Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate the anticipation of gifts from DH

59 replies

SheWasYar · 13/12/2023 09:29

25 years of it.
The tiny secondhand engagement ring (not keen after burglars went through mine & my mum's stuff)
After a physically tough year renovating, he wrapped the new toilet pan, nothing else.
Nothing - he worked in London, I was at home with a 3&1 year old. After that year I stopped buying for his family.

Over 25 years there's been very little memorable and very little on the trivial end - chocolate orange, etc.
There was one outstanding crazy thing, that he accidentally walked past and bought 20 years ago, it's on our wall and he uses that as proof he's brilliant.

For years he spent a lot of time on his work secret Santas - eg. A company Guess Who, a complex product recreated in Lego, etc which just made the lack of effort, a few days later, for me, even more hurtful.

How can I get past the past, accept each new year as a fresh start?
Am I being unreasonable to hate the idea of a gift from DH? How the fuck can I make this better in my head on the build up to Xmas & birthdays and as an example to my kids and for DH himself.

OP posts:
Shoxfordian · 13/12/2023 11:23

How have you still got any respect left after 24yrs of it?

These threads are so depressing; it's not hard to buy a present for someone - there's really no excuse for it- just thoughtless inconsiderate behaviour from a man who's supposed to love you

MothralovesGojira · 13/12/2023 11:21

Yep, I'm 24 years in with this type of bollocks from DP and it never ends.

One year I didn't write a list and I didn't really get anything apart from chocolate and a pair of 'sexy' leggings that were too small and more of a gift for him anyway. Another year he went out and panic bought some expensive toiletry sets which I am allergic to and never use which went straight to the charity shop.

I always get excuses such as "I didn't have time/you didn't say" but I always find the time to plan, execute and gift things that I know DP would like. He asked me for a list last month which I duly did provide and asked me if I wanted his - I said no because I had already got things that I knew that he wanted.
So who knows what I've got this year but he will open gifts that he will be very pleased with. He will always feel guilty at falling short/lack of effort but it doesn't actually change anything - he will put on his hair shirt and berate himself for being useless but never actually does anything about it.
Fucking shite is what it is and I lose a little more respect for him - every time.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 13/12/2023 11:20

My DH is hopeless at present buying. For my 60th he suggested going on a trawl of local antique shops so I could choose something. Nice idea but there are no local antique shops! So I gave him a list - with links - of 20 or so different things that he could choose from so my present was surprise anyway.

Two years ago for my birthday he gave me a set of 3 scented candles from the supermarket, the next year another scented candle - a larger one of the three from the previous year! For the past few years we have made large purchases for the two of us but this year I have told him to find me a present (and told him exactly what I want and where to find it!)

Workawayxx · 13/12/2023 11:03

Is he kind, considerate, thoughtful in other ways? Does he make you happy at least some of the time? If so and you do want to stay together, I'd just change the whole situation to avoid the suspense/disappointment etc.

Let him know you don't need to do gifts for each other anymore. Sit down and agree an activity/holiday/weekend away etc that you will both "give" each other (paid for jointly) for each event. Make it in the middle of your birthdays if possible. Then (very important) stop any buying gifts for him, even small ones, and just do the fun event/holidays.

Whataretheodds · 13/12/2023 11:01

How can I get past the past, accept each new year as a fresh start?

Why would you be trying to do this? Tell him how you feel - not your generic "not looking forward to Christmas" but specifically "it disappoints me that you put so little thought and effort into a Christmas present for me, especially when you spend time and effort on activities for work. Here is a list of the kind of things I would love to receive from you, and here's a couple of things to avoid.".

WhoIsnt · 13/12/2023 10:58

Agree not to do gifts? We only do tiny token gifts, like, a notepad or a chocolate orange. We don't really do Christmas presents (but we do birthdays).

Agree that with him and then buy yourself a treat as a consolation prize for having picked a slightly thoughtless DH.

BluebellsForest · 13/12/2023 10:46

How can I get past the past, accept each new year as a fresh start?

Why would you try to do this? Set yourself up for more disappointment?

Why do you think you can "model" present giving to him after 25 years of him not bothering?

possibly he just doesn't see it as a man thing, he doesn't see it as a human thing.

But you said he makes an effort for work secret Santas ie when he wants to impress.

His behaviour in getting angry is awful. He doesn't sound like a decent man. What is the rest of your relationship like?

SeulementUneFois · 13/12/2023 10:43

SheWasYar · 13/12/2023 10:23

Does he know how I feel?
Yes, but after 25 years that's basically all the emotions. If I say I don't look forward to Xmas, he gets sad, angry guilty. He also has has 25 years worth rolled in.
I've told him in the past it doesn't have to be fancy, expensive, original, unique it's just a thing, wrapped for surprise, that is delivered on a set day.
He gets angry and then guilty and resentful that the magical perfect gift doesn't mysteriously just appear, hence the nothing or it misfires like the lavoutry pan. . He's dismissive of the time and planning that goes into Christmas, his mum does a lot, even still and possibly he just doesn't see it as a man thing, he doesn't see it as a human thing.

@SheWasYar
Do you sit him down and compare what he does for this for you, with what he does for work people as you said earlier?

And explain clearly that if he can think and do all that for work and not for you, he shows he can do it but just doesn't care about you enough?

Like expressly and detailedly spelling it out to him? Even if he gets angry?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/12/2023 10:43

Maintain a list of things you would like, explain to him where to access the list, and make clear that you would like him to get you something from the list (and the list only) for your birthday and on Christmas. If he still doesn't bother then you have bigger problems, but my guess is that if there is a clear process he will follow it correctly.

DuploTrain · 13/12/2023 10:42

Me to DH: “what are you getting me for Christmas?”

DH: “what would you like?”

Me: “I’ll send you a link” or “x thing from y shop”.

I find it hard to comprehend that this is just an isolated present issue and everything else is fine in your relationship. You seem to be holding a lot or resentment… I’m not saying it’s unfounded resentment - maybe you should pay more attention to it and address whether you’re actually happy with the way things are.

Frasers · 13/12/2023 10:41

I never get the martyrdom and angst about gifts, I really don’t. If you want something send a link. End of.

WildFlowerBees · 13/12/2023 10:41

Send him a list and tell him to pick something, then you know you're getting something you want but it's still a surprise.

possiblenow · 13/12/2023 10:38

I don't understand why you can't clearly and specifically tell him what you would like and are expecting for Xmas?

There is Amazon and online shopping. Send him links if necessary.

Tell him in no uncertain terms that you are fully expecting gifts - that it's not unusual or too much to ask. Tell him very clearly that he needs to change in this respect or that's it.

Ponoka7 · 13/12/2023 10:36

Did you ever point out the effort for the secret Santa? We don't do adult gifts, when I've had partners we've given each other a list. I'm not good at gifts, even for my children etc. There's nothing that I want. It's been a communication issue, as much as anything. Did he start buying for his family when you stopped? What was that like?

Teddleshon · 13/12/2023 10:29

I buy my own Christmas present from DH using his credit card. He seems to be frozen in terror by the idea of coming up with present ideas and is generally incompetent at facilitating their purchase. He still buys me some small presents but the main present is now something that I really really want.

frazzledasarock · 13/12/2023 10:28

Tell him not to bother his clear lack of effort hurts. So please don’t bother.

do you get gifts from others?

Buy yourself nice gifts wrap them up and have something nice to open on Christmas morning.

SheWasYar · 13/12/2023 10:23

Does he know how I feel?
Yes, but after 25 years that's basically all the emotions. If I say I don't look forward to Xmas, he gets sad, angry guilty. He also has has 25 years worth rolled in.
I've told him in the past it doesn't have to be fancy, expensive, original, unique it's just a thing, wrapped for surprise, that is delivered on a set day.
He gets angry and then guilty and resentful that the magical perfect gift doesn't mysteriously just appear, hence the nothing or it misfires like the lavoutry pan. . He's dismissive of the time and planning that goes into Christmas, his mum does a lot, even still and possibly he just doesn't see it as a man thing, he doesn't see it as a human thing.

OP posts:
Northsideoftheriver · 13/12/2023 10:22

Being the tit for tat, spiteful bitch that I am when provoked, I would gift wrap a loo brush for him and make sure it matches the toilet pan.

Gingerbee · 13/12/2023 10:09

What do you get him? How about a toilet seat for his Christmas!
Actually, we don't do a great deal of presents for each other on Christmas. Make more of an effort for our birthdays.
Every year he sponsors two children through Action Aid in my name.
I donate to local charities and the RNLI in his name as our main Christmas presents to each other.
Presents to unwrap are rather mundane.

Give him a list.

Runnerduck34 · 13/12/2023 10:07

He wrapped the toilet pan!! Wtf!
Send him a list with links.
My DH isn't great at presents, it can be hurtful.
Especially when youve bought for him, DC and family and they haven't put any thought in effort in buying gifts for just one person ( you!)
To save disappointment I now send DH a list with links and am clear about what I would like and my expectations.
This is double edged as it would be nice to have a thoughtful surprise gift, but from experience the likelihood of that happening is low to non existent so if you are in same situation send a DH a list with clear instructions and stop hoping he will take a hint.

susiedaisy1912 · 13/12/2023 10:07

Have you actually spoken to him about this op?

JimBeamCoke · 13/12/2023 10:06

What sort of thing do you get him as presents? Usually when someone buys you something more thoughtful or expensive than you have bought them in return then there is some sort of comment. What does he say?

Aquamarine1029 · 13/12/2023 09:59

You still haven't answered the question. Does he know how you feel about this?

SheWasYar · 13/12/2023 09:58

Thank you, very useful particularly the word ' martyrdom ' it does feel like I've been stuck there.

It's a time of change, kids finally all at uni, time to reframe for the future.
I have bought two lots of tickets for next year - printed them out for hanging around on Xmas.
It helps for the inevitable family & friends 'what you get for xmas' question.

OP posts:
Allthecatseverywhereallatonce · 13/12/2023 09:58

I buy my own gifts and give them to dh to wrap. We have been together for over 25 years but he still has no clue. That said, he genuinely wouldn't care if I gave him nothing at all for Christmas. I buy all the presents for everyone else and this year I am fed up with it, I have changed jobs so have much less time.
Either write a list or buy yourself gifts and ask him to wrap them.