Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it reasonable for a company to demand my measurements before helping me?

142 replies

Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 12:13

I bought a pair of jogging type trousers from a company that promotes itself to larger sizes, and with not much wear they became faulty. I emailed and complained expecting them to help me. The reply I got had me feeling uncomfortable. The person said before they could help me that I would have to measure myself and give them my usual dress size, thigh size, waist, hips, inside leg and said that they had looked at my previous orders and had seen I had bought 3 different sizes over the orders, which I felt was implying I had caused the fault by being too fat. They said I would have to provide all of these before they could help me. I have never had to do this before for a bit of faulty clothing. Am I being an unreasonable to think this isn’t on? Maybe it’s just me being sensitive but is this standard practice? What do people think? If it’s me being sensitive I’ll leave it but my first instinct was to be upset over it.

OP posts:
ApoodlecalledPenny · 13/12/2023 16:43

I stopped buying from them a year or so ago. I just didn’t find the tights great quality, but the colours were so good that I overlooked it for a while.

The level of questioning goes way beyond acceptable. Even if you think they need to work out if the op is in the right size, this isn’t the way to go about it.

Cerealkiller4U · 13/12/2023 16:41

Mrsttcno1 · 13/12/2023 15:07

Totally agree with this.

They want to know if it is a fault, or if it’s something caused by ordering the wrong size at which point they don’t have to replace it. Totally fine and if it was shoes and they were querying your size etc then you wouldn’t think anything of it, clothes are no different.

Edited

They know the size.

they saw the order.

Cerealkiller4U · 13/12/2023 16:40

Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 12:13

I bought a pair of jogging type trousers from a company that promotes itself to larger sizes, and with not much wear they became faulty. I emailed and complained expecting them to help me. The reply I got had me feeling uncomfortable. The person said before they could help me that I would have to measure myself and give them my usual dress size, thigh size, waist, hips, inside leg and said that they had looked at my previous orders and had seen I had bought 3 different sizes over the orders, which I felt was implying I had caused the fault by being too fat. They said I would have to provide all of these before they could help me. I have never had to do this before for a bit of faulty clothing. Am I being an unreasonable to think this isn’t on? Maybe it’s just me being sensitive but is this standard practice? What do people think? If it’s me being sensitive I’ll leave it but my first instinct was to be upset over it.

They can’t do that. Under the consumer rights act 2015 they should replace or repair your item.

they can’t ask that you measure yourself. I would say the above and say that they can’t ask you to measure yourself and if they can’t help you. You can I’ll ring citizens advice and get them to open a case with trading standards.

I did this when a skate company wouldn’t refund my daughters skates that came broken.

Flickersy · 13/12/2023 16:37

Asking if you're sure you have the right size is not fat shaming.

if you're a size 10 wearing a size 4 and they wear out faster, it's not fat shaming to ask if you're sure you have the right size. Just the same as if you're a size 26 wearing a size 20.

Making sure your customer has a good fit is good service.

cezannesapple · 13/12/2023 16:18

Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 13:19

It’s snag

That is shocking from Snag!

Onionsmadeofglass · 13/12/2023 16:15

Finteq · 13/12/2023 16:08

Well I guess they could have sorted out a replacement and then sent a questionnaire asking for feedback after?

Which no one would fill out?
They want to know if they should replace or not. Which does depend somewhat on whether the size bought was sufficient for OP’s measurements. And that’s not necessarily a yes or no question because there are lots of measurements involved in a pair of joggers. Waist, hips, low hips around the bum, rise, thighs, inside leg.
12 wears is also a bit of an issue. I agree it’s not very long and indicative of crap quality but it’s not nothing either. Most clothes will break after say 50ish washes.

Mrsttcno1 · 13/12/2023 16:14

Finteq · 13/12/2023 16:08

Well I guess they could have sorted out a replacement and then sent a questionnaire asking for feedback after?

Right… but if the size is the problem and they just send another of the same size, OP will be back on the phone complaining again when the new pair rips.

The item was not faulty when OP received it, which means part of the business “helping” is establishing what/how it is faulty. If I bought a top and 6 weeks later spilt wine on it and stained it, I can’t get a replacement because it’s my fault. If you order the wrong size clothing, it is naturally going to show wear & tear quicker, that’s not the businesses fault. They are trying to establish if that is the case here, and if it is then they will be helping OP by giving the correct size for future.

ShouldIbeLeftWithLess · 13/12/2023 16:13

Gosh that's really disappointing to hear OP. My most recent pair of tights had holes form by the big toe quite quickly. I guess they might ask the length and width of my toe if I complain!

SgtJuneAckland · 13/12/2023 16:12

I find their products so disappointing, their tights are very comfortable but they snag quicker than Primark cheapies which is ironic.
I bought five pairs last winter and in weeks 4 had holes in them , they replaced them all but the same happened. They never asked for my measurements though

Finteq · 13/12/2023 16:08

Onionsmadeofglass · 13/12/2023 15:58

OP, how is snag supposed to update their designs and recommended sizing if no one will give feedback about fit on different body sizes/shapes ? If they’re making a size that’s supposed to fit a 30inch thigh and 50inch waist but they start getting feedback that actually their customers with 50 inch waists generally have 35inch thighs and the tights keep breaking at the stress point where the thighs come together - that’s useful feedback and they might change the proportions of the tights in that size.
Reframing the question, it’s not really about whether you are too fat for the tights. It’s about whether the tights can accommodate the bodies snag says they are supposed to. It’s about making better fitting tights for plus size customers.

Well I guess they could have sorted out a replacement and then sent a questionnaire asking for feedback after?

Mrsttcno1 · 13/12/2023 16:06

OP your item from them is broken after 12 wears, they want to work out why that is to see if it is something they can prevent happening in future, if you’ve bought a size too small then that is the reason and they don’t have to worry or make any changes to their products, to know that they need to know your sizes.

I’d argue they actually were trying to help you, because if you have indeed bought the wrong size they will be able to tell you that to save you doing the same thing again.

MargotBlobby · 13/12/2023 16:04

I genuinely don’t think that email was bad. To me, it’s sounds like they are trying to ensure you get the correct size. I mean, you feel how you feel and no judgement, but on first read it sounds like genuinely helpful customer service.

WhyMeWhyNowWhyNot · 13/12/2023 16:03

That’s awful - and so disappointing from Snag 😢

Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 16:03

My point is no other company ever has said before they will help me that they needed my measurements. In fact I’ve never ever been asked for my measurements by a company for any reason so other companies must manage to develop decent products without getting their customers measurements.

OP posts:
Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 16:01

And it was joggers not tights.

OP posts:
Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 16:00

They can pay for research with different sizes. They aren’t paying me.

OP posts:
Onionsmadeofglass · 13/12/2023 15:58

OP, how is snag supposed to update their designs and recommended sizing if no one will give feedback about fit on different body sizes/shapes ? If they’re making a size that’s supposed to fit a 30inch thigh and 50inch waist but they start getting feedback that actually their customers with 50 inch waists generally have 35inch thighs and the tights keep breaking at the stress point where the thighs come together - that’s useful feedback and they might change the proportions of the tights in that size.
Reframing the question, it’s not really about whether you are too fat for the tights. It’s about whether the tights can accommodate the bodies snag says they are supposed to. It’s about making better fitting tights for plus size customers.

Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 15:55

Because I WAS a big fan of their stuff. My point before we got into my size, was that if I had paid £5 from primark that I might have said oh well after a few months but at £23 a pair I had expected them to last longer considering they aren’t daily worn. Probably only worn them a dozen times or so.

OP posts:
Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 15:53

And not all of the stuff had been for me. I bought some tights for a gift.

OP posts:
Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 15:53

The orders were over a 3 year period so not lately.

OP posts:
Allofaflutter · 13/12/2023 15:51

I had only had them a few months.

OP posts:
Precipice · 13/12/2023 15:48

Unfortunately, there's nothing unusual in a customer ordering things across multiple sizes before. Sizing varies across particular items offered and sometimes varies even within what's supposedly the same item line.

Mrsttcno1 · 13/12/2023 15:44

Nanny0gg · 13/12/2023 15:12

Unless they measure the OP themselves, they won't really know, will they?

They obviously can’t personally measure each customer, asking their size is the best alternative, but you’re being deliberately a bit obtuse.

The item was not faulty when it arrived, so the company is trying to work out what has gone wrong. Couple that with the fact OP has ordered multiple different sizes previously, they are trying to ascertain what has happened and how to help. It’s no point them sending the same size out again if the size is the issue, it will just happen again!

Heyhoherewegoagain · 13/12/2023 15:38

I’m going against the grain, and saying they’re trying to give you good service. You’ve made 3 failed orders and the6 want to help you get it right…

without seein the actual words of the email, I’m not commenting on that because you e said they’ve “implied”, so it’s your interpretation of their words.
If you’re a larger than average person, of course sis is a very sensitive issue, I’ve been there and was there for years so it’s not that I don’t understand the issue,

MrFlibblesEyes · 13/12/2023 15:32

I don't actually think the email reads too badly. It sounds like they are trying to work out the nature of the fault if there is one. The fact that you have ordered 3 different sizes previously could look to them like you keep guessing which size you may need rather than actually taking your measurements, so asking for them could be to double check you are ordering a big enough size (a lot of people don't read size guides at all).

Swipe left for the next trending thread