Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not doing Christmas gifts with DH?

134 replies

pumpkinfarm · 13/12/2023 09:32

Does anyone else not swap Xmas gifts with their DP? Can't work out if it's a bit miserable of me. There's nothing we both want/need that we couldn't just buy ourselves. We share a bank account and I'd rather just use the money to pay off the mortgage tbh 😄

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DangerousAlchemy · 16/12/2023 11:19

Twoweeksandcounting · 16/12/2023 08:40

I made a similar post once, explaining we were booking a night away in the new year as a Christmas treat, but didn’t really plan to give additional presents. I had lots of people telling me it was miserable and we really ought to get each other a few little bits (socks, shower gel, etc) to put under the tree, to set a good example to our daughter of how Christmas is about giving and sharing.

Then another time I posted asking for some little “filler” gift suggestions for my daughter, who had some nice main gifts, but essentially it was going to look a bit sparse under the tree. I had enough money to get a few more little bits and pieces, but was told by rather a lot of people that it was wasteful, giving for the sake of giving, and essentially made out like my daughter would be a spoiled madam for having some little extras.

So you can’t win, it would seem!

That's mumsnet for you 🙄@Twoweeksandcounting I comment on posts but I'm not sure I'll ever be brave enough to start my own post! Some people are brutal!

Twoweeksandcounting · 16/12/2023 08:40

I made a similar post once, explaining we were booking a night away in the new year as a Christmas treat, but didn’t really plan to give additional presents. I had lots of people telling me it was miserable and we really ought to get each other a few little bits (socks, shower gel, etc) to put under the tree, to set a good example to our daughter of how Christmas is about giving and sharing.

Then another time I posted asking for some little “filler” gift suggestions for my daughter, who had some nice main gifts, but essentially it was going to look a bit sparse under the tree. I had enough money to get a few more little bits and pieces, but was told by rather a lot of people that it was wasteful, giving for the sake of giving, and essentially made out like my daughter would be a spoiled madam for having some little extras.

So you can’t win, it would seem!

Wellhellooooodear · 16/12/2023 08:16

I don't think it's unusual but I find it a bit sad. But then I love giving gifts so each to their own.

Coffeeismyfriend1 · 16/12/2023 08:10

It depends on you and DP, I guess. We tend to buy each other stuff for our hobbies. DH likes diamond painting so I got him one he really wants and a nice new pen for it. In the past I got him a light board for it. He also build Star Wars Lego so I usually get him a new one of those. I like Harry Potter Lego so he usually gets me a new set etc.

We usually get something for each other from the kids too. I think it’s nice for the kids to see us get something too.

EarthMamaLee · 15/12/2023 10:06

Totally fine.

We’re the opposite however and go a bit overboard with each other, sane with our daughters. Both grew up being fairly spilt by family so I guess it’s what we’re used to 🙈

margotrose · 15/12/2023 07:42

CalistoNoSolo · 13/12/2023 09:53

I think it is a bit miserable really. If dp and I can't think of anything we want, we book a weekend away together instead. Can't you at least treat each other to a meal in a swanky restaurant?

We do that whenever we want throughout the year. It doesn't need to be Christmas to treat your partner.

beguilingeyes · 15/12/2023 07:40

DHs birthday is in February so it feels that as soon as we've come out of Christmas expense I have two things to deal with. It's just never ending and I'd love to stop it.

Twobigsapphires · 14/12/2023 17:20

Exh and I stopped after we had dc as we we typically too broke after buying for kids etc. if we had spare cash we would use it for a meal out or something for the home. Never bothered us.

im remarried now, and more financially stable to boot, but mooted a few years in if we shouldn’t bother exchanging gifts. Dh was horrified and said he would never not want to get my anything for Xmas. He loves gift buying and always buys me lovely things so I’m not complaining. As Dh rarely treats himself, I like to treat him at Xmas too. Yes we have our own money and can buy ourselves what we want, but it is nice to be thought of, be thoughtful towards each other and surprise each other.

Imisssleep2 · 14/12/2023 17:17

Last year we said just do something small like £20-£30 as we were buying zoo passes in the new year. This year his family are doing secret Santa and I didn't want one of us to get the other, then have to buy another gift to exchange with each other if that makes sense? And like you there is nothing we need, so we are just doing secret Santa with the family, although I suspect he picked my name anyway haha. We will do a token gift from the our son to the other parent for our son to give on the day though, just like choca or socks etc.

gettingthereonemistakeatatime · 14/12/2023 16:57

No don't do gifts for any occasion. This is mainly because he is so awful at buying gifts and I am so bad at receiving rubbish gifts, but also because we are grown ups and buy things for ourselves as and when we want and need them.
If I see something he might like then I will buy it as a surprise... but to be honest if I saw something and it wasn't near birthday or Christmas I'd buy it anyway.

We (I) buy a few little things for the stockings, just to open with the DCs on Christmas morning (face cream and gloves for me, whisky and socks for him) but only so the DCs don't think we hate each other 😅
Any romance and effort is long gone, along with the panic and anxiety... and we are both far happier as a result😆

DoesNotPlayWellWithIdiots · 14/12/2023 16:54

We stopped exchanging presents a few years ago. We never knew what to get each other because if there was anything each of us wanted during the year we'd just buy it for ourselves anyway. Likewise birthdays and anniversaries, though we do celebrate those with a day out and dinner somewhere. Christmas shopping is stressful enough as it is so it's a relief to have fewer presents to have to think about!

Mulhollandmagoo · 14/12/2023 16:28

We don't do gifts either! Christmas is a super expensive time of the year, and I hate buying for the sake of buying. A few years ago, we decided we would stop doing birthday gifts too, and once a year book ourselves a night away somewhere nice and spend some time together - no work, no kids! it was a great idea!

Toomanysquishmallows · 14/12/2023 15:45

My partner and I do presents , I really enjoy getting him things . Both our younger children have special needs so meals out and holidays don’t really happen, so the presents are nice

Hunterrose · 14/12/2023 14:59

As long as your both happy with it don't see why not!
My partner and I usually book our summer holiday around Xmas instead of spending money on presents!

EnjoyTheMushrooms · 14/12/2023 14:55

We haven’t for something like 15 years of being together. Birthdays or Christmases. I just don’t see the point.

bakewellbride · 14/12/2023 13:55

We never do xmas gifts - we'd rather the money went on the kids! I always write something heartfelt in a card to dh though.

We do birthday and anniversary gifts for each other and that's enough for us.

Mumtryingtolivethedream · 14/12/2023 13:31

We have started buying things to do rather than items so as a surprise he could get a voucher for a meal or a salon voucher or tickets to a show or concert a magazine subscription theres lots on Groupon etc.
It gives you something to look forward to throughout the year and to spend a bit of time together.

JuliaJoJelly · 14/12/2023 13:00

We always do gifts, even if it is something small.

I think it is important to teach children to buy for others and to watch others get presents. My daughter loves picking a present for daddy - even if it is is something totally random.

We are very big on teaching giving and not just receiving and always take her to buy something for the toy drive and food bank too. Helps her to understand that some people need help.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 14/12/2023 12:55

We used to just get token gifts - favourite chocs that sort of thing.

But we've got more money this year and I have to say I've really enjoyed spending money on him on stuff I know he wants but wouldn't buy (e.g. bought him new trainers - he doesn't need them, he would just like a new pair, so why not?!)

I think even if truly broke I would feel a bit let down with nothing to unwrap from him, and he would too. I like a physical reminder that someone's actively thinking and caring about me!

Lulu123450 · 14/12/2023 11:43

I’m completely with you on this. My husband is different to me though - a bit precious about presents 🙄 I think it’s an upbringing thing tbh. I’m just not fussed.

Coffeeandcocktails · 14/12/2023 10:49

This is the first year we’ve agreed not to do presents, partly as there’s nothing either of us can think of that we need/want, partly because I’m in my last 3 months of mat leave so finances are tight and don’t see the point in spending when we don’t need to.

Anyway, I felt guilty that he’ll have very little to open (from family) so I’m now putting together a sort of inexpensive gift hamper for him of mainly food, drinks and some toiletries.

FreshWinterMorning · 14/12/2023 10:14

@pumpkinfarm

I think it's a bit boring and miserable. JMO. Could you not just have a bottle of wine/port/whiskey, and a selection box or box of chocolates, and some socks, and a box of biscuits, and maybe a book? Several useful things, and several that you can eat/drink.

Me and DH sometimes earmark things we want - eg, I like a particularly expensive perfume, and have several hobbies that I spend money on, and he has a bit of an expensive hobby/interest, and he likes new shirts/socks. So we will use Christmas and birthdays and our Wedding Anniversary etc, to get what we want/need for things we like IYSWIM. (As well as a few goodies like booze and chocolates and socks and a book etc...)

Couldn't imagine having nothing from each other. Actually, we did that once - one Christmas, when we were struggling badly financially, when the kids were little (some 21-22 years ago,) and it was so fucking gloomy. Our children bought us nothing as they were just kids! And the adults in the wider family only bought for children. I got box of Roses from a friend, and a poinsettia from my neighbour. That was my lot.

.

caringcarer · 14/12/2023 09:54

I think it's a bit miserable. I like to be given a gift and a stocking too, so does DH. I ask what he wants for his main gift if I can't think of something I know for definite he wants. He does likewise.

DappledThings · 14/12/2023 09:51

All adult Christmas presents on my side are charity goat type. DH and I don't get for each other. I can't pick anything for myself let alone for someone else. I do get him birthday presents but never feel I've actually done well. Not because he seems ungrateful at all, I just have no confidence in it.

Not having to think about adults and presents is a massive gift in itself.

beguilingeyes · 14/12/2023 09:44

This is the dream. I would be all for it but my husband disagrees. See also Valentine's day, birthdays and anniversarys.
If there's something specific that I/we want then fair enough but it just seems relentless and I don't want random stuff that I'll never use.
A friend does Secret Santa for the family with a £50 limit. I would love to persuade my lot to do that.