Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not doing Christmas gifts with DH?

134 replies

pumpkinfarm · 13/12/2023 09:32

Does anyone else not swap Xmas gifts with their DP? Can't work out if it's a bit miserable of me. There's nothing we both want/need that we couldn't just buy ourselves. We share a bank account and I'd rather just use the money to pay off the mortgage tbh 😄

OP posts:
crozzfit · 13/12/2023 15:01

We don't do them for each other. Nothing we need or want. We always agree in advance though.

PoppyCup · 13/12/2023 15:00

To me it would send the message: we're not important anymore. You can't be bothered to make me happy or be kind and generous to me and I can't be bothered either. Our relationship isn't worth any effort or supposed to be fun. Only the kids matter.

Presents don't have to cost the earth if you are skint - it could be a paperback of a new novel by an author they know you love/you know they love, or a bar of hand soap in your/his favourite scent. It's about showing you still see the person and their tastes and pleasures matter to you. If you are not skint, all the more reason to make some effort at the darkest time of year to cheer up your partner. Why would anyone not bother to do that for the person they chose to spend their life with?

AnotherEmma · 13/12/2023 14:50

One year I was so stressed and overwhelmed about Christmas (with young children and work, December always feels stressful) that DH and I agreed we wouldn't worry about getting each other presents; one less thing to do. However, it tends to be easy enough to think of one or two presents that the other will like, since we obviously know each other well, even if we are both difficult to buy for and buy ourselves things we want/need anyway. We do enjoy exchanging gifts but I prefer birthdays as they're spread throughout the year and you can focus on one person at a time! Like PPs I prioritise the children. And we do secret Santa between the adults in the family which makes it a bit easier.

EmptyYoghurtPot · 13/12/2023 14:29

DH and I don’t do presents for occasions but we do treat ourselves/each other as and when we see things we like. For example I like a perfume that is only available in France and Spain so if he is there on business he’ll try and get me some. Christmas for us is more about the children/grandchildren.

stayathomer · 13/12/2023 14:25

We used to not but then it’s a lovely added little bit of niceness when you do, even put a limit on it

DancingDangerously · 13/12/2023 14:24

But yes, if we had children who needed to see a good relationship modelled and also the joy of giving as opposed to just the fun of receiving - and most importantly the fact that mum deserves to be valued and thought of on special days too, then we would do a gift exchange for sure (and did, when my grown-up children were younger).

DancingDangerously · 13/12/2023 14:21

Our relationship is very strong, very close and we both love to spoil each other. He gets me the most wonderful, thoughtful gifts when he does get them.

That's probably why it's not a big deal to either of us to do gifts on specific days - the rest of the time is full of thoughtful, loving, caring exchanges between us.

ChristmasTreeMagic · 13/12/2023 14:13

I think it's down to each couple really and what their relationship is generally like.

Dh and I are married 20+ years and we still love to spoil each other at Christmas and birthdays. We're also kind and thoughtful to each other throughout the year and willingly do lots to help each other so the idea of dh driving / collecting me from a night out with simply not register for us as a 'present' as it's something we do all the time anyway.

We're both very good at buying the other nice, thoughtful presents and have always felt that it's also a good thing for dc to see us care for each other in this way.

This year we're going on a holiday directly after Christmas (with dc) so we're doing smaller gifts and we always do a stocking for each other too.

I absolutely understand that some people are not into buying / receiving presents but I would not like it myself to be honest. I LOVE buying things for dh and seeing his face. He had a very poor upbringing and never really had Christmas until we got together. Now he loves it!

ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 13/12/2023 14:13

The only thing that matters is both partners being on the same page.
My DH and I exchange stockings at midnight, usually consumable luxuries of some kind that are a real treat. It's our "tea break" in amongst all the building of toys and last minute tidying up. I'd be really sad to not have our little tradition anymore, even though I could buy myself all those things whenever I felt like it.
To each their own etc.

RubyWinehouse · 13/12/2023 14:11

We also share finances so unless he specifically wants something I will just get him something useful, handy or a game for his xbox etc. He wouldn't know where to begin with me, so I usually just pick something myself, presents don't really matter, there have been times when we couldn't afford presents at all, but that's OK, it's really not important as long as we have each other.

Flossflower · 13/12/2023 14:09

Seagrassbasket · 13/12/2023 10:16

Going against the grain here but I think it’s the beginning of the end.

Was for my previous LTR anyway.

Absolutely rubbish. We have been very happily married for many many years. We only bought presents for the first few years of our relationship. I also don’t buy for adult children. We are all happy about this. We do spend quite a lot on grandchildren.
i just don’t see the need. It is the little things that you do for each other all the time that counts, not a present for Christmas or your birthday.

Socialyawkward · 13/12/2023 14:07

We don't receive gifts from famil so we do it mainly for dc we also buy from dc to each other. These are all small value token gifts. Dc feel sad if we can't join on the opening.

OrlandointheWilderness · 13/12/2023 14:07

Ah as well, and I apologise for being utterly nauseating - it's a bloody gift to fall asleep together every night. We've only been living together 6 months, together 2 1/2 years and we are so in love. 😂 😂

Sorry!!!

slowwalkofshame · 13/12/2023 14:05

I suppose we cheat a bit and buy things we would normally but we give them as gifts. DH needed new trainers, slippers, ice scraper, diary, socks and so on so I bought him them and a few other bits a game, puzzle book, bottle of gin etc.

I wanted a record player and needed some skincare, art materials, calendars so he is giving me that and a few bits he'll pick up probably perfume, chocolates and a book or two (he has access to my amazon wishlist).

Its my birthday in the autumn and so from late summer on I usually hang fire on buying stuff for myself and just add it to my gift wishlist and DH gives it to me.

I suppose it is nice to get a total surprise that you love but didn't even know you wanted but how rare is that? My best gift like that was a pair of waterproof socks a friend gave me and my first pair of bluetooth headphones neither of which I even knew existed prior to getting given them.

My SIL insists on surprises from everyone and is then disappointed with most of her gifts.

To the OP do whatever suits you, in reality the most important thing about Christmas is the the food, the time off and spending time with your loved ones.

WallaceinAnderland · 13/12/2023 14:03

We don't buy presents just because it's a date on the calendar. It's pointless and a waste of money.

easylikeasundaymorn · 13/12/2023 14:02

CalistoNoSolo · 13/12/2023 09:53

I think it is a bit miserable really. If dp and I can't think of anything we want, we book a weekend away together instead. Can't you at least treat each other to a meal in a swanky restaurant?

but if they share finances they aren't treating each other, just basically going out for a meal together and paying for themselves. Which is nice if you want to do it but not really a treat or a present.

I've had a few 'buy/not buy' for family etc discussion with friends and colleagues recently - it's weird how for many people the only reason they exchange gifts with anyone other than their children is because they think OTHER people would judge them as miserable/grinchy if they didn't. Which is all a bit mad really, millions of people spending money they don't have on crap they don't want. Shows how much marketing affects us.

Fair enough if you do get joy out of giving/receiving, absolutely crack on but it was interesting how many people said 'I really don't want anything but feel I have to/should buy for x.' And x is probably thinking the same!

Spencer0220 · 13/12/2023 14:01

DH and I did surprise gifts our first Christmas/birthday. It was fun once, but we both came to the conclusion that it wasn't for us long term. Especially because we share all online shopping accounts!

Now we decide what we both want and the other gets it.

emmylousings · 13/12/2023 14:00

We don't. I really can't be arsed and just seems totally pointless!

DancingDangerously · 13/12/2023 13:59

If you're both happy then why would it be miserable? We swap and change depending on mood and circumstances - sometimes we exchange gifts, sometimes I pick my own and his, sometimes we don't do anything and other times we buy a bigger 'gift' for the house.

Pinocolada · 13/12/2023 13:57

Me and DH never get Xmas or birthday presents for each other. Like you finance's are completely shared so it is not like he would be buying me a gift as I would be paying for it too! I also don't believe it is the beginning of the end we have been like this for over 10 years. If you are both on the same page it is fine better to do that than waste money on something pointless just because you feel obliged to buy a gift.

ParkerPipe · 13/12/2023 13:53

We don't buy gifts for each other for Christmas, anniversaries or birthdays. We just decided not to as anything we wanted, we would buy as and when we wanted it.

In the last 2 years we decided as a family (3 adult kids) not to buy Christmas presents for each other. All my kids are in new careers, with relationships and rents to pay for. We decided to keep to birthday gifts but not Christmas. The only exceptions we have for the Christmas rule is the oldest and youngest get gifts, that means my mum, who couldn't stop buying presents if she tried as it is the way she shows love and my granddaughter who is 2. As more grandkids come along we will keep it to kiddies and my mum only.

I like to buy things for people as I see something or they need something, It's liberating not to have to exchange wishlists etc and we much prefer spending time together

ToriesAgainstHumanity · 13/12/2023 13:50

We don't. It involves more thinking on what he can get me.
I do all Christmas related things so it's one less job.

ToriesAgainstHumanity · 13/12/2023 13:50

We don't. It involves more thinking on what he can get me.
I do all Christmas related things so it's one less job.

FrozenGhost · 13/12/2023 13:48

We don't exchange gifts on Christmas or birthdays. That makes it sound negative but I think of it like I'm getting a gift - the gift of not thinking of something and the gift of not shopping for it. It's also the gift of less clutter in the house, and the gift of not having to go oh wow I love it it's amazing.

SpongeBob2022 · 13/12/2023 13:46

We stopped doing proper gifts for each other a few years ago and I haven't missed it at all. We do still get a token gift for each other via our 9 year old. This year there's a book I'd like and I'll likely get my favourite chocolates (so total of about £10-15).

I think the first year we decided we'd put the money we'd usually spend on presents on some furniture between us in the New Year. And we've never really gone back to presents since (but not bought anything between us either).

ETA we do still do birthday gifts (although not £100s worth). I think that's a bit different because a birthday is an individual day just for you.