Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be ok with race-based segregation?

411 replies

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:00

In Boston USA, the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only. It's been a long road for racism, segregation, discrimination of minorities to be recognised and punished as the crimes that they are. What are we trying to achieve here?

AIBU to think that democratically elected representatives of the people should know better than to promote and/or support segregation?

OP posts:
LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:49

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:45

@LusaBatoosa I stand by the statement that if white people had a "White Only" group, they would be vilified. I cannot think of another group where it would be deemed unacceptable.

If you stand by the statement, then answer my question. Do you look at groups for people with disabilities and say ‘if people without disabilities did this, they’d be vilified’?

Autumnalday · 14/12/2023 10:49

@savoycabbage When I had my baby I went to a playgroup that was for black and mixed race babies run by Surestart

So Asians and mixed race Asians weren't allowed to join? Only black and mixed white/black women and babies were allowed to join? Mothers can relate to other mothers' pregnancy and birthing experiences, especially if they all gave birth in the same country. It doesn't matter what your race is.

Ploctopus · 14/12/2023 10:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Myfabby · 14/12/2023 10:48

Ktime · 14/12/2023 09:57

the Mayor holds parties for 'elected of colour' only.

Why are you lying and spinning this in to multiple parties OP?

It’s one get together for the 6 BAME people, out of 13 people.

Then there are several parties planned:

'There are multiple ways that we celebrate with everyone. There are several parties where all the entire city council and all of our elected colleagues have been invited to.'

Edited

OP's learnt her attempt at journalism from the Fail Lies are their thing 😂

Tempnamechng · 14/12/2023 10:48

I think if poc suggest they want a group specifically for poc, then its up to me to accept that they have different experiences to me and not question or ask them to explain. I won't answer men for example who don't understand why women need sex specific groups, I just expect men to accept it when I tell them we need it.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:48

You should go educate yourself on intrinsic systems of power, built in racism etc. Good luck

I never said it didn't exist, I questioned how you can be so certain that a group that only consist of white people is only so purely do to racism.

If you can't distinguish the two, biais might be an issue.

Ploctopus · 14/12/2023 10:47

it is genuinely revolting for you to use the word ‘segregation’ - with its extremely specific historical and cultural meaning - in respect of a party designed to celebrate the very people who are proof of how important it is to challenge segregation.

Take your small-minded, idiotic, disingenuous, racist and ignorant views back into your deep subconscious and don’t let them see the light of day again.

Roundycippae · 14/12/2023 10:47

Maybe the question should be - do YOU feel the need of an all white group? If so, why@MooseBreath

Roundycippae · 14/12/2023 10:46

‘MooseBreath · Today 10:45

@LusaBatoosa I stand by the statement that if white people had a "White Only" group, they would be vilified. I cannot think of another group where it would be deemed unacceptable.’

mmm, anyone think of a reason why that might be?? Perhaps the systematic racism that excluded non-whites from so much of normal life in western countries, South Africa etc?

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:45

Autumnalday · 14/12/2023 10:41

I'm mixed race and 'x race only' events and groups make me uneasy. Women's only spaces are very different and cannot be compared to race.

Please explain how they are ‘different’ and cannot be compared to race.

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:45

@LusaBatoosa I stand by the statement that if white people had a "White Only" group, they would be vilified. I cannot think of another group where it would be deemed unacceptable.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:45

There is still a lot of issues with racism, especially in the USA, and people from some communities come across discrimination/lack of representation in the workplace

The debate here is the word 'parties'.

Groups that get together to discuss specific matters affecting them is totally legitimate. Parties to have fun is not exclusive.

If I organised my team Christmas party and told the 4 non white people that they couldn't come, that certainly would be an issue justifying a disciplinary. The same if these 4 arranged a Christmas party excluding the other 6.

SparklesInTheCloud · 14/12/2023 10:44

Smellslikesummer · 14/12/2023 10:26

I thought the rule of thumb was that it is ok to discriminate when the purpose is to empower a minority (black politicians, women in tech, etc).

But in the case of a baby group I genuinely don’t get it. One of the few things that women share universally. I would go as far as saying that if a woman only feels comfortable going to a playgroup limited to her race then she has a racism issue.

But this group is for mothers (I assume of all races) who have black or.moxed race children. Just yesterday there was a thread about white mothers educating themselves on the issues that their mlxed race kids might face. So many issues came up that mixed race kids face and wish their white parent could have helped them with. This group would be one such place to help them navigate things like that

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 10:44

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:29

Go take a look at the management teams of the vast bulk of larger firms. "diversity" usually means the odd woman. Very occasionally, one person of colour
But you can't infer that the reason for this is purely sexism or racism. There are many other factors that impact on recruitment. The law is thankfully very clear on this matter.

This actually made me laugh. I didn't realise that there were adults in a country that is broadly well educated etc, who can so confidently believe that racism and sexism play little or even no part in lack of representation for women and people of colour. You don't even come across as "faux naive" as the OP does.

Mind blowing.

You should go educate yourself on intrinsic systems of power, built in racism etc. Good luck.

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 10:43

LateAF · 14/12/2023 10:40

Ah I didn’t realise we’re 4 times more likely to die in childbirth in the UK because we’re letting racism be an issue.

I’ll pass on the message to my black friends- don’t let racism be an issue and it won’t be. Wish someone had told me that earlier.

Just to clarify, I definitely don't think that. I was being very sarcastic.

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 14/12/2023 10:43

MsMarch · 14/12/2023 10:17

Because in groups where there are white mothers, if those white mothers are genuinely willing and able to listen to the problems faced by their brown and black peers, great. Except, speak to any person of colour and they will tell you that the vast majority of the time, their experiences are dismissed.

I've seen it on here in this exact context loads. "I'm sorry to hear that you personally had bad maternity care but I don't think that was because you are black. I have a white friend who also had bad maternity care so of course, it's just bad luck" etc etc etc.

That's a shame, objectively it would seem such a beneficial thing. But I guess even though we know the national statistics, on a smaller scale it's easy to brush off someone's experiences as being just one of those things, especially if the area has poor maternity care in general. I had it in my probably naive head that it would open the eyes of white women to hear the experiences of their black and brown sisters.

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:42

MooseBreath · 14/12/2023 10:29

@LusaBatoosa Men do have groups. There are male-only therapy sessions, working men's clubs. Women have groups like the WI. My SIL attends groups for people with disabilities. I have no issues with this, just as I have no issues with meet-ups and gatherings specifically for POC. I take no issue with the event in question as I have said.

I spoke of my own discrimination to show that white people can also experience prejudice and their skin colour doesn't make them immune to racism.

Yes, Boston has a majority of Caucasian people. But surely this thread is about more than this one specific incidence and is relevant elsewhere?

Not sure why you're picking on my post on particular, I haven't said anything remotely divisive.

You said ‘if white people did this, they’d be vilified’. I’ve asked if you would say that for any of the other examples given. It’s a straightforward question that you’ve refused to answer. Because the answer is obviously ‘no’.

Autumnalday · 14/12/2023 10:41

I'm mixed race and 'x race only' events and groups make me uneasy. Women's only spaces are very different and cannot be compared to race.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 14/12/2023 10:41

jbeble · 14/12/2023 09:17

But all these are private and initiated by private individuals!
We're talking about elected representatives, it's different.
When they attend an event because of their position (or indeed in an official capacity which is not the case here I think) surely they should not promote division.

I think it's even more important for elected officials to recognise and acknowledge the importance of these events.

Actual racial segregation in the US is not as far back in history as many people seem to think ...

LateAF · 14/12/2023 10:40

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 10:36

if a woman only feels comfortable going to a playgroup limited to her race then she has a racism issue.

Wow. Just wow. Peak victim blaming right here.
BAME people take note - racism is only an issue if you let it be.

Ah I didn’t realise we’re 4 times more likely to die in childbirth in the UK because we’re letting racism be an issue.

I’ll pass on the message to my black friends- don’t let racism be an issue and it won’t be. Wish someone had told me that earlier.

Roundycippae · 14/12/2023 10:40

a few men have complained about the women only grp - about us being given ‘opportunities‘ they aren’t - like free training.
Butnif they didn’t exclude women the extent they do, we wouldn’t need the extra support.

Vuurhoutjies · 14/12/2023 10:40

I took a quick look at the top section of The Times business page today and looked up every company. I then looked at their executive leadership teams to assess how many were all white. Note, surprisingly good representation of women but here's the list from a race perspective - pretty clear how easy it is for defacto white events I'd say!

Thames water - All white
BP - all white
Bank of England - all white except, possibly one. Hard to tell from picture
Flexa - one person of colour (man)
Entain - all white
Shaftsbury Capital - one person of colour (man)

LusaBatoosa · 14/12/2023 10:39

Smellslikesummer · 14/12/2023 10:26

I thought the rule of thumb was that it is ok to discriminate when the purpose is to empower a minority (black politicians, women in tech, etc).

But in the case of a baby group I genuinely don’t get it. One of the few things that women share universally. I would go as far as saying that if a woman only feels comfortable going to a playgroup limited to her race then she has a racism issue.

You cannot be serious. Black women are four times more likely to die while pregnant or just after childbirth than white women. There has been a huge amount of work and campaigning around the treatment and outcomes of ethnic minority women during maternity and we are STILL dying. You think that’s a ‘shared experience’ and the fact that we might need to support each other through something so horrific means we have ‘racism issues’?

Roundycippae · 14/12/2023 10:38

Depends innit. Is okay for minorities or under represented grps to have their own events? Yes.
mens groups to support make mental health. Women only awards lists. lGBTG grps. BAME support meets, groups etc.
I’m part of a women coaches grp in a sport dominated by men and male coaches.

Oliotya · 14/12/2023 10:38

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2023 10:35

There are areas with almost zero diversity. If you go to events in those areas, they will only have white people. Even in ‘diverse’ areas of industries, there are often very few non-white people
It doesn't take much to understand that there is a difference between groups that are made up of majorities and groups that exclude minorities. Two totally different things.

The problem with exclusive groups is how are we ever going to learn about other groups if we focus on issues only affecting ourselves? Tolerance grows with knowledge and knowledge grows with focusing on others, not just ourselves.

It is not the responsibility of an excluded minority to be inclusive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread