Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not doing Christmas gifts with DH?

134 replies

pumpkinfarm · 13/12/2023 09:32

Does anyone else not swap Xmas gifts with their DP? Can't work out if it's a bit miserable of me. There's nothing we both want/need that we couldn't just buy ourselves. We share a bank account and I'd rather just use the money to pay off the mortgage tbh 😄

OP posts:
Devon23 · 14/12/2023 09:38

Each to thier own however having seen my inlaws go in to a care home and thier house and savings disappear within a year on fees the same home another lady with nothing to contribute gets the same service. Added to that my children's dad died from c aged 42 i believe we should pay our bills so they are not a worry but live life every day as its not guaranteed we will be here tmw.

Wishingdirect · 14/12/2023 09:29

I have bought my DH a draught excluder for Christmas…. And I think he’s got me an electric blanket (we’ve moved to a cold house!) We don’t have loads of money and would rather prioritise getting kids presents. The idea in our society that you must buy presents for people because it’s Christmas really irritates me and is commercial bullshit imo. It just contributes to more tat produced and more landfill so I think it’s great you are going against the grain and doing what works for you.

blackpear · 14/12/2023 09:25

My DH hasn’t got me anything the last couple of years and his attitude to birthdays is v perfunctory too. It really upsets me. I spend weeks and a fortune trying to make Christmas nice and then sit there, not even an afterthought. I would be happy with a nicely wrapped second-hand book from Oxfam and a bar of chocolate, but I want to feel appreciated and loved.
he is a v generous, kind person, who hates occasion and ceremony, so I get it, but I do mind.

Minimooncat · 14/12/2023 08:50

We got a new bed which was a present to each other and said we aren't doing gifts. Though every year I can't help myself and I end up buying him stuff. Always things he's mentioned though and needs.

DangerousAlchemy · 14/12/2023 08:46

We're not doing pressies for each other this year. Together since 1996 & married since 2000. I might buy us an air-fryer after Christmas maybe. 😆😆 I'm not bothered about Christmas anyway. It's stressful enough buying gifts for the kids & other relatives.

nokidshere · 13/12/2023 23:36

We always do gifts. For birthdays and Christmas. For anniversaries we usually go out. Our finances are totally shared, it's not about the money, it's just about knowing the other person has thought of you and taking part with the children in present opening. It doesn't have to be expensive, just a token to unwrap, a 'saw this and thought of you' little thing. Mostly these days it's edible or quaffable.

The best present ever was from a little girl I used to mind, her mum told her to choose something for me and she bought a large bag of walkers crisps because she knew they were (still are) my favourite.

Agreeing not to do presents is one thing, but not doing them because 'you can't be bothered' seems a bit sad really.

EverySporkIsSacred · 13/12/2023 22:40

DH and I have almost never done gifts. Some years one of us notices something the other would really like and will get it (one year, quite some time ago in a galaxy far far away DH got me a Game Boy Color which I was over the moon with, another year I got him a maglite which he used on evening walks for years) but the only regular thing is that we gift each other an equal pre-agreed on amount of money.

toddlermam · 13/12/2023 22:40

We usually just use the money to book a weekend away so it's something we can both enjoy together

Onelifeonly · 13/12/2023 22:39

Over the years we've changed it around. For a while we used to buy ourselves a present for the house e.g. a new rug. Sometimes though we buy each other presents as an example to our children, though that usually happens more for birthdays than Christmas. TBH we have got bored of the whole thing - we share our money so it doesnt really make sense. I'd rather buy my own, and I rarely know what to get for DH so end up buying him clothing he only likes about 50% of the time.

BlackAldi · 13/12/2023 22:37

We have a “no present” rule unless we saw something that we were really inspired to get. It’s worked out to be fairly equal over the years. We don’t get much but when we do it’s usually a really great present!

Wednesday6 · 13/12/2023 22:31

We almost stopped but decided to continue. He splurged on me last year and honestly it was just so lovely! We went without gifts on one occasion and I'm not a huge fan of gifts and wasting money.. but without the gifts the day started on the wrong foot and got spoilt.

FairytaleOfKent · 13/12/2023 22:11

Gwenhwyfar · 13/12/2023 18:16

Is that really a gift or just you ordering something?

I guess you could say that, but we can't afford to treat ourselves to luxury items that we wouldn't purchase ourselves. I'd have to buy running shoes in the new year if I didn't get them for Christmas, but I can't afford to do that. We used to buy surprise gifts before we had children.

CeriB82 · 13/12/2023 21:59

DH & I have never swapped Christmas gifts. Don’t see any point in it. If i want it i buy it. We stopped birthday’s too. Its not affecting me…. Its happened for 26 years!

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 13/12/2023 21:57

Nope, we haven't for several years. It doesn't feel right when we have debt to pay off to dip into our account. He's rubbish at buying presents and there's nothing he ever wants so we just don't bother. Have a great relationship and some times I wish there were big sweeping romantic gestures but then I'd just get annoyed at him for spending so he can't win!

My father on the other hand totally expects presents and a stocking....he's in his 80s. He genuinely would tantrum like a child if he didn't have his stocking!

WorkCleanRepeat · 13/12/2023 21:45

We haven't really bothered with xmas gifts for each other since we had children.

We do always get each other an advent calendar and my Mum and Dad look after the kids for a day between Xmas and New year so that we can have a day out together. This year we've booked an immersive theatre thing in London.

I think we might have to start doing a stocking for each other again because as a pp said, I think it would be nice for the children to see now they are getting a bit older.

Goodlard · 13/12/2023 21:20

36 years married, never a year without buying each other a present.

Best year was when we had a budget of £10 as we were skint, he made me the most lovely hand made present, that still pride of place in our home.

Never ever been extravagant and never ever a budget of more than £50, often less.

But we both enjoy it, always can think of something.

It suits us.

Yes, we buy what we want during the year also.

waltzingparrot · 13/12/2023 21:11

We've stopped buying each other 'stuff' to find house space for. We buy tickets to go somewhere together.

User2856948 · 13/12/2023 20:35

We haven't for years, we did when DS was small as part of the present opening but only small things like a CD or book. We never do now as we get things when we want them.

2chocolateoranges · 13/12/2023 20:28

I think it’s nice for the children to see us exchanging gifts, we give gifts to everyone else so would seem strange not to get each other a gift.

we used to spend lots on each other however we now spend under £50 and then go away for a weekend Jan/Feb time. A wee child free weekend which is a nice treat.

Seagrassbasket · 13/12/2023 18:59

Oooooh I was contentious 😉

I do agree with a PP that it was perhaps a symptom of a failing relationship rather than a cause.

But with DP, we rarely go out or do things for ourselves at the moment and have very little spare cash. The daily grind is a bit of a grind, luckily we are not particularly materialistic, but we do put aside money every month to have a nice Christmas. So it’s a way to be thoughtful and think of each other and a way for us both to have a treat. Almost a reminder that we do think of and value one another. I enjoy thinking of what he would like and him having a nice thing or two.

But equally I understand other peoples points of view! Horses for courses.

phoenixrosehere · 13/12/2023 18:33

It's about showing you still see the person and their tastes and pleasures matter to you. If you are not skint, all the more reason to make some effort at the darkest time of year to cheer up your partner.

DH and I see each other without feeling the need to spend/waste money because there are shorter hours of sunlight for a few months. We don’t need to buy gifts just because it’s a holiday. We treat each other and ourselves plenty throughout the year.

TheOGCCL · 13/12/2023 18:26

We won't be doing gifts.

For a long while I've been in the tell the person what you want so there isn't a load of waste and disappointment camp. But more and more I'm thinking that is so ridiculous as then everyone just buys things on a list when each person might as well buy the stuff directly. So that starts to lend itself back to surprises.

So where we can control it without looking like Scrooges we will take it. No gifts at all for each other.

If it was up to me I would make charity donations on people's behalf and ask them to do the same on mine. We tried that during the pandemic when it felt even more ridiculous to be spending money on gifts for a rather random commercially driven occasion but think some family members found it weird and pious.

I think Christmas would be a far lovelier thing without all the gifts (children excepted).

Mehjustmeh · 13/12/2023 18:26

We didn't for a couple of years when we'd just brought our house and money was tight.

We've started again now and it's quite nice as we're a small family unit. DH loves stuff so he's easy to buy for and we always set a limit of about £150 we also set up a Xmas whattsapp throughout the year that we drop ideas in of what we want to avoid things for the sake of it

lightelmqueen · 13/12/2023 18:24

We just exchange a small token gift just for the kids sake. I always buy my husband a hard back book from the local second hand book shop. I'm a sahm so I always feel strange buying him gifts as even though it's family money it's like he's just buying himself a present

thebear1 · 13/12/2023 18:22

We set a £20 limit so our children see we also get gifts and Christmas is for the whole family. Otherwise we'd not bother.