Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about this London birthday gig present situation?

94 replies

warmmincepies · 13/12/2023 20:42

Compared to other threads, this is all very first-world problems but I feel like I've lost all perspective on this so please let me know if IABU.

I found out a few days ago that my favourite band is playing a one-off gig in London this month - the day after my birthday. They were on hiatus for many years, but they played a small comeback gig in Scotland (where I live) earlier this year, and which my DP and I attended and loved. For info, I've been to almost every gig they've ever played in my city, always with DP, and I've loved them for decades.

So when I learned they were playing the day after my birthday, I thought it was a total no-brainer as a birthday present. Nothing else would have lived up to it. Especially as we actually travelled several years ago to Ireland for my birthday, where and when the band played a gig. I thought we could make a mini-break out of it in London, like we'd done in Ireland. Easy.

But my DP is Not Keen at all. He says there's no point, that we've already seen the band this year. They're releasing a new album soon, so in all likelihood will be touring next year with a good chance of being in our city again. He says there'll be too much rushing around for trains, that the venue is in an awkward place to get out of time-wise, if the gig ends at 11pm and our train is at 11.45pm. It'll be expensive if we also stay overnight, there'll be too much walking around in the cold to kill time, and taking time off work might be an issue. Frankly, he's been a workaholic all year - not really his fault, he's been placed on a big project at work - but we haven't been on holiday, and did nothing for a milestone anniversary.

I thought this plan could rectify all of these things by giving us a mini-holiday. I've never seen London at Christmas. So I said, well, if we're staying overnight, we'll do something special the next day that you want to do. Every time we've gone down to London before, because it's such a trek, we usually see two shows/attractions, one for each of us. So he took a look online but said nothing appeals. I just don't think he enjoys London. He says he only went to the Ireland gig because he'd never been to Ireland before. He said he'd have been more likely to go to this gig if the band had announced a one-off gig in Berlin or somewhere we've never been.

By now, I'm very exasperated. This is my favourite band, this is my ideal present, nothing else would compare frankly. So I say fine, I'll go down by myself. This alarms DP. He says that if I went down on my own for my birthday, then he would feel incredibly guilty and he should be there with me to celebrate. I shrug and tell him that sounds more like his problem. He's now very sad and having a bit of an existential crisis over it, says it's all he's been thinking about. I don't think he'd forgive himself if I went down alone, but also... I just want to see the band?? And if we both went down, I have a feeling he'd be so stressed about travel that he wouldn't make it the most enjoyable experience.

So now we're at a sort of stalemate. DP and I very rarely disagree on things and usually manage to hash something out. I don't know if I'm doing the equivalent of screaming I WANT A PONY and should get over myself, especially as DP only had a modest cinema/restaurant birthday this year, or if I should just LTB, etc.

Maybe the tickets will sell out first and we won't have to make a decision??

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/12/2023 07:43

idontlikealdi · 13/12/2023 21:15

London at Christmas is horrendous, did you see last weekend?!

Go on your own or with a friend op!

Ps I live in London

Idk

I live in London and generally avoid the West End. I still think the lights are pretty cool and magical if you’re in the right frame of mind, which someone on a trip would be.

ilovelamp82 · 14/12/2023 07:42

Of course go on your own. Have fun! And London is lovely at Christmas. Plenty to enjoy on your own.

Allfur · 14/12/2023 07:39

Christmassteps295, london has great transport links, car drivers are not encouraged

Allfur · 14/12/2023 07:36

All these london haters, it's such a narrow way of thinking, London is made up of so many different things

DreamingInPhosphorescence · 14/12/2023 00:47

One of my favourite bands is touring soon, and I have a dh who is a reluctant gig goer. I did exactly the same as I always do, bought two tickets without consulting him and then he can please himself whether he joins me or I’ll take a friend or sell the other one. If I waited for him to make a decision we’d never see another band in our lives…
I’d buy a ticket, also wishing you an advance happy birthday!

Isittimeformynapyet · 14/12/2023 00:30

BrimfulOfMash · 13/12/2023 23:47

It has become a big issue because you have noted it as your birthday celebration. Separate it out from that.

Celebrate your birthday with cinema and pizza and DH, and then the next day do a no frills trip to see your band.

I never understand posters who sound like they're giving orders instead of suggestions.

Go to the cinema OP, and then eat pizza - even if there's nothing you want to see and you don't like pizza 🤔

Yesyoucant · 14/12/2023 00:26

I go to gigs myself all the time now. My husband also hates London, so we've not been there together in a long time. A gig I really want tickets for is sold out in my home town so we're all (kids too) going to Liverpool. My son is going to legends football game with one of us in the afternoon and I'll go to the gig myself at night.
I'd just go by myself if I were you. I spent a few hours on my own on my bday this year. Coffee, cake and cinema then met a friend for dinner later. Bliss!

Also trying work out the band you're wanting to see......

mrsjackrussell · 14/12/2023 00:18

may he has something else planned for you as a surprise and that’s why he’s being funny over it. Maybe a break somewhere else?

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/12/2023 00:11

I'd just go by myself. It's your birthday. Do what YOU want!

TheSquareMile · 14/12/2023 00:09

Which band is it and where are they playing in London?

Which part of the country would you be travelling from?

BrimfulOfMash · 13/12/2023 23:47

It has become a big issue because you have noted it as your birthday celebration. Separate it out from that.

Celebrate your birthday with cinema and pizza and DH, and then the next day do a no frills trip to see your band.

WilloTheWispy · 13/12/2023 23:23

@warmmincepies please tell us who the band is!
BTW - I say go by yourself.
And have a blast!!

CatWithARabbit · 13/12/2023 23:18

Hmmm I think he's got tickets and arranged an overnight stay

PinkyPork · 13/12/2023 22:52

Go by yourself, I always go see my favourite band by myself. That way I can do what I like, queue for the front, etc. it's his problem if he feels guilty.

autienotnaughty · 13/12/2023 22:42

I'd be a bit irritated by him tbh. This is what you want to do for your birthday and he's making it all about him.

He's put you in the position of if he comes you are going yo feel like he is not enjoying himself. And if he doesn't come he's told you he will feel bad.

I'd take a friend or tell him you are going alone and leave him to feel whatever he feels

gannett · 13/12/2023 22:41

Absolutely go, no question. You're up for doing it by yourself if needs be, and you shouldn't feel guilty about that. If you love an artist or band enough to follow them through so many years and so many cities that's something to treasure imo. And a one-off gig that isn't part of a larger tour could be an opportunity for them to do something new in terms of setlist or vibe. You'll probably get chatting to fellow hardcore fans even if you're on your own. I don't think I'd want to drag someone who wasn't also really into my favourite artists along to a gig.

Your husband is being weird, epecially as it sounds out of character. If he's gone to an entirely different country with you to see them, he can't be that averse to either the band or to travel, so... I'd try to get to the bottom of that. Maybe it's London he really doesn't like?

ChristmasSteps295 · 13/12/2023 22:35

ClemFandangoCanYouHearMe · 13/12/2023 21:19

Do it on your own. You'll have a great time and there'll be plenty of people to talk to at the gig who all like the same band you do.

I flew four hours to Australia (from New Zealand) on my own for one night to see JimBob support Pop Will Eat Itself because I love them both so much and their tour didn't cross the ditch to NZ. I got cheap flights and had an absolute blast

Love PWEI!!

ChristmasSteps295 · 13/12/2023 22:33

I think he should go along with you, but it's not the end of the world if he doesn't. I've gone to many cities on my own to gigs. I don't know how far away you are from London, but I am happy driving up to two or three hours and then back after a gig.

London is my least favourite city to go to because it's a nightmare to park but if that was the only date, I'd do it.

I'd rather go on my own than not go at all/go with someone who is going to be a misery guts about it.

You're there to see a loud band, not chat to others so I don't think it makes any difference really. I go early and get right to the front. Always have a great time.

ShazzyG71 · 13/12/2023 22:32

OP. Please tell us who you’re so desperate to see x

FlyingCherub · 13/12/2023 22:24

DH gets dragged to all sorts of concerts that he mutters about cost and transport but is a fairly good sport. We saw Coldplay 4 times on the last tour....!!
He did say he's a little over them now, bless. But we saw Springsteen at BST and I've just booked again for Cardiff next year as I didn't get the whole BST vibe at all and was desperate to see him in a stadium atmosphere. BST felt like a food festival with a band playing... and we were a long way back.

If he's being miserable, go on your own or go with a friend. But don't miss out on seeing your favourite band.

Icepop79 · 13/12/2023 22:21

Another vote for going alone. I choose to
see my favourite band on my own. I love it and I feel more able to let my hair down. In fact they’re playing in London next week and I’m trying to decide whether to get a resale ticket and go, despite having seen them a couple of weeks ago!

easylikeasundaymorn · 13/12/2023 22:10

I think it's the opposite of a lose-lose situation FOR YOU to be honest, it would only be that if you let his feelings either stop you from going or affect your enjoyment. Presuming you can afford it you are doing a completely reasonable thing, tickets, transport and 1 night in a hotel is hardly excessive.

otherwise - you get a ticket and go by yourself/with a friend - I would definitely stay overnight and make a little break of it = win
or he decides to come = win

It might be lose/lose for him but why make that your problem? I would just book, tell him you've done so and if he wants to come he's very welcome but the onus is on him to decide. Make it clear you won't begrudge it if he doesn't come but if he does come it has to be with good will not 'I'm doing you a favour' sulking.

I can't believe there is NOTHING he'd want to do in the whole of London, ffs!

Plus it's not even on your actual birthday so you could still spend that with him.

10HailMarys · 13/12/2023 22:01

First of all, I think if my DP’s favourite band was playing a one-off gig in London the day after his birthday, I would probably be happy to go whether I was excited about the gig or not, because it would be his birthday present, and not about me. Assuming I could get the time off work, I’d go and we’d make a mini break of it. In fact, DP once did this for my birthday for a gig in Oxford that he wasn’t at all bothered about. So I think your DP was being a tit to moan about it in the first place because it’s for YOUR birthday and not his.

Secondly if he doesn’t want to go, he is being ridiculous to then make you feel guilty about going on your own! Just go. Sod him.

3luckystars · 13/12/2023 21:59

Is there nobody else you can go with???

warmmincepies · 13/12/2023 21:58

Oh, I didn't expect so many replies!

Yes, the LTB/existential crisis comments were tongue-in-cheek - other than this weird situation, he's normally as good as gold. And as much as I'd love it, I highly, highly doubt he's about to whisk me off on a surprise birthday trip to London, as he clearly detests the place!

To the poster who pointed out that it's a lose-lose situation: yes, that's exactly how I feel. Like, what am I supposed to do here, in his view? He's suggested plenty of alternatives to do for my bday here, but... none of them are going to the gig? Which is the day after my birthday?? How can I do anything else when I know that's happening?

I think I'll have to raise it again, otherwise just go by myself. It'll be a bit ££ to go by train, but I'd even be fine slumming it on a coach (something he refuses to do after his first/last traumatic Megabus experience). Maybe he can put up money for a hotel to ease his guilt 🙄

I've gone down to London myself for shows but I think it's more the fact that it's for my birthday and he wouldn't be there with me that's the issue. But if he hates London that much, well... that's on him? Thanks, all.

OP posts: