the USA have not been discriminated against for decades or been the targets throughout the history of that country of slavery and segregation...

It just sounds like the type of 'what about' arguments that some men use when women try to carve safe spaces or want to discuss the discrimination/domestic violence they face.

RancidRuby · 14/12/2023 10:30

Women do not have a universal maternity experience, it's well documented that women of colour have worse maternity outcomes than white women.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:29

Go take a look at the management teams of the vast bulk of larger firms. "diversity" usually means the odd woman. Very occasionally, one person of colour
But you can't infer that the reason for this is purely sexism or racism. There are many other factors that impact on recruitment. The law is thankfully very clear on this matter.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:29

@LusaBatoosa Men do have groups. There are male-only therapy sessions, working men's clubs. Women have groups like the WI. My SIL attends groups for people with disabilities. I have no issues with this, just as I have no issues with meet-ups and gatherings specifically for POC. I take no issue with the event in question as I have said.

I spoke of my own discrimination to show that white people can also experience prejudice and their skin colour doesn't make them immune to racism.

Yes, Boston has a majority of Caucasian people. But surely this thread is about more than this one specific incidence and is relevant elsewhere?

Not sure why you're picking on my post on particular, I haven't said anything remotely divisive.

Smellslikesummer · 14/12/2023 10:26

savoycabbage · 14/12/2023 09:09

When I had my baby I went to a playgroup that was for black and mixed race babies run by Surestart.

Someone complained and it was disbanded. Along with the breastfeeding support group as that was also discriminatory.

I thought the rule of thumb was that it is ok to discriminate when the purpose is to empower a minority (black politicians, women in tech, etc).

But in the case of a baby group I genuinely don’t get it. One of the few things that women share universally. I would go as far as saying that if a woman only feels comfortable going to a playgroup limited to her race then she has a racism issue.

MsMarch · 14/12/2023 10:26

It used to be that the white male may have had advantages, but now inclusivity quotas mean he's often the last to be employed

Categorically not true. At "worst" for white men, if a firm is trying very hard to improve its diversity, and the choice comes down to a white man OR someone else with similar skills etc, the white man MIGHT be passed over. But in real life, in light of the fact that white men are still very much dominant, what really happens is that if a mediocre white man is up against a very compelling person who is NOT a white man, he now only has a 50/50 chance of getting the job vs his previous 90% chance.

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:26

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:16

So let's be clear, white only events are the defacto events, whether or not you want to admit that
Really? Any specific examples? I can't think of any such event.

What do you mean, specific examples? Are you in the U.K.? It’s a white majority country (by a massive margin). There are areas with almost zero diversity. If you go to events in those areas, they will only have white people. Even in ‘diverse’ areas of industries, there are often very few non-white people.

Some of these comments. Wow.

Iwasafool · 14/12/2023 10:26

Sirzy · 14/12/2023 09:44

But the babies will still face the same sort of challenges as growing up so it’s not really confusing.

even for something as “simple” as haircare is so different!

It can be different, for mine it was. Other mixed race children in my family from a different racial mix have no issue at all and why would they?

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 10:22

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:16

So let's be clear, white only events are the defacto events, whether or not you want to admit that
Really? Any specific examples? I can't think of any such event.

Um, I already said - at work, over many years. I worked in finance. Now I consult to finance, professional services and technology firms. In the last 6 months, I think I have attended two client meetings or events at which someone who was not white was present. Two. Many of my clients do have people of colour working there, but inevitably, I am working with senior leaders and you guessed it... they are almost all white.

Amazing you don't know that.

Go take a look at the management teams of the vast bulk of larger firms. "diversity" usually means the odd woman. Very occasionally, one person of colour.

What this means is that an event for senior leaders... white people are the only ones present.

Is this difficult to understand?

Neitheronethingnortheother · 14/12/2023 10:20

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:48

To be clear, this is not about people supporting each other and having to get together to have their voice heard, their concerned answered, their cause taken into account.

But the fact is these people are elected, they represent everyone that elected them. Now is the time, and it is their role, to have the hard conversations, not to entrench and divide.

As a woman in technology I am there to work on behalf of all of my customers not just the female customers

But when I meet with the women in technology group I'm part of we are more focused on how the job affects us, issues we encounter as a minority (80% of our company is male) etc etc

It's about how we navigate through our work lives and the challenges we face

This meeting is not to do with the people they represent, they have all the rest of their work for that. Can you really not see the difference? Or do you just choose not to because it's an easy way to take a pop at people of colour?

C1N1C · 14/12/2023 10:20

I guess this all depends on the individual.

If you feel you're underrepresented, have a day for your 'type'. If you want to blend in and be treated equally, then these days are promoting segregation.

And it will never be popular when someone highlights the obvious... Black days but no white days. Female-exclusive events but no male exclusive events. LGBTQ+ events but no heterosexual events. It used to be that the white male may have had advantages, but now inclusivity quotas mean he's often the last to be employed

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:20

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:14

@RancidRuby @LusaBatoosa White people are in the majority in some areas. I have lived in many places where white people are in the minority. And there was certainly prejudice against them that I saw clear as day (not from all, but it was significant enough to be noteworthy).

This doesn't minimize the experiences of POC who, by and large, have had worse and more if these experiences. But as a "white" woman who is ethnically Jewish, I have been discriminated against on many occasions, you just wouldn't know it if you saw me.

I addressed men and women having groups in my previous post.

How is the fact that you’ve (allegedly) been discriminated against relevant to this conversation? I’ve been discriminated against, as well. What does that have to do with whether or not minorities can have groups and events?

And this post is about Boston. White people are very much the majority there.

You didn’t answer my question. Do you also look at women only groups and say ‘if men did this, they’d be vilified’? Groups for people with disabilities and say ‘if people without disabilities did this, they’d be vilified’?

LateAF · 14/12/2023 10:19

Givemepickles · 14/12/2023 10:15

It's absolutely hideous to see people obsessing over race so much that they divide people up by skin colour. My mixed race family and I are appalled by it and would never attend such an event. It sickens me to my stomach. I hate that it's been so ingrained in UK culture now that people here actually think this is reasonable! Genuinely despair for the future of the West.

Are you mixed race, white or black?

sprigatito · 14/12/2023 10:17

Are you an All Lives Matter type? Because it's really quite obtuse not to recognise the difference between racial segregation - something imposed on the oppressed race for the benefit of the oppressors - and an event celebrating the achievements and acknowledging the experiences of an oppressed minority. Can you really not see it?

MsMarch · 14/12/2023 10:17

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 14/12/2023 10:14

I don't have an issue with the OPs example, it's none of my business and obviously beneficial to the participants.
Although I do wonder about the baby groups, I know black and mixed race Mums are being failed by health services, which is bloody shocking. But would it not be beneficial for mums of all colours to be sharing their experiences, which would highlight any prejudice and failings in their local services. Surely if they are only meeting with women who are experiencing the same then how will the difference be apparent. I realise I'm explaining that badly.

Because in groups where there are white mothers, if those white mothers are genuinely willing and able to listen to the problems faced by their brown and black peers, great. Except, speak to any person of colour and they will tell you that the vast majority of the time, their experiences are dismissed.

I've seen it on here in this exact context loads. "I'm sorry to hear that you personally had bad maternity care but I don't think that was because you are black. I have a white friend who also had bad maternity care so of course, it's just bad luck" etc etc etc.

LateAF · 14/12/2023 10:17

Ktime · 14/12/2023 09:43

If it was for mixed raced babies as well than the mum of the baby would have been welcome regardless of race surely.

Exactly - I’m part of a group for black and mixed race babies and there are a couple of proactive white mums to mixed race kids in the group. A mixed race child of a white mum will have similar experiences of race and racism outside their family as a mixed race child of a black mum.

My eldest had his first racist experience (that I know of) aged 3. Now age 7 he’s recently come home upset that white boys in his school have taken to faux naively asking him what the ‘n’ word means. His first time hearing the ‘n’ word was from them, and he came home asking us what it meant. This is one of many shit experiences he’s had of racism in his short life. Hence why the group is needed- both one for black mums, and one for black children.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:16

So let's be clear, white only events are the defacto events, whether or not you want to admit that
Really? Any specific examples? I can't think of any such event.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:15

@Ktime I don't have an issue with this particular event. I said I would take issue with a large-scale social event with a political nature.